StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Equity and Trust: Trends in Trust Law - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The goal of this essay is to explore the aspects of contemporary trust law by analyzing a particular case of appointing the trustees and declaring provisions. Specifically, the writer of this essay seeks to reveal the legal advice for the subjects of such provisions…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.2% of users find it useful
Equity and Trust: Trends in Trust Law
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Equity and Trust: Trends in Trust Law"

Equity and Trust Dominic died a year ago having appointed Tick and Tock as his trustees. His will contained the following provisions My trustees are to hold 175,000 on trust to distribute as they see fit to the past and present members of Oakley Riding Club who have proved themselves fit to be in the saddle. 2. 16,000 on trust for my niece Abigail so that she can learn to ride 3. 5,000 on trust for my daughter Beatrice so that she can ensure that my old mare Clopalong will be looked after in the manner to which the horse has become accustomed Abigail was aged 15 at the time Dominic died. Soon after Dominic's death Abigail discovered that she was allergic to horse hair and asked for 9,000 from the 16,000 to pay for sailing lessons instead. Tick agreed to this and gave her the 9,000 which Abigail immediately spent on a new wardrobe for herself. Beatrice looked after Clopalong for a year but has just been reported to the police for wilful neglect of an animal. Tick and Tock are of the view that the money should be used to maintain the horse at a rescue centre. Tick and Tock invested the 175,000 held in trust for the ridding club members in Meltdown plc, a recently formed company that was very soon under investigation by the fraud squad. Tock had asked his friend George, a registered financial adviser, about Meltdown before they invested the money when they met at race meeting. George told Tock that all new companies came under investigation by the Fraud Squad and that Tock should not worry. The share value of the company dropped dramatically last month but Tock has told Tick that they are better off leaving the money invested in Meltdown Plc as the company is bound to make a profit sometime. Last week Tick and Tock were approached by Clarissa, a member of Oakley Riding Club, who has asked them for some money out of the trust fund to finance her proposed trip to the Olympic Show jumping finals. The trustees have told her that this is not possible due to the current low value of the trust fund. Advice to Tick and Tock The will appointed them as trustees of Mr. Dominic fund which they are entrusted to distribute to the parties provided in the will following the probate words. For the case of Abigail, this is a fixed trust where they were to give her 16,000 'so that she can learn how to ride'. However, after they discovered that she is allergic to horse hair and subsequently giving her part of the trust fund for sailing lesson where she spent on new wardrobe instead, they had no authority beyond the probate to follow and ensure that she did as the Dominic wished. Secondly, the words 'so that she learns how to ride' is uncertain it doesn't even give us direction what kind of riding is, sailing is also riding and it is wishful that the money would be used by Abigail to learn how to ride. Therefore they acted within their trusted duties. They should also remember that she is entitled to the whole amount since the probate states clearly that she be given 16,000. In case of Beatrice, the same kind of problem occurs, the is very clear why Beatrice is given the fund, that is, to look after Clopalong, the mare horse in the manner it's accustomed to. However after she is given money she fails to look after the animal and Tick and Tock have no power to withdraw the fund and look for another person to accomplish this. This is because the will is not explicit as to what should happen if Beatrice fails to look after the animal as it's accustomed. Here Beatrice has legal right to retain the horse and look after it as she deemed fit. Another uncertainty is that what if the ill health of the Clopalong is due to other reasons or old age Why Dominic appointed her and not somebody else These are some of the uncertainties we see in this will and Tick and Tock have no choice other than to give her the whole amount. For Oakley fund, Tick and Tock had been entrusted to hold this fund in trust for members of this club. They were to discretionary disburse this fund particularly to those members 'who prove fit for the saddles'. By investing the fund to this company the trustees were acting within the will since Dominic gave them power to decide how, when and to whom the fund will go to in the club. However the company in which they invested the fund was not doing fine and the knowledge of the fraud investigation