Evidence Based Medicine in General Practice - Essay Example

Running Head: Evidence Based Medicine in General Practice - An Exploratory Study Evidence Based Medicine in General Practice -An Exploratory Study The central dynamism of Evidence Based Medicine (EBM) is simply to employ support acquired from the logical technique to fastidious parts of medical performance. The discipline endeavors to analyze the eminence of substantiation that is ideal to the risks as well as the advantages of medication. With regard to the centre for Evidence-Based Medicine, basically (EBM) is a painstaking, unequivocal and sensible application of modern oriented evidence in constructing decisions concerning the treatment of a patient (Coomarasamy A, Khan KS, 2004). EBM is cognizant of the fact that many aspects of medical care depend on personal factors such as quality and value-of-life judgments, which are purely embedded on the systematic lines of approach. Nonetheless, EBM endeavors to illuminate those elements of medical practice that are in principle subject to scientific methods and put these methodological functions to enhance eminent forecast of upshots in medical healing, even as discussion about which results are enviable persists (Department of Medical Sociology, 1998). A clerical anthropological line of attack was employed to analyze inter-reliance with reference to the healthcare teamwork. This line of attack is embedded on the function of ethnographic fieldwork by means of participant observation. Corporations are conceptualized as a civilizing phenomenon with their own edifying principles and models that stipulate the traits of workers. Ethnography approach has been widely employed in health management reviews. It is viewed as a way of accessing beliefs and traditions enhancing these to be conceived in the context in which they occur and aiding the understanding of traits of actors. The opinion polls were conducted for a period of 6 months with 30 interrogations involving doctors as well as nurses that are group participants in hospice sections; this include functional rooms, intensive care units as well as ward areas in a colossal teaching hospice in Australia. Precise cataloguing was employed. Scholars employed semi-configured opinion polls and contestant inspection. Those that were interviewed consist of surgeons, anaesthetists, nurse overseers, and foster clinicians. (Jassawalla, A.R., Sashittal, H.C, 1999). Methodology Methodology is the selection of the variety and type of data and information to gather, method of analyzing the data and information and the target group or audience from the data is to be gathered. There are various types of methodologies that can be used for the data collection, collation and compilation of the research. The importance of methodology in an approach to acquire relative data in regard evidence based medicine from the general practitioners point of view. The hypothesis revolving around any topic can be better analysed through the data on which it is built. There cannot be any investigation without hypothesis. Hypothesis defines the aims and objectives of an investigation and leads to the development of sound methodology. Phenomenology is one of the methodologies used in philosophical research which was first used by mathematician Edmund Husserl. The core of this methodology includes use of reflective techniques of 'bracketing' and 'reduction' to unveil the data which is actually required by the researchers. A wide range of literature analysis offered the hypothetical construction against which the examination stretched out. Since this review is beyond being innovative, it is however, not probable to establish a direct comparison that flanks the results and the findings carried from preceding lessons, (Wadland WC, Barry et al 1999). Whereas there are copious studies that feature obstruction to engaging with the EBM replica of concern, there exist incongruity in their approaches and interpretative line is oriented on borderline arguments as barricades that trounce; treatment discrepancy at the bottom line if often the levelheaded introduction to suggesting or conniving an interference of dismissing and enhancing uptake. Additionally, all chronological review findings target distinct expert groups an aspect that extrapolating across professional boundaries could be viewed as so dishonorable and intricate or conceivably, fundamentally phony. Besides, all previous findings target distinctive professional groups- in addition. On the extreme hand, virtually all available pure accounts comprises of assessment commentaries, educated estimation as well as notion infuriating editorials. To conclude, it is apparent therefore that no literature linking critical attitudes to EBP and the functions of healthcare libraries-in scrupulously whether evidence of a wide range of views quantifies a supplementary bendable approach to in sequence condition relatively than adopting an overriding replica and motivated to complete it, (Coomarasamy A, Khan KS, 2004). For that reason, preceding research was basically employed as an indicator to shared challenging, moderately than as a proposal