StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Inadmissibility of Character Evidence - Term Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The paper presents the main aim of the Federal Rules of Evidence (404), the set of rules that govern the admission of facts in the U.S. federal court system, is to regulate the evidence that jurors may rely on to decide cases presented before them (Rothstein, Raeder & Crump, 2003). …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.7% of users find it useful
Inadmissibility of Character Evidence
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Inadmissibility of Character Evidence"

Inadmissibility of Character Evidence
The main aim of the Federal Rules of Evidence (404), the set of rules that govern the admission of facts in theU.S. federal court system, is to regulate the evidence that jurors may rely on to decide cases presented before them (Rothstein, Raeder & Crump, 2003). The Rules of Evidence are also aimed at eliminating the distrust that may exist amongst jurors while also encouraging the admission of evidence in close cases (Rice & Delker, 2000). The Rules also ensure that the juries have a wide spectrum of evidence to rely on without being bogged down with too much evidence that is practically unnecessary, time-wasting, confusing, repetitive or inflammatory. In other words, the Rules are purposeful in eliminating evidence that may lead to unfair prejudice against a party.
One case that illustrates the inadmissibility of character evidence in a criminal proceeding is the Greenberg v. Aetna Ins. Co., 427 Pa. 494, 235 A.2d 582 (1967) in which it was established that the plaintiff was erroneously permitted to testify that he had a heroic record having served in the U.S. Army during WWII (Paco de, N.d.).
Inadmissibility of Character Evidence in Rape Cases
The admissibility of character evidence in respect of a rape victim as presented by a defendant is limited if the court case is for assault, intent to commit rape or rape. If the defendant seeks to use opinion or reputation evidence to show the sexual conduct of the rape victim, the character evidence remains inadmissible (Scott, 2000) as it may be inflammatory. The defendant, however, may only enjoy admissibility of character evidence if they intend to show specific instances of behavior by a sex victim in proof of the claim that a party different from the defendant was the source of injury, semen or other physical evidence. Alternatively, the defendant may enjoy admissibility of character evidence to show that their sexual behavior with the victim was consented to by both parties. In the two cases, the evidence is used solely to prove the defendant’s innocence. Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Inadmissibility of Character Evidence Term Paper, n.d.)
Inadmissibility of Character Evidence Term Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1602183-unit-2-db-introduction-to-american-court-system
(Inadmissibility of Character Evidence Term Paper)
Inadmissibility of Character Evidence Term Paper. https://studentshare.org/law/1602183-unit-2-db-introduction-to-american-court-system.
“Inadmissibility of Character Evidence Term Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1602183-unit-2-db-introduction-to-american-court-system.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Inadmissibility of Character Evidence

Character analysis

...?Assignment Assignment Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, a highly acclaimed composer spent the last ten years of his life in Vienna, a where art metcreativity and ideas met their end if they were not looked after. His character sketch, according to the words and thoughts of Antonio Salieri provide a twist as he is depicted to be a man of few morals. Mozart is a fun loving man who believes in working as much as enjoying life at full blast; he indulges in drinking, gambling and being affectionate and intimate with women – an act that was frowned upon at his time by various members of the society. Mozart, unlike the character of Salieri, is unaware of the talent that lies within him; he does not know the path of success and that is, perhaps...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Character trait

...?Sur Lecturer Character trait This paper seeks to discuss the character trait that is common to Harrison in Kurt Vonnegut’s “HarrisonBergeron,” Sammy in John Updike’s “A & P,” and the narrator in Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s “The Yellow Wallpaper.” These characters share particular traits and qualities in the way they carry out themselves in the novels. They posses certain qualities that are identical with all of them in their reactions to the other characters in the novels, however, this paper will identify a specific trait that is common to all of them and is exhibited by at least three characters in the novels. Harrison, Sammy and narrator portray bravery, courageous and romantic character traits to the other characters in the mentioned...
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Evidence

In certain cases it can be essential to withhold convinced evidence from the protection in order to save the basic rights of another person or to protect a significant public interest. “Disclosure is one of the most important issues in the criminal justice system and the application of proper and fair disclosure is a vital component of a fair criminal justice system” (Attorney General’s Guidelines on Disclosure, par.1). In the criminal law there is a responsibility for taking an action in order to give the full revelation of all the applicable data in its possession. The extent of this obligation is decided by the ideas of constitutional which has its due procedure in addition to the requirements of the constitution. The criminal...
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Evidence

