StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Discuss the concept of national identiy in the Iliad and the Aeneid - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The epic poem Iliad, which was written by Homer in 8th or 7th century BC about the Trojan war and Aeneid, written by Virgil in the first century BC is about the Roman ancestor Aeneas (he was already a character in Iliad) and the war involved have many commonalities…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.4% of users find it useful
Discuss the concept of national identiy in the Iliad and the Aeneid
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Discuss the concept of national identiy in the Iliad and the Aeneid"

Download file to see previous pages People of a certain region had their own national symbols and Iliad as it is said to be based on arguably historical facts, it had much of national romanticism in it. Even though Homer was Greek, he writes Iliad with impartiality towards Trojans too. The work covers one incident of Agamemnon's refusal to return Chryseis to her father; then his decision to take Breseis, Achilles' girl in the place of Chryseis, because he had to return his own to stop Greeks from dying due to some obscure disease and thus creating hatred in Achilles who refuses to fight and this resulting in diminishing Greek strength and increasing Hector's and Trojans'. It also covers Achilles' dilemma about fighting or not fighting, his mother's prophecy etc. Talking about national identity, one can get surplus of it from Trojans and Greeks both. Actually Greeks fight with Trojans because it was a foreigner, Paris, who had taken Helen from her husband, as they were honor-bound to do so according to the oath and their existence was within the national framework of the same identity. Paris was from another state and they felt a common hatred towards him. At the same time, Trojans fought the war, because they were united against the Greeks, who did not belong to their culture and the threat was against an action of their prince Paris. Even though the war (around 1200 BC) was about Helen and Paris, it lasted another ten years not because of the desire to bring Helen back, but because of the national identity and national pride that the war had unleashed. Both the armies fought for their own dignity and pride and Helen was simply an excuse. They did not want to end the war, because they did not want to hurt their national dignity. They dreaded the bad name that might get attached to their region and their clan. So, both the sides had to win the war somehow and thus, it went on beyond all expectations. At the end of it all, Trojans burn the Hector's dead body as though it was a national event that unified them even in their disastrous defeat. We can see that the funeral of their adored Prince resurrects their national identity once again. "And then they gathered again in due order and held a glorious feast in the house of Priam, the god-ordained king" (410). Heroes like Achilles, Hector, and even Paris are there because of the national identity. What we see here is a pure and undiluted form of national identity, and the glorification of the nation that has already existed before the war and gave strength to it.
Another classic, Vergil's Aeneid, has similarly strong national identity attached to it. Here it is the Roman nation, though provisional, against other ethnicities like Trojan, Italian, Greek and Carthaginian. But the national identity here is not what we see in Iliad. This roman identity is not absolutely stable, but adaptable. While Homer simply expresses the already existing national identities impartially, Vergil tries to build the state's identity by demonizing other states. This is another kind of narrative and is a powerful story, and pitted against to Aeneid, Iliad becomes a sincere report. People who have 'failed' in their duties towards the state are treated abominably by all the sides. While talking about war prisoners and the way of dehumanising them, the principle employed here is that they have failed in saving their national pride ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Discuss the concept of national identiy in the Iliad and the Aeneid Essay”, n.d.)
Discuss the concept of national identiy in the Iliad and the Aeneid Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1499646-discuss-the-concept-of-national-identiy-in-the-iliad-and-the-aeneid
(Discuss the Concept of National Identiy in the Iliad and the Aeneid Essay)
Discuss the Concept of National Identiy in the Iliad and the Aeneid Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1499646-discuss-the-concept-of-national-identiy-in-the-iliad-and-the-aeneid.
“Discuss the Concept of National Identiy in the Iliad and the Aeneid Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1499646-discuss-the-concept-of-national-identiy-in-the-iliad-and-the-aeneid.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Discuss the concept of national identiy in the Iliad and the Aeneid

Virgils Aeneid

...?How does Aeneas's piety and sense of duty change as the poem unfolds? To what extent is the Aeneid a political poem? Is it propaganda? Discuss with reasons and examples. In Virgil’s great epic poem Aeneid, the adventures of Aeneas are registered to create a powerful human drama that still retains its force two millennia past. Aeneas, the hero of the epic, is born of a divine union between the mortal Anchises and the goddess Venus. Believed to have been written circa 20 BC, this rhapsody illustrates the virtues of piety and duty on part of the hero. The grand scale and difficulty of the adventure of Aeneas provides several moments of examination of his virtuous qualities. In his mission to find the prophesied place where he is to build...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Heroic Paradigms from Iliad to Aeneid