before investments prove a bit technical. The fact that it's an investment adviser who misleads them to invest in this company the outcome of the low value of trust fund is beyond their blame. If they give Clarissa, a member of Oakley Riding Club, the funds at this level they will have to go back to their pocket since the initial fund value would be less than as stated in the will. Therefore they acted within the will by denying Clarissa the fund to participate in the jump finals against the testator's wish. As in case of Re Gisbourne, where the Judge decided that 'the trustees have unfettered discretion whether to pay the income to A or not, provided that the trustee had exercised his dispositive power honestly and bonifide...' (Trust cases). This is also the case with McPhaile v Doulton case decision. Advice to Abigail The testator who doubles as her uncle entrusted the fund to her in the hope that she would learn how to ride. However she is allergic to horse hair which the testator did not know about it and she decided to learn sailing instead. Interestingly, after she receives the fund she buys a new wardrobe. This is another case of uncertainty of intention versus an absolute gift. She acted within the will since the clause of 'so that she can learn how to ride' is problematic. It doesn't specify exactly how this fund will make her learn how to ride. Again it doesn't advice the parties as to what should happen if she doesn't enrol for riding classes. So as in the case of Re Lipinski's WT (1976) the judge can rule for her to receive the rest of the money despite her using it to do other things as along as she is the one using the fund and nobody else (Trust cases). Advice to Beatrice Beatrice is testator's daughter, and she is entrusted with the fund in the hope that she would take care of the mare horse as it is used to. However she fails to take care of the horse as her father wished. Here again the Tick and Tock have no right of taking the horse to the care centre using the fund. First because the testator father just 'hoped' and this fails the certainty of intention test. Failure of Beatrice to give the horse the care it deserves doesn't rule her out of the fund, she just failed. The clause doesn't attach the benefit of fund to the horse in absolute terms and failure to give the horse the care it deserves will not disqualify her from benefiting from the fund. Moreover, the testator knew of the existence of the centre but he decided to entrust the horse he loved so much to his daughter. Furthermore, this is an absolute gift and Beatrice doubles as a beneficiary and a daughter of the testator, thus the fund cannot be taken away from her. Advice to Clarissa, Oakley Club member He should understand that Tick and Tock were appointed as executors of the testator's will to the club on discretionary terms. That they will decide what and who to benefit from the fund. So by denying him the fund when he really needed it due to the fund low value is within the will of Dominic. Tick and Tock have the full authority to decide when and how to distribute this fund to the members. However, Clarissa can still sue Tick and Tock for wrong decision in investment and claim they knew the company they invested the fund was under investigation and was not doing well as in case of Stannard V Fison's Pension. In this case the judge overruled the trustee's decision as wrong and void. References Gillen & Woodman (eds.) (2000), The Law of Trusts: A Contextual Approach, Toronto: Edmond Montgomery. Oakley, A, J.(eds) (1996), Trends in Contemporary Trust Law, Oxford University Press Inc., New York. The Law Site, (2006), Trust Law/Cases, Available at http://groups.msn.com/thelawsite/trustcases.msnw, Accessed on 14th August, 2006: 10.00 GMT. McPhaile v Doulton (1971) A.C. 424, Available at http://groups.msn.com/thelawsite/trustcases.msnw, Accessed on 15th August, 2006: 15.10 GMT. Re Lipinski's WT (1976), Available at http://groups.msn.com/thelawsite/trustcases.msnw, Accessed on 15th August, 2006: 15 GMT Re Adams & Kensington Vestry (1884), Available at http://groups.msn.com/thelawsite/trustcases.msnw, Accessed on 15th August, 2006: 16.00 GMT Stannard v Fison's Pension Trust [1991] PLR 225, Gisbourne v , Gisbourne, (1877), 2 App. Cas. 300 (H.L.) Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Equity and Trust: Trends in Trust Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Equity and Trust: Trends in Trust Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1513017-equity-and-trust-degree-essay
(Equity and Trust: Trends in Trust Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Equity and Trust: Trends in Trust Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1513017-equity-and-trust-degree-essay.
“Equity and Trust: Trends in Trust Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1513017-equity-and-trust-degree-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Equity and Trust: Trends in Trust Law

