Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Evidence Is The Basis of Justice - Dissertation Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
This dissertation examines the English law of evidence within the context of the Jeremy Bentham’s quote “to exclude evidence is to exclude justice”. This paper also examines the treatment of criminal evidence in judicial trials under the English law…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.9% of users find it useful
Evidence Is The Basis of Justice
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Evidence Is The Basis of Justice"

Download file to see previous pages The dissertation "Evidence Is The Basis of Justice" presents the analysis of the treatment of criminal evidence in judicial trials under English law.
In common law, the rule is that admissible evidence should be excluded if its probative value is more than offset by its illegitimately prejudicial effect. Probative value refers to the correct assessment of the significance evidence in relation to law and facts. The prejudicial effect is an incorrect assessment of the significance of evidence in relation to the erroneous application of law to the facts. Probative value and prejudicial effect are commensurable prone to a continuum of risk of error.
In Maxwell v DPP, the House of Lords observed the exclusion of propensity evidence as ‘one of the most deeply rooted and jealously guarded principles of our criminal law’. Forty years later, in DPP v Boardman, House of Lords described the exclusion of propensity evidence as ‘pitted battlefield', obviously referring to the trajectory of treatment of exclusionary rule and admission of propensity evidence in some exceptional cases. In 2006, the High Court made a strict application of the exclusionary rule in Phillips v The Queen. This case involved the independent allegations of six teenage girls that the defendant known socially had raped or indecently assaulted them in like situations for over two years. The defendant denied the allegations and asserted that it was with the consent of some others. In the current U.K. law, the common law exclusionary rule has been abolished....
The defendant denied the allegations in some cases and asserted that it was with consent in some others. Since credibility of the complainants was in issue, judge allowed to tie all the cases together with cross-admissibility so as to justify admissibility of propensity evidence under exceptional circumstance, resulting in conviction of the defendant in respect of allegations of five out of the six complainants. Although the appeal court confirmed the decision, the High Court quashed the convictions holding that evidence should be excluded. However, retrials were ordered. This, an Australian case, was pursued further only by two of the complainants. One of them resulted in a hung jury with the complainant abandoning any further trial. The other ended in conviction for rape. Meanwhile, another complainant made a charge that the defendant while on bail awaiting retrial, raped her twice for which the defendant pleaded guilty. Thus, the cases ended with conviction of the defendant for six and a half years of imprisonment and three years and three months non-parole.9 The current U.K. law in this connection is that common law exclusionary rule has been abolished with the enactment of Criminal Justice Act 2003 in part 11, Chapter 1.10. However, propensity evidence is relevant for only admission and it is for the trial judge to exclude it or not depending on whether it would be unjust or its likely to have adverse effect on the fairness of the proceedings as per section 78 of Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 (PCE) 11 and s101 of Criminal Justice Act 200312. PCE actually provides for exclusion of unfair evidence. Part 11 of the Criminal Evidence Act 2003 deals with evidence of bad character which the common law had provided for ...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Evidence Is The Basis of Justice Dissertation Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 4250 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Evidence Is The Basis of Justice Dissertation Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 4250 Words)
“Evidence Is The Basis of Justice Dissertation Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 4250 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Evidence Is The Basis of Justice

Forensic Evidence of Gunshot Residue

Proves are very crucial to many investigations, especially when attempting to reach a logical conclusion of whether or not the investigated shooting was done in self-defence, suicide, or in fact a homicide. Again, all the most up to date studies are also included in this researched literature being presented. The conclusion is in showing just how valuable of an asset these specific tests really are towards the outcome of numerous investigations from the past and in the present.
The materials that are found to make up gun powder residue and seemingly found to predominantly consist of a mixture including organic and non-organic substances are basically elemental metals, among other items. However, it has been determined by a nu...
11 Pages (2750 words) Coursework

Criminal Justice Ethics

In 1979, Donald Creesey discussed the evolution of the science of criminology since its official inception fifty years previous to the authoring of his article. In defining the term ‘criminology’, he makes it clear that earlier unconnected studies were necessary in order to eventually form the current definition, which takes into account sociological, biological and environmental factors as contributing events in the creation of a criminal. Earlier definitions attributed all deviant behavior to the ‘free will’ of the individual without taking any external factors into account. Through this discussion, he provides useful information regarding the various sciences that have contributed to current theories of...
19 Pages (4750 words) Term Paper

Argument for Increased Prison Sentences in British Criminal Justice

The addition of prison time, while effective for keeping habitual criminals off the street, serves to further overcrowd prisons. This situation creates a ‘revolving door’ effect which releases violent criminals early and adds to an environment that is hardly conducive to rehabilitation.