... Philosophy 1o May Heroic Paradigms from Iliad to Aeneid “The Iliad” is a tale of Greeks who sailed across the sea to besiege the Trojans in their walled fortress in the city of Troy, which is also known as Ilium (hence name “The Iliad”). The story revolve around Achilles, who was the greatest of the Greek warriors at Troy, however when Agamemnon, insults and angers him, he refuses to fight, which turns out to be a devastating blow to the mission. Achilles anger at Agamemnon acts as an integral theme of this epic, hence a short yet explosive outburst nearly undermines the Greeks' struggle and desire to conquer Troy. The Aeneid does not explicitly deal with Roman politics in fact it is a story about a mythological figure Aeneas who lead...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Aeneid

...Aeneid Aeneas is the hero of Virgil's Aeneid. He survives the siege of Troy by the Greeks, who entered the deceitfully, by hiding themselves in a large wooden horse. This epic poem is in two parts-the first part (Books 1-6) is about Aeneas' flight from Troy accompanied by his father, Anchises, and son, Ascanius (his wife dies in the confusion following the sack of Troy), and the ordeals he faces, till finally he reaches Rome. This ordeal includes long voyages across the seas, interrupted by significant events that include a stop over at Carthage, where he falls in love with their queen Dido, and lives with her. But he has to finally leave, sacrificing his personal feelings to the pull of destiny and the call of duty. Fate decrees that he...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

The Iliad by Homer and The Aeneid by Virgil

...The Iliad by Homer and The Aeneid by Virgil are two time-honored ics referred to as epics. These epics are argued by many to be two of the greatest ever written. Both focus on men who are half god and half mortal. These books form part of the foundation on which western classical tradition was built upon. The Iliad and The Aeneid contain numerous similarities. Both books are a reflection of the Trojan War and events that took place. This paper will discuss and address other such similarities. Honor, fate, and strife will be explored from a Roman and Greek viewpoint. Honor takes on different roles within each book. In The Iliad, Greek hero Achilles is ruled by personal honor. The concept is used in an individualistic manner...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

The Aeneid The Iliad The Song Of Roland

There is thus a lot of chaos. Howvere, the main characters occupy different positions on the hierarchy and have different roles to play. Thus while Aeneas is the undisputed leader of the Trojans, Roland is merely the nephew of the main leader of the French, Charlemagne. Essentially Aeneas occupies the same position as Charlemagne does, at least as regards his people. Of course Aeneas is not defending any "land" as Roland is; he is seeking to find new land for his wandering people.
Roland is killed while mounting a heroic defense against superior numbers as he protects the rear of the French forces. Aeneas ends his story with the killing of Turnus. The readers (or audience) never see him marrying Lavinia and founding the Roman...
3 Pages(750 words)Book Report/Review

Virgils Aeneid

...Nisus and Euryalus in APA style Nisus and Euryalus The tale of Nisus and Euryalus is a tragic episode that is narrated in book IX of Virgil's Aeneid. It is about two friends who attempt to carry a message for help in the dead of the night across enemy lines, on behalf of their besieged comrades. They come heartbreakingly close to achieving their ideal and amassing untold treasures, but by a cruel stroke of fate they end up failing miserably in their mission and losing their lives in the process. And yet this poignant tale is a tribute to the enduring bond of friendship, indomitable courage in the face of insurmountable odds and the power of sacrifice. Therefore it has inspired many and continues to do so. A thorough analysis...
8 Pages(2000 words)Book Report/Review

Helen in the Iliad and Dido in the Aeneid

...Helen in the Iliad and Dido in the Aeneid Dido and Helen are woman characters of famous ancient stories - Aeneid and Iliad, respectively. Both these characters play a significant role in the writings that describe these characters and their actions, and these characters were used by the authors for different purposes. These woman characters have some common features and characteristics, but also have distinctions that make them differ from each other. Helen is treated as a character, symbolizing ambiguity of feminine character, and she has become a model for many characters of women described in later writings by various authors all over the works. She is a symbol of woman bringing grief to the men loving her, but she is also a symbol...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Virgil Aeneid

