Nobody downloaded yet

The Use of Lurking Doubt Test - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Use of Lurking Doubt Test" highlights that consigning the test to history would override the experience of the trial and appeal judges and vest authority only on the jury in the case. This could lead to serious miscarriage of justice as indicated by the various appeals…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.8% of users find it useful
The Use of Lurking Doubt Test
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Use of Lurking Doubt Test"

Download file to see previous pages Some events indicate that the court has more power and can take into consideration some actions of the Court of Criminal Appeals. One of the residual actions that the Court of Criminal Appeals is the ability to reverse a conviction based on lurking doubt. This residual power is explained in R. v B. (2003),2 where it is stated that;
“... there remains in this court a residual discretion to set aside a conviction if we feel that it is unsafe or unfair to allow it to stand. This is so even when the trial process itself cannot be faulted”.3
An analysis of the statement of the court indicated above reveals that the court is saying that, even if the law dictates the court’s jurisdiction, the court can still access residual parts of its jurisdiction dictated by the statute. The issue of lurking doubt was first brought to light by Lord Widgery in Regina v Cooper (1969),4 wherein the interest of criminal practice, stated that the court has, within, its powers, the right to interfere with a jury’s working even if the trial has been impeccably conducted. In Regina v Cooper (1969),5 it is evident that every issue in the trial had been placed to the jury, and the court was not willing to interfere in the verdict. Lord Widgery stated that any court must realize the advantage that the jury possesses in hearing, seeing and analyzing the witnesses and material presented to them, so the court should take serious consideration before interfering in the verdict. However, until the Criminal Appeals Act (CAA) 19666 was passed, it was uncommon to find a court interfering in a jury verdict.
But after the passing of CAA 1966, the court is now vested with the power of allowing an appeal against a conviction if the court feels that the jury’s verdict should be discarded on the basis that the case is unsafe or not acceptable or does not satisfy all conditions. Lord Widgery (1969) stated that a court must leave the objective part of a case and take a subjective measure to the case analysis.  ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Use of Lurking Doubt Test Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words, n.d.)
The Use of Lurking Doubt Test Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1780914-appeals-of-an-otherwise-unmeritorious-nature-are-allowed-by-the-court-when-it-allows-appeals-uses-the-lurking-doubt-test-and-the-test-should-therefore-be-consigned-to-history-discuss
(The Use of Lurking Doubt Test Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
The Use of Lurking Doubt Test Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1780914-appeals-of-an-otherwise-unmeritorious-nature-are-allowed-by-the-court-when-it-allows-appeals-uses-the-lurking-doubt-test-and-the-test-should-therefore-be-consigned-to-history-discuss.
“The Use of Lurking Doubt Test Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1780914-appeals-of-an-otherwise-unmeritorious-nature-are-allowed-by-the-court-when-it-allows-appeals-uses-the-lurking-doubt-test-and-the-test-should-therefore-be-consigned-to-history-discuss.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Use of Lurking Doubt Test

Compare Movie Doubt with the Novel Doubt

...?Doubt Order No. 518720 The movie Doubt and the play differed from each other in more ways than one. Some of the general difference we find in ‘A Parable’ and ‘Doubt’ the movie is that the script of the play is more direct and more compact as when compared to the script of the movie Doubt. The movie script was expanded to accommodate more characters and sub- plots. The cinematic visuals component as demanded by the movie was incorporated into the script. A play requires greater immediacy of action and more emphasis is laid on the tension of the dialogue. In ‘Doubt: A Parable’ these components are very articulate and emphatic. In the movie...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper

Doubt

...?‘DOUBT A parable’ by John Patrick Shanley, unfolds through its key character Sister Aloysius, the principal of Saint Nicholas School. The other three characters; Donald Muller, Mrs. Muller; Father Flynn and Sister James who are subjected to the suspicion of Sister Aloysius serves a medium for the audience to be revealed with the key theme of the play. The storyline of the play is that of a very strict principal doubting over something dubious in the relationship between Father Flynn and Donald Muller, the only black student of the school. Sister James is portrayed as a character that is very submissive to the principal. The play has utilized many symbols to represent certain elements which either...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

The issue of lurking doubt

...Lurking Doubt Test Appeals of an unmeritorious are only allowed by the court when it allows appeals using the lurking doubt test, so the test should be consigned to history. In law, miscarriage of justice in a court of law can usually be corrected by an appellate court if it is decided that the judge can review the evidence and give credence to luring doubt in a conviction or otherwise. From an analysis of Section 2 of CAA 1968,1 it can be deduced that the Court of Appeal is a statutory body and should not at any time go beyond its mandate of a statutory jurisdiction. However, some...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Descartes' Doubt

