Nobody downloaded yet

Exclusion clause - Case Study Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Contracts are essential documents for all commercial relationship between two or more parties that are willing and ready to go into an agreement with the hope of enjoying some certain levels of relationship as indicated in the contracts. These relationships could be in business, employment, education and other service-related transactions…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.4% of users find it useful
Exclusion clause
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Exclusion clause"

Download file to see previous pages In recent years, it has become common that the weaker parties have often challenged the stronger parties for compensations in case some accidents or dangerous things happen to them in the course of carrying out their commercial relationship, even though they were statutorily excluded from their contractual agreement. This essays explains how these exclusion clauses could find their ways into a contractual agreement that the stronger parties would be willing to accept, although grudgingly.
For the purpose of explaining how exclusion clauses could become a part of a contract, the famous law case of Sayers v International Drilling Co. N.V is used. This is an example of an employment contractual agreement. Sayers, an English rig worker was hired in England by a Dutch subsidiary of a Texan oil drilling company to work on oil rigs abroad. He had an employment contract with International Driving Co. N.V that stated that if any injury occurs to him while working, he would accept the company's "Compensated Program" as his only remedy, and that he should waive any cause of action he might have in United Kingdom or under any other laws. But, suddenly, Sayers was injured when he was sent to work on an oil rig off the coast of Nigeria. The injury was as a result of his co-workers' carelessness. Sayers then decided to bring a legal action in tort against the Dutch company in England: this is an action expected to force the Dutch company to compensate him other than the "compensation program" stipulated in his contractual agreement with the company (Nygh, 1999).
Possible ways the Dutch Company could include its exclusion clause in the contract
Nygh (1999) explained that it is possible for Mr. Sayers to compel his employer in the ways described below to include an excluded clause into the contract: in this regard, offering compensations for injury suffered by an employee rather solely relying on limited "Compensated Program".
(a) Broader classification: An employee that drags his or her employer to the court seeking an inclusion of a clause may do so on the reason that the excluding clause is inconclusive in its definitions. Take for example; International Drilling Co. N.V may have defined compensated "injury" as the one sustained in the course of duty. However, this classification could be extended to cover the injury caused by carelessness of co-workers, as in the case of Mr. Sayers, if his co-workers injured him in the course of their duty for the company. Indirectly, Mr. Sayers is involved in the process of carrying out such company's duty, even though he may be at rest when the mishap happened. Broader classification like this has compelled employers to re-consider their stance on excluded clauses. Another relative example was in the case of an employee that got injured while using the company's car on a weekend; meanwhile his company stated that all off-duty car accidents would be at the employee's liability. However, extending this classification to cover using the said vehicle to convey another employee on duty for the company could force their employer to accept removing the exclusion clause.
In the court of law, cases like these are handled by lawyers who employed the principle of deconstruction to argue with ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Exclusion clause Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Exclusion Clause Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words)
“Exclusion Clause Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document


Contract Law, Exclusion Clause

...? Exclusion Clause in Service Contracts – Whether One party to a contract can restrict their liability by adding negligence by it will be excluded from the future liability – An Analysis Word Count-1539 excluding List of References Introduction “The Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982 (SGSA)” covers all contracts involving the supply of services. S 13 of the Act deal with the benchmark of execution of services, s 14 concerns with the period within which the performance has to be mad and s 15 ,the consideration or price for such services. This Act is applicable to all service contracts either independent or along with the supply of goods. Some of the examples of service contracts are providing accounting...
6 Pages(1500 words)Coursework

History and Political Science

5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Poverty and Social Exclusion

...?Poverty and Social Exclusion By Introduction This present essay deals with the issues of poverty and social exclusion. In particular, itsmain objective is to clearly define or establish the true meaning of poverty and what it entails. Secondly, the essay will seek to establish how poverty differs from social exclusion. In this regard, the essay will commence with a critical analysis of the issue of poverty and then it will analyse the issue of social exclusion. These initial analyses will help in providing the reader with adequate background information about the essay title and the objective of the study. In the third section, the essay will state the relationship...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Financial Exclusion