alongside which to ponder existing result. Copious restrictions should displeasure the understanding of the outcomes in this study. Foremost, at the planning phase, the reviews might to devoid of precise objectives: a cross punitive line of attack that targets disparate categories at divergent phases of comprehension and with diverse backdrops and inspirations, doesn't' allow somersaulting the study at the right level for each person. For this reason, the outlook polls- as some respondents commentary pointed out-could be viewed as missing meticulousness in item directives or illegal behavior, and aiming excessively high, hence minimizing its feasibility. Indistinguishable configuration, on the contrary, could be consultations core weakness, making it more laborious to evaluate results. Nevertheless, the submission of assorted systems of statistical compilations ought to have alleviated the constraints of survey advance and improved the study's authority. Subsequent, the opinion poll's moderately low rejoinder tempo- even though, participants represented a fairly broad range of experiences and viewpoints suggest that the findings ought to be satisfactorily replicas of the target population; and the opinion polls exterior legitimacy may be undecided. Of lesser apprehension, is the bias introduced by self-selected respondents, since the outcomes appear to recommend that fascinated in EBP does not necessarily correspond with constructive attitude. (Wadland WC, et al 1999) In reality the reverse ought to be true; the opinion polls decisive undertone could have wielded a stronger magnetism on nonconformist. What's more ways, the moderately low rate of unresolved rejoinder appear to demonstrate the investigation met its aim of attracting strapping and multifarious views. (Wadland WC, et al, 1999). The known propensity to concentrate on items in a communally adequate manner may have affected the collective comeback fastidiously for the proclamation about the future of documentation services, as an outline of understanding towards the researcher. In a nutshell, the tight timeframe, the large sample population and the intricacy of the theme being reviewed unavoidably dictates the investigative natural history of this case study. Fundamentally, it does not present an opinion of the situational intricacies in whichever challenge to investigate the associations flanking EBP, information administration and in sequence furnish, (Audet N et al 1993). Each interview was audio-taped and transcribed verbatim. Ethnographic chronicle was kept; it consisted of occurrences that were verified. Remarks were hoarded in the structure of keywords, legends and minutes of congregation. Arguments post meeting were also written down and hinted. Notes from audio files were transliterated and manifestations of the researchers of incidences that had transpired. Vigilant distinctions were made in the event of observations flanking traits approved by doctrine or customs and authentic traits or what persons actually do. Ethnographic portraits were employed as illustrations and interviews were employed to give voice to actors calculating the team traits. Scientific advances were adopted to help in detailed coding and evaluation of the collected review material, enhancing the interpretation process, (Illich, I. 1990). Sophisticated software QSR N-Vivo was employed for that reason. In the evaluation phase of the project, the review material was established to revolve around various central topics. To realize cohesion within each topic required the development of a detailed definer of each topic, insertion as well as delineating scale, and eminence of review substances. Statistics were collectively themed and coded by means of a progressive relative evaluation and expression. Evolutionary yet relative evaluation is constantly employed in analyzing statistics to expand provisional codes and to develop theories, clusters of relationships, commonalities and disparities flanking the profession establishment (Fitzgerald, 2002). Evidence is a methodical thinking surrounding connections and interconnections flanking performers and was employed to define and comprehend underlying conventions that control circumstances in which medical professionals as well as nurses find themselves, (Hansen, M.T. 1999). It has been acknowledged that examinational is problematic. Our conception of the issues under analysis cannot claim exclusive privilege in the depiction of those issues. Conversely, to ensure that assorted opinions were mirrored from the review materials, at least 2 interrogators were available at every single opinion poll that was to be conducte., (Hermsen, M., Ten Have, H., 2005). Additionally, habitual conventions were conducted to present the evaluation group with a platform by which to debate the study substance and their versions. These conventions offered elementary prospects to create check and recreate meaning from interpretation and impersonation, relentlessly mirroring on our own prejudice. (Freidson, E. 1977). The multi-disciplinary operating theatre team In the context of health care teams, task specialization synergy is only