StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Melting Pot or Mess - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
In the years since September 11, 2001, what had already been a predominant sentiment against immigration received the validation of fear: these foreigners seething into our country's borders might not only be taking jobs away from hard-working Americans, so the argument went, they might also be planning to murder thousands of those Americans…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.5% of users find it useful
Melting Pot or Mess
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Melting Pot or Mess"

Download file to see previous pages To some, it may seem sensible to tighten American borders, to remove those from the country who are here illegally, and to enforce a stricter sense of security throughout the nation. However, there is no realistic way to do this. Immigration foes who realize this have then put forth another, easier barrier against the foreign hordes: proposing legislation to make English the official language of the United States.
Mauro Mujica is one of the supporters of the movement to make English the American language. He cited in his research polls that show that, throughout the developed world, over 90% of adults believe that learning English is necessary for children to succeed. Because English is the "language of business, higher education, diplomacy, aviation, the Internet, [and] science"(Mujica 1) among other fields, it is something that every child must learn. Mujica asserts two reasons why such an already pervasive language should be made the official language of the United States.
First, governments that provide bilingual services ultimately create linguistic ghettos that immigrants cannot escape. Mujica cites the 2000 census results that showed over 21 million Americans classified as "limited English proficient" - almost 8% of the population (Mujica 2). When children grow up in homes where they are not required to learn English, they struggle receiving a basic elementary education in American schools, and are relegated to the economic opportunities left to those who cannot speak English.
Second, the cost of multilingual accommodation is an unfair burden on the rest of society. Mujica cites the billions of dollars spent annually on multilingual education; the fact that 15% of Los Angeles County's election budget goes to multilingual ballots and poll workers; traffic accidents caused by foreign drivers not understanding English instructions and warnings (Mujica 3-4). It would seem that accommodating other languages is not an option that Americans can afford.
However, given the fact that immigrants are not going to just up and leave, just like their predecessors from Italy, Germany, Ireland and Poland did not leave in the face of prejudice in the early 1900's, it can be argued that denying speakers of other languages access to government services could be even more costly than accommodating them is. Thomas Ricento agrees with Mujica's assertion that English is the language of success: he asserts that immigrants want to learn English as a supplement to their own languages, not as a replacement. He sees the linguistic enclaves not as ghettos but as nurturing communities providing a link between the old culture and the American one, much like the old neighborhoods in Northeastern cities that used to be separated by varying European backgrounds (Ricento 3). Additionally, while short-term social costs might decline if multilingual services were removed, the longer-term costs would skyrocket. Immigrants would not leave the country but would instead let health problems worsen, leading to higher medical costs; their children might be forced out of their schools but would then cause problems later on as unemployed, uneducated adults (Ricento 5).
Governor William Dempster Hoard of Wisconsin had this to say about the right of children to education in English: "The child ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Melting Pot or Mess Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Melting Pot or Mess Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1500579-melting-pot-or-mess
(Melting Pot or Mess Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
Melting Pot or Mess Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1500579-melting-pot-or-mess.
“Melting Pot or Mess Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1500579-melting-pot-or-mess.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Melting Pot or Mess

Myth of the Melting Pot

...? Topic: Myth of the Melting Pot The melting pot is a metaphor used to describe a society which is becoming increasingly homogeneous in terms of people of different societies blending together to form a common or unified culture. Elements of different cultures combine together, to create harmony in culture. It is a blend and union of different nationalities and ethnicities. Previously this term was more used for immigration and colonization of countries with different nationalities and races in the world. Now, mainly this metaphor is used for United States and its ever-increasing incorporation and integration towards the level of immigration in the country. This concept is criticized to quite an extent because of its components...
14 Pages(3500 words)Term Paper

Applicability of Multiculturalism or Melting Pot Theory

...?Kevin Zhoe English 96 October 16, Applicability of Multiculturalism or Melting Pot Theory A Mexican American d Richard Rodriguez was asked if he was an American or a Hispanic; his answer was that he thinks of himself as actually Chinese. Rodriguez’s parents were both Mexican but he grew up in Los Angeles where his neighbors were all Chinese. As such, he identifies himself more with Chinese cultural orientation than that of being either a Mexican or an America. The concept of culture has evolved through time. It was initially viewed as an intriguing complex sociological framework since it reflects the elaborate interaction of values, attitudes, perceptions and behavior displayed by a particular society. Eventually, culture emerged...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Melting Pot

...? Due The American Melting Pot: Reality or Myth? Introduction When we look back on old documentary footage or watch period style movies we are often reminded of what the ports of the United States looked like at the turn of 20th century. People from all over the world came to this country with few belongings and a lot of big dreams of the better lives that they would build in this new land. They came to be free of the oppressions of their past and embrace the ideals and the freedoms of America. Ideally, these immigrants would bring the best of themselves, blend those talents, gifts and skills, and become Americans, sharing the unified hopes and greater goals of this country. The idea of the United States as an immense cultural “melting pot...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Social struggles in The Melting Pot and America

