StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Observation of Participational Cinema in Action - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Margaret Mead has observed that where ethnographic films are concerned, critics demand a disproportionate amount of camera artistry from the director, while, conversely, the work can be discredited from an academic perspective should it abandon certain scientific methodologies in favor of artistic goals…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.6% of users find it useful
Observation of Participational Cinema in Action
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Observation of Participational Cinema in Action"

Download file to see previous pages

Dramatic films are generally shot from a third person 'voyeur' perspective, which allows the audience to observe the unfolding events from a distance. In order to accomplish this state of awareness and acceptance from scientific films, researchers spend a great deal of time with their subject population prior to shooting any footage at all. This is meant to encourage the indigenous community to ignore the filmmaker completely and to return to their normal everyday activities. However, this idealized approach - the 'invisibility' of the camera and it's director - raises new ethical, technical, and artistic issues.

The foremost argument against this style of filming lies in defining between 'research' film and 'ethnographic' film: the parameter's of the first ideally contain an undisturbed recording of environmental behavior (which can be used to deduce or extrapolate information); the latter classification is designated by it's editing, which is chosen be the filmmaker to create a narrative. Thus, as MacDougall notes, the fallacy of the all observing camera eye is itself misleading, for the camera is ultimately directed by the filmmaker's choice and/or opportunity.

The camera essentially decided what small section of reality is recorded. Along similar lines, the goal of a director's self-effacement from the project is a further removal from reality: many of the filmed communities are remote and isolated to pretend that the director's physical presence has absolutely no effect on the subjects (and a feedback effect on the project itself) is ludicrous. Along this principle, subjects reactions to cameras depends on their level of familiarity with the media itself.

Filming Live with the Herds (1972), MacDougall's silent film camera became accepted by the natives on the premise that he was shooting all of the time (and would therefore present an accurate overall account); when he brings out a still camera near the end of his sojourn, his subjects automatically stuck photogenic poses (MacDougall, 1973) A Ghana director named Braun, discovered a similar effect while shooting footage in his childhood village during carnival time: when a girl noticed him shooting from a rooftop, she began to perform.

She grew angry when the camera's attention no longer focused on her, leading Braun's narrative to hypothesize about the power relationship between the camera and its subjects (Pink). Cerezo, Martinez and Ranera, three anthropologists recording African workers in Spain, showed some of their footage to their subjects. Because they had access to television, the workers objected to their own images as being ugly and impoverished, which has resulted in the anthropological argument that visual footage cannot be taken without the express consent of the subjects (Pink).

Yet MacDougall takes this argument one step further. In requesting permission to film a community while simultaneously denying them any information to the direction of the film of footage that has been shot, the director "withholds the openness" he requires from his subjects. While this may be rooted in the director's fear of influencing the community's behavior, it also denies him the input of the community information which may prove inaccessible any other way (MacDougall, 1973

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Observation of Participational Cinema in Action Essay”, n.d.)
Observation of Participational Cinema in Action Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1514750-observation-of-participational-cinema-in-action
(Observation of Participational Cinema in Action Essay)
Observation of Participational Cinema in Action Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1514750-observation-of-participational-cinema-in-action.
“Observation of Participational Cinema in Action Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1514750-observation-of-participational-cinema-in-action.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Observation of Participational Cinema in Action

The Modern Level of Technological Development of Society

The depiction of racism in the films that more often occurred in the beginning of twentieth century showed colonised nations from negative sides, which was not an unpredicted action of European film-makers.... It is no wonder that the issue of racism and colonialism has been covered in cinema numerous times with a further criticism expounded in different literary works....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Marketing, Advertising, and Public Relations

Marketing, Advertising and Public Relations Practice Name University Course Tutor Date Reflective Essay What is Reflective Practice?... Reflective practice was initially introduced by Donald Schon back in 1983.... Reflective practice essentially seeks to help an individual reflect on certain given actions with the aim of helping them engage in a general process of continuous learning....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

McLuhan's Theories Applied to Television

This essay "McLuhan's Theories Applied to Television" says how Understanding Media was published as early as in 1964, McLuhan had predicted along with his famous theory of media as extensions that one day there could be the collectivization and corporatization of all information.... nbsp; It has been rightly pointed out that the Internet is nothing but an extension of one's powers of cognition....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Regeneration Projects of Europe and Their Implications

The author states that the process of regeneration links needs and opportunities, economic growth, social cohesion and cultural development, health, social care, and environmental sustainability and this has helped the British Governments to correct to some extent of their lost social balance.... nbsp;… The Council of Europe's intergovernmental committees supervises the convention's implementation....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment

How Has Photography Been Used To Reflect Upon The Ways In Which Looking Is Socially Structured

Mulvey contends that female viewers of mainstream cinema cannot experience visual pleasure the way that men can, because the Ergo, what exists for women is a sort of masochistic pleasure of observing one's own pain.... In her work, “Visual Pleasure And Narrative cinema” (1975), Mulvey states that women's place in society is to compensate for the weakness in men by submitting her own strength, thus removing the threat of emasculating and upsetting the male world, or as Mulvey calls it, the phallocentric order....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Group Therapy Among the Adolescents

ational emotive behavior therapy is action-oriented.... EBT is an action-oriented psychotherapy that teaches individuals to identify, challenge, and replace their self-defeating thoughts and beliefs with healthier thoughts that promote emotional well-being and goal achievement....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

The Society, Politics, and Women in Chicano Films

The new age potential directors also realized quite clearly that in order to create critically acclaimed cinema it is important to come up with new cinematic styles as well as striking storylines.... A new wave of socialism was introduced by the revolution and it surely created a huge impact over the development of the Latin American cinema.... nbsp; There are quite a few instances, where Chicanos were represented in a narrative manner to the audience and the early 21st century “Greaser” films are excellent evidence in support of such observation (Fregoso xvii)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Movie Review

Forms of Documentary Films

From the early days of cinema, “Documentary should act on our hearts, not just our minds; it exists to change how we feel about something”: Michael RabigerA Discussion2008Documentary films have for long been used to grow public opinion about issues.... From the early days of cinema, since the time of Lumiere Brothers in 1890 when motion pictures was innovated, films were expected to reflect reality.... cinema then was essentially a means to document reality – single shots of natural scenes, news or daily events - although the term ‘documentary' had not yet arrived....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us