Our website is a unique platform where students can share their papers in a matter of giving an example of the work to be done. If you find papers
matching your topic, you may use them only as an example of work. This is 100% legal. You may not submit downloaded papers as your own, that is cheating. Also you
should remember, that this work was alredy submitted once by a student who originally wrote it.
This paper “Supplier Appraisal Engineers” critically assesses main engineering problems faced by supplier’s appraisal engineers. It will integrate such problems with common mistakes committed by suppliers and or contractors. It also provides the best solutions to the identified problems and mistakes…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
Student’s name
Course code+name
Professor’s name
University name
Table of Contents
1.0.Introduction 2
2.0.Engineering problems faced by supplier’s appraisal engineers 3
2.1.Supplier Infrastructure 3
2.2.Lack of performance measurements 4
3.0.Common mistakes from contractors and suppliers 6
3.1.Failing to measure and track cost of poor supply quality 6
3.2.Inadequate safety assessment process 6
3.3.Frequent Systemic Problems 6
3.3.1.Figure 2: Systemic Problem 7
4.0.Suggested solutions to the problems 7
4.1.Closed Loop Corrective Action 7
4.1.1.Figure 3: Closed Loop Corrective Action 8
4.2.Application of Supplier Scorecard 8
4.3.Supplier Audit 9
5.0.Reference 10
1.0. Introduction
Supplier’s appraisal engineers represent challenge for big organizations. That is, a company that needs to be considered for supply of commodities must be subjected to pre-qualification that ascertain whether all control frameworks are in tandem with expectations and thus covering all elements required in the new global standard for supplier governance. This is where supplier’s appraisal engineers come in. Unfortunately, in order to ensure the process of contracting and supplying comply with industry standards, these professionals face engineering problems that may affect quality of appraisal(s) given. In view of this, the essay critically assesses main engineering problems faced by supplier’s appraisal engineers. In so doing, it will integrate such problems with common mistakes committed by suppliers and or contractors. The conclusion will be provision of best solutions to the identified problems and mistakes as faced by engineers and committed by contractors.
2.0. Engineering problems faced by supplier’s appraisal engineers
2.1. Supplier Infrastructure
In the process of ascertaining whether a supplier qualifies, engineers face poorly integrated supplier infrastructure. Supplier infrastructure means the required tools and practices which that necessitate the process of supplying. A good example of a poorly integrated supplier infrastructure is lack of automated process. One of the key roles of supplier’s appraisal engineer is to track data management tools that can measure service and supplier performance. Therefore it becomes an engineering problem trying to audit a company that has poorly automated process as one of its infrastructure. The problem here is that the engineer will not be able to present quality metrics as relates to supplier performance to the contracting management team. In broadly speaking, when a supplier lacks proper infrastructure platform (automation), the engineer will not be able to ascertain the following;
a. Compliance: rating infrastructure of the supplier that can support scope of supply (like processes, systems, resources)
b. Performance: evaluation of elements such as quality, price and on-time deliveries
c. Criticality: engineer needs this to ascertain impact of supplier’s performance on the study chain
The figure 1 below represents risks that engineer may not be able to present to the contracting company incase suppliers have poorly integrated infrastructure.
2.2. Lack of performance measurements
One of the key roles of supplier’s appraisal engineers is to evaluate on behalf of the contracting companies, performance measurement of suppliers. However, one technical or rather, engineering problem that face supplier’s appraisal engineers is when suppliers do not have record of their performance measurement. Within the realm of supplier’s appraisal engineering, performance measurements mean assessment of the following;
a. Parts Per Million (PPM)
b. Quality Performance Measurement (QPM)
c. Plant Disturbance (PD)
To highlight the above terms, PPM means the efficiency of products or machines to be supplied. The value is calculated and reported to supplier quality management periodically. On the other hand, QPM means the engineer will be able to assess and calculate performance indicator based on a three month window. For engineer to report QPM to the contracting company, s/he will be able to calculate;
a. PPM for the most recent three month period
b. Actual number of non-conforming materials or products from the supplier and
c. Total number of inspection reports that have been issued during the three month evaluation period
Other than PPM and QPM, the engineer will also be able to evaluate the performance of the supplier. Therefore when a supplier or contracting companies do not have proper performance measures, supplier’s appraisal engineers will have the above levels of engineering problems that actually affect their operations.
3.0. Common mistakes from contractors and suppliers
3.1. Failing to measure and track cost of poor supply quality
Most contractors and or suppliers do not take initiative of recording or tracking Cost of Poor Supply Quality (COPQ) attributed to their goods. As earlier noted, when supplier’s appraisal engineers do audits of the supplier (source inspection) there is examination of customer-purchased product - performed at the supplier's facility which is meant to ensure there is product integrity and conformance to a given requirements. Unfortunately, Bill (2010) argues that most of suppliers fail to measure and track information provided by engineers thus failing quality management systems---they may not be able to track quality related issues.
3.2. Inadequate safety assessment process
One common mistake with suppliers and contractors is that some of them assume that it will be the responsibility of contracting companies to hire supplier’s appraisal engineers with technical knowledge to assess the building, product and the feasibility of the items to be supplied. However, it needs to be noted that these engineers are constantly needed to assess issues immediately affecting quality of items that can be supplied. Further to this, safety assessment process ensures development of the remediation plan by suppliers especially when engineering team revisits for a follow up.