...? Social struggles in ‘The Melting Pot’ and ‘America’ al affiliation Social struggles in ‘The Melting Pot’ and ‘America’ Introduction The struggle one goes through socially shapes one views and perceptions of life in general (Karren, 2006). The poems ‘The Melting Pot’ and ‘America’ are poems that both portray different characters. These characters seem unsatisfied or displeased with the current state of affairs in the country. In the poem America, the narrator identifies a boy who describes America in a way that shows his negative attitude towards the state of affairs in the country. The second poem, ‘’The Melting Pot’ also talks about the problem of identity of immigrants. It talks about discriminations experienced by the immigrants...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

A New Vision of America's Melting Pot

.... Over the years, American society has been described in many ways, one of which is as the 'melting pot'. The early twentieth century debate about the 'melting pot' evolved as Jewish writers envisioned an America that might better accommodate Jews. Their historic experience as a minority prompted them to take the lead in re-imagining America for an entire wave of immigrants. Melting pot is a term used to describe a multi-cultural or multi-ethnic society. So far as this definition goes, the term melting pot surely suits American society with so many cultures around the world mingling with one another and melting into this one pot called America. (http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.htmlres=9E00EFDC1331F932A25751C0A9679C8B63&sec=&spon...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment

An overcome approach to the Melting Pot

...August 8, 2007 Military Draft: an overcome approach to the "Melting Pot" Would you leave your mate or brother in the lurch Could you be comfortably seated at your living room watching on the TV how your compatriots fall one day after other, sometimes in Basra, sometimes in Kabul, perhaps in Baghdad Would you be able to do your bit for the common good Would you be responsible enough to weigh up how much you are receiving from your country and how much are you ready to give for it Would you be able to assume your duty and personal responsibility - always understood the latter as your personal contribution to your society - and to respond to the military draft in case this came into action These are questions that resound for the last...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Postcolonial Melting Pot

...Running Head: POSTCOLONIAL MELTING POT Postcolonial Melting Pot [The [The of the Postcolonial Melting Pot In The Buddha of Suburbia, the space of performance, shifting from one margin to another, repeatedly destabilises the controlling narratives that define ideas of centre. Unsurprisingly, most commentators have tended to see Kureishi's sympathies as lying with the underdog. But such is the indeterminate subjectivity of both films-the contradictoriness of their characters, their unresolved ethical dilemmas, their wryly tragicomic representation of conflicted histories and divided allegiances-that they end up striking an ironic attitude to their own radicalism. Kureishi's approach questions the alleged righteousness of rioting and is less...
8 Pages(2000 words)Book Report/Review

Melting Pot versus Cultural Mosaic

...The "melting pot" or fusion model of acculturation has been contrasted with the "cultural mosaic" or multicultural model of acculturation. What are the advantages and disadvantages of these two models Which of the models is most likely to become a reality in this country The two theories of acculturation, the melting pot and the multicultural often reflect the ideological perspective of the person who is proposing them. Thus those who adhere to a melting pot theory tend to be more traditional and/or conservative in nature. They see "America" as a white, English-speaking country in which minorities need to arrive and assimilate in as few years as possible. The multiculturalists tend to be left-leaning, and seek to enable immigrants...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

The United States: The Worlds Melting Pot

...Running head: THE UNITED S: THE WORLD’S MELTING POT The United s: The World’s Melting Pot Put Here Put Your al Affiliation Here The United States: The World’s Melting Pot Introduction The United States has been styled a “Melting Pot.” As Herman Melville said, “We are not a narrow tribe of men … No: our blood is as the flood of the Amazon, made up of a thousand noble currents all pouring into one” (1849/2004, Chapter 33). Our nation is rich in its diversity. Nowhere is this more apparent than in the collection of peoples that have settled this country, bringing with them a wealth of cultural variety and a willing labor force. This melding of societies has influenced the formation and growth of the United States and continues to have...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

The Connection between American Language in Literature and Melting Pot

...The Connection between American Language in Literature and “Melting Pot” “Melting Pot” is a term used to describe cultural process and development of homogeneous societies. It is linked with the use and development of American language in literature and influences of other cultures and societies on American literature. The “Melting Pot” is a metaphor for the way in which homogenous societies develop, in which the ingredients in the pot (people of different cultures and religions) are combined so as to lose their discrete identities and yield a final product of uniform consistency and flavor, which is quite different from the original inputs. An influence of “Melting Pot” processes on American language in literature is a complex notion...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Myth or Truth: The Melting Pot Can Lead Economic Egalitarianism

... Myth or Truth: The “Melting Pot” Can Lead Economic Egalitarianism American culture is inextricably linked to the idea of equal rights and freedom for all. The philosophy is wonderful in principle, but hard to obtain in practice in a large and complex culture. The idea that anyone living in the United States can become a millionaire if he works hard enough falls short for a vast majority of Americans. The economic gap between even moderately rich people and everyday, middle class Americans grows by the year. Americans like to think they can be completely independent of government help. The idea of receiving welfare, food stamps, heating assistance, etc. is foreign to most Americans. However, when the average American buys a house, he...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Corporation Privacy and the Impact of Mess Media to Business