a part of team performance outcomes. Although in an operating theatre team task specialization is vital, team member interactions to achieve their goals in confluence is an important competence for operating team performance. This requires managing fragmentations between and within professional and occupational groups; managing autonomy; and, balancing functional diversity (skills), social cohesion between occupational cultures and super ordinate identities, (Fitzgerald, J.A., 2002). Managing fragmentations Lucid disparities flanking group members in functional theatres can bring about diverse specialized trait. These traits can consist of influence as well as self magnitude illustrated by proficiency control and ability and conceived answerability for the accomplished tasks. For instance, it has been observed that most doctors have separated themselves from the rest, intentionally or not, by displaying traits that sets them apart, normally above the rest, by exhibiting superiority of status. In the operating theatre these demonstrate of features demarcate the medical line of work from others. (Fitzgerald, J.A., Lum, M. 2006). Top add up on that, these traits also symbolize a vital separation within the health check line of work itself. The genesis o this perception emanates from the social view into the expertise, this is the phase where normative trait is nurtured through rule-like ceremony at gatherings not reachable to anyone that is not part of the occupation. For instance, various doctors in the operating theatre remarked that their position being higher than that of anyone else in the health domain and that this was reinforced by associates within the expertise. (Faulkner Schofield, R., Amodeo, M. 1999). One medical doctor commentary: I know I have a fair-haired bit of domination here and I exercise it when I want to. A separate medical practitioner remarked that the reinforcement of self-determination from the precincts of the work force. (Eagleson, G., et al 2000). The two precursors, comes out loud and clear and denotes the demarcation of medical identity, socialization into the profession at higher institutions of doctors within the division of labour in the hospice. Whereas the former source of demarcation starts to construct the expertise identity in a way that is implicitly in a hierarchical association to other healthcare professions as well as occupations, the successive endlessly reinforces a hierarchical categorization of labour with the therapeutic line of work at the top of the pecking order. Additionally, these holier-than-thou myths of the inherently superlative attributes of themselves as experts of their know-how and also their function are typified by how others envisage the medical career. With regard to knowledge and expertise; fairness, morally and ethically, medical experts have been conceived by a potent acceptance associated with what they do and say to be honorable. (Eagleson, G. et al 2000). As a result the communal perception in reality detaches the society from the professional doctor that is seen as advanced. These facts and figures can help comprehend why doctors have so much difficulties being part of a group typified by impartiality and cohesion. As illustrated by medical practitioners during interviews, the central difference flanking surgeons, and other health care workers lies in the function of work they do, the significance if that occupation, the heights and facades of information the function demands, the accountability for the function and who analyses that utility. A medical illustrated the existing disparities of methodological to work between separate employee clusters as labeled below: You have to be, as a medical doctor, infatuated irrational. The anomaly is one cannot meet the expense of inaccuracy, as well as drifts, since you don't realize a subsequent bite and the difficulty that we have as a team, as an expertise, is the other persons functioning in the firm that do not exhibit an aspect of compulsiveness (Tasi, W. 2001). Synopsis and Assessment of the hospice case study This segment joins the central review from across the statistical sets by illustrating the overarching subject matter in response to the survey queries. Occurrence evaluation carried out in chief healthcare records intrigued the approximately exponential development in the functionalities of EBP expressions and accepted wisdom over time, and illustrated the repeated contemporary convention of the confirmation-based qualifier as a hymn-like blotch of the EBP dialogue and theory. The review assisted in the comprehending how EBP has time-honored itself as a governing subject matter in the healthcare prose and outside its perimeters to the attractive tune of its paranormal words. Predictably, in the radiance of such oral torrent, these findings establish that consciousness of EDP in the model population is prevalent. The respondents familiarity with the jargon and concepts does not necessarily emerge from any specific training, nonetheless, there happens to be a optimistic association flanking training as well as confidence echelons in the pursuit and critical appraisal of