StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Robert Kagan and His Qualifications - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Robert Kagan and His Qualifications" focuses on Robert Kagan who identifies four factors as playing a powerful role in the rapid growth of legislation over the last few decades. One of them includes the intensification of international economic competition…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.5% of users find it useful
Robert Kagan and His Qualifications
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Robert Kagan and His Qualifications"

? Law Channels of Distribution Number Discussion One: Section A Robert Kagan (1995) identifies four factors as playing a powerful role in the rapid growth of legislation over the last few decades: the intensification of international economic competition; rapid technological change; a growing concern with the environment; and an increased geographic mobility. Nevertheless, Kagan postulates that more focus should be directed to the third. However, from a personal standpoint, it may be in order to part ways with Kagan, to evince the first agenda (the social, political and economic forces that explain law and institutional forms) as being the most dominant in socio-legal research and the most compelling. The standpoint immediately above is worthy of credence, based on the fact that man’s gregarious nature and subsequent human interaction may be social, economic or political in nature. However, man’s environment is graced with inadequate resources, yet man’s relations are competitive in nature, since man has a strong innate drive towards self-preservation. In turn, there is need for legislation, to curtail chances for man unfairly exploiting, harming and endangering his fellow man, or the environment, as he interacts with fellow man, the environment, or both (Ginsburg and Kagan, 2005). One may also repudiate Kagan’s standpoint on the account that it assumes a one-way flow of effects, in the relation between legal processes on social life. Because of this, Kagan’s standpoint assumes that legal processes affect man’s social life, while the fact of the matter is that social life also pervades and seriously affects legislation. This standpoint is also underscored by the fact that legislations are always made in accordance with socio-cultural customs and not to expunge socio-cultural customs. For instance, stealing or/ and negligence of tort may not be wrong because they are merely proscribed by the law, but because they contravene the dictates of universal law and natural justice. The laws of natural justice and the universal law are universally distributed across all cultures and are enshrined in societies’ socio-cultural values. In fact, it is in order to turn around the problem and posit that it is social life which births legislation. This is because man’s social life includes all functions that he dispenses within the auspices of the community, whether these functions are legal, economic, or cultural in nature. Section B Robert A. Kagan and His Qualification to Speak To Such an Issue According to Kagan (2009) himself, Robert A. Kagan graduated with a Bachelor’s degree in Harvard University (1959), an LL.B from Columbia University (1962) and a PhD from Yale University (1974), before he began lecturing political science at the Berkeley Law University of California in 1974. He would later proceed to become a member of the Boalt faculty in 1988. He has also served as the Director of the Center for the Study of Law and Society between 1993 and 2004. Kagan has also serves as a visiting scholar at Ohio State University, Oxford University, the Russell Foundation, the Netherlands Institute for Advanced Study and the Center for Advanced Study in Behavioural Sciences. Kagan has also made several publications which are cited as authority. Thus, it is fitting for Kagan to speak of these things pertaining human interaction and legislation due to his authority in the related field. Discussion Two: Answers and Opinion: Section A It is clear from the account provided that there are traces of negligence on the side of different parties involved. The owners are negligent of failing to verify the security agents’ skills. Patrons always fought 2-3 times a night and this therefore demanded thoroughly skilled bouncers, yet Calvin Hollins Jr. and Calvin Hollins III did nothing about this. The owners also failed to place proper infrastructure in E2 nightclub, in relation to: people who fell to the bottom of E2 nightclub stairway; the absence of alternative security facilities such as safety exit door; signs leading to the safety exits; and independent sources of lighting. The same owners failed to place strict security measures and protocol on nightclub fights: patrons always had 2-3 fights a night, and the owners of E2 should have therefore improvised anti-fights measures. Had this war been the first one, Hollins Jr. and Hollins III may not have been culpable, but this is not the case (Kiernan, 2003). Employees of Hollins Jr. and Hollins III working at E2 nightclub may also be held liable for negligence since there were seven of them (a number adequate to stop the fight at its nascent stage) but they did not stop the war from becoming full-blown. In fact, Navarro seems to have acted all by himself, attempting to break the fight. The fact that these employees owed the patrons duty of care underscores the extent of their negligence. However, this standpoint may only be annulled if information showing the security employees’ timely intervention is adduced. The club attendees may not be wholly lumped together for negligence: there are victims and instigators of violence in the group. Harmless victims are not legally responsible. However, legal action may be taken on the aggressors and the woman who fired the pepper spray, if they are identified and found to have been compos mentis during the incident. Section B The people in the club may be classified as a rowdy crowd. Contributory and comparative negligence may be attributed to this crowd (Prosser, 2008). Section C Hollins Jr. and Hollins III may have committed gross negligence, since their failure to institute safety measures (not verifying the security team’s skills and not placing safety infrastructure and anti-fighting protocol and policies) at E2 nightclub exacerbated the insecurity therein, and thereby leading to 21 deaths. The other six security officers also committed gross negligence through their inaction. However, Hollins Jr. and Hollins III may also assume vicarious liability on their employees’ behalf (Williams, 2008). Section D According to Punnakanta (2012), the burden of proof may be accounts from different witnesses and victims, and reports tabled by the police. The burden of proof can be established through timely police investigations. The information which the police will have come out with to sustain the case will be the burden of proof, which may further be subjected to cross-examination by the prosecutor and the defence. References Ginsburg, T. & Kagan, A. R. (2005). Institutions & Public Law: Comparative Approaches. New York: Peter Lang Publishing, Inc. Kagan, A. R. (2009). Adversarial Legalism: The American Way of Law. Harvard: Harvard University Press. Kiernan, J. V. (2003). Torts, Negligence, Duty and Recreational Injuries. Journal of Physical Education, Recreation & Dance, 74 (4), 18. Prosser, W. L. (2008). The Law of Negligence. Harvard Law Review, 52 (2), 342–343. Punnakanta, L. (2012). Space Torts: Applying Nuisance and Negligence to Orbital Debris. Southern California Law Review, 86 (1), 163. Williams, R. (2008). Rediscovering the Law of Negligence. The Cambridge Law Journal, 67 (3), 654 – 656. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Assignment 1 Topic: Robert A.Kagan ( Critical Thinking Question ) Essay”, n.d.)
Assignment 1 Topic: Robert A.Kagan ( Critical Thinking Question ) Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1487927-assignment
(Assignment 1 Topic: Robert A.Kagan ( Critical Thinking Question ) Essay)
Assignment 1 Topic: Robert A.Kagan ( Critical Thinking Question ) Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1487927-assignment.
“Assignment 1 Topic: Robert A.Kagan ( Critical Thinking Question ) Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1487927-assignment.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Robert Kagan and His Qualifications

