StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Killing Torture Idealism: Logos in Intuition and Pathos in Counter-Aesthetics of Torture - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The paper describes the  most effective way of contesting torture idealism, it is a combining pathos and logos appeals through the “Ancient Empiric” and “The Counter-Aesthetics of Torture” because they can show that torture is ineffective in generating truthful confessions and that it is dehumanizing, not only to the tortured and torturers but to the general public who condones it…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.5% of users find it useful
Killing Torture Idealism: Logos in Intuition and Pathos in Counter-Aesthetics of Torture
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Killing Torture Idealism: Logos in Intuition and Pathos in Counter-Aesthetics of Torture"

Killing Torture Idealism: Logos in “Intuition” and Pathos in “Counter-Aesthetics of Torture”
Many people want to be seen as humane, however, Brent J. Steele asserts in “The Insecurity of America: The Curious Case of Torture’s Escalating Popularity” that the same people may also believe in torture idealism. Torture idealism refers to beliefs that romanticize torture because of the perception that it can attain “accurate information” and that it relieves anxiety over the imagined “ticking time bomb” (Lafayette presentation, April 23, 2015). Steele provides four micro political tactics that challenge the torture logic. The most effective way of contesting torture idealism would be combining pathos and logos appeals through the “Ancient Empiric” and “The Counter-Aesthetics of Torture” because they can show that torture is ineffective in generating truthful confessions, and that it is dehumanizing, not only to the tortured and torturers, but to the general public who condones it.
The “Ancient Empiric” or “Intuition” of Tortured Confession is effective because it appeals to human logic regarding the ineffectiveness of torture in generating valid confessions. It asserts that torture may get the fastest confession from tortured individuals, but this confession may not necessarily be true or accurate. “Intuition” means that people will say anything to stop the torture. Indeed, if surveyed people themselves experience torture, what would they do? Their intuitive response is to agree to anything they are accused of doing to stop the pain and save their lives (Lafayette presentation, April 23, 2015). Jesse Ventura, a political Independent, gives an example: “You give me a waterboard, one hour and Dick Cheney, and I will have him confess to the Sharon Tate murders” (Steele 2013: 186). If torture does not produce truthful confessions, then it is not a valid way of getting the truth. Torture idealism opposes the empirical reality that torture does not produce relevant results (Steele 2013: 185). Logos, however, may not completely convince people in challenging torture logic, so a pathos appeal remains necessary.
“The Counter-Aesthetics of Torture” appeals to the imagination of the public regarding the dehumanizing process and outcomes of torture. It asserts that, if people only saw and heard what torture actually looks like; they will realize its immorality and ineffectiveness. The government does not release photos of torture and did not punish Jose Rodriguez, the CIA agent who destroyed the 92 tapes of interrogations of terrorist suspects Abu Zubaydah and Abd al-Rahim al-Nashiri, because they will reveal how horrific torture is (Lafayette presentation, April 23, 2015). These images will counter the image of torture as something acceptable because it will divulge the “blunt description of the reality of the torture chamber itself, and the (in)validity and (un)reliability of the confessions such torture produces” (Steele 2013: 189). People learn to accept torture from watching 24 and a decades-old program that aims to avert soldiers from providing false confessions, if ever they were interrogated, because they produce “image interdependence,” which happens when people become more sensitive and vulnerable to insecurity due to re-presentations of violence that constantly bombard them in the media (Lafayette presentation, April 23, 2015). If these images are so powerful in creating torture idealism, images of “The Counter-Aesthetics of Torture” can effectively undermine it. These images will horrify people and shake them into saying “no” to torture because they do not want it to represent who they are.
Others might assert that torture idealism has been embedded too deeply already into American politics and the public imagination that it cannot be easily challenged. They forget that this idealism lacks logic because it contains more pathos than logos and it portrays trust in politicians’ ethos. If the public and politicians will know how illogical and immoral torture is, they will increasingly change their torture-approving mindset. They shall come to develop a new understanding- that torture is so inhumane that it challenges the personal and collective identities of those who see and hear what it is and how it happens. Hence, the “Ancient Empiric” and “The Counter-Aesthetics of Torture” can be effective means of killing torture idealism because it weakens image interdependence and strengthens the logic and pathos against torture. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Killing Torture Idealism: Logos in Intuition and Pathos in Counter- Essay”, n.d.)
Killing Torture Idealism: Logos in Intuition and Pathos in Counter- Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1691280-can-the-writer-help-me-decide
(Killing Torture Idealism: Logos in Intuition and Pathos in Counter- Essay)
Killing Torture Idealism: Logos in Intuition and Pathos in Counter- Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1691280-can-the-writer-help-me-decide.
“Killing Torture Idealism: Logos in Intuition and Pathos in Counter- Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1691280-can-the-writer-help-me-decide.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Killing Torture Idealism: Logos in Intuition and Pathos in Counter-Aesthetics of Torture

Torture

...? 24 February, Torture and its psychological aspect: The term “torture” has been derived from “torquere” which is a Latin term that means to twist (Gushee). Torture is the name of extreme mental or physical suffering that is inflicted upon an individual so that he/she may be intimidated, punished, or be made to make a confession for the presumably committed crime. Definition of torture offered by the United Nations Convention Against Torture and other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (UNCAT) is, by far the most comprehensive and widely used definition. The definition also mentions several ways and reasons for which people may be tortured. It is as follows: …‘torture’ means any act by which severe pain or suffering...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Torture

