StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Reaction to The Moral Instinct by Steven Pinker - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
If two people enjoy themselves, have a good time together without harming anyone in return; they are just pleasuring themselves by ignoring the burden of morally acceptable norms for a while. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.1% of users find it useful
Reaction to The Moral Instinct by Steven Pinker
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Reaction to The Moral Instinct by Steven Pinker"

Morality demands that Julie and Mark not indulge in an incestuous act. But viewing their actions from a ethical egoist point of view they had taken all precautions, were in mutual consent, and keeping the event under supreme secrecy. If two people enjoy themselves, have a good time together without harming anyone in return; they are just pleasuring themselves by ignoring the burden of morally acceptable norms for a while. This is what Steven Pinker tries to stress in his write-up in the New York Times(January 13, 2008) titled "The Moral Instinct" with more examples and theories.
He in fact favors Borlaug and Bill Gates over Mother Teresa in the choice of admiration and philanthropy. Borlough brought about the Green Revolution which still feeds millions of hungry mouths and Bill Gates aids missions to fight fatal diseases of the developed world. Pinker also contends that while Mother Teresa was backed by hefty donations from all quarters the other two were self motivated individuals expending their own time and effort in the up-liftment of humanity.
Pinter is critical of the entire question of morality and claims it to be passed on from one generation to the next and accepted without question because we were taught that way! He cites three predicaments where the choice is between morality and discretion. We discussed the first one at the beginning of this essay. The second example is about the American flag being cut and used to clean the bathroom. No individual with moralistic mindset would ever think of doing such a thing but come to think of from a rational point of view. The flag is pretty old and unused, when found serendipitously the owner thought of practical uses to it. Though it may be blasphemous to all patriotic citizens the woman in this example doesn't think so, it her own judgement.
The third instance is of a family eating a dead dog. Most of us find the idea repulsive but the persons involve did not harm anyone, not even the dog, it was already killed in an accident. Where does morality stand in all these circumstances
As per Pinker morality of one kind or the other is a universal phenomenon and may be rooted in the "design of the normal human brain". Whether the entire spectrum of morality is sacrosanct is very much debatable because people in general put their interests first , become selfish and their ego takes the better of them in crunch situations. That leaves morality as a figment, an illusion. The "Selfish Gene" as propounded by Richard Dawkins explains the universal desire by humans for self preservation, growth and sustenance with or without paying heed to morals. Even within a community it is the nepotistic altruism that prevails.
The Varieties of Moral Experiences:
Anthropologists like Shweder and Alan Fiske found out that certain themes, for example: a sense of fairness, loyalty to the community, reciprocation of favors, rewarding benefactors and punishing the cheaters were consistent across countries and cultures. The exact number of themes though differs.
A rigorous approach to human morality, like the one employed by Jonathan Haidt had identified the five moral instincts of harm, fairness, community (or group loyalty), authority and purity which made up the primary colors of "moral sense". Pinker had used vivid examples to illustrate each moral instinct.
Whether human behaviour is genetic or not is open to many questions. It can also be learnt adaptatively. Pinker insists that the moral sense is vulnerable to illusions as any other sense.
Genetic basis for Morality: There should be a genetic basis to the concept of morality because it is so ubiquitous and common across cultures. Again the self centered nature of humans could have contributed to a universal acceptance of right and wrong.
Aberrations from what is considered normal exist, though. The debates over global warming, homosexuality, atheism etc. nevertheless exist in the strictly supervised moralistic societal setup
A commentary on Pinker is best conluded his own way as Anton Chekhov wrote, "Man will become better when you show him what he is like."
Source:
Steven Pinker, The New York Times(January 13, 2008) "The Moral Instinct" Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Reaction to The Moral Instinct by Steven Pinker Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1507624-reaction-to-the-moral-instinct-by-steven-pinker
(Reaction to The Moral Instinct by Steven Pinker Essay)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1507624-reaction-to-the-moral-instinct-by-steven-pinker.
“Reaction to The Moral Instinct by Steven Pinker Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1507624-reaction-to-the-moral-instinct-by-steven-pinker.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Reaction to The Moral Instinct by Steven Pinker