Personal and Professional Development

Students, who aspire to become able professionals, need to focus on the most appropriate routes to obtain professional qualifications.... There are several ways to obtain accredited and recognised qualifications in the field of engineering at the different levels.... In the UK, there are different universities and institutions which offer various British engineering qualifications.... The Engineering Council of UK regulates and monitors the standards of these qualifications....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Professional Career Path for Accountant

The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA) offers qualifications for people who want to make a career in professional accountancy and finance.... Other qualifications include International auditing certificates, Financial management diplomas, certificates,s and diplomas in International Financial Reporting, for ACCA full membership, individuals are offered MBA from Oxford University (Mike, 2008)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Early Childhood Education

In England, Early years teaching qualifications are nationally recognized thereby providing career advancement.... The Qualification and Curriculum Authority as well as the NSTO are charged with the responsibility of training and the responsibilities for training and qualifications for early years.... his paper makes a conclusion that the development of the early childhood education in England has come a long way....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

The Effectiveness of Special Weapons and Tactics Teams (SWAT)

This essay describes the Special Weapons and Tactical Teams that are a relatively new form of law enforcement.... The researcher focuses on whether it is prudent to deploy these military style, combat ready forces in neighborhoods where women go about their routines and children play.... ... ... ...
23 Pages (5750 words) Essay

Formal and Systematic Approach to Recruitment

Systematic procedure comprises of four states namely: assessing whether the vacancy needs in filling, production of job descriptions, job analysis and personal specifications.... ... ... ... According to Torrington, a person needs to consider relevant aspects and requirements of the job.... Consideration is then given to the possibility of the internal filling....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Recruitment, Selection, and Training Methods

The author of the paper "The Recruitment, Selection, and Training Methods" argues in a well-organized manner that both recruitment and selection are different but somehow connected which Bratton and Gold defined in their definition of recruitment and selection.... .... ... ... Recruitment and selection are two of those processes that help organizations to select such a candidate that fits organizational culture (Bowen, Ledford, and Nathan, 1991)....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Recruitment and Selection Role for Company Competitive Strategy

This paper "Recruitment and Selection Role for Company Competitive Strategy " provides an understanding of the importance of recruitment and selection given the changing nature of the business world and increasing turnover and decreasing retention rates.... ... ... ... Companies in the UK are wasting at least £ 12 billion because of recruitment and selection mistakes in addition to training the new employees....
18 Pages (4500 words) Term Paper

Social Worker Administrator

This paper ''Social Worker Administrator'' tells that Individuals' quality of life depends on coping with real life challenges such as conflicts, unemployment, and alike.... Today's life has been characterized by many of these challenges; some require more than just the family's resolution question, but a specialist's help....
13 Pages (3250 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us