... Evidence The parties in either civil or criminal case must disclose their evidence as broadly as possible, to the other side of the case, and especially the disclosure of any exculpatory evidence (Federal Judicial Center, 27).The broad disclosure covers even the disclosure of confidential informants, like in this case, the “Eye” officer. According to Weingarten, Gene’s: "The Police Couldn't Hide Their Lying Eyes” case, it would have certainly not be possible to understand that the “Eye” police officer was lying in his testimony, until the fine details were given regarding the clothing and the item that the defendant was described to have been possessing (Weingarten, n.d.). While the $10 note serial number that was used by the undercover...
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Adducing Bad Character Evidence Through Cross Examination

...Introduction By virtue of Section f)(ii) of the Criminal Evidence Act 1898 an accused person may only be cross-examined with respect to previous convictions or bad character evidence if he or she have asked questions of previous witnesses that tend to “establish” the accused person’s “good character.”1 The reason for this exception is twofold. It allows the prosecution to demonstrate that the accused may not be trusted. A key purpose of cross-examination is to test the veracity of the evidence.2 The second reason for the exception is founded on the principle that once the accused asserts good character, his or her character becomes an issue capable of rebuttal although the prosecution was not at liberty to introduce original evidence...
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

Evidence

...Evidence al affiliation Law and legal process According to the civil of Procedure in California, the supreme courts shares similar dealings with the courts of appeal concerning reversing, verifying or modifying any orders appealed. Passing a direct and proper judgment by the jury or judge should involve new trials or further records. While in the process of making their decisions, the jury should be able to issue the possibility of a fresh trial being issued. The mother falls in the civil case category since it is being handled by the Supreme Court. Therefore, his trial is supposed to be placed in the calendar of the judiciary in the arrangement of the appointment of subject, in line with the proceedings concerning state party cases...
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Character Development

... English Character Development In any narrative writing, character development is a key issue for effective message delivery. Particularly the main character holds the message of the story and allows character development helps the ready to understand the meaning of the story. By analyzing character development in Kate Chopin’s two stories, “the storm” and the “the story of an hour”, it is possible to show the significance of character construction within a story. Louise Mallard is the main character in Kate Chopin’s “the story of an hour”. When she receives the message that her husband is dead, she mourns outwards but inside she is happy for the new acquired independence. When her husband happens to be alive, she is shocked...
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Character Analysis

...Character analysis in twenty-six men and one girl by Gorky A critical analysis of twenty-six men and one girl by Gorky reveals some interesting relationships between the characters. It is through character interactions in these relationships that the author has been able to develop and extrapolate his major themes. One of the most notable relationships is the one between Tanya and the twenty-six who have locked up in a damp cellar. At first, it is plausible that the Tanya and the men enjoy fruitful relationships. It is noteworthy that even though the men talk coarsely about other women, they never speak bad things about Tanya. According to them, her beauty and warm demeanor brightens their otherwise dull mornings in their locked cellar...
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Forensic Evidence of Gunshot Residue

Proves are very crucial to many investigations, especially when attempting to reach a logical conclusion of whether or not the investigated shooting was done in self-defence, suicide, or in fact a homicide. Again, all the most up to date studies are also included in this researched literature being presented. The conclusion is in showing just how valuable of an asset these specific tests really are towards the outcome of numerous investigations from the past and in the present.
The materials that are found to make up gun powder residue and seemingly found to predominantly consist of a mixture including organic and non-organic substances are basically elemental metals, among other items. However, it has been determined by a nu...
11 Pages (2750 words) Coursework

Evidence Law

... Evidence Law – Discuss Evidential Issues in the following Case Scenario Introduction: This essay deals with evidence law in which a certain criminal case is discussed and the legal implications are highlighted. A comparative analysis is drawn with other similar cases. The case involves one eye witness and one informant for an incidence of armed robbery in a post office in Dover. The evidential clues have been tied to a prime suspect depending on CCTV footage as well as statements made by the informant and the witness. In this case an analysis will be done on the basis or grounds of arrest of the suspect and the viability of the evidence obtained. Case Scenario: Michel, a Frenchman, has been charged with the armed robbery of a post office...
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

Evidence Law

Consent given because of exhaustion after persistent struggle and resistance would appear to be no consent. Usually, evidence of some struggle or resistance by the complainant may be the best proof of lack of consent but this is not always necessary.
It will be recalled in the case D.P.P. v Morgan3 the House of Lords held that if an accused person believed that the woman was consenting he should not be guilty of rape even though he had no reasonable grounds for his belief. The mental element of rape is an intention to have sexual intercourse without the woman’s consent or not. The sexual offenses (Amendment) Act 1976 amended the law relating to rape in England by providing that a man commits rape if he has sexual interc...
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment

