Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

The Concerns of the Management Team of All Star Industries - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
In the case study in question, it is easy to understand the concerns of the management team of All-Star Industries. The management’s fears of a public relations backlash are realistic, especially since organ transplant via dubious procurement channels throw up ethical and legal conundrums. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.9% of users find it useful
The Concerns of the Management Team of All Star Industries
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Concerns of the Management Team of All Star Industries"

Is it ethical or unethical to buy body parts? Would your view change if it was for yourself or a loved one? In the case study in question, it is easy to understand the concerns of the management team of All Star Industries. The management’s fears of a public relations backlash are realistic, especially since organ transplant via dubious procurement channels throw up ethical and legal conundrums. To be fair to Yvonne, she’s not done anything criminal. Every individual has a right to life, albeit within certain legal and ethical limits. And Yvonne has not brazenly or blatantly breached these limits, especially since the company has no written policy on organ transplants. Hence, it would be unfair to mark down Yvonne for any policy violation. Considering all the facts of the case, it is fairly clear that the potential public relations backlash that the management fears is purely their problem. Consequently, Yvonne is entitled to have a full refurbishment of costs for the surgical procedure. The suspicion that she may have acquired the kidney via unauthorized channels is again a problem for the regulators and policy makers, taking for granted the basic entitlement of a citizen to.
Looking exclusively at the issue of buying body parts, one can take guidance from principles of environmental ethics in ascertaining the legitimacy and ethicality of particular decisions. (Ashley, 2006, p.47) It is important to remember that regulating transplants and aiming to stamp out illegal trading in organs is the need of the hour, for this practice is seen as tainting medical standards and causing a shortage of donated organs for those most in need. Critics of the practice bemoan how transplant surgery in China has now become
“a cash cow, due to the rising trade in illegal organs and the fact that many hospitals offer the operations despite having staff who are poorly qualified to carry them out or inadequately supervised. The illegal organ trade has led to a severe shortage of donated organs, to the extent that it is estimated that only around 20,000 transplants can be carried out annually despite up to 2 million Chinese people needing these operations every year.” (Perspectives in Public Health, 2006, p.152)
Social class also plays a major role in who gets the transplant and who does not. For a Chinese company like All Star Industries, this is a sensitive issue, for despite all the genuine intentions behind approving Yvonne’s claim, they could be perceived as siding with the elite – an image that could damage their business prospects. Further, many foreigners from advanced nations also visit China for transplants as they “are far more affordable than prices for the same operations in Western Europe, thus pushing the poorer Chinese people (80% of whom have no medical insurance) still further down the queue”. (Gudorf & Huchingson, 2010, p.114) Hence, as things stand today, organ transplant operations in China do not satisfy all ethical imperatives. Yet, in the particular case of Yvonne, it would be unfair on part of the management to decline her medical claim.
Ashley, B. M., Deblois, J. K., & ORourke, K. D. (2006). Health Care Ethics: A Catholic Theological Analysis. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
Gudorf, C. E., & Huchingson, J. E. (2010). Boundaries: A Casebook in Environmental Ethics. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
Lock, M. (2002). Twice Dead: Organ Transplants and the Reinvention of Death. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
New Committee to Regulate Organ Transplants. (2006). Perspectives in Public Health, 126(4), 152. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“The Concerns of the Management Team of All Star Industries Essay”, n.d.)
The Concerns of the Management Team of All Star Industries Essay. Retrieved from
(The Concerns of the Management Team of All Star Industries Essay)
The Concerns of the Management Team of All Star Industries Essay.
“The Concerns of the Management Team of All Star Industries Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Concerns of the Management Team of All Star Industries

Management and the Cultural Industries

...of society including formalized and unofficial systems. (Davey) As culture is evolving constantly by the developments around the society, industries such as the media which include print, radio, television, music, entertainment among others represent the culture of a society and also influence it to a certain extent. These industries, that are known as cultural industries produce cultural texts, which are manifestations of the prevailing, culture for example ‘An American Brat’ by Bapsi Sidhwa is a book that represents the culture of Zoroastrians and how it is affected by moving to a Western country and integrating into a different cultural environment. Cultural...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Management and the Cultural Industries

...?Management and the Cultural Industries Is there still a place in the contemporary cultural industries for small, independent producers, or is it only possible for large conglomerates to compete effectively in today’s globalized cultural marketplace? What are the implications of your answer for cultural workers? With the advent of globalization all over the world, companies of all sizes have becoming competition for each other. The debate over the positive and negative effects of globalization is a hot topic for many individuals, agencies, organizations and government departments who find themselves in a position to defend or attack the current...
11 Pages(2750 words)Essay