3.3. Frequent Systemic Problems
Systemic issues in suppliers and contractors are, as a matter of fact, common across a number of organisations. These systemic issues are daily occurrence in operations thus limiting quality of items to be supplied. The table below has been developed to help explain some of the systemic problems and the percentage most organisations have failed to address.
3.3.1. Figure 2: Systemic Problem
Category of Systemic Problems
Percentage of Occurrence
Standardization (i.e. quality reaction plan, work instructions, process and quality control plan
30 percent
Tiered supplier management (supplier quality etc.)
45 percent
Operating training (inadequate regular training, certified workers, etc.)
23 percent
Maintenance programmes (inadequate of proactive maintenance, delayed reactive maintenance etc.)
24 percent
Source: Quality Focused Supplier Process Assessment for Supplier’s Appraisal Engineers
4.0. Suggested solutions to the problems
4.1. Closed Loop Corrective Action
Systematic drop in the Cost of Poor quality can be achieved through the implementation of a Quality Management System (QMS) which has an integrated and closed loop corrective action process. This is particularly a solution to the problem of Frequent Systemic Problems especially when there is nonconformance or deviations in standards of goods supplied. In addition, application of this corrective measure ensures that the process of supply becomes auditable by the engineers thus giving the organization a tool for continuous improvement. The diagram below shows how Closed Loop Corrective Action operates. It is also essential in providing answers to problems related to inadequate safety assessment process.
4.1.1. Figure 3: Closed Loop Corrective Action
Source: Learning to See by Mike Rother and John Shook
4.2. Application of Supplier Scorecard
Introducing supplier scorecards is an important step especially when it is designated to rank relative performance of the supplier within the supply base and tracking improvement in supplier’s quality after a given time. Since scorecards also provide the needed data point into any future of the contractor/supplier, it is a necessary tool for solving in situation where suppliers fail to measure and track cost of poor supply quality.
4.3. Supplier Audit
This process ensures that the supplier works with the procedure and process that the contracting parties agreed upon. The process of supplier auditing encompasses conformances in shipment process, engineering change process and quality process at the supplier. This is an effective solution for problems related with infrastructures.
5.0. Reference
Bill, C. (2010). How Delhi Helps Suppliers Develop a Quality Focused Culture. Marcus Chao, Supply Chain Management Review, January/February review.
Read
More
Share:
CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Supplier Appraisal Engineers
Thus before the determination of the salary structures they should have high level meetings and also conduct a proper performance appraisal for the... Most of the contract of employment of any company will clearly state that the salaries of that particular company are clearly set based on the local government salary scales....
Therefore, controlling materials procurement activities starting from the supplier warehouse through the delivery process until storage on construction sites is essential.... From a contractors view, a successful construction project is a project that accomplishes the clients required scope with the shortest possible time....
However, not many organizations usually share the problems that they face during performance appraisal sessions.... A study conducted by the Bureau of National affairs showed that in 244 organizations that were studied, 90 per cent of them conducted performance appraisal exercises every year.... With the rapid development of global economy in the past 20 years, performance appraisal has become a tool for increasing productivity among employees in organizations (Gruman and Saks, 2011: 123).
...
This sequence is comprised of the project managers, site engineers, suppliers, etc (mindrelief 2007).... For that reason, if a total infrastructure and facilities management (TIFM) solution is properly integrated within the organization, it could permit the proper appraisal of assets on whether they meet or exceed the company's present and future requirements (King 2006).... The installation of the control measures assist in the performance appraisal of any installed systems and components (mindrelief 2007)....
"Evaluation of the Effectiveness of Performance appraisal Strategies of Tesco Plc in the UK and Walmart in the US" paper evaluates the effectiveness of performance appraisal strategies used by a large global retail company, Tesco Plc in the UK, and one of the dominating companies in the Walmart.... The basic agenda of the paper is to critically evaluate the performance appraisal strategies operating in Tesco in the United Kingdom and Walmart in the United State....
The first creation of this effort at an engineering standard was printed by the Society of Motorized engineers (SAE) in October of1996 as ARD 9000.... As an implement for control, an appraisal, done internally or externally is designated.... The difficulty with flow down necessities and multiple appraisals had not lessened in the supplier public.... n 1995 numerous major airspace manufacturers, recognizing the need for unwavering supplier supplies, came together under the authority of ASQ and fashioned the (AAQG)....
The best supplier of the service is carefully identified.... This will include the right contractor or supplier.... The outcome of the project will be determined by the competence of the supplier or contractor to handle the project.... In most cases when the contractor or supplier does a sub-standard job then the cost of the project will increase.... It is therefore advisable to use the best channel and procedures when selecting a contractor or a supplier....
These departments include supplier appraisal, Purchasing, Materials, Quality and Expediting departments.... The supplier appraisal department failed in its application of the appraisal techniques.... t should be noted that material engineers have a great role to play in a company and in the procurement process.
... his is the main work of material engineers.... At the same time, it should be noted that the main differences between quality control and assurance engineers is that an assurance engineer is tasked on overall prevention of any quality issue, while a quality control engineer detects such flaws (Plummer, 342) ....
11 Pages(2750 words)Report
sponsored ads
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the coursework on your topic
"Supplier Appraisal Engineers"
with a personal 20% discount.