Reaction

...?Reaction Paper on David Cole Interviews Dr. Franciszek Piper David Cole Interviews about Auschwitz and its gas chambers are quite informative. According to my perception, the gas chambers have holes that are indicative of the fact that these holes were employed for discharging the gas Zyklon B from outside. Ceilings of the gas chambers were used for discharging the gas inside the chambers. After World War II, changes were made, as the gas chambers are not in its original form. They are reconstructed. They are not fully representing the extremity of their homicide capability, The doors at the time of killing were made airtight while after World War II, there were new doors placed, which were not airtight. In my opinion, the number...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Book Opinion Paper on How the Mind Works, Steven Pinker

...?Book Opinion of How the Mind Works by Steven Pinker There are many books that talk about the mind and how to use it to bring about miraculous things. There are many new age books that state how people can use their minds to control their emotions and to live more fully. In this book, Pinker (1997) provides the reader with an understanding of the mind from a scientific point of view. One interesting point in the beginning of the book was that Pinker states that no one really knows how the mind works. He also explains that he does not know how the mind works, though he is a cognitive scientist. I thought to myself, “then why die he write the book?” The premise was intriguing enough to make me want to read on. He explains that he’s chosen...
8 Pages(2000 words)Book Report/Review

Analyze George Orwell's, Shooting An Elephant through the eyes of the author of the Moral Instinct Steven Pinker

This has never been put across more effectively as in the George Orwell’s essay, shooting the elephant. The author is forced by the general expectation to do what he does not believe in. He takes us through his ordeal so that we can understand the reasoning we often undergo in order to make decisions that seem conflicting in our lives. It’s not just the content of our moral judgments that is often questionable, but the way we arrive at them. We like to think that when we have a conviction, there are good reasons that drove us to adopt it (Steve 1).Orwell goes to a great length to try to justify decisions he made in this essay. A great lesson can be learned from his work. The author hated being a police officer. This was because h...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

The Moral Instinct

... Moral Instinct Introduction The article is about the of morality in our body since very many people have different views concerning the subject. The author admits that morality is a universal phenomenon observed all over the world across all societies and people in general making it have a larger area coverage. The article states that morality is like a switch that people switch on and off as per the situation and it is within us. The article also states that people practice their moral behavior because they are afraid of punishments which are the consequences of immoral behavior and this pushes them to indulge in socially acceptable standards of the society. However, the author points out that there are no clear avenues of reasoning...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Steven Johnson Syndrome

...Steven Johnson Syndrome Steven Johnson Syndrome Stevens Johnson syndrome (SJS) is a disease that leads to severe complications amongst individuals. It damages the skin and causes prolonged irritation that compromises an individual’s performance capacity. It is indicated that, “Steven Johnson Syndrome (SJS) and toxic epidermal necrolysis (TEN) are acute, severe, life threatening diseases with a mortality rate reaching 30 %” (Wolf, 2010, p. 154). The disorder is becoming prevalent in several settings due to medication complications. This is apparent in the increasing proportion of individuals who are reporting cases of skin and mucous membrane damage due to severe reactions to medication. Indeed, SJS is a serious disorder that individuals...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Argument Analysis about The Moral Instinct by Steven Pinker

...Topic: Argument Analysis about "The Moral Instinct" by Steven Pinker In analyzing the argumentative tactics used by Steven Pinker in the essay in the New York Times titled ‘The Moral Instinct,’ which proposes the hypothesis that “there is a distinctive part of our psychology for morality,” it is evident that the author has constructed the reasoning from a number of classical rhetorical techniques focusing on historical analogy and authoritative referencing. As an essential example of the argument, Pinker describes a scientific experiment in neuroscience in which subjects are asked to ponder moral issues while their brain activity was recorded by MRI scans. He asserts that the distinct patterning of brain activity displayed...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

The Moral Instinct by Pinker

Moral Instinct Some philosophical researchers have tried to research about moral instinct possessed by different people across the world. Several people expressed different opinions about three well-recognised individuals who have contributed a lot in helping people across the world. The researcher termed their opinions as moral instincts and the instincts are sometimes universal depending on the type of actions. The change of opinions about certain things or people has been happening often where people immoralize some actions while the amoralize others. Such things are evident when the individuals express their opinions globally and that sense of morality fall under set of rules. Moral judgments of certain actions and things have...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Steven Pinker