.... The above lines, though brief, have considerable significance in Virgil's Aeneid, and have been discussed at length by scholars. The lines are placed strategically at the end of what may be considered the end of the first part of Aeneas' story. Apart from this, they are a little terse in contrast to the previous long-winded and descriptive passages. Scholars have suspected that Virgil cleverly tried to convey a different message through these lines. The fact that Aeneas exited through the Gate of False Dreams is interpreted to mean that whatever Aeneas did subsequently was false. This is taken to be a veiled criticism of Emperor Augustus himself-the descendant of Aeneas. It has been said that since Virgil was a protg...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Virgil Aeneid

...Virgil Aeneid rhetoric 2006 Outline: A) Rhetoric technique used. Analysis. B) Does the rhetoric technique suit the situation? A Trojan man (Laocoon)in Virgils Aeneid in his speech uses a number of rhetoric devices which form the hypophora. The speaker opens his speech with powerful rhetorical questions which in addition are parallel constructions: "A gift from the Danaans, and no ruse? Is that Ulysses way, as you have known him? With this the speaker catches the attention of the listener. Rhetoric questions are used to arouse concern and attract attention. That’s what the speaker wanted to do. He wanted to attract the attention of the audience to the problem. He does not assert but inquires and in this enquiry the listeners clearly...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Aeneid

... the queen of Carthage that is Dido. However, Mercury is sent by Jupiter to remind Aeneas of his journey (Hoena, 29) v. Furthermore, Aeneas also receives prophecies of Apollo from other gods. For instance, the hearth gods of Troy are able to tell Aeneas to sail to Italy. In discussing the fate of Turnus and Aeneas, Jupiter calls a meeting of the gods to mediate between Juno and Venus, to prevent them from interfering with the fates of the two men. Works Cited: Hoena, B. A.. Aeneas. Mankato, Minn.: Capstone Press, 2004. Print.... Aeneas: Aeneas is considered as a son to Aphrodite, the goddess of love, and a prince of Troy, Anchises. One of the major duty that Aeneas was supposed to carry out, is to take the surviving Trojans to Italy, and...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Moffetts Concept of Trust

Several formalities have been associated with the development of the trust, most of which have been formulated with the intent to prevent fraud and misappropriation in the transfer of property, especially from the point of view of payment of taxes, stamp duties and such related fees for the capital wealth. While trust law is said to be administered based on principles of equity, the reality has been quite different and the results of adjudication in trust disputes have been primarily ad hoc, conditioned from a financial perspective rather than to establish any distinct equitable principles. In fact, the law of formalities has created inflexibility in some cases and there have been instances where the interests of beneficiaries hav...
13 Pages(3250 words)Research Paper

Concept Analysis: Humor in Nursing

Humor is one of the methods and strategies used by medical professionals to support a client and create positive feelings and emotions. Responsibility of a nurse is to ensure that a thorough assessment is made of the client's health concerns, that suitable nursing actions are chosen and implemented to help clients, and that an evaluation of the results is carried out. Assuming this leadership does not mean that nurses take over and do for, or to, clients. The quality of nursing care is determined by the completeness of the interchange of knowledge, attitudes, and skills between nurses and their clients. To be most helpful to all clients, nurses should make sure that they solicit their knowledge, become aware of their feelings and...
15 Pages(3750 words)Case Study

The Concept of Reconstruction

The rampant oppression of black citizens remained commonplace in the South due mainly to the racist, pro-slavery sentiments of Lincoln’s successor Andrew Johnson. Racist groups such as the Ku Klux Klan emerged and flourished during Reconstruction, a circumstance that would have been much less likely had Lincoln lived. Lincoln’s dream of rebuilding the South and unifying the nation fell well short of his expectations. His dream became a nightmare for Southern blacks under the Johnson administration.

