StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Nobody downloaded yet

Women and Law - Infanticide and Forced Caesareans - Assignment Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
This paper "Women and Law  - Infanticide and Forced Caesareans" focuses on the fact that George Burrows put forth the proposition that there exists a connection between the functions of the brain and the uterine system. He states that the interruption in one process may interfere with the other.  …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.4% of users find it useful
Women and Law - Infanticide and Forced Caesareans
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Women and Law - Infanticide and Forced Caesareans"

Download file to see previous pages Ethical issues are posed in this connection, especially in the violation of a woman’s fundamental right to autonomy in her reproductive decisions, which has been guaranteed under Articles 8 and 12 of the European Convention of Human Rights and incorporated into the UK law through the Human Rights Act of 1998.

The first forced caesarean section in Britain was sanctioned by the High Court in 1992. Subsequent petitions were made on an emergency basis, against the women’s wishes, when the lives of the fetuses were perceived to be in danger. As Dyer reports, one of the women had a history of psychiatric treatment but did not have any mental disorder, while there was no question at all about another woman’s mental competence1. Yet the High Court allowed the caesareans to be performed, overriding the wishes of the women. In the two cases reported by Dyer, the question of the mental competence of the women was questioned by the judges, who concluded that the pain and stress of labour had prevented the women from weighing all their choices and making an informed decision which could be relied upon and on this basis, the caesareans were authorized.

Another unusual case that involved the question of the autonomy of a women’s right to refuse treatment was that of Dolan B, Parker C, Bewley S, Whitfield A, Bastian H, Conroy C. Tameside and Glossop Acute Services Trust v CH (a patient).2 In this case, there was a conflict between the ethical duty as perceived by the doctors to save the fetus which was in a critical situation against the mother’s express wishes. The right to perform a forcible caesarean was granted by the Court under the Mental Health Act, rather than falling under the purview of common law where the free will consent would have been vital.

This decision in the Glossop case and the sanction of the Court provided under the Mental Health Act has been criticized as overriding a woman’s right to decide on the kind of obstetric care that she may wish to receive.     ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Women and Law - Infanticide and Forced Caesareans Assignment, n.d.)
Women and Law - Infanticide and Forced Caesareans Assignment. https://studentshare.org/law/1705798-women-and-law
(Women and Law - Infanticide and Forced Caesareans Assignment)
Women and Law - Infanticide and Forced Caesareans Assignment. https://studentshare.org/law/1705798-women-and-law.
“Women and Law - Infanticide and Forced Caesareans Assignment”. https://studentshare.org/law/1705798-women-and-law.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Women and Law - Infanticide and Forced Caesareans

Forced Marriages and UK Law

... the law was a criminal law. As such, it is quite difficult for people to come forward and provide information about their family members in forced marriage cases. However, the issue of forced marriages is causing a lot of problems for people. It is causing hardships and people, particularly women are enduring a lot of inhumane treatments due to it. In the same study by Dr. Gill, six of the 20 victims agreed that criminalising forced marriages would create awareness and encourage the protection of victims. Thirdly, perpetrators of forced marriages deserve to be punished. If the law on forced marriages is criminalised, most people will get their due punishment and they will be deterred from trying it on other people. Also, this will protect...
16 Pages(4000 words)Essay

Women forced into prostitution

... of the of the Submitted Women Forced into Prostitution Introduction Every few minutes, some unfortunate woman becomes a victim of prostitution, somewhere in the world. This is almost always without her consent, for no self respecting woman would want to sell her body to an unknown man or have her honor laid bare for all to see. Research in many parts of the world has shown that women are most usually tricked into a life of prostitution and servitude. It is a life no one wants, for it brings shame, disrespect and dishonor not only to the woman concerned but also her family (Troubnikoff, 27). In fact, few self respecting individuals would want to associate with her. Not only does prostitution affect her physically, but women are also shown...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

American Independence Forced Founders

... Introduction It is apparent that there were many reasons why Virginia’s chose independence among them being political and economic gains. However, although the economic gain is seen to have been the primary driving force for the independence, it is evident that there was more than meet the eye, which in this case is the political gain. This is arguably true because with British being involved in matters of American independence and from whom entrepreneurs such as Jefferson relied on in conducting their businesses, it is apparent that the whole process of seeking independence was instigated by politics. In fact, Holton, (1999) argued that the ability of such gentlemen to profit from the sale of western land partially relied...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Women and The Law

