Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Story Truth and Happening Truth in the Things They Carried - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
This essay is about the “Story Truth” and “Happening Truth” in The Things They Carried. In the entire Things They Carried book, the writer's approach is befuddling as there is no easy way of knowing fabricated and actual events. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Story Truth and Happening Truth in the Things They Carried"

Download file to see previous pages Of course, "happening truth" talks about the genuine occurrence and acts as the main foundation of the piece of literature. On the other hand, the "Story Truth" comes with an opposite perspective, which requires a different approach if you want to get the entire picture. It is the foundation or modeler of the "happening truth," which gives the writing the ideal oomph. Considering the writer's ingenious strategy in the "Story Truth" and "Happening Truth" in The Things They Carried Essay is somewhat perplexing, readers struggle to discover a distinction between the two. Fortunately, in certain areas of the book, Obrien unveils what most people are finding hard to discover, making it straightforward for the audience to connect and follow through. Although Obrien expresses his intent in different instances, readers sometimes, be blind to the true aspect. Hence, there is an excellent possibility for them, after conducting a thorough overview of the literature, to arrive at a completely different conclusion relating to the 'happening truth" and 'story truth." What is the dominant style in the books that makes it hard for the readers to grasp the true narrative? It is simple, "happening truth" is the actual occurrence, but as you know, a writer's take is essential. Therefore, there the "happening truth" compliments the "story truth" in every chapter. It is clearly evident that the "story truth" creates the foundation of the "happening truth." Every chapter possesses a unique perspective that contributes to the book's development. Therefore, Tim Obrien's genuineness concepts appear conspicuously ins some pages. You will notice such intensity in certain chapters of the book, mostly the one that narrates in detail about a true war narrative.  In the beginning, in the second chapter, Tim Obrien perplexes readers with his ingenious take on truth, whereby he mixes the true story with his creativity, and it is hard to tell the difference. What is happening here is that he talks about the happening in the real world and mixes it with his creative take about the narrative, which is a different truth. The entire chapter is mostly about Tim Obrien and Jimmy remembering their time and action during the war. The scene's theme is perfectly expressive of the intent as the duo is drinking and smoking while recollecting a long time ago. War Moments – Comprehending the Different Truths In a somewhat confusing take, Obrien starts narrating battle stories, chiming in, and talking about a particular narrative. For instance, he talks about Lavender's death as if he were there.  In some cases, as they talk, Tim Obrien and Cross take a different turn, making the audience fail to understand what is going on with their narration. Immediately they talk about one thing, and then they start on something else as if they are unrelated but share the same link. Such statements, alert the audience that both the character in the book and Tim are the same. Hence, the story comes out as realistic encounters that the writer experienced during the Vietnam war. This ideology becomes even more believable when at the culmination of the chapter, Obrien requests talks to jimmy about composing a book about their encounters. They joke about it with Jimmy telling Obrien to go ahead and write the book, making sure that he puts him in a good perspective. He even goes further requesting him to compose about their platoon. When reading the book from this conflicting perspective, it is clear that readers find it hard to distinguish between the "happening truth" and the "story truth." Tim Obrien makes it so believable, and the way he transitions between different realities makes it hard to pick instances of each genuineness. However, if you closely follow what is taking place in the piece of literature in every chapter, you will get the approach and know the ideal way to spot the difference. Any inexperienced reader will face a very hard time creating a distinction. Here's why:
  • There is an excellent chance that Jimmy met Tim Obrien; however, the writer might have altered certain facts to make the book interesting to the audience utilizing the "story truth."
  • There is a high possibility that Obrien might not recall everything he and Jimmy talked about that day. Therefore, Obrien might create something else that connects the dots and linking to the story to patch up loose elements in the narrative.
  • Additionally, Obrien might utilize this approach to make his narrative more enjoyable. As you read the first chapter, the author starts with the statement, "This is true," which is something that you ought to take great note of as you are going through the true war story text.
Obrien clearly states the true account of the story; however, in the ensuing paragraphs, when he talks about the essence of genuineness in war narratives, he creates conflict. According to him, everybody ought to hold a story with doubt and have a skeptical approach. Tim states that it is hard telling a true story, as in some cases, the war personality loses a sense of reality. Hence, they lose the sense of genuineness, meaning that whatever is mentioned as part of the battlefield story is hard to be completely accurate at all times. Such statements in this chapter make it harder for the audience to understand the reality of the story they are reading. If Obrien contradicts himself about the "story truth" and "happening truth," how can the reader pick the actual story and choose what to believe? Picking the Deeper Meaning in the Narrative If you select a deeper meaning, you will start to understand what is happening here. In essence, Tim is telling the audience about the real sense of "real truth" and "story truth" so that the reader can grasp the original concept and enjoy the battlefield story. It is hard for one to recall the actual genuineness during the war; one must create the perfect "real truth." Hence, since there is no way of giving the original course of events that happened, an author must come up with the "story truth" to conceal the loopholes of the story, and everything ought to connect perfectly well. It is hard realizing these instances of "story truth" until you have completed the novel, and that is the perfect depiction of a true masterpiece from Obrien. For example, in "The Man I Killed" chapter, the author takes the realness methodology to a whole new level, playing with the reader's mind, and one only realizes the two perspectives at the end of the chapter. The chapter's entirety contains exact (according to the author's descriptive words) definition, in great detail of a character leaving the reader to imagine. There is such great detail about the hair, face, mouth, ears, and other physical features that invoke the reader's senses, putting them in the right universe of the narrative out of imagination. And the way Tim remembers his dialogue between his platoon members is impressive. There is so much "story truth" and "real truth" perfectly integrated that everything falls in perfectly well. Obrien even composes his thoughts about a Vietnamese man before he killed him during the war. However, after a few chapters, Obrien comes clean about the actual genuineness, something exceptional in the entire text. In five simple words, 'It is time to be blunt…" and going ahead to give out a brief explanation, Obrien tells readers that whatever they have been reading has probably been invented. The writer tells the audience that the only genuineness is that he was there. And to the reader's surprise, Obrien never took part in any action, nor did he converse with any of his platoon members as described in the section. Even far much worse, Tim never killed any person. Why do you think Tim took this approach to tell the narrative? Is it not misleading? According to Obrien, he wanted any reader to feel what he felt. The entire narration is all about informing the audience of the relevance of the "story genuineness," which is superior to the "real truth." Tim was, at some point, a soldier and was in the battlefield for real. He experienced all the gore that comes with the battlefield, but since he was a young soldier, he was afraid to look.  Therefore, Tim's perspective of telling a compelling war story involves applying "story truth." Eventually, based on how perfectly narrated the entire book is, the "story truth" comes out even more true than the "real truth." And that is how Tim gets the readers to listen and get entertained. Whatever's going on in the novel The Things They Carried is an expression of Tim's love for the "story genuineness," which he perfectly depicts on his "telling the story" approach. ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(Story Truth and Happening Truth in the Things They Carried Essay, n.d.)
Story Truth and Happening Truth in the Things They Carried Essay.
(Story Truth and Happening Truth in the Things They Carried Essay)
Story Truth and Happening Truth in the Things They Carried Essay.
“Story Truth and Happening Truth in the Things They Carried Essay”.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Story Truth and Happening Truth in the Things They Carried