expertise. More so it is illustrious that other reviews pointed out, character-ranking of statistics come into view to be prompting the actual information and expertise. However, wide ranging perception from the findings conducted indicated that most participants expressed that EBP presented a conviction, in-depth interrogate statistics illustrating the terms, research support as well as evidence centered could be employed interchangeably, substantiating findings as well as probable denotation to tell between the two theories. (Audet N et al 1993). The evidence-based live out mock-up: inspections of health experts This review in correspondence with preceding study in sundry professional areas indicated by and large, a positive approach to the EBP faction. Thus far, somewhat challenging findings from other reviews, a direct similarity flanking knowledge of EBP and compassionate observation could not be conventional. In reality, the accessible reviews by various researchers may embody that critical line of attack of the EBP theories, unarguably a gauge of information; match up to a precautious estrangement from it. At this point in time, it could be argued that critical evaluation abilities, interior enablers of the EBP replica empower professional to view through its face value axioms, hence presenting a conceivably inadvertent in built direct apparatus guarding alongside indiscriminate embracing and a mechanistic submission. With this hypothesis, an explanation as to why studies discovered that enhanced knowledge of EBP represents not a variation in practice traits. An optimistic analogy flanking the age of participants and sanguine approach to EBP was confirmed by the statistical opinion polls and more so by those that were interviewed especially by senior staff melancholic the junior's uncritical approval of the reproduction. (Audet N et al 1993). Proviso participants were collectively complimentary to EBP and welcomed its dissemination, both their narratives and their quantitative data set indicated that, when assessing and discussing the models anomalous regions, the critiques and manifold restrictions explored in the published literature are fairy comprehensively corresponding in the review mock-up. Core issues as collected in the research indicate some of the shortcomings constituted through the implementation of EBP. (Audet N et al 1993). Specialized regions were shown to have divergent opinions at the theoretical as well as scientific echelons. Questions surrounding the source of proof; thus dependence and conviction in review as well as the very financial support system, and the procedure developers and sponsors. Apprehension to whether EBP presents patients the best accessible choices or deprive them of choices. Strapping doubts over the collective data statistical anecdotal data to sick persons. Existence of hidden motives political and monetary driving factors underlying the proof tabled to medical expertise. Additional strain grouped around the issue of the replica's effect on expertise; perceptions covered an overtly wide gamut, spanning from viewing EBP as an essential tool for validating status to a controlled intercession geared at imposing monopoly over individual know-how and clinical sovereignty. In summary, the evaluation designated those dangerous objections to the EBP theory and model bang on its uptake, and inveterate opinion polls evaluation that the EBP theory is not cost gratis. Critics embody a tiny marginalized, and their percentile consequence could augment if the practically established and lack of rendezvous also mirrors deficiency of true hold up for the EBP assemblage. Consequently, to deduce from the present findings as argued from similar response trends, that objections to EBP represent a meticulously assembled and intelligent flexible set of stratagems for checking the consequences of EBP upon performance and pass on an egalitarian opposition of the leadership 'philosophy of substantiating' with a strapping emphasis on practitioner's expertise autonomy as well as concentrating on the long-suffering person. (Barnett SH et al 2000). General Discussion Apart from the fact that the study above points out the same problems found in other related studies as barriers to the implementation of EBM, it does provide new insights into the issue. One of these insights that have not been covered explicitly in other studies is the identification of consumer organizations as a major contributor. The other is the health care policy. The study generally emphasizes the need for better communication, more teamwork, better educational programmes and more objective studies. It is a fact that most medical practitioners have habitually developed the tendency to treat their patients based on intuition rather than Critical Appraisal (CA) and EBM. They trust their medical judgment and are not in a hurry to adopt a different system. One way of making them change their approach is of course to provide more evidence that EBM actually works and more reliable and efficient in the long run than what they are used to. As a way of convincing them, credible and reliable research findings that