... throngs of people to witness various acts of violence as part of their leisure activity. Wallace Hadrill, explored this in his investigation of the Roman Empire, wherein it was posited that the torture of people was an offshoot of a slave society wherein humans are owned like properties and could be used and abused at will. The way torture became some form of national sport in the Roman world is best exemplified by the gladiatorial contest, for whom, the magnificent coliseums were built. The brutality that came with forcing men to kill other men or men to fight beasts was supposed to be a necessary part of the system that dominated the Roman society. Using torture and public execution served a lot of purposes for the Romans, and surely...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Torture

... caper is to provide a refreshing and detailed insight on torture - what it feels like first-hand from the point of view of an objective observer. The media has been the main source of our information on the subject and people - whether consciously or subconsciously - are averse to believing everything that has been reported so far. This reference is a credible and unique evidence to achieve and strengthen pathos in the way that the paper presents its case. A Necessary Evil Out of all the drumbeating against torture, there are sectors that are actually in favor of it or at least sanctioning it up to a certain degree. Michael Levin, for instance, believes that there are times when it is morally mandatory. He cited several scenarios...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Medical Torture

This was essentially the same debate that existed in Britain during the nineteenth century on vivisections (Miller 334). If the prisoner dies from taking the herb medicine, then that herb plant or its active ingredients can be eliminated from the list of possible medicinal drugs from the list kept by the imperial doctors. If the prisoner gets well, then that herbal concoction gets examined for its other healing properties and included in that precious list. Ancient Chinese medicine could be cited here as an example of medical practices that may have bordered on the unethical if it is considered within today’s stricter context in bio-ethics. Acupuncturists could not gain much knowledge about the human body without using live human...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Prisoner Torture

For criminal investigators dealing with cases such as homicide or terrorism plot, properly interacting with witnesses and suspects is essential to unearth the truth. Interrogating subjects like juvenile require special sensitivity. As a result, successful investigators must be resourceful and good in communication. They must be strong in ethics and compassionate. An investigation to uncover misuse of information by a chief executive of a company to buy shares (insider trading) is quite different from a case of suicide or homicide. Despite the fact that over the years, the field of investigation has branched into many specialized parts, the basic rules of good investigations and desired qualities of good investigators are universa...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper

Torture

... – capable of killing and injuring a huge number of civilians (Dershowitz 259). The grave moral dilemma here is whether the captured terrorist should be subjected to torture in order to disclose the location of the device or the bomb to be allowed to explode and kill perhaps thousands of people because of legal and moral considerations. In other words, the safety and security of a nation’s citizens must be weighed against the preservation of human rights, which engenders a choice between one evil or another (Dershowitz 266, 272). While both Dershowitz and Scarry agree that the ‘ticking bomb’ scenario is a rather hypothetical situation, they consider its implications for the individuals and institutions involved, as well as for the society...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Torture

...Torture Our country is no stranger to torture. America is a country of two distinct narratives. The first narrative, ideals of justice, therules of law, and respect for human dignity, are intertwined throughout our Constitution and history. The second is a historical narrative of torture and disregard for the humanity of others, proven by the attempted genocide of Native Americans and the enslavement and segregation of Black Americans. In post-9/11 America, the controversial topic of torture has become a significant ethical issue that has created much debate. On one side of this national issue are those who believe that torture is necessary and justifiable to safeguard the lives of innocent people. On the other side are those who believe...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Ethos, Logos, Pathos

...Ethos, Logos and Pathos Ethos, Logos and Pathos Braet (1992) asserts that whilst giving speeches, people employ the use of different argumentation theories for the purposes of developing relevant and specific concepts. On this basis, Aristotle argues that through ethos, logos, and pathos, speech creators always ensure that they appeal to audience. In a bid to establish a deeper understanding of ethos, logos, and pathos, the following paper uses speech delivered by Martin Luther King, “I have a dream”. Notably, Braet (1992) confirms that Martin Luther King delivered powerful speeches during the ancient time. In his speech “I have a dream”, he stated firmly that all men were created equal despite other social constructions such as race...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Ethos Pathos and Logos

...Ethos, Pathos and Logos Ethos, pathos, and logos are all words with similar origin that is the Greek language. However, the three words convey different meanings when used as a means of persuasion. The word ethos, which implies credibility means using the author’s character to convince someone. This implies that the author’s personality is displayed in such a way that the reader has a good impression of the author.Pathos brings in the element of emotional appeal in persuasion. In this case, the reader or the audience is captured in emotions and is capable of identifying with the characters. Logos as a means of persuasion refers to using reasoning to convince the audience or the reader. This method of persuasion requires the author to back...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Pathos Ethos, Logos

... Lecturer This paper will be seeking to identify the Ethos, Logos and Pathos based on the story “Little Girls or Little Women? The Disney Princess Effect, written by Stephanie Hanes”. The essay was written by the author with the aim of discussing the different cultures that girls have gotten used and which they emulate. The author has incorporated the testimonials from other people who have issues similar to hers in regards to the way the girls view their bodily image. The author presents an insight that shows how much input is placed in “looking good” as girls start to get worried of their appearances at a very early stage in the childhood development. The author places the blame on the Disney Princess franchise that has been explicit...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Killing Torture Idealism: Logos in Intuition and Pathos in Counter-Aesthetics of Torture for FREE!

Contact Us