StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Article by Gordon Fee - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Read the article by Gordon Fee and answer the following questions: How convincing is Fee in his contentions that (a) this passage is a non-Pauline interpolation and that (b) therefore it is not binding on Christians
Fee provides a convincing argument that this is a non-Pauline interpolation rather than a genuine…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.4% of users find it useful
Article by Gordon Fee
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Article by Gordon Fee"

Download file to see previous pages Thus on the basis of its rarity and illogicality it seems as though the words were not originally written by Paul but were in a fact a subsequent interpolation.
The second major argument that seems convincing is that "one can make much better sense of the structure of Paul's argument without these intruding sentences." This is based upon the idea that Paul's argument should be logical and coherent rather than apparently more impressionistic and illogical. In and of itself the idea that Paul's argument should be logical does not necessarily imply that it is logical in this case. But Fee provides an exhaustive, detailed explanation of how the passage (without the interpolation) is a traditionally Pauline piece in terms of substance and structure. This includes the rhetorical, argumentative question of "or did the word of God originate with you" .
Fee is convincing because he is apparently balanced in his argument. Thus he does allow that "if one were to conclude that vv.34-35 are authentic, they would appear to be best understood as something of an afterthought to the present argument." While Fee does not consider such an "afterthought" very likely, he at least places it within the realms of possibility. Rhetorically, this is an effective device that allows the reader to take on board the main thrust of Fee's argument without believing that he has something of an axe to grind.
More proof is provided by Fee through the pointing out of the fact that "these verses stand in contradiction to II:2-16 where it is assumed without reproof that women pray and prophesy in the assembly." Other possible explanations, such as the idea that Paul is in fact quoting from someone else here, is effectively dismissed by his suggestion that "it presupposes the unlikely scenario that some in the church were forbidding women to speak - and especially that the quotation would come from the same Corinthian letter that is otherwise quite pro-women." Thus even if Paul is quoting, it seems unlikely that he would want to quote from those who are supposedly "anti-women" when his argument actually stems from the opposite point of view. Here Fee implies that Fee is simply too good a writer, with too broad a knowledge of his subject and too great an arsenal of persuasive skills to fall into such a trap.
Thus Fee succeeds in effectively making it both unlikely that Paul actually wrote these verses in the context of other interpolations as well as the fact that the verses would simply not make sense within the context of the writing that surrounds them. Paul is not attempting to limit the role of women in the rest of this Letter, so it seems unlikely that he would suddenly start to do so here.
b)
The idea that the verses are not binding on Christians, because they are, as Fee convincingly suggests, non-Pauline in nature is a perhaps more complex matter. This assumes that Paul's actual writing is the inspired Word of God whereas that of the unidentified, later interpolator is not. If this is the case then these verses need not be binding on Christians.
Fee's argument is based upon the perhaps more sophisticated idea that Bengel's first principle should be adhered to. Thus "the form of the text is more likely the original which best explains the emergence of the others". The verses that in question here clearly do not best explain the emergence of ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Article by Gordon Fee Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Article by Gordon Fee Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1499373-article-by-gordon-fee
(Article by Gordon Fee Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Article by Gordon Fee Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1499373-article-by-gordon-fee.
“Article by Gordon Fee Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1499373-article-by-gordon-fee.
  • Cited: 1 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Article by Gordon Fee

Reality Television: Oxymoron by George F. Will

... other, offending the other person. Rather than protecting the individual suffering, they laughed about it because that is what TV does. On television, calling someone fat and stupid is something we laugh about, but in reality these actions hurt individual's feelings. So, in real life when children bully, the crowd around them or “audience” would laugh. Reality-TV shows are displaying bullying on TV and assume that it is permissible. Fox pays Gordon Ramsey millions to bully contestants on “Hells Kitchen”. Americans are following these forms of bullying without even realizing them. Such actions not only impede cognitive development of the individual but also hampers the psychology. With repeated incidents of such acts, an individual who...
7 Pages(1750 words)Article

Produce your college technical note for : Condition Scoring and its use/ importance in autumn and spring calving suckler cows