show that Relative Risk Reduction (RRR) and Absolute Risk Reduction (ARR) factors are more enhanced by EBM more that in mere routine practice. (Barnett SH et al 2000). As the GPs so clearly point out in this research, the need for Continuing Medical Education (CME) is critical to the enhancement and improvement of medical practice. It is not proper for the purposes of coordination and performance, for any medical practitioner to swing off the tangent in the practice. This can result in unethical practices as one progressively ignores medical ethics and becomes more of a traditional faith healer with all the answers at his fingertips. However, much as CME is critical, it must be carried out in a practical way that downplays the profit paradigm and recognizes medicine for what it actually is, the science of providing healing. Another obvious limitation of CME that is pointed out here is its tendency to be so intellectual and academic in nature such that it completely ignores the practical aspects and challenges of medical practice. The recommendation that facilitators and trainers be from both the universities and the field is quite important here. Though some of the findings of this study sound specific to the Belgian situation, such as the problems of the health care policy, they cannot be disengaged from the general problem facing medical practitioners in other parts of the world. Health care policy, that is mostly propagated by governments are usually more oriented towards expediency rather than actually solving health problems. The main problem is that those in government propagating such policies may either totally uninformed or misinformed, and where they have studied medicine, totally disoriented by their executive duties. Furthermore, medicine is not a loud-mouthed practice like law, teaching or journalism. As such the very genuine grievances of doctors usually go largely unnoticed or unattended to. Doctors all over the world face various difficulties arising from official policy on their work. Here they don't get adequate pay; there they do not receive the correct equipment in sufficient quantities to carry out their duties; elsewhere they are either not given sabbatical leave or adequate security to make night calls. All the while as governments talk about improved or even free and universal health care, they are more concerned with the access to rather than provision of it. It is therefore, an indisputable fact that the views of GPs should be taken into due consideration when policies concerning them are being formulated. Otherwise, like the Flemish GPs they will take to shortcuts and exploit policy loopholes to maximize profit at the expense of evidence-based practice. (Barnett SH et al 2000). Going hand in hand with this need for better policy formulation is the need to build networks among GPs which will enable speedy consultation and communication among and between them. Of particular interest is the proposal among the GPs that a website be established which they can access cheaply and freely. They also propose how such a site should be organized so that they can access what they want easily and quickly. Above all, they recommend that the site be created by practicing GPs who should be paid by the government. This is a proposal that no right thinking government can afford to ignore if it is genuinely interested in "improved health care" One outstanding thing about the Flemish GPs study, unlike others, is that it gives a theoretical framework by which solutions can be implemented. It categorizes all the barriers at different levels and in this way it is easy to apply interventions using this categorization in an efficient manner. This classification model is a useful tool to orient the process of change management. Other studies on EBM carried out by different individuals and organizations in different settings have also come up with quite similar and equally interesting findings. One such study was carried out by Kenneth S Yew (MD) and Alfred Reid (MA) from the Uniformed Services University and The University of North Carolina respectively, (Physicians for the twenty-first century, 1984). The aim was to find out the long term effects of teaching Critical Appraisal and Evidence Based Medicine on practicing physicians. Their goal was to explore ways in which the long-term outcomes of an integrated CA/EMB curriculum could be evaluated using a qualitative analysis of self-reported use of the two skills in everyday medical practice. Their secondary goal was to find out barriers to CA/EMB application. Reinhold Wentz has estimated that 50,000 physicians, students and health care workers receive training each year. (Wentz R. 2001). Participants mentioned that they had found the approach they used in residency was still helpful to them in situations that they faced as full time GPs, but only in circumstances that allowed them to search and reflect. However, where they immediately had patients to deal with, they preferred to rely on their own intuition and experience. A good number of them expressed guilt that they were not applying the EBM methods even though they were fully aware of how useful these were. However, when it came to the question of barriers, almost all those interviewed were unanimous that time was the main culprit. Some pointed out that where they had to choose between attending to patients and making references, they often found themselves opting for the former. About 30% of the respondents said that they applied the EBM methods regularly but not when resolving an immediate clinical question. All the participants were also unanimous on the importance of attending CME courses and as a matter of fact they did attend them. They were sure that they valued keeping up to date as it gave them immense satisfaction. 