A strong argument for increased prison sentences is the positive consequences of deterrence. However, the significant increase in the prison population has not correlated with a similar reduction in violent crime. The evidence showing whether an increase in prisoners is cost-effective in regards to a reduction of crime is mixed. Research demonstrates that “prison may have cost beneficial for violent crimes, but it also...
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The State of Racism and the Criminal Justice System in Britain

Catholics are known to be active, intelligent, and less reactionary than colonizers in Northern Ireland; these features are racial in nature; as Africans can not change their skin color, similarly, natives can not change their inherent race features.
According to BBC News (20 May 2002), Britain is a racist society. The results of a large scale survey conducted by BBC News Online suggest that more than half of British citizen thinks of the society as racist. Although the tolerance level of people has increased with the times' racism is more common in the workplace – about one in three blacks and Asians complain of losing a job opportunity because of racism. Again, the opinion is corroborated by 52% whites and 53% blacks...
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

A Problem with Categorizing the Secret trust and ascertaining its Jurisprudential Basis

The will itself will make no mention of the secret beneficiary and o9n the face of the will it appears that the money has been left to the named person for them to dispose of the funds as they see fit. Anyone reading the will would be likely to assume that the money has been bequeathed for the benefit of the named individual. Only the named person and the testator will know of the identity of the secret beneficiary and the agreement for the money to be held for the secret beneficiary will not be committed to writing anywhere. With half secret trusts, the trustee will appear in the will as holding the money on trust but the names of the beneficiary will be withheld.

Three elements have to be present for the creation of a...
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Communitarian and Cosmopolitan Approaches to Questions of Justice

Cosmopolitan/Communitarian divide relates to a dispute on whether or not the state or the species stand in for the limit of human society. In Campbell’s distinguished definition, he explained justice as “like the pre-original, anarchic relation to the other, and akin to the undecidable. It represents the domain of the impossible and the unrepresentable that lies outside and beyond the limit of the possible and the representable.” (1994, p. 472)

In general, there are two contrasting positions in understanding international justice and intervention. In its universal sense, the two perspectives can be distinguished as a particularist and universalist. One perceives in a state-centric manner while the othe...
7 Pages (1750 words) Literature review

John Rawls vs Robert Nozick: Social Justice

It is logical to look at political philosophy within the framework of history and ethics emerging from it. As could be observed, the question of justice, and how we perceive its nature has remained the prime concern throughout history. This will include, among other things, the existence of specific obligations towards each other and towards the state, the existence of natural rights, claims of property/liberty and equality.

In face of this, the Anglo-American political philosophy has seen famous philosophers like John Rowels, Robert Nozick and recently Amritya Sen to focus on issues and arguments concerning the above...(political Philosophy, 2005 pp1)

As political philosophy is about politics mainly, it s...

6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

Identification of problems in the Criminal Justice System of the US

They are on trial and will be dealt with fairly. These laws ensure that no one, even if he or she has committed a crime is abused or punished cruelly.
Following the history of civilization like in china, we see the traces of systems for Criminal justice in order to provide safety for the citizens. Evolving through the years laws have been modified and changed to form the system that we know today.
 From its start, the “U.S. criminal justice system” has advocated the idea of “checks and balances”. To avoid dictatorial rule, the people who founded this system in such a way that one person was not given control or authority completely to punish the criminals. The idea of assigning a ‘jury...
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Validating Late Mover Advantages in e-commerce: Evidence from Selected Companies

... suggests that with the existence of early movers in e-commerce it is not true that late movers cannot achieve competitive advantage. He implies that with greater investment and effort late movers can push early movers to rethink of their business strategies and even force them to exit the market. Furthermore, being a late mover in e-commerce does not surely mean that such companies cannot opt to provide “a particular service, a combination of services, or other unique value propositions” (p.8). The role of the senior management in allowing higher investment and their willingness to try new ideas on the basis of the assessment of the existing market is very much needed for late movers to succeed. However, it is clear from corporate evidence...
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Proposal

Various Treatment of Young People in the Criminal Justice System

The ways in which the treatment of young offenders is differentiated from that of adult offenders are also presented using appropriate literature; particular reference is made to the role of Young Offender Institutions (YOI). It is proved that the current criminal justice for young offenders in the UK is not effective, despite the measures taken by the government for securing the rehabilitation of these individuals. On the other hand, the full alignment of the treatment of young offenders with that of the adult offenders, as this practice is in progress in the UK, will not resolve the problems related to the rehabilitation of young offenders. The alteration of the rules of the existing criminal justice system without eliminating t...
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Dissertation on topic Evidence Is The Basis of Justice for FREE!

Contact Us