This is quite risky given the changing seasons and different food demands. In producing this technical note we aim at developing a technical note that can guide the application of condition scoring and the meaning of the resultant scores. Defining condition scoring Condition scoring is a procedure employed in determining the body condition of livestock on a regular basis. Moran (****) defines condition scoring as the visual appraisal of the quantity of muscle and fat casing the bones of the cattle (.p.209). This can be done independently of live weight; pregnancy and gut fill and entails a look at specific parts of the cow’s body (Moran,.p.210). Body scoring technique can be an informative means that contributes extensively to th...
7 Pages(1750 words)Article

Public relations in music and media subject

... the music business in particular to rethink corporate marketing strategy and this is further highlighted by the proliferation of the multi-channel retailing paradigm as required retailers to "innovate" in order to maintain position in the marketplace (Levy & Weitz, 2008; Kusek, 2008; Gordon; 2008). As such, it is submitted that blue ocean strategy is arguably essential to Ears Music Limited in providing the foundation of dynamism in line with Schumpeter's theory that the evolution and sustainability of a successful business model is not dependant on how capitalism administers existing models, but rather with how it destroys them through creativity to survive long term growth (Metcalfe, J.S. 1998; Levy & Weitz, 2008). The incoming...
22 Pages(5500 words)Article

Apple iphone

...Introduction Often considered as a marvel of the modern technology, the Apple iPhone is an eye opener into the world of flashy gadgets, which are fast catching the likes of the young and old alike. Equipped with a high resolution in-built camera and a mini media player, the Apple iPhone is blessed with perfect picture quality and the ability to shoot, store, record and send data from one location to another. Apple is a new player in the cellular phone market; nonetheless, it has successfully managed to do introduce a product which is not only attractive but also efficient in terms of the technological enhancements and durability. Of the numerous features, the 8GB of memory space, incorporation of the latest cellular technology... Often...
6 Pages(1500 words)Article

Leadership and Management: Solution of Conflict Resolution

...Leadership and Management In an ideal situation coworkers would work together harmoniously to achieve desired end results. Whether it is a boss-subordinate or colleague relationship all participants would work collectively to accomplish task at hand. However, through the expression of individuality, it is most probable that conflict will arise. Although conflict in the workplace is anticipated and in many cases prepared for, its method of resolution may determine if interoffice harmony can resume. Frances Hesselbeing, (2002: 4) recommends in the article “Crises Management: A Leadership Imperative” that crises management be learned and practiced before a storm arises. Being prepared to deal with conflicting staff allows... and Management...
6 Pages(1500 words)Article

Use of Sound in Citizen Kane and Stagecoach

While sound in film was being developed as early as 1911, it wasn’t until 1927 when the first monumental moment in sound occurred. Alan Crosdale’s The Jazz Singer provided not only the first real example of the technological advancement but gave Warner Bros. a marketing advantage that was intended to bring a waning audience back into the theater. Sound in the film allowed for a stronger competitive edge against both radio and vaudeville which were distracting audiences from the movie theatres (Hayward 333). The new technology had an effect on a great number of aspects of the film industry.

The sound that would now be included as part of the development of a film had an impact on a great number of factors th...
9 Pages(2250 words)Article

Top Female Leaders Around the World

... and people like Lee Kun Hee are credited with high respect as they truly deserve it.   3. Gordon Ramsay  Gordon Ramsay is one of the strictest yet swanky leaders on earth. He is a master chef and his students learn and follow his leadership. His demeanor tells that he answers to no one and always defines his own set of parameters. There would hardly anyone who would argue that this man doesn’t possess leadership abilities. If someone can swore his kitchen staff on BBC television (Overview of Gordon Ramsey, n.d.) then what else do one need to know if has leadership qualities or not? 4. Oprah Winfrey A black African American woman, who earns $200 million every year and has a net worth of over $2 billion, these credentials speak...
3 Pages(750 words)Article