2% of the participants identified CME as their primary self-learning method. All reported that they regularly read journals while 5% read their specialty society journal regularly. About half also identified teaching and questions arising from patients as their main incentive for learning. Apart from luck of time, the participants also mentioned that the nature of their work kept them constantly under pressure to produce clinically. The majority expressed frustration at this constant pressure to perform, a common sentiment among GPs. (Barnett SH et al 2000). Unfortunately, none of them associated performing in their duties with applying EBM since they mostly regarded this as a drawback on quick efficiency. Yet they all felt that they could do their work much better if they found the space in their punishing schedules to make references a little more and keep up to date. They figured themselves struggling to cope with work pressure while seeking enlightenment at the same time. On the question of whether they counseled patients regularly, a third of them admitted that they needed evidence-based approaches on such occasions while the rest resorted to counseling based solely on their previous experience and intuitions. When faced with diagnostic dilemmas, it was discovered that two groups of participants came up with two different diagnostic plans and rationales for tackling a suspected pulmonary embolism. Only one of the plans was consistent with EBM. Just like many surveys have revealed in the past, this survey revealed that asking a colleague was the most common method of approaching clinical questions. Many doctors rely on this method in the course of their work. This is because they find it to be efficient, free and not cumbersome in any way. The biggest limitation of this as an EBM method is of course the fact that a situation may be encountered which one's immediate neighbour may not be so well informed about. Most medical practitioners, (including those in this survey) however, only use this method as the initial approach to try and resolve the problem (Bazarian JJ et al 1999). The next method is usually to widen the consultation by calling someone or some agency. Only a limited number of practitioners usually go a step further by consulting a book, journal or the internet, especially when the other sources do not seem to work. (Elnicki DM et al 1999) Among the reasons the participants gave for this localized consultation was that it is easy, the people they consult have more experience and they tend to trust more those immediately around them. Only one participant pointed out that consulting in the immediate environment was driven merely by force of habit. (Green ML et al 1997). However, one physician in a rural practice did not mention consulting a colleague as his environment afforded him no such luxuries. However, he relied more on books, journals and the internet to keep update. All the other participants relied on all these too, to be sure, only that it was not their first choice. (Ibbotson T et al 1998). All medical practitioners regularly refer to books and medical drug references. Their main complaint as expressed earlier in this paper is the lack of up to date versions of these materials. This according to the participants in this study and other practitioners in general, gradually discourages them from using the materials to the extent that they end up relying mainly on their personal appraisal and judgment of situations and draw conclusions thereof, Jouriles NJ et al (1996). Another preferred method of quick consultation was the use of pictures as a means of confirming dermatological diagnosis. This method, together with the use of simulation videos is a much more enjoyable and practical way of keeping GPs updated. Though it has the limitation in terms of facts, a picture is a very effective way of accurately summarizing a medical or any other situation. Pictures pass information quickly and minute details are mostly portrayed in them. However, they may themselves encourage laziness in finding out more. Secondly, vivid as they are, they do not cover details such as what exactly the patient is feeling, the history of the development of the problem and the patient's general medical history. Such facts must just be found the same old hard way, through reading. (Landry FJ et al 1994). Computers and electronic sources proved to be an unpopular way of gathering information for 60% of the participants. An oft quoted reason for this, which also