Analysis of the Fast-fish and Loose-fish Article by Melville - Research Paper Example

Initially, I did not understand the judge’s ruling regarding the dispute. I did not get why the judge awarded the defendants the whale, the harpoons, and the line, and the plaintiffs awarded the boat only (Fast-fish and Loose-fish 575). I reread the article so I could get a better understanding of the law of Loose-fish and Fast-fish at first.3. Do you think the settlement of the dispute was fair? Why? The settlement of the dispute was fair. This is because the judge followed the law of the Loose-Fish which states that when a fish is loose, it is fair game to whosoever catches it first (Fast-fish and Loose-fish 575).

Since the plaintiffs had forsaken their boats and lines with the whale, the whale was no longer in their custody, thus loose. What is the article about? What is the main theme, its main discussion? The article is about the possession of the property. The article talks about the universal undisputable laws, whether written or unwritten, that are used to solve any disputes that arise over the ownership of property. That is the main theme of the article. The article also discusses a dispute, whereby the judge used the law of Loose-Fish to give a ruling.

In addition, the article discusses the common person’s feelings towards the laws of possessing property and gives different examples of situations where the law was applied and how the law seems unfair in most situations.