Thunderstorm

The theatrical attraction and general characterization of the plot, in line with the thematic relevance of the play is magnificent. Despite the play exhibiting more of the ancient settings of the time, the relevance and the brilliance of the actors is exceptionally fascinating. The paper is an analysis of general plot, characterization, the cultural influence and reception by the audience, and the general commentary on the contemporary society of the Chinese through interactions and actions.
The thunderstorm is in this case used to describe the complex blood relationships as well as the various tragic incidences that are perceived inevitable. Therefore, it is a dramatic occurrence with significant connotation together with he...
8 Pages(2000 words)Article

Development of a Theory of Mind in Blind Children

...A Critical Review of "Factors influencing the development of a theory of mind in blind children". SUMMARY This research article attempts to provide clear visualizations of the factors influencing the theory of mind in blind children. A step by step procedure is applied to meet the criteria of experimentation and data gathering. The study revolves around the findings taken from actual observations and experimentations conducted to blind children with different bracket ages, with the intent to implement a comparative study. About 23 children participated in the research, with ages ranging from 5 to 12 years old. The research is designed in different experimentation procedures, such that will test the respondents’ response based... Critical...
6 Pages(1500 words)Article

The Religious Perspective of John Hick

... The Religious Perspective of John Hick In presenting his argument, John Hick introduces the problem ofstudying world religions as being an issue of multiply divergent belief systems and suggests a more beneficial approach might be to look at the various world religions as a means of achieving salvation. “’Salvation’ is primarily a Christian term, though I shall use it here to include its functional analogues in the other major world traditions” (Hick, 1988: 2). While he concedes that often salvation is defined in specific terms that require adherence to a single tradition in order to be attained, he argues that the fundamental concept of salvation is generic, indicating a radical change from one imperfect state of being... The Religious...
9 Pages(2250 words)Article

Human Resource Development in the United Kingdom

...Human Resource Development in UK Inserts His/Her Inserts Grade Inserts (17, 02, 2009) TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. Introduction…………………………………………………………………………….. 2. HRD at the environmental level………………………………………………………... 3. HRD and the organization.…………………………………………………………….. 4. The learning organization....…………………………………………………………… 5. Development programmes......…...…………………………………………………….. 6. Induction…………………….…………………………………………………………. 7. Star performers………………....……………………………………………………… 8. Empowerment and HRD.........………..…………………..…………………………… 9. Management and professional education.……………………………………………... 10. Training methods.........………..…………………..…………………………………… 11. Leadership development.........………..…………………..…………………………… Human Resource... Resource...
6 Pages(1500 words)Article

The Use of Rhetoric in the Electronic Age

The rubric of the rhetorical theory is an extremely contested discipline with classical rhetoric theory focusing on the concept of rhetoric as a form of persuasion or an ideological perspective that asserts “rhetoric’s role in upholding power and domination” over the “general public” as the underlying basis of societal communication (Stacks & Salwen, 2008, p.240). However, the boundaries of the classical rhetorical theory have been challenged by cultural change, context and the permeation of alternative perspectives. 

In particular, the impact of the digital revolution and the growth of numerous multimedia streams on cultural norms has challenged classical theory propounding the fu...
14 Pages(3500 words)Article

Scottish Parliament Complex: Holyrood Project

... analysed in view of the four phase model of project management. According to Lockyer and Gordon (1996) project management activities can be clustered into four process groups which are Conception, Development, Realisation, and Termination. Activities within these groups have clear dependencies and must be performed in the same sequence for each project regardless of the industry in which it is applied or any particulars related to the project lifecycle. The four phases are shown in Figure 1. Figure 1: The four phase model of project management The Conception phase involves the specifications of broad outline of the project, its scope and the prime objectives that are meant to be achieved at the end of the project. Based on this initial...
14 Pages(3500 words)Article

Analysis of Banker's Work Concerning Manufacturing Overhead Cost Drivers

...Critical Analysis of Banker et al.’s “An empirical analysis of manufacturing overhead cost drivers 0. Introduction and overview This work is a critical analysis of the work of Rajiv Banker, Gordon Potter, and Roger Schroeder on “An empirical analysis of manufacturing overhead cost drivers.” The work was published in the Journal of Accounting & Economics in 1995. When the authors wrote their work, Rajiv Banker and Roger Schroeder were with the Carlson School of Management in the University of Minnesota. Gordon Potter were with the School of Hotel Administration of the Cornell University. The Journal of Accounting and Economics received the work in April 1992 and the final version by July 1994 before the work was finally published in 1995...
20 Pages(5000 words)Article

