Nobody downloaded yet

Does the Battered Woman or Battered Child Syndrome Justify Committing Murder - Term Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Although murder is a subject of definition in law as it may have applied in the case, this paper uses to refer to the mere killing of one human being by the other. The arguments are both supportive of the verdicts and against the verdicts in the cases. The conclusion gives a verdict of the paper. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.6% of users find it useful
Does the Battered Woman or Battered Child Syndrome Justify Committing Murder
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Does the Battered Woman or Battered Child Syndrome Justify Committing Murder"

Download file to see previous pages The arguments by Dr. Walker are yet to gain broad and dependable scientific backing. All the alternative studies on the subject indicate otherwise. Therefore, the issue of battered child and women syndrome can only be accepted as an existing issue but not for the purposes it has been used. The issue can be addressed in a better way by enhancing the law to deal with such issues amicably because the current situation discourages one vice and encourages another. Two wrongs can never make a right. Introduction Children and women alike have been involved in killing in the United States but justice rendered in the courts is debatable, especially to the victims’ side. Children have been convicted and found guilty of killing their parents but the courts both in first trial courts and appellate courts have considered four possible judgments: first and second-degree murder, manslaughter, and acquittal on the self-defense rule. Generally, lighter sentences and even acquittal on account of self-defense dominate the judgments in all cases. In most cases, first-degree murder sentences have been reversed and lesser punitive sentences given to the defendants (Wilson, 2000). The lawyers from both sides of the divide have been making their cases in all the cases mentioned. In any case, justice is expected to be delivered to both sides. However, in all these cases, the victim is not alive to state their case whereas the perpetrators of the crimes are there to state their case. This implies that it is the prosecution case against the defense case. It can be concluded from the outcomes in most of the cases that the defense has been carrying the day in either getting a lesser sentence or being acquitted altogether. Whether the decisions were based on truth or partial truth is speculative. However, does the reason of battered child or woman syndrome justify committing murder? (Malmquist, 2007)
In the first case, the Menendez boys killed their parents, and after it was found that although they were guilty of the action, they were subject of child abuse (psychosexual abuse) there was a mistrial in the first trial because the jury tied two versus two on whether rule murder or manslaughter.  ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Identify a CRITICAL ISSUE from the reading to write about and present Essay”, n.d.)
Identify a CRITICAL ISSUE from the reading to write about and present Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1485855-identify-a-critical-issue-from-the-reading-to
(Identify a CRITICAL ISSUE from the Reading to Write about and Present Essay)
Identify a CRITICAL ISSUE from the Reading to Write about and Present Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1485855-identify-a-critical-issue-from-the-reading-to.
“Identify a CRITICAL ISSUE from the Reading to Write about and Present Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1485855-identify-a-critical-issue-from-the-reading-to.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Does the Battered Woman or Battered Child Syndrome Justify Committing Murder

Murder

...a decision based on the intention of the defendants. However, there exists a conflict in the Woolin case which leaves the test for the criminal intention too specific. In the event that in the future a crime of murder is committed, the victim or his family shall be prejudiced by the conviction of the criminal to a lesser offence, carrying with it a lesser penalty because of non-compliance with the attendant circumstances as stated in the Woolin case, to make him liable for murder. Thus, it gives the criminal the privilege to demand for a lesser penalty and escape a portion of the imprisonment. Moreover, there are two issues which are left unanswered by the Woolin case, which concern the...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Battered Child Syndrome

...that the professional need not investigate child abuse and that one need only have reasonable suspicion to justify a report. Research findings, although varied in approach, imply that training in identifying a range of symptoms associated with abuse is needed (e.g., Hawkins and McCallum, 2001). Knowledge of such symptoms could help mandated reporters identify presence of abuse and may minimize discrepancies in reporting practices. The following section helps to outline some of the physical, psychological and behavioral symptoms that may be exhibited by a child who has been physically abused. Characteristics of Physical Abuse Physical symptoms Since the coining of the term...
7 Pages(1750 words)Term Paper