Truth In Storytelling: Embellishment vs. Actual Truth

... the audience. On the other hand, if he adopts the second method, he may not get that many liberties. In short, narration of actual truths with the help of embellishment will help the orator in communicating his ideas more strongly to the audience. While narrating an incident with the help of storytelling method, the storyteller will get continuity. Such continuity will never be observed if a person simply explains something he has observed or understood. “In every story the continuum keeps shifting between fatter and thinner. Furthermore, the factuality/imagination continuum is constantly on the move. It moves as the story moves, and it moves in our minds as we read or watch the story unfold” (O'Brien, The Things They Carried) “The problem...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay


... are perceptually aware of actual physical things, but 2) all experiences are experiences of mental representations. Justification and belief are not enough to make a premise true as mentioned earlier. This insufficiency results in the Gettier problem. Philosophers try to solve this problem for instance, some theorists suggest redefining reliability. Nonetheless, the state of the mind controls the senses in which case truth still relies on an individual’s perception, however, fallible. What then are universal truths? Are all human minds playing a universal trick? Truth is the relation between a thing, state of affairs and their supporting evidence. The statement made is as a result of thought and judgment which require logical constructs...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

TOPIC Option I----- Story Truth and Happening Truth ( Tim O'Brien----The Things They Carried )

... on the incidence and that O’Brien should not feel bad that he had killed but he does not give back any comment. This whole incidence displays an accurate true happening and thus, brings the feeling of sympathy to a reader, as one could feel the shock and the unbelief O’Brien had towards what he had done on taking another persons life. But the accurate thing about this incidence is that, he was there to witness the death of that soldier but he did not kill him. The story truth is that he had done the killing (O’Brien). O’Brien strongly conveys the fact that in wars, restrictions tend to be unclear until the order blend into disarrays, love into hatred, laws into anarchism and courtesy into savagery. The aspects of justice and beauty tend...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Truth Telling

