StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Reading and thought - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
According to MacDonald, the "printed matter that inundates us daily" has been reduced to being reduced to being flimsy and overwhelming and the reading materials available in today’s modern society purports “shallow thinking” (MacDonald). This supported by Carr’s…
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98% of users find it useful
Reading and thought
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Reading and thought"

Teacher What is the nature of the "printed matter that inun s us daily," and what connection does this kind of reading have with thoughts? What do you think about the position he takes here? According to MacDonald, the "printed matter that inundates us daily" has been reduced to being reduced to being flimsy and overwhelming and the reading materials available in today’s modern society purports “shallow thinking” (MacDonald). This supported by Carr’s opinion that he could no longer read a book fully because he could no longer concentrate reading on the book blaming the blast of information brought about by information technology.

According to him, the “linear, literary mind” has become “yesterday’s mind” (Carr). In short, these assessments state that today’s reading materials are making our reading attention shorter and making us dumb. I disagree with these positions because they are an exaggerated and overstated assessment of today’s literature and “printed matters”. MacDonald and Johnson failed to recognize that while there are a lot of flimsy literatures available today, the mere availability of these information has empowered the modern readers today.

True, there are a lot of “flimsy” literature available today. But equally important also is that there is also an equal number of worthy and enlightening literature. The student or the reader will just have to make a wise choice of what sort of material he or she will read. The reader can choose to read the flimsy literatures as McDonald has described or the student can chose to read the useful literatures. Both materials are readily available to him or her. The reader can chose either to be become dumb by inundating himself or herself with flimsy and useless information or he or she can educate and empower himself by reading academic materials.

We can take this assignment for example where the student can do the research work right at the comfort of home and finish it accordingly without leaving home. The materials are readily available which could be accessed through Google and school library to complete the assignment. Of course, in the process of doing this assignment, there were also distractions such as visiting Facebook or Googling nonsense that could prevent completing the work. The student however has to make a choice. If the student will do the right decision, the assignment can be done in a breeze since everything is already at the disposal of the fingertips.

Unlike before, the choice to become smarter is not readily available. One has to physically go to the library and go over the books and journals which could take forever. The challenge was doubly hard because in addition to the usual distractions that haunts a teenager, there is also the inconvenience and limitation of the physical library (i.e. limited library hours, limited number of books that can be borrowed). So I disagree to the position of MacDonald that today’s literature are flimsy.

If he only went to the university today and he would realize how empowering technology is in the life of the student. Of course it could also be abused when not used properly.I also disagree with the position of Johnson that Google makes us dumb. On the contrary, I think it makes us smarter and more critical. Google is like fire it has no intrinsic value by itself. Its value depends on how the user will make of it. It is a tool that can be used either to foster stupidity as Johnson have described that would make us dumb, or it could also be a source of empowerment for the user by being a tool to make the needed information readily available.

Again, using this assignment as an example, Google served as an empowering tool to search those articles needed as an input for to complete the work. On the other hand, Google could also be used to search other dumb things that would distract from completing the work. Again, it is a matter of choice and Google is just a search engine, a tool whose value depends on how it is used. It also enables the student to develop a critical mind because it teaches us to evaluate which sources are valid and which are “flimsy”.

MacDonald and Johnson may be referring to the literature of the distant past where literature can generally be had through books, magazines and printed materials where most of the writings were given thought by their authors considering the high cost of print then. But those materials were not readily available and more often have to be unearthed in the library. Today, they are readily available if we wanted them but of course, together with other flimsy materials that inundates us. The key is, to choose critically which kind of information we are going to digest.

Works CitedDwight Macdonald. "Reading and thought"Carr. "Is Google Making Us Stupid?" Johnson. "Yes, People Still Read, but Now It"s Social" (Johnson 145-147)

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Reading and thought Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words, n.d.)
Reading and thought Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. https://studentshare.org/literature/1870129-reading-and-thought
(Reading and Thought Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
Reading and Thought Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/literature/1870129-reading-and-thought.
“Reading and Thought Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”. https://studentshare.org/literature/1870129-reading-and-thought.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Reading and thought

Thoughts on Reading/Writing Process

As far as reading and writing go, I typically need to find some place completely quiet in order to do so.... Most of the strategies in the book I already employed, though I didn't typically have a specific name for them and I never really thought to differentiate them in regards to my writing.... For instance, I never really thought about the term synthesis before reading the text, but upon doing so I definitely found it to be a technique that I employ....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Engaging the Mind Through Reading

In this essay, the author demonstrates how reading is one of the core skills that every growing child should have.... hellip; One of my favorites states that 'it is chiefly through reading that one enjoys intercourse with superior minds'.... This reading albeit for fun was quite instrumental in laying a foundation for more serious academic work as well as arming me with the knowledge that helped me make sense of the various issues I encountered in life....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Junk Food through Vending Machines at Schools

 This essay discusses systematically delve on the issue of the dispensing of junk food through vending machines at schools and its relationship to childhood obesity and the associated medical and social problems.... Childhood obesity is a very broad issue.... nbsp;… They also provide a learning laboratory to enhance the overall health and development of students, from learning how to socialize, to exercise, to nutrition (2011, p....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

M2a2 Leading through and beyond Change

Nevertheless it is also a fact that some time human being seeks changes and some time resists it.... It is true fact that society always looks for changes, and therefore queries such as when,… Now in the organizational perspective change serves as the method by which important amendments are addressed....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Secret Meaning of Art

There is a strong link between psychiatric disorder and artwork, in which talented artists can use art to communicate their emotional anguish to their clients, which help them to comprehend their problems and seek for solutions (Rustin 1).... Visual arts such as paintings from… Historically, many artists used paintings to portray suicide, with Pieter Breughel, who produced paintings depicting the suicide committed by Saul in the bible being 0 The Secret Meaning of Art There is a strong link between psychiatric disorder and artwork, in which talented artists can use art to communicate their emotional anguish to their clients, which help them to comprehend their problems and seek for solutions (Rustin 1)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Reading through the Self-assessment

The paper "reading through the Self-assessment" highlights that reading through the self-assessment essay reminded me of how my determination helped in establishing fundamental better performance.... reading through the self-assessment provides an insight into personal strengths that need to have before taking an online course....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Society through the Lens: Where It Heading

In the essay “Society through the Lens: Where It Heading?... rdquo; the author evaluates the abundance of new media platforms, which means quite a high integration and transformation in the field of photography in terms of educating the people and informing them of what is happening in the surrounding environment....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Management Through Leading and Creating an Environment

The paper describes the basic difference between a leader and a manager that is within their working domains.... They are doing the same job of managing people but in different capacities.... Whereas the leader looks at forming instructions of his own which he will forward to the middle management....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us