Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Freges Puzzle of Identity Statements - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
This paper will critically examine the Frege's puzzle of identity statements and provide a solution based on the works of G. Frege. The emphasis will be on resolution of the cognitive significance of difference between the identity statements based on the famous work of philosophy - "On sense and reference" by G…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.6% of users find it useful
Freges Puzzle of Identity Statements
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Freges Puzzle of Identity Statements"

Download file to see previous pages Friedrich Ludwig Gottlob Frege, a German philosopher, was one of the founder fathers of establishing a systematic and analytical approach to the philosophy of language. He instituted the idea of logically proving the quantified statements. In Frege's philosophy of language he found two puzzles, of which one related to the identity of statements. Frege says
Now if we were to regard equality as a relation between that which the names 'a' and 'b' designate, it would seem that a = b could not differ from a = a (i.e. provided a = b is true). A relation would thereby be expressed of a thing to itself, and indeed one in which each thing stands to itself but to no other thing (Bencivenga E, 1993).
Here, he observed that mere representation of names and descriptions does not convey the information content of a statement or a sentence in terms of logic and meaning. He further probed and found that a minimum of two relations are required for significant understanding of the language. In the subsequent paragraphs we will discuss the Frege's Puzzle of identity statements in detail and reasonably justify the solution of the puzzle as suggested by Frege himself.
Identity statements are the expressions that equate the objects on both sides of the identity sign (Geach, O. and Black, Max, 1960). For example, "(2+3) = 5", "Clint is Eastwood" and "John is Peter's father". All these statements essentially belong to the same clan of kind " a= b". The statement "a = b" can only hold true when "a" and "b" both represent the same object or an individual. Now, consider a statement of kind "a = a". This statement also requires the same truth condition as required for the statement of kind "a = b". For both the cases, object or the individual is same and also, the denotations represent the same individual or the object. However, the meaning conveyed in the two cases is different. This appears to be a paradoxical situation as the representations of a unique object or an individual have a difference while being true at the same time. The Frege's puzzle states that when the difference in the representations, that is, "a" or "b" is not established by the two cases under consideration, then how we can find the difference in meaning or cognitive significance between the two true identity statements (Fiengo, Robert and May, Robert, 2006).
Cognitive Significance of the Difference of Identity Statements
To resolve the issue of difference, we first understand cognitive significance of a name or a statement. Cognitive significance of a statement, as brought out by Frege, can only be described by two important aspects of the statement, namely, 'sense' and 'reference' (Zalta, Edward N, 2005). Here, the 'sense' of the statement conveys more information then its interpretation by mere visual inspection (Schirn, M, 1976). Moreover, 'sense' is the integral part of the name and different names are associated with different 'sense' (Zalta, Edward N, 2005). A group of two or more statements may indicate or refer to a singular object but each statement has a unique sense of its own.
Next, we obtain the distinction between the ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Freges Puzzle of Identity Statements Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Freges Puzzle of Identity Statements Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
“Freges Puzzle of Identity Statements Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Freges Puzzle of Identity Statements

Australias National Identity

Evidently Australian politicians and public stand divided on the issue of Asianisation, yet, it remains a reality that contemporary Australia’s socio-economic and political future as a nation is more directed towards its geographical neighbour Asia, than the country’s historical allies – Europe and United States. Asian influences in shaping the identity of contemporary Australia is apparent in almost all spheres of national significance.
The paper explores the Asian influences and challenges that have shaped Australia’s changing national identities – from the imperial ‘White Australia’s’ image as a European settler-society to its assumed identity as a multicultural nation, posit...
8 Pages(2000 words)Coursework

Protecting Yourself from Identity Theft

Each individual now has a digital or virtual presence on the web or Net as an inevitable counterpart of the physical presence in the real world. In fact, this digital or virtual presence of an individual threatens to overshadow the physical presence as ICT grows all the more pervasive. The digital or virtual presence of an individual is established by the digital or virtual identity of the individual. The digital identity of an individual is defined by a set of parameters including the individual’s Social Security Number, bank account information, credit card information, etc. If these parameters are known to a second individual, he or she may falsely assume the identity of the original individual and carry out financial and...
14 Pages(3500 words)Term Paper