...?Truth Telling Introduction Truth telling is a psychological concept that refers to the elimination of deceit in a conversation. It dictates that people do not withhold information from their partners during an interaction. This implies the avoidance of lying, misrepresentation, and deception during an interaction. Truth telling is a social virtue thus is a prerequisite to the creation of an ideal society. Everyone in a society must therefore learn to tell the truth at all times. However, this is not always the case as different scenarios present different diverse challenges thereby prompting people to reveal their facts sparingly. There are a number of disciplines that do not encourage lying. Such a discipline as medicine and its related...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

The things they carried

... The Things They Carried Considered as the combination of interconnected stories and a novel, Tim O’Brien’s “The Things They Carried” is a great fascination for book lovers, extracted from intricate traditions of literature. The author presents himself as a Protagonist based on complicated fiction in the form of an autobiography. To fully praise the quality of writing, the readers must first realize that the story is fictional rather than based on historical accounts (O'Brien, n.p.). The author, as a central character, is a veteran from Vietnam War. The major part of the book is concerned with the author trying to recall form the past some memorable events. The story presents a bunch of soldiers Rat Kiley, Lieutenant Jimmy Cross, Mitchell...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay


...Truth 'I am the Way, the Truth and the Life may be the standard answer one may expect from a priest when asked to define truth. Indeed, they may even go on to add that Jesus was truth personified and so we had the embodiment of truth walking on earth some 2,000 years ago requiring no definition or explanation. The matter though is older than 2,000 years and even though philosophers have been struggling with the meaning of truth since before Christ the word requires elucidation. The exposition of truth therefore may be as varied as our perception of it, owed in no small measure to our culture, background and surroundings. One might wonder what the truth was for Alexander the great when he set out to conquer the world For Socrates when...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Story-truth versus Happening-truth

...Story-truth versus Happening-truth Tim O'Brien, in his book, The Things They Carried, describes two different kinds of truth, story-truth and happening-truth. He describes story-truth something that "makes things present" (O'Brien 180). He describes happening-truth as reality, as what actually happened. However, for O'Brien, story-truth is more true than happening-truth, for several reasons. While happening-truth may be what literally happened at war, the fighting, the death, the destruction; it loses everything that makes it human to describe war that way. Story-truth, on the other hand, allows the listener to be there, with the narrator in the present, and see how things were. Story-truth allows for the emotion of war...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Truth and Truth-Telling

...Ethics- "truth and truth telling" In this chapter the gives importance to telling truth. Telling truth is tried to inculcate into each one of us even as a child. In the health care sector especially in the nursing profession the author emphases that truth plays a major part as it forms the trust that bonds the patient with the treatment. Trust plays a major role in patients' life as it is the only way that patient will be able to cooperate with the medical staff to perform treatment. For instance, the patient should be able to trust in the capability of the nurses that the medicines that are administered on them are correct. Trust is a mutual aspect. In many instances, the mutual trust is lost. For instancem the hospital management loses...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Diplomatic truth

... of the term diplomatese or the lingo and jargon of diplomacy. A non-diplomat untrained in an art that hides its message in plain language may have difficulty deciphering its actual message. In todays globalized environment, diplomacy acquires greater significance to impose order and avoid conflicts among various competing national interests along strategic issues like in trade or military considerations or in the scramble for scarce and declining resources. Discussion One baffling question is whether there is such a thing as “diplomatic truth” when the art of diplomacy requires and dictates that diplomats avoid harsh or direct language but still in diplomatic parlance deliver the message as intended that is well understood...
2 Pages(500 words)Coursework

Inconvenient truth

... Inconvenient truth Introduction In his prediction, Gore begins by describing the basics of how greenhouse effect works. He starts with a cartoon depicting rowdy global warming gases stopping Mr. Sunbeam from evading earth’s atmosphere. The accumulation of carbon IV oxide and other gases causes a coagulated atmosphere, hence it hinders the reflected long wave heat radiation from escaping to the atmosphere. These gases are produced from heavy machineries, factories and the general burning of fossil fuels. This causes an increase in the terrestrial temperature as a result of the reflected terrestrial heat failing to reach the far atmosphere, hence it is trapped to the earth’s surface due to failure of leaving the earth surface, which in turn...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Story Truth and Happening Truth in the Things They Carried for FREE!

Contact Us