Domestic Violence and Battered Woman Syndrome

...and it is quite prevalent even in the developed world. It has been deduced through research that men that saw their fathers abuse their mothers are more likely to engage in domestic violence themselves. There are other factors besides this one which affect the pattern in which IPV occurs such as personality traits and cultural influence. The interesting thing is that after a long sustained battering, the woman with BWS acquires a new personality which is and not limited to be withdrawn, lacking in enthusiasm, lost the will to live and can commit murder due to psychological depression. The biggest problem in the escalation of this problem of IPV is lack of reporting of...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

Japan's Battered Men Suffer abuse in Silence

...? Japan’s Battered Men Suffer abuse in Silence Introduction The world generally defines domestic violence as an issue affecting women only, but the study shows that men are victims too. In many instances, it is only the women who report having been punched, kicked or shoved by their partners. Evidently, cases of women who have been abused in marriages are more than those of men. Thus, people will tend to oversee the fact that some men too, undergo abuse in marriages. A recent study carried out showed that the percentage of women who suffered from domestic violence was almost equal to that of men who suffered from the same (Michels, 1998). The study also indicated that, the reported cases of men were however; lower in...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Child Sexual Abuse Accommodation Syndrome

...? The Child Sexual Abuse Accommodation Syndrome The Child Sexual Abuse Accommodation Syndrome Child sexual abuse can be considered to be one of the most heinous crimes that an individual can commit and yet it has occurred on a frequency level that is simply too disconcerting when one thinks about it. There are a number of problems that a child who undergoes such a trauma can suffer from and one of these is known as the Child Sexual Abuse Accommodation Syndrome (CSAAS). This is a term that was coined by Roland C. Summit in the early 1980s, but it is however considered to be a...
5 Pages(1250 words)Term Paper

Battered woman Syndrome

...Battered-women Syndrome/Battered-women Defense The Battered-women Syndrome/Battered-women can be a good thing when used appropriately. However, there is the potential for misuse of this defense. Two cases will be examined to show the pro and cons of the Battered-women Syndrome/Battered-women Defense. The first case is Francine Hughes. If any case deserved a Battered-women Defense, the Francine Hughes case did. The second case is the Betty Broderick case. Betty Broderick portrayed herself as a battered woman, but was in reality a...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Battered women

...of upbringing does not allow her to think or feel that she has a right to leave a relationship and a family if she finds that the relationship is causing a harm to her well being. The traditional social thinking is that a woman should sacrifice everything for her husband and her family. If she leaves her husband and a family, then she is not a ‘good’ woman, a ‘good’ wife or a ‘good’ mother. The fear of social reaction keeps her from leaving the violent relationship. b) Hope A research conducted on the basis of attribution theory to study the internal belief system of the women who were ...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Does Every Child Matter

...Running Head: DOES EVERY CHILD MATTER? Does Every Child Matter? of the of the This paper involves the evaluation and comparison of efficacy of ‘Every Child Matters’ programme for the locals and Immigrant/ asylum seeker or refugee families living within the United Kingdom. Its participants involve the children and parents of local and asylum seeker families. The result of the study will confirm ‘Does Every Child really Matter’ or it is just a name of a programme. The study will give new directions to the social services in providing an improved provision of facilities to the children of both the locals and asylum seeker...
14 Pages(3500 words)Essay

Battered Women

...Battered women article: Desperate lives of women domestic workers exposed to appalling exploitation, physical violence and sexual abuse in Qatar Thearticle is about the plight of women migrant domestic workers in Qatar which are exploited and sexually abused by their employers. They are being promised of good salaries only to work at long hours up to 100 hours per week without day offs for months at horrible working condition. This is reported amid the bid of Qatar to host the World Cup. The article may not have obviously taken a stance but it however subtly argued for the case of women that were abused by exposing in public the abuses that these women underwent. It assumed the position of Amnesty International... women article:...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Term Paper on topic Does the Battered Woman or Battered Child Syndrome Justify Committing Murder for FREE!

Contact Us