The Importance of Place in a Groups Ethnic Identity

His work spans a broad range of subjects from ethnography among peasants in Algeria, to sociological analysis of nineteenth-century artists and writers, education, language, consumer and cultural tastes, religion, and science in modern French society. (p. 2)
Bourdieu’s major theoretical contributions to sociology are his notion of habitus and its associated concepts of social field and agency. Given the breadth of literature and uses of examples that Bourdieu produced in order to articulate these concepts, there is much room for interpretation of what they meant and how much social agency they afford to individuals. Nonetheless, this paper will explore the habitus, field, and agency in terms of the fluid dynamics of the...
13 Pages(3250 words)Assignment

Identity Perception in the Virtual World

...Identity Perception in the Virtual World Rough Draft This essay deals with defining the nuances of identity perception in the virtual world. To beginwith, this essay will describe what identity is. Further, it will develop the human relation setting within which the analysis will be conducted and descriptions put forth. This human relation setting is important from the point of view of the individual who looks at cyber space with a certain level of optimism. This model of optimism will be used within the framework of thinking aloud and evaluation methods that dictate the decision aids that a person makes use of when creating an identity through various choices and means. These choices can include the various activities that one indulges...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Christian Identity Movement

verted to this religion believe that finally they have found their true identity by discovering that they are the descendants of the tribes of “white” Israel that were lost (Quarles 2004, p.7).
When any group of people say that they are superior to others on the basis of the race they belong to and also inculcate the belief that they are the only chosen people of God and not the people from other ethnic background, then one can very well say that that group or the organization is practicing racial beliefs. People who follow the Christian Identity believe that the people from Caucasian ethnic background are true Israelites and hence they are the only people from the God’s family (Quarles 2004, p.9). The teach...
6 Pages(1500 words)Coursework

Critical Review of Goth: Identity, Style and Subculture by Paul Hodkinson

The allure from this standpoint is seen by the author. This report measures mainly the methodology that Hodkinson uses, which is grounded theory research, and the report also examines questions of fixed vs. flexible research. The findings of the research are briefly presented before the current research investigation concludes.

The Goth subculture is founded on principles of viewing some of what society outside this subculture, or mainstream culture, views as abhorrent or negative. There is some fetish tendency in this subculture towards the macabre and death, with face-paint style makeup and mourning clothing being prominent features of belongingness, which are certainly not reflective of mainstream fashion and makeup....
6 Pages(1500 words)Book Report/Review

Identity Online: Bullying and Anonymity

Bullying is defined as to “act the bully (towards); persecute, intimidate, oppress (physically or morally) by threats or superior force” (Shorter Oxford English Dictionary, 2003).  However, this dictionary does not contain a definition of cyber-bullying, implying that the word was not in common usage at the time and the issue has evolved as a phenomenon since 2003. This would tie in with increased usage of the internet for such things as socializing using Twitter and Facebook, as well as more educational establishments using e-resources and virtual learning environments as part of their teaching.

Recently, attention has focussed on the phenomenon of cyber-bullying following the deaths of two students wh...
7 Pages(1750 words)Term Paper

The Ugly American: Duality and Identity

Because of the aftermath of World War II and the development of a xenophobic nature to the American identity, the ability for Americans to relate to foreign cultures is often stunted and without the flexibility required to successfully engage foreign states. William Lederer and Eugene Burdick wrote a book titled The Ugly American in which real events were related through disguised identities in relationship with the real histories of the American presence in Asia. The novel creates a duality between what exists and what it represents within many of the characters within the book.

The 1950s created strange beasts out of the American public. On the one hand, great strides in both social order and in technology had create...
8 Pages(2000 words)Book Report/Review

Uniqueness for Personal Identity

Teleportation is the process of disintegrating the body to make a copy of a person in another place say, for example, Jupiter as a means of travel. In the teleportation experiment, Parfit demonstrated the problem of teleportation when the machine malfunctioned. The machine was not able to destroy the original body and yet a copy was already sent to Mars. So the problem arises of determining who is the real you? This phenomenon of teleportation is bad because it is problematic. It is problematic not only in the sense that the machine malfunctioned that there became two individuals because the original was not destroyed. It is mind-boggling, but we cannot cease to wonder how does the copy thinks? About himself, the universe around h...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Identity and Buying

However, whether to fulfill basic needs or for prestige, what people buy usually make a statement about them and the sense of identity they have found themselves in. A consumer’s sense of identity will place them in a certain class based on their social power. Their possessions relate to the way they define themselves and how they are perceived by society and this paper will argue that people buy things they feel represent their identities and class.
Purchases motivated by class serve purposes related to personal enrichment and, more importantly, self-esteem. The social class concept introduced to marketing literature shows that the real or perceived social class in which a person belongs will influence the type of good...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Freges Puzzle of Identity Statements for FREE!

Contact Us