The impact of Work environment on employees satisfaction in 5 star hotels in the USA

.... (Kamakur, Mittal, de Rosa & Mazzon, 2002; Gelade & Young, 2005). However, other scholars have suggested that job satisfaction and productivity are not related. Graham, H.T. & Barnnet, R. (1998) 1.4 Five star hotels in USA. The American hospitality industry is highly competitive. In recent times however, security concerns have shifted focus of industry movers. Currently, a more comprehensive strategy reviewing the various aspects of hotel management practices is required to ensure competitiveness. Studies have revealed that of all industries, hotels (especially five-star hotels) are most...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Team Management

...on the part of the work force. The numerous challenges organizations are faced with such as ; competitor activity and unfavorable business environment all play a very important role in determining the success of the organization. Of all resources an organisation has in its disposal none is perhaps as relevant and important to the success of the organisation than the human resources. Human resources if managed well hold the key to the success of the organization. According to Cranny, Smith, and Stone, (1992) human resources output is higher when the employee's function as a team than it is the case when employees function in their individual units. A synergetic effect...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

CLevel Concerns in IA Management

...hacked. At this point in time, our system administrator met with all information technology members in the organization and decided to implement a full-fledged policy to prevent such an incident from occurring again. Developing and Implementing the Policy The first step in developing the strategy was to take permission from the manager and gets the funds allotted. This is easily done specially after the incident as the managers wanted to regain the lost image of the organization due to breach in patient information which is a requirement in the medical profession. A security memorandum was issued in response to the incident detailing of how security will be managed in...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Memo: Advice for all team members

...WRTG 394 Team Members HERE July 28, 2009 Re: Advice for all team members to utilize WWW.CAREERBUILDER.COM After carefulanalysis of many different types of job search websites, it has been decided that is the most user friendly, provides the most accurate job search listings based on the search parameters entered online, and seems to reach a much wider reading audience than other websites. In terms of the website being user-friendly, everything on this website is very easy to locate, with very detailed headings, links, and other appropriate information which a user would expect in a job search site. Further, once the desired jobs have been identified, the structure...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Hospitality Management Industries

...Hospitality management industries Resort consumers are unique people with varied tastes and preferences and are an integral part of the tourism industry since they are known to be people who love finest hotels and restaurants, enjoy a spectrum of luxury resorts, diverse cultures and fine Eco-lodges.They are dynamic demographic, demanding , exploring and hoteliers must be alert and strive to meet the demands and needs of this segment. In the coming decade, the consumer will be looking for resorts encircled by attractions and tourist sites, shopping malls and entertainment joints, subjected restaurants and hospitals with highly qualified staff. In order to be relevant in the market in the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Hospitality Management Industries “The Whole World on a Plate” concept to run and manage their businesses. This paper, therefore, describes the various components of “The whole world on a plate” concept, and how it resonates with my personality. “The whole world on a plate” concept provides a strategy of pilling flavors from different ethnic communities onto a single plate (Enz 67). While many Americans still seek spicy food, it is a fact that the American cuisine taste has been significantly influenced by Old European cuisines like Greek, German, French and Scandinavian (Enz 67). This has led to greater popularity and recognition of many ethnic foods, in most American societies. About 75 percent of Americans is familiar with Indian soul food,...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Hospitality Management Industries

...s 14 December Hospitality Management Industries Isadore Sharp Isadore Sharp is a Canadian businessman knownfor his revolutionary ideas that he brought in the hospitality management industry. He is also the chairman of Four Season Hotels and Resorts which is a chain of five star luxury hotels, having its name in the list of Fortune 100. Isadore Sharp founded this company a long time ago in 1961 with a vision of operating a successful chain of five star luxurious hotels and providing quality services. His sparkling ideas about hospitality management revolutionized the hospitality management...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay


...high. On the other hand, when airlines have to exit the sector, they require writing down and absorb several losses. All these features make the airline industry cede authority to the consumers and thus, the power of buyers is moderate to high. Despite all, there is power of the supplier as there are only two major manufacturers of large commercial aircraft. In the case of a major accident, the structures of within the industry always tend to change. The airline industry is likely to undergo a technological revolution that will make air travel even safer. Normally, key aspects of the change may witness heavy investments from various...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The Concerns of the Management Team of All Star Industries for FREE!

Contact Us