Analysis of the Rationale behind the Rule that Non-charitable Purpose Trusts Are Unenforceable

trust law, whose applicability may start before or after a trust commences has the objective of clarifying the activities and purposes for which trusts are created.... While the law of equity governs the individuals entering such relationships, the law of trust offers the mechanisms for dealing with the different situations and circumstances of such relationships including pension funds, family relationships and charities among others.... In fact, trusts that purport to or are contrary to the law are considered invalid....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

The Origin of the Trust Law

THE trust law The Trust is considered to be a peculiar system of law that finds its origin in the English law.... hellip; The modern form of trust law originates from Anglo centric legal system because it is the product of English History.... If the idea of the trust law is developed in the Middle East then quasi charitable purpose will be provided within the family in the form of “waqf”.... Therefore it may be concluded that it is not necessary that the idea of trust law will always find its origin in the English system only1....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Equity and trusts Master Case Study

(The K-Zone - Certainty of Subject Matter) The transfer of five thousand shares in Echo Ltd to be held in trust will be considered as valid trust property as has been decided in the case of Re Rose (1952)4.... hellip; (Wikipedia) In general there are three basic requirements to be met with for the formation of a trust.... As decided in the case of Knight v Knight1 the three certainties that should exist for the creation of a trust are: Thus from the foregoing it may be observed that while any item of property whether real or personal can be made the subject matter of a trust....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

Pension Trust Funds

Sui generis character of the trust relationship implies the characteristic of the trust to distinguished itself from other legal concepts, such as, for instance, powers and fideicommissum and usufruct respectively of Civil law.... The author of the paper comments on the issue of pension trust funds.... According to the text, trusts are generally used in order to provide money for the benefit of another person or persons but to provide them in such a manner that the person benefiting from the trust does not control anything....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Resulting and Constructive Trust in Equity & Trust

Answer:The current state of caselaw on implied trust and beneficial or equitable interest in property due to indirect contributions to family home is not favourable to the appeal being considered by Lynn Jones.... English courts are reluctant to adopt the remedial constructive trust principles of Canadian courts.... t seems to be that judicial reasoning on implied trust rely on contributions to the purchase price and provable agreement, arrangement or understanding between the parties to share the property beneficially prevent the application of principles of justice and conscience in the present case....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Equity and Trust and Validity Discretionary Trusts

This is a body of law that evolved in the courts of chancery.... The law of trust is one of the most crucial creations of the court of Chancery, which is responsible for the administration of the law of equity.... The principle of Equity was developed as a result of the hash outcome as a result of rigid application in the common law rules.... Equity is referred to as fairness and was a powerful source of law because this overcame problems found in the common law....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Nature and Development of Equity and Trusts

This paper "The Nature and Development of equity and Trusts" focuses on the fact that historically, common law principles operated in a vacuum of inflexible applications of procedural formalities.... That purpose was the administration of both principles of equity and common law.... nbsp; It is important to note here that the common law courts would not entertain writs where damages were not an adequate remedy.... Moreover, the Common law courts did not recognize trusts and as a result, did not enforce them....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Quistclose Trust and the Requirements for Its Creation

During insolvency or bankruptcy proceedings, the insolvent borrower's estate is distributed according to the procedure specified by law.... he difficulty with defining Quistclose trusts in terms of the foregoing is that Quistclose trusts are created by operation of law, arising out of any situation involving a loan where the creditor insists that the borrower use the money only for a stated purpose.... This report "Quistclose trust and the Requirements for Its Creation" focuses on means by which a lender of money can retain a 'security interest' in loan money only for specified purposes....
7 Pages (1750 words) Report
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us