Guilty Until Proven Innocent - Essay Example

of the of the Concerned English Literature ic and Modern) 30 January Guilty Until Proven Innocent The biggest error of the police was to frame Biff Barnes as being guilty of committing the bank robbery, because a systematic deconstruction and reverse engineering of the chain of events and incidents that led to the identification of Barnes as being the primary accused, by Justice Joe Gamboni, established beyond doubt that their existed ample discrepancies and errors in the trail that led to the labeling of Barnes as the culprit.

First and foremost, the detectives resorted to an inordinate delay in the questioning of the prime witnesses, as mentioned in the article. Commonsense well corroborates the fact that human memory and perception, irrespective of all the notions of surety and solidity attributed to it, is actually a very fragile entity, which is prone to condense around the most dominant opinion in case of an extended time lapse. This is what happened in Barnes’ case. As mentioned in the article, all the prime witnesses held divergent opinions regarding the salient attributes that led to his identification, are they his height, or the logo on his ball cap.

Above all, all the witnesses failed to identify the scar on Barns’ face. The result was that the long ignored memory of the witnesses led to the consolidation of their opinion around the images projected on their mind by the media and the police. So, conclusively, the identification of Barnes was inherently flawed and erroneous. There is no denying the fact that to a large extent this incident is closely akin to writing a good essay because it has all the essential ingredients of a good essay that are a systematic, organized and logical line of causation giving way to an organic whole, a smooth chain of analysis with one theme seamlessly and unobtrusively flowing into and leading to the other, ample ingenuity and original thinking eventually culminating into a valid, well thought out and well expected conclusion.

It is obviously clear in the given article that the theme for the acquittal of Barnes is served before the readers, right in the very first paragraph, which is “identity is the main issue.” In the rest of the article, the writer builds on this theme by unraveling layer after layer of flaws inherent in the identification of Barnes as the culprit, are they his height, or the ball cap donned by the robber or the scar on Barnes’ face. Definitely, the writer took ample care to prop up his line of reasoning by referring to the related issues like the influencing of the witnesses by the “Crime Stoppers bulletins”, or the unwarranted delays in the questioning of the witnesses by the detectives.

This eventually led to a text that is well integrated and whole, logically relevant, creatively rich and well placed in its conclusions. Certainly, the narration of this incident in the given article is aptly suitable to be classified as a good and well wrote essay. Works Cited The Leader-Post article attached with the instructions.