Slavery was an emotional topic in which everyone in the country at the time maintained a strong opinion. Lincoln and those of abolitionist ideology acknowledged that slavery was a part of the American culture and...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

The Concept of a Mongolian Restaurant Business

The fact that it gives customers a variety of fresh food ingredients to choose from made the business very attractive to customers.
For this study, a brief overview with regards to a Mongolian restaurant business will be provided followed by discussing the concept and the primary purpose of a business plan. Eventually, the importance of using a business plan in starting a new Mongolian restaurant will be discussed.
In the process of discussing the importance of a business plan, the role of a business plan with regards to the success of a restaurant will be highlighted. Aiming to project the student’s understanding of the subject matter, the point of discussion will include: (1) selecting a good location and the ren...
9 Pages(2250 words)Term Paper

National Health Service Human Resource Planning

There are about 1500 primary care dentists who are working on a salaried basis with the NHS, in most cases employed by primary care trusts. This group of individuals was a part of the local government earlier but in 1974, they were transferred into the NHS. (Personnel Today, 2007). Starting from the year 1997 onwards, the U.K. Department for Education and Employment had allowed for additional funding of $7.2 million to ensure that medical schools are able to pay clinical academia staff the awards that have been recommended for doctors and dentists in the NHS, by the Doctors and Dentists Review Body (Beecham, 1996). This move was initiated to introduce pay parity because university employers found it difficult to pay the 3.8% incre...
14 Pages(3500 words)Term Paper

A democratic political system is an essential condition for sustained economic progress. Discuss

What is now clear is that democracy is superior when it comes to countries that have a heterogeneous mix of people and cultures since it is imperative that all sections of society be carried along if the process of economic development has to succeed. In case this does not happen, the concerned country faces the risk of social unrest and the inability of the government to carry all the citizens along with the process of economic development.

If we look at some of the competing ideologies of the 20th century. Communism was the dominant ideology of many countries of the eastern bloc. The basic tenet of communism is the absence of private profit and state ownership of the factors of production. This means that all workers...
11 Pages(2750 words)Term Paper

Evolution of the Concept of Childhood

Philosophers, psychologists and educationists have attempted to approach and analyse the issues of childhood from either their socio-cultural perspectives or from their respective disciplines (Richards & Light, 1986; Burman, 1994a; Woodhead, 1999). A look at the theories suggests that the concept of childhood and the position of children has evolved down the ages into a child or childhood-centric view. In the research works of both Elizabeth Coates from the discipline of Education and Wataru Takei from Psychology, the child-centric model of research is apparent. This aspect of their research has not only made it interesting but at the same time palpable.
Coates’ research on children and their learning response in an...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

The National Drug Intelligence Center

...The National Drug Intelligence Center One of the most common crime in the United s nowadays is of drug trafficking. This lucrative business has become a trend in the American society and is increasingly becoming a threat for the state. Just before this crime could become a national issue the government of United States realized its potential and formed several intelligence agencies which would look after the drug traffickers. The National Drug Intelligence Center is the formation of government of United States in this regard. It was formed in 1993 and is operating till date. The NDIC has proved quite successful in achieving its tasks and has proved as an asset to the United States. This essay would further describe the agency in detail...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

The Concept of Karma in Pure Land and Zen Buddhism

Additionally, the views regarding the concept in different cultures outside Buddhism are also included.
The concept of karma can be considered fundamental in the Buddhist religion. It is related to morality and the manner of behavior of the Buddhists which can be illustrated in the verses of the Sanskrit Dharmapada which expressed that “evil should be prevented to be able to avoid sufferings” and there is no place a person can hide to be safe from karma. This is according to the verses that expressed that “not in the sky or in the ocean’s middle…where karma does not catch up with the culprit” (Conze 83).

These verses express the importance of karma in guiding the Buddhists in th...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

The National Youth Agency

A local area of Ofsted provides this organization with a perfect opportunity to inspect children and young people and contribute much to develop social networks. The concept of social capital is a key concept, which determines the Coalition Government’s aspirations for a Big Society development. It is relevant to distribute power "from the state to society; from the center to local communities, giving people the opportunity to take more control over their lives" (An investigation into the delivery of Integrated Youth Support Services (IYSS) in England: Headline findings from quantitative data collection, July 2010). Youth organization works in three main directions: participation in education, employment, and training. Young...
6 Pages(1500 words)Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Discuss the concept of national identiy in the Iliad and the Aeneid for FREE!

Contact Us