... Women and The Law June 5, Final Paper: Three Articles Article The Opt-Out Generation Wants Back In Explanation on How the Topic Relatesto a Subject Discussed in Class The topic presented in the article entitled “The Opt-Out Generation Wants Back In” written by Warner relates to the topic discussed in class particularly in terms of the effect of staying at home of previously working mothers on the income of the family; the roles that continue to be played, especially in sharing the household chores; as well as in these women who opted –out while in the apex of their professional careers, only to find out that returning is more challenging and provides significantly lower income than what they used to receive before the crossroads...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Women and the Law

Furthermore, Section 2 of the Street Offences Act 1959 provides that where a woman is cautioned by a constable, in respect of her conduct in a street or public place, that if she persists in such conduct it may result in her being charged with an offence under section one of the Act, the woman, within fourteen clear days afterwards, must apply to a magistrates' court for an order directing that there is to be no entry made in respect of that caution in any record maintained by the police of those so cautioned and that any such entry already made is to be expunged. The court will make the order unless satisfied that on the occasion when she was cautioned she was loitering or soliciting in a street or public place for the purpose o...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Forced Segregation

... Massive Resistance and the People's Response to Forced Segregation The 1950s witnessed growing activism in the civil rights movement and the escalation of the hostilities on both sides of the issue. In 1954 the US Supreme Court, in the landmark case of Brown v. Board of Education, ruled that segregated schools were in violation of the US Constitution. Racist factions throughout the South organized to oppose school integration. Under a movement that became known as 'Massive Resistance' (a play off the Civil Rights slogan of 'Passive Resistance') business and political leaders across the South maneuvered to block the integration of the public schools. By confronting the injustice and potential violence, African-Americans organized...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Women in law enforcement

According to (Jon Felperin, 2005) in 1845, the first women to be hired by the New York City Police Department were called "matrons." In 1985, Penny Harrington of the Portland Oregon Police Department became the first female Chief of Police, Today, once the last bastion of male domination in the workplace, police organizational attitudes are finally beginning to change. And yet serious problems still remain.
In 2004, women accounted for only 12.7 percent of all sworn law enforcement positions in large agencies and the numbers are declining. The percentage of sworn female officers in smaller agencies is even lower in spite of women comprising at 46.5 percent of the entire labor force.
There could be many possible reasons fo...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Abortion and Infanticide

...Abortion and Infanticide In this article, Tooley, tries to defend the basic moral principal which specifies that an organism should posses a condition so that the organism becomes eligible for a serious right to life. As is depicted by the arguments proposed to defend the point of view the writer belongs to liberal group and he has really tried to force to accept his arguments. As he mentioned in the very first sentences that “one is forced to conclude that these practices are normally accepted…”, in these sentences, though he uses the word force to be incorporated based on arguments but throughout in his article he forced the reader to accept his arguments based on intuition less and power more. Abortion is immoral if we accept...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Forced Migration

A major reason that has intensified forced migration is the international terrorism which is being driven by certain religious ideologies.  For instance, the notorious organizations like the Al- Qaeda and Taliban which have targeted the conversion of entire world in to Islam, consider all other religious groups as their foes.  This Spiritual Terrorism addresses itself as Jihad.  Although they are against all governments, their major concern seems to be the United States of America and some other European nations that have a colonial or imperial history. The global terrorism has left far reaching consequences on the social, moral and economic areas of the present world. People suspect the members of other ethnic g...

6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Primate Infanticide

...Primate Infanticide Primate Infanticide Primate infanticide has overtime been one of the most controversial s in theworld of anthropology. This is because anthropologists have provided contrasting information in regard to whether the practice is simply a male reproductive strategy or is a pathological behavior, compelled by the high population of primates. This essay aims to analyze the two hypothesis above, and establish that indeed the practice is as a result of the sexual behavior of primates. According to ethologists who study animal behavior, primates have the habit of staying in groups, for that makes it easier for them to acquire food and at the same time identify and evade any source of potential danger. Primate infanticide...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Assignment on topic Women and Law - Infanticide and Forced Caesareans for FREE!

Contact Us