...A REPORT ON WHAT IS FINANCIAL INCLUSION AND HOW CAN IT BE TACKLED EFFECTIVELY In the simplest of terms, financial exclusion is when the people of any community or financial status are excluded from the general financial system of the country and generally with very severe consequences for the people who are excluded and the society in general. The first question anyone would ask is why would anybody be excluded And how could anybody exclude them The answer to these questions is not difficult. While nobody goes out of the way to exclude, the rules of the game are such that they are excluded. For example , if you are a single mother on welfare , the chances are very good that you do not have a checking account or a...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

School Exclusion

...This essay presents a concise account of the various methodological methods adopted in carrying out my qualitative research task. In doing so, it concurrently highlights the inherent strengths and weaknesses that observed with the use of the various methods coupled with what was generally learnt as the various methods are being used. The essay presents a brief synopsis of the findings, which will then be followed by an explanation of how this topic relates to the wider issue of social exclusion. Basically, it will explore the different understandings of social exclusion, including questions of structure and agency, and the links to poverty via a more detailed discussion of the different perspectives on...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Theory of Clause

...Theory of Clause August 11, . Introduction This paper will analyze the theory of Clause as Representation including discussion of types of process, participant and circumstance and their realizations, and suggest ways in which this aspect of grammar might influence English Language Teaching (ELT) course design. The Nature of the Clause In grammar, a clause is a pair or group of words that consists of a subject and a predicate (Halliday & Mattiessen, 1999). A clause is different from a phrase. Clause could be dependent or independent. Dependent or relative clause is derived from a "basic structure" (Celce-Murcia &...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Social Exclusion

...SOCIAL EXCLUSION The term social exclusion came out in Europe due to “prolonged and large-scale unemployment that provoked criticisms of welfare systems for failing to prevent poverty and for hindering economic development” (Loury, n.d., p.1). The concept was first used in France (Yepez-del Castillo, 1994, cited by Loury) then swiftly spread to the United Kingdom and the rest of the European Union. The Social Exclusion Unit describes social exclusion as “a shorthand label for what can happen when individuals or areas suffer from a combination of linked problems such as unemployment, poor skills, low incomes, poor housing, high crime environments, bad health and family breakdown” (1997, 2005, cited by Levitas). Walker and Walker... , on the...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Exclusion Clauses in Business Contracts

...Exclusion Clauses in Business Contracts Introduction: The business which is being started is a service industry but he also intends to sell some products; as a result, Mr. Gillespie needs to be aware of the contractual implications of warranties, representations and exclusion clauses. The obligations arising out of a contract may be distinguishes on the basis of mutual agreement between parties.1 In some cases, certain warranties or guarantees may not actually be written into a contract, yet those contractual terms are implied by statute. For example, the Supply of Goods and Services Act of 1982 makes it clear that when a sale is made, there is an implied condition that...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Exclusion clause

...Exclusion Clauses Number Department Exclusion Clauses An exclusion or exemption clause is a contractual term that limits liability of a party to the agreement on issues which it spells out. This kind of clause in a contractual agreement can be unlawful or lawful depending on the nature of the liability which the party was seeking to exclude himself or herself from (Page, 1994). Exclusion clauses are common in business contracts in which settlements of liability are unreasonable and would otherwise threaten the financial assets. Contracts with exclusion...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

The Commerce Clause

... The Commerce Clause Every in America operates autonomously with their government systems not entirely answerable to the federal government. In several instances, the states have their independent bylaws governing their operations independent of other states. However, the US as a nation has constitutional provisions that regulate socio-economic, political, and legal perspectives of its states. Furthermore, in several instances, states enact laws in line with the national constitution; some of the laws, however, conflict sharply with the provisions of the constitution. Georgia is no difference from other states pursuing conflicting laws to those of the federal government. The state’s statute establishes that all trucks and trailers...
1 Pages(250 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Case Study on topic Exclusion clause for FREE!

Contact Us