It gives in detail what has led to the criticism of this theory. My personal responses about the evolutionary theory of psychology are given as well as a conclusion.
Psychology is an applied and academic discipline which involves the scientific study of behavior and mental functions. Evolutionary psychology tries to understand mental abilities in light of the evolutionary progressions that shape them. It often examines the adaptive purposes of cognitive and emotional systems (Tsotsos, 1990). It involves investigation into how natural selection engineers someone to solve problems that he faces. The rationale of this theory follows from two premises. One is the existence and central significance of adaptation by natural selectio...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Reaction

...Movie Reaction Movie Reaction: Training The training of employees in an organization is an integral part of development and improvement. In fact, the challenge of improvement and service delivery is based on increased training. The training of the employees is a vital aspect in the management of human resource. Therefore, it is vital for the Human resource team to understand and prepare schedules for training. In the video, several issues are addressed that affect human resource training and improvement (Lambert, 2014). These issues include language training especially when focusing on international market. The training video covers array of issues including effective communication. Effective communication is an important factor...
2 Pages(500 words)Movie Review

Dual Instinct Theory


THEORETICAL ANALYSIS OF THE GORE AND WHITEFIELD CASES
Student’s name
Institution
Theoretical analysis of the gore and Whitefield cases
For years, academics have tried to understand the reasoning of a serial killer. They try to understand why people engage in such an inhuman act, the motivators, and how such deviant behavior can be eradicated. In studying serial killers, academics take three theoretical approaches namely: Biological, Psychological and Social. The biological approach seeks to find DNA anomalies in a serial killers genetic code. The psychological approach analyses a serial killer’s mind, while the social approach tries to understand a serial killer by studying his/her environment. This study seeks...
2 Pages(500 words)Case Study

Whether Abortion Is a Moral Issue

There may be instances of unwed girls who are pregnant or at times abortion is felt necessary to save the life of the mother. There are arguments that fetus does not have life. This paper will argue that abortion is morally not permissible. People claim that abortion has moral support today. Abortion is a moral issue but different theories of morality have diverse opinions. The arguments against abortion will be supported by theories on Morality, and views on abortion by different philosophers.

Morally, Warren (1996) states that a fetus is not a human being in the moral sense because a human being must have at least one of the following capacities - reasoning, self-awareness, complex communication. Warren further expla...
8 Pages(2000 words)Coursework

Critique of Research Article Moral Problems Among Dutch Nurses: A Survey by Arie JG van der Arend

...Critique of Research Methods and Statistics in the Research Article: ‘Moral Problems Among Dutch Nurses: A Survey’ by Arie JG van der Arend and Corine HM Remmers-van den Hurk. Published in Nursing Ethics 1999 6 (6) Arnold This essay will critically examine the survey and report, in order to determine whether the research methods, hypotheses and findings were appropriately utilized and if they made a valid contribution to nursing research in the fields of ethics and moral problems. Each section of the article will be looked at in the order in which it was presented, using a critical appraisal checklist to assist the process of analysis. Introduction: The opening statement clearly outlines what the survey was about, and summarised...
12 Pages(3000 words)Term Paper

Mother Teresa: An Example of Moral Courage

... Mother Teresa: An Example of Moral Courage Since the fall of Enron Corporation, there has been a greatdeal of talk in leadership circles about the question of ethics in a business context. However, in order for ethics to enter the business world, it must first exist in the personal. This has not always been easy because, while it is possible to hold a clear idea of personal ethics and behavior, it is usually much more difficult to act on these beliefs, particularly when the rest of the world is either turned against you or apathetic to your concerns. Rushworth Kidder defines moral courage as “standing up for values” and “principled action.” “In the defining moments of our lives – whether as a student watching a videotape...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

What Money Can't Buy: The Moral Limits of Markets by Michael Sandel

... Critical analysis Introduction Michael Sandel is a political philosopher who is well renowned. He was born to a Jewish family in Minneapolis in 1953. He went to school in Palisades and graduated with a degree in politics from Brandeis University in 1975. He also received his honor of doctorate from Balliol College. Michael is best identified by his readers for his book ‘justice’ that made great sales. He is the author of several books which have had great impacts in the society. He is the author of the book ‘Democracy’s discontent and public philosophy’, ‘justice’ and ‘what money can’t buy: the moral limits of markets’ which will be the subject of discussion. He is a professor at Harvard University and a political philosopher. Sandel has...
7 Pages(1750 words)Book Report/Review