...) and include feelings and sensations (Aune, 2013). Descartes recognises that sensations are involuntary thus some external world exists. Descartes attributes sensations to corporeal substance or some other created substance. He tries to explain that all beliefs about the external world are doubtful since they come through senses (Aune, 2013). Exposition Descartes starts his first meditation by doubting all falsehoods he has believed as truth during his life. He acknowledges that he has learned through senses and senses can be deceiving. Descartes also claims that things that seem perfect like geometry and arithmetic may be mistaken since an evil genius deceives us (Aune, 2013). In the...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Doubt

...’ by Patrick Shanley has also used women’s powerful intuition to raise doubts against a catholic priest who is suspected of child molestation. Both the books posit the importance of women’s view and reveal their innate desire to expose the injustices of the society which thrives on patriarchal social structure. ‘A Jury of Peers’ is a murder mystery where wife of murder victim is the main suspect. The Sheriff and County Attorney go to Mrs. Wright’s home to look for clues and evidences that could help solve the case. Sheriff’s wife and Mrs. Hale go with them to collect personal items for Mrs. Wright who is in the custody of local authority. Both the women go to the kitchen and look for things that could...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Doubt Movie

..."Doubt" Doubt (2008), a gripping film adaptation of John Patrick Shanley's stage play Doubt: A Parable, deals with the story of a priest accused of having a reprehensible relationship with a Catholic school student. Written and directed by Shanley, the film stars Meryl Streep, Philip Seymour Hoffman, Amy Adams, and Viola Davis and their performance was highly appreciated at the international level. Whereas the themes and casing of the film have contributed to the success of the film at the international level, Doubt has been more of a film of strong Catholic interest and the movie has a great relevance in the background of the contemporary Church experience of sexual...
4 Pages(1000 words)Movie Review

Lurking in the shadows

...Grandfather's Porch: A Descriptive Essay The wooden porch creaks, I stop the sway of the splintered old chair in which I had been rocking so absently-mindedly, and the fawn that I have been watching scampers between the doe's steady legs. It is early morning, the scattered clouds overhead are as white as a baby's bottom, and the rays of the penetrating sun spew scattered patterns on nature's floor. The bite of the breeze is temperate, cooler than cold, and the occasional passing of the clouds allows my body a frequent enough warming of the skin. My mood contrasts sharply with the more visible trepidation of doe and tender fawn. I am relaxed, away for a few days from any responsibility save peering into nature from the back... Porch: A...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Doubt script

...Doubt Full The proposition of the play is that, even in the most sacred walls of priesthood and nunnery, doubt is present. However, this doubt is not only about the trust people could give to the sovereign God who is preached in the church but that which exists among men who should be a model of faith and good examples as in the case of sister Aloysius’ doubts toward father Flynn. 2. The exposition begins by presenting the nun as a strict person in contrast to the other characters and develops the story from their natures, affecting their reactions. For instance, the innocent young nun, sister James is too trusting and easily convinced while sister Aloysius is quite her...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Doubt

...and the conservative Sister Aloysius; Irish students and black students; and the guilty and innocent Father Flynn. These are instances which are very important in the play because they help in promoting the development of the plot and thematic concerns. For instance, by comparing the guilt and innocence of the priest, the play brings out Sister Aloysius as a very suspecting and doubtful character that can not actually make a concrete decision based on the ‘allegations labeled against the priest’ (Brantley). Just like her, the audience is left wondering about the actual truth about this matter. Question 2 In my own imagination, I think the best word to use to describe Father Flynn is shrewd. Although...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

The use of undrained triaxial test

...The use of undrained triaxial test Abstract The major purpose of the report was to explore the use of undrained triaxial test on studying the mechanical properties of soil. In studying deformable solids, such as soil, the need for triaxial test arises especially when measuring the mechanical properties. In which case the method is used to determine the apparent cohesion and shearing angle resistance of the material. Achieving the objective of the lab called for the need of finding initial stability of a footing on soil by the help of undrained test. There was increase effective stress as the stain on the soil was...
3 Pages(750 words)Lab Report
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Research Paper on topic The Use of Lurking Doubt Test for FREE!

Contact Us