Mental Health and Evidence-Based Practice in Social Work

...A review of an article on mental health and evidence-based practice in social work Summary The article in review (Crawford & Brown, 2002) presents anassessment on how stigma is applied to the care of mental health patients residing in rural areas in the UK. The study was conducted to describe how the concept of stigma has evolved from what previous studies have first suggested some 40 years ago, where a bigger part of mental healthcare was done in hospital settings. Due to the shift in providing care from the hospital to the communities, the traditional protocol of having mental health patients receiving institution-based care has drastically changed, allowing patients to be increasingly provided care in community settings. Furthermore...
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

Character Development in Last Holiday

... that Georgia’s lack of development is a direct result of her fearing the possible consequences of her actions. The character Georgia Byrd, in the film Last Holiday, exhibits many of the developmental traits that are discussed in Erikson’s psychosocial theory. This starts with stage two of this theory, which is autonomy versus shame and doubt. She has had shames develop in the self-conscious over the years, which could be why she denies herself any enjoyment. She does not feel as if she should be allowed to enjoy life, even as she cooks meals for her neighbor and Grandfather, while only eating Lean Cuisine herself. This is common in adults, as Erikson noticed that “step by step they go together: moralism with moral obedience, fanaticism...
7 Pages (1750 words) Movie Review

Managing Diversity: An Evidence-Based Approach

Diversity is a factor that is inbuilt into nature itself and the sheer variety that one can see in the flora and fauna in nature is a testimony to this fact. This is reflected in the human race also. Imagine a world where every human being belongs to the same race, is socially equal in all respects and shares the same beliefs. There will be no diversity here and it will not fit into the diversity scheme of nature. In effect, the diversity that is seen in nature is reflected in the human race also. People are different in terms of culture, social behavior, religious beliefs, color, race, and economic status. There was a period when travel and communication were limited and hence interaction between diverse people was rare. But the...
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Empirical Evidence in Different Areas of Knowledge

...Running Head: Empirical Evidence in Knowledge Progress Empirical Evidence in Different Areas of Knowledge Over the years, the importance and applicability of empirical evidence in progressing knowledge in different areas has become one of the most contentious issues, not only in scientific fields but also in art based fields. The major reason behind this is the fact that both science and other knowledge oriented endeavors acclaim empirical evidence as an integral part of their progressive advancement. In order for us to understand the various ways through which empirical evidence can be used to progress different areas of knowledge, it is imperatively valuable to have a clear understanding of what empirical evidence entails. Empirical...
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper

Validating Late Mover Advantages in e-commerce: Evidence from Selected Companies

...Research Proposal: Validating Late Mover Advantages in e-commerce: Evidence from Selected Companies Table of Contents Table of Contents 1 Title 3 Background 3 Objective 4 Project Aim 4 Research Hypothesis 5 Research Questions 5 Ethical Considerations 6 Literature Review 6 Research Methodology 9 Phenomenological Paradigm 9 Positive Paradigm 9 Deductive vs. Inductive Research 10 Data Collection Techniques 10 Proposed Research Methodology 11 Primary Data Collection 11 Survey Questionnaire 11 Research Methodology Limitations 12 Proposed Structure of Report 13 Time Schedule 16 References 17 Title Validating Late Mover Advantages in e-commerce: Evidence from Selected Companies Background E-commerce is a global market place that is characterized...
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Proposal

Law of Evidence: Reliability and Relevance

Evidence can only be deemed to be relevant if it is used to prove or disprove a matter that is in issue before the court. The evidence adduced with the intention of causing the jury to disapprove of the defendant is generally inadmissible unless it is properly presented as evidence of bad character to show the propensity of the defendant to a particular kind of crime.

Since scientific evidence is a specific area of expertise it is essential that the person giving evidence relating to scientific findings is suitably qualified, and that the evidence can be relied upon in order to secure a conviction. It is not always easy to draw a distinction between a person who is giving an expert opinion as opposed to evidence of fact1....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

The Effects of Police and Criminal Evidence Act in English Policing

... The Effects of PACE in English Policing English and Wales established the police and criminal evidence act in1984 as a move to curb crime rates in the region. The act outlined a comprehensive legal framework that gave guidelines on how the police would use its powers. The act has changed the shape of English policing over the years. However, just like any other act, PACE has had its shortcomings. This paper will highlight the issues surrounding PACE. English Policing before PACE Before the enactment of the 1984 police and criminal evidence act, the famous stop and search operation by the police had given rise to multiple crises. There were public claims that the operation oppressed some races, by carrying out unwarranted searches...
7 Pages (1750 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Term Paper on topic Inadmissibility of Character Evidence for FREE!

Contact Us