Multicultural and Ethical Issues Dealing with the Court Systems

...Multicultural and ethical issues dealing with the court systems The criminal justice system of any nation is a reflection of that country’s approach towards cultural tolerance, the society we live in, as well as that of the issues faced by its citizens in present times. The criminal justice system in America depicts the widespread public sentiment and social trends which has grown to be highly multi-ethnic and multi-cultural in nature. The trend in crime and criminal activities have hence, also taken a multi-cultural turn, pushing the advocates of justice to make and implement laws to address the rapidly changing society. For instance, many developed countries have seen a drastic increase in immigrant population from all over... and ethical...
7 Pages(1750 words)Article

Are Viruses Considered Living Organisms

It also has a display of properties typified through the organisms like the reaction of its environment as well as directing the various efforts for self-replication. Like bacteria, viruses are rather microscopic and induce human diseases. However, unlike bacteria, the nature of viruses is of acellular in particles (which means that they do not comprise of living cells such as plants and animals). Instead, they consist of central cores of RNA or DNA coupled in protein coatings (Marshall Cavendish Corporation. 2007).
The viruses do not have properties for living things as they do not have any energy for metabolism hence do not grow in a bid to eradicate the production of waste products. They have no response to any form of sti...
6 Pages(1500 words)Article

Should the Government Raise the Driving Age

... of Driving is one of the most ordinary actions that the human population experiences in the dailyundertakings. The issue is because the cars are a means of upholding efficiency and saving on time that is an important resource in the economy of the country. However, there is the need of care in the control that the drivers have on the automobiles. The perspective thus brings in the argument of the need to raise the driving age to a mature age. The following article thus articulates on the various issues that different research works establish to be beneficial by raising the driving age. Most of the research works command on the fat there is an urgent requirement to set the driving age to a more mature age. The article illustrates... of...
6 Pages(1500 words)Article

Identity in Context and Stereotyping

... Identity in Context and Stereotyping Identity refers to who one is, the way they think about themselves as well as how the world perceives them. Our identity is in most cases shaped by the environment around us, which could be the media or culture in the society we live. Stereotype threat on the other hand is the situation individuals find themselves in and develop the fear of being judged in a negative way due to the stereotype. The environment one lives, their education or gender are the bases of these stereotypes we experience in our society. As far as gender is concerned, there exists a stereotype that females are poor in mathematics and this has proven to negatively impact on them by having them down their tools... Identity in Context...
9 Pages(2250 words)Article

Debate Surrounding the Standard and the Non-Standard English Language

...Fabiola Chayele Hoskins College Writing 16 February The Debate Surrounding the Standard and the Non-Standard English Language The debate surrounding the English language has been going on since the 17th century from the British and passed onto the citizens of the United States shaped around the white man that has run this country through the categorization of either Standard or Nonstandard English (Mufwene, 1999). The major perception is that Standard English language is superior to the Non-standard English. However, the major problem arises from an effort to define what Standard English is, since “it can be difficult to pinpoint its features exactly” (Curzan, 341). Moreover, even though most speakers perceive the Standard English...
6 Pages(1500 words)Article

Media Impact on Young Girls

... Media Impact on Young Girls Introduction Young girls in the United s of America and all over the world have been struggling with body image for a long time. The media has been no help in making the women comfortable in their skin. Being thin is considered the ideal body shape that the women require to have in order to gain approval from their peers and the media. The young women and girls lack a proper role model to guide them on feeling comfortable in their skin. Most of the young girls, therefore, look up to women in magazines and models as a source of inspiration for the kind of person they want to be and how they should live their lives. The article will focus on the challenges the young girls go through trying to look like... Media...
6 Pages(1500 words)Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Article by Gordon Fee for FREE!

Contact Us