...Research Proposal 152.785 30 Credit The relative balance between corporation privacy and social media and the impact of mess media to business. By Xiaoxiang Gu ID: 06195865 Extramural Student Abstract This research proposal aims at examining the processes of incorporation of social media in small businesses, and to investigate the impacts it has on the overall network of business. The main focus is on making social media, such as facebook, acceptable and adaptable for small business enterprises and entrepreneurs in an organizational setting. One of the major concerns of businesses in adopting such technologies is the maintenance of reputation and privacy, these concerns have also been mentioned in studies like that of Gunther... Proposal...
9 Pages(2250 words)Thesis

Effects of Salt on the Melting Rate of Ice

...Effects of Salt on the Melting Rate of Ice s Effects of Salt on the Melting Rate of Ice Objective: to investigatethe effect of dissolved salt on the melting rate of ice. Hypothesis The null hypothesis is that the salty water would melt faster than pure water. The second hypothesis is that the more the impurities in water, the faster the melting point (Van der Put, 2013). Materials and equipment Two Thermometers Ice cubes Two bowls Salt- sodium chloride (NaCl) Stopwatch Procedure Take two equal bowls and put the same amount of ice in each. Put some salt on the ice in one of the bowls. Label it A. Record the temperature of each bowl. Observe the ice as it melts completely in both bowls, and measure the temperature in both...
1 Pages(250 words)Lab Report

Our Iceberg is Melting by John Kotter

...INTRODUCTION “Our Iceberg is melting” by John Kotter it is a fable that talks about one group of penguins living on an iceberg that is in danger of melting. Those penguins have to solve this problem with new and innovative ideas if they want to save the colony of penguins. John Kotter, the author, was born in 1947, he graduated from a MIT Bachelor, nowadays he is a Professor at Harvard University, where he studied his PhD in Business Administration in 1972. He wrote 18 books and 12 of them were bests sellers when published. He also receives several awards due to the relevance of his texts and the importance that it has in nowadays society. His work has been printed in more than 120 languages and he has sold more than 2 million copies...
5 Pages(1250 words)Book Report/Review

The American Nation: A Melting Pot of Asian Americans

As a result, American society is experiencing dramatic transformations (Skop & Li, 2005).
The Asian community in the United States is a cultural group that has assumed form since the passing of the 1965 immigration legislation. Even though Asians have been arriving in the United States since the middle of the 1980s, only in the previous four decades have the waves been remarkable. At some stage in that period, the U.S. Asian population has increased dramatically, and Asians one of today’s fastest-growing ethnic and racial minorities in the nation (ibid).
Asian immigration to and settlement in the United States is somewhat well recognized. Generally, Asian immigrants are geographically concentrated, with the imm...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

The International Community Students Club Is More Than Just a Cultural Melting Pot

... who share the same feelings is very appealing. As Klein puts it, "What better way to stay connected, active and focused than to unwind with peers who enjoy fun and common interests?" The club I chose for my report is unique, in a way different to most other clubs. It is truly a “melting pot” of sorts, representing different countries, philosophies, customs, cultures and much more, where people simply bond with and support each another. They have a lot in common, starting from the fact that they are all strangers in a new country. It is my personal belief that exchange students and children of immigrants strive harder than the native students do, in order to achieve even more. They are more self-driven, determined to achieve goal(s) set...
15 Pages(3750 words)Essay

Is America a Melting Pot or a Salad Bowl

...IS AMERICA A MELTING POT OR A SALAD BOWL? The debate over America being considered as a melting pot or a salad bowl is not a new one. Many people have opinions of their own regarding it and I feel that America is best described as a salad bowl rather than a melting pot. America has a rich history of immigrants who posses different cultures, languages, dances, foods, clothing styles, social disciplines and principles. They therefore form a vigorous mixture. Some claim that the mixture is homogenous and over the years has amalgamated to form a unique culture while some prefer to describe the country as a salad bowl. In the process of melting a solid, as all its constituents become homogenized, similarly, the metaphor “melting pot” refers...
9 Pages(2250 words)Research Paper

The Melting of the Polar Ice Caps

...The melting of the polar ice caps Introduction A polar ice cap, according to researchers, refers to a high latitude region of a natural satellite or planet that is covered up in frost. There are no necessities with regards to composition or size of a body of ice for it to be termed as a polar ice cap, nor any physical condition for it to be over land; just that it ought to be a body of frozen phase matter in the polar expanse. This makes the phrase 'polar ice cap' to come out rather as a misnomer, as the phrase 'ice cap' itself is used with a lot of scrutiny as such bodies have to be found above land and cover a surface area of under 50000 km². Greater bodies are given the name ice sheets (Buckles 2). This paper will discuss the melting...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Melting Pot or Mess for FREE!

Contact Us