StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Historic Voyages of Two Distinct Personalities in History, William of Rubruck and Marco Polo - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
"Historic Voyages of Two Distinct Personalities in History, William of Rubruck and Marco Polo" paper compares the historical accounts of both voyagers, the physical and cultural circumstances surrounding them among societies during the Mongol time, and concludes which is more reliable in information…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.8% of users find it useful
Historic Voyages of Two Distinct Personalities in History, William of Rubruck and Marco Polo
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Historic Voyages of Two Distinct Personalities in History, William of Rubruck and Marco Polo"

[Running Head: Xxxxxxx] [Full of the Paper] This paper explores the historic voyages of two distinct personalities in history, William of Rubruck, and Marco Polo. They both journeyed through the lands of China, and have witnessed the different cultural practices, traditions, and way of life. However, their views and opinions vary as William of Rubruck was on a missionary journey to China, and Marco Polo, on the other hand, was a Venetian trader and explorer who travelled the world. Both travelers wrote about their journey, each describing what they have seen, learned, and experienced. This paper compares the historical accounts of both voyagers, the physical and cultural circumstances surrounding them among different societies during the Mongol time, as well as concludes which is more reliable in information. [Full Title of the Paper] As commonsense would dictate, a person's words are only as convincing as the listener's opinion of it. Two distinguished explorers have written historical accounts of their trip to China during the Mongol period. Both explorers wrote about the geographic details of the land, the cultures and beliefs of the inhabitants, and the political aspect of the society. However, seeing that William of Rubruck was a Flemish Franciscan missionary who, under Louis IX's orders, set out from Constantinople on a missionary journey to convert the Tartars, obviously illustrates the idea that his view is that of a religious individual's view. Whereas, Marco Polo, an explorer who came from a family of Venetian traders, may have views that are more freethinking in nature, as well as may bend towards the more political side. Although William of Rubruck was in China earlier than Marco Polo, they wrote historical accounts that could be compared to each other, especially on the physical and cultural circumstances surrounding these voyagers among different societies during the Mongol period. Life under the Mongol rule was illustrated by both writers, and both showed that indeed, during that time in history, it is the Khan who held power. In William of Rubrick's account, he told of how people bowed in reverence to the Mangus Khan, and that the latter was so powerful in society that once he summoned an individual, he hastens to the court of the Mangus Khan. In one of William of Rubrick's anecdote during his stay at Karakourum, he noted that once the Khan notices an irregularity and questions it, those questioned seem to tremble in fear of such circumstance. Marco Polo's account regarding the Khan's position in society was very much similar to that of William of Rubrick's. Polo described the Khan as a powerful individual, wherein each city they passed were all subject to him, and his power in conquering kingdoms is highly stressed by Polo. Polo also mentioned of the Great Khan's authority over the decisions and fate of the cities and its inhabitants. However, William of Rubrick wrote about the Mangus Khan in a more religious view. He talked about the Mangus Khan and his wives, taking into particular detail who were pagans, and who were Christians. He also noted his life in Karakourum, the encampment of the Mangus Khan, wherein he was fed well, as were the other priests, but that there were many inhabitants who were hungry and they had to share everything that they had with these unfortunate individuals. Polo, on the other hand, related about the Great Khan's power in a more political view. He acknowledged the Great Khan's power when he mentioned in his account the Great Khan's taking of Siang-yang-fu city in the province of Manzi, wherein he, his father, and his uncle were acknowledged and given credit for the successful taking of this city due to their idea. It is also stated in Marco Polo's narratives that he governed the city of Yang-chau for three years. Whereas, compared to William of Rubrick, Marco Polo enjoyed a higher position of authority in society during the time he was in this land, and was working more closely with the Great Khan in a different light as that of William of Rubrick. In accounts pertaining to the geographic descriptions of the journey, both travelers also took into account the places they passed through. However, William of Rubrick was more detailed in talking about the geographic descriptions of the land, whereas Marco Polo talked about the length of time it took to travel from one city to another, and the direction of the destination from the city they previously were at, as well as the trade and commerce aspect of each city he passed through. In the ways of life of a certain society, William of Rubruck told of the different Christian feasts and narrated in his account what occurred on that day in the Khan's camp. As for Polo, he told vastly of the life in Kinsai - explaining the people's livelihood, what they do for recreation, and explaining as to why the city of Kinsai is known as the 'City of Heaven', noting each detail carefully, illustrating it to the reader. William of Rubruck, on the other hand, talked about his undertaking in Karakourum, and how the events shaped them. In the light of customs and traditions, William of Rubruck simply told of the events in a personal journal manner, noting observantly the chain of events in a certain occasion. However, Marco Polo discussed about the customs in Chinese society in detail. He discussed about marriage customs whereas explaining thoroughly the existence of marriage contracts and covenants, and how women, particularly from Cathay, took this aspect very seriously - taking good care of their integrity, or they may be considered invaluable. He also talked about the customs in burying the dead, wherein the dead is burned together with things that he is believed to have with him in the next world. He also stressed on the fact that being honored in death is precisely what the people of Cathay wanted the most. Hence, it is clear that both travelers did have different reflections of lives of the people under the Mongol rule, as well as the interactions among the different societies during the Mongol period. However, when it comes to realizing which historical account is most reliable, it is here that we conclude that both accounts are accurate but in different aspects. William of Rubrick wrote in detail, noting down many observations along the way, asking questions a lot. His accounts of the physical circumstances are more credible to that of Polo. However, in regard to the cultural circumstances of the accounts, it is Marco Polo whose anecdotes may be deemed plausible. His carefully detailed narratives of the customs and beliefs of the people in each city in China are very much conceivable. History sees them as great men, and so they are. References Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Comparising Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1519742-comparising
(Comparising Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1519742-comparising.
“Comparising Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1519742-comparising.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Historic Voyages of Two Distinct Personalities in History, William of Rubruck and Marco Polo