came up in the survey, is difficulty in finding the required information accurately and in sufficient quantities on the internet. Many practitioners regard the internet as time wasting, vast and complicated (Milne R et al 1995). Another problem with computer consultation is that after all the trouble in finding the information, one finds to his dismay that it is not immediately applicable to the immediate situation. On the contrary, those who have used these electronic sources regularly, including CD-ROM, praise them as a quick and efficient way of retrieving much needed information and prefer to use them instead of books and other sources. Just like in the case of personal consultation, force of habit is the main determinant here. (Wadland WC et al 1999). More participants also mentioned critical appraisal as being more useful than outright EBM methods since this was immediately and directly related to the problem at hand. As such 60% of the participants were found to use the method more regularly than EBM. Conclusion Whether, widely used by GPs in their day to day medical practice or not, EBM remains an integral part of medicine. (Audet N et al 1993). None of the physicians interviewed over the years has ever expressed any doubt whatsoever about the importance, usefulness and applicability of this method to their practice. (Burls A. 1997). What is required is an important and relevant frame of reference to implement the requisite changes that will enable the practice to thrive rather than be one of last resort as it is today. In implementing such changes the following factors must be put into consideration as the studies mentioned here and many others carried out show. (Green ML 2002). CME must continue to be carried out regularly, health policies must reflect the needs of GPs, networks must be established between practitioners and all efforts must be put in place to provide GPs with the up to date material they need to carry out their work. (Coomarasamy A, Khan KS. 2004). Above all, each and every stakeholder involved, including the media, consumer organizations, pharmaceutical companies and even patients must be coordinated in playing their roles effectively for the realization of this noble objective. References Academic Centre for General Practice, 1994 1Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Kapucijnenvoer 33 blok J, 3000 Leuven, Belgium Audet N, Gagnon R, Ladouceur R, Marcil M. How effective is the teaching of critical analysis of scientific publications Review of studies and their methodological quality. CMAJ 1993; 148(6):945-52. Barnett SH, Kaiser S, Morgan LK, et al. An integrated program for evidence based medicine in medical school. Mt Sinai J Med 2000; 67(2):163-8 Bazarian JJ, Davis CO, SpillaneLL, Blumstein H, Schneider SM. Teaching emergency medicine residents evidence based critical appraisal skills: a controlled trial. Ann Emerg Med 1999; 34(2):148-54. Burls A. An evaluation of the impact of half-day workshops teaching critical appraisal skills. Anglia and Oxford Region: Institute of Health Sciences, 1997:11-9. Coomarasamy A, Khan KS. What is the evidence that postgraduate teaching in evidence-* based medicine changes anything A systematic review. BMJ 2004; 329(7473):1017. Department of General Practice, 1994Universiteit Antwerpen, Universiteitsplein 1, 2610 Antwerpen, Belgium Department of Medical Sociology 1998, Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Laerbeeklaan 103, 1090 Jette, Belgium Department of Public Health, 1994 Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Laerbeeklaan 103, 1090 Jette, Belgium Elnicki DM, HalperinAK, Shockcor WT, Aronoff SC. Multidisciplinary support centered medicine periodical clubs: prospectus blueprint and contributors' responses. Am J Med Sci 1999; 317(4):243-6. Green ML., (2002) Graduate medical education training in clinical epidemiology, critical appraisal, and 'evidence-based medicine': a critical review, Oxford, Brisbane. Green ML, Ellis PJ. Impact of an evidence based medicine Curriculum based on adult learning theory. J Gen Intern Med 1997; 12(12):742-50. Ibbotson T, Grimshaw J, Grant A. Evaluation of a programme of work-shops for promoting the teaching of critical appraisal skills. Med Educ 1998; 32(5):486-91. Jouriles NJ, Cordell WH, Martin DR, Wolfe R, Emerman CL, Avery A. Emergency *medicine* journal clubs. Acad Emerg Med 1996; 3 (9): 872-8. Landry FJ, Pangaro L, Kroenke K, Lucey C, Herbers J.A controlled trial of a seminar to improve medical student attitudes toward, knowledge about, and use of the medical literature. J Gen Intern Med 1994; 9 (8): 436-9. Milne R, Donald A, Chambers L. Piloting short workshops on the critical appraisal of reviews. Health Trends 1995; 27(4):120-3. Physicians for the twenty-first century. Report of the Project Panel on the General Professional Education of the Physician and College Preparation for Medicine. J Med Educ 1984; 59(11 Pt 2):1-208. Wadland WC, Barry HC, Farquhar L, Holzman C, White A. Training medical students in evidence based medicine: a community campus approach. Fam Med 1999; 31(10):703-8. Wentz R. (2001), Modern Medical Practice, OUP, Oxford Read More