Do Humans Have an Ethical or Moral Responsibility to Protect the Environment

...Yuxin Cui Do Humans Have an Ethical or Moral Responsibility to Protect the Environment? The environment is made up of everything that is around us (Gardiner 390). This means that all tangible and intangible properties around us that make our existence complete as human beings make up the environment. All people are born into the environment, and there is every indication that through whatever means the world came into existence, the environment existed before human beings. If not for this, there should be no way that the first kind or group of human beings to have occupied the earth would have survived because the environment supports both the natural and artificial needs of mankind. The issue of who is responsible for the protection...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

An Ethical and Moral Decision to Share Information

...And human experience and technology increases, the overall application that ethics and morality have in helping to define the interaction between individuals and their environment takes on an entirely new role. For instance, utilizing the case of Singer’s “Visible Man: Ethics in a World Without Secrets”, the reader can come to a firm appreciation of the way in which recent technological growth has created an entirely new set of questions and moral concerns that are concentric upon the way in which privacy is replicated and information is shared. As a function of engaging with such an understanding, the following analysis will focus specifically upon moral and ethical concerns relating to information sharing and the impacts that these have...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

Moral and Ethical Rules of Analects of Confucius

... here refers to discussing the meaning of the text. Yang Bojun describes the word Lun as compiling in an orderly way and ‘yu’ as language (Yan, 2011). These anecdotes, conversations and analects of Confucius bear some resemblance to the Biblical Gospels (Kirkland, 2004: p. 57) whereby a well-respected, noble, and wise leader has laid down certain moral and ethical rules and guidelines for his disciples and other readers to follow. These analects reflect his ideologies from diverse perspectives and on various topics from the several branches of schools of thought that he founded and led (Cua, 2002). This section includes a summary of the key features of Confucianism including a brief overview of the social context in which it was written...
22 Pages(5500 words)Book Report/Review

Moral and Legal Status of Abortion

...Moral and Legal Status of Abortion 1. True (Reading 10, Page 168, paragraph 2) Rosalinda Hurst uses virtue theory in reading 10 of page 168. She postulates the feeling women get of being bearers of new life within them. Therefore, she postulates that the virtue of life underlies within the sole responsibility of child bearers (Warren 168) 2. C ( Reading 10, Page 166, paragraph 1) The understanding of the beliefs and rights of the growing fetus can only be based on rightness or wrongness through understanding the wisdom of the fetus as a virtuous person. One therefore has to develop the correct attitude on the correct undertakings relative to a rowing fetus. (Warren 117) 3. A (Reading 10 Page 166, paragraph 6) An establishment...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

Steven Spielberg about the Life of Lincoln

... s the assignment was due Steven Spielberg’s Lincoln History is filled with key moments where nation’s leaders played a strong catalytic role for the actualization of significant issues. As these issues would bring about positive and beneficial changes to sections of people, those leaders would push their limits and work in utmost urgency to actualize those issues through official laws or amendments. One of the greatest American presidents, Abraham Lincoln is one such leader who worked with strong determination to have the Thirteenth Amendment passed by the United States’ House of Representatives with the intention to liberate the African-American slaves from white masters and thereby abolish slavery once for all. Lincoln, a historical...
6 Pages(1500 words)Movie Review

The Moral Rightness Of The Suggestion To Sterilize Women

... Ethical Arguments Many problems existing in the society hinder its overall welfare and happiness, posing the challenges for human beings, while decision-making process related to solving these problems might be rather difficult, for many issues faced by modern communities imply a wide range of peculiarities that are to be counted. Human beings are generally characterized by reason and intelligence, as Immanuel Kant’s theoretical framework implies, therefore, an issue of ethics and morality arises. Many optimal decisions that are highly rational and well-designed tend to have flaws in moral aspect, while morally acceptable decisions often lack logic in design with the cost exceeding the value of the initial goal. In the current paper...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Reaction to The Moral Instinct by Steven Pinker for FREE!

Contact Us