Distance Education: History and Peculiarities

In the United States, the concept of extended education through satellite colleges was established in the University of Chicago, by william Rainey Harper, who was the University's first president.... In 1829, william Rainey Harper further promoted education by encouraging the concept of providing school courses through correspondence, an idea that was originally put forward and practiced by Columbia University.... The paper "Distance Education: history and Peculiarities" focuses on the critical analysis of the major historical milestones and peculiarities of distance education....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Marco Polos Travel Account

This paper ''Marco Polos Travel Account'' tells us that marco polo presents a firsthand account of his long journey from Venetian City to China, at that time known as Cathay.... Also, his study is unique in the sense that before marco polo along with his Polo brother's explored the land that was completely alien to the Western world at that time.... In addition, though a few other travelers had already made an effort to travel far-off lands, they hadn't recorded their accounts the way marco polo did....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Primary Source Analysis: Marco Polo

This paper aims to discuss he entries about Baghdad (Baldach) in The Travels of marco polo and Ibn Battuta's Travels in Asia and Africa which are the example of two ways of spiritual justification of the claims for land, protective in Ibn Batutta's case and active, “conquering” in marco polo's.... Of course, marco polo himself is not to be blamed for the imperialist overtones of the text.... But even in this case, there were global historical trends in which marco polo was personally involved....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Explorations of Marco Polo

The great explorers of the history such as Columbus, Bartolomeu Dias, Vasco da Gama, and marco polo have done important service to humanity in general and to the Europeans in particular.... marco polo (1254 - 1324), the Italian explorer who found most of Asia for the Europeans, gained reputation for his worldwide travels and is considered the greatest of the European explorers.... "marco polo, Christopher Columbus and other explorers couldn't resist the urge to trade in goods that they could not find at home, such as precious metals, spices and silks....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

What Part Did Religious Ideals Play In The Renaissance Voyages Of Columbus

An author of the essay "What Part Did Religious Ideals Play In The Renaissance voyages of Columbus?... Christopher Columbus embarked on his voyages of discovery during a time of great social and intellectual ferment in Europe.... Each of these elements was significant for the voyages of discovery, but they were heightened by the missionary character of Christianity and the ideals urged upon its followers by the New Testament.... She was a woman who would be famed throughout history for her great political foresight but who would also plunge all of Christendom into a frenzy of religious 'cleansing', through her 'devotional fanaticism'....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Columbus first voyage, 1493

Columbus' first journey and discovery were a remarkable event in world history because of its extensive importance.... In addition, Columbus' discovery motivated other explorers to embark on other voyages that marked the Era of Discovery.... The researcher of this paper analyses literature on Columbus first voyage in 1493....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Role of Continuity and Change in Colombian Voyages

Any moment in history is a combination of change and continuity.... here is also another less moronic aspect to the Columbian voyages in history.... Priests like Las Casas recorded that brutal history and raised their voices against them (Symcox and Sullivan, 46-47).... This small example from history itself is proof of how continuity and change can play with human history and life.... he Columbian voyages were a continuation of that great human history itself....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Along The Silk Road: Marco Polo and Sir Aurel Stein

His travels took him over and above what other Europeans such as Friar Julian and william of rubruck had accomplished.... The author of "Along The Silk Road: marco polo and Sir Aurel Stein" paper argues that the travels done by marco polo and Sir Aurel Stein had a decisive cultural impact since the cultures they were coming from had very strong foundations, to begin with.... erhaps the most famous of all Silk Road travelers was the Venetian trader named marco polo who gained fame within his lifetime for the wonders that he saw and brought back with him after his worldwide travels....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us