On Kind Checks Cashed, Inc.Talcott - Case Study Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Any Kind Checks Cashed, Inc. v. Talcott is a case involving Talcott, an elderly man from Massachusetts and Any Kind, a check cashing outlet. The case seeks to establish whether Any Kind qualifies to be a holder in due course (HDC) based on the decision of the court. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.9% of users find it useful
Case Study on Kind Checks Cashed, Inc.Talcott
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "On Kind Checks Cashed, Inc.Talcott"

Case Study Any Kind Checks Cashed, Inc. v. Talcott is a case involving Talcott, an elderly man from Massachusetts and Any Kind, a check cashing outlet. The case seeks to establish whether Any Kind qualifies to be a holder in due course (HDC) based on the decision of the court. The court, by upholding a trial court finding, held that Any Kind failed to act in good faith after cashing a check of $10,000, but on the other hand, acted in good faith by cashing the other check of $5,700. Guarino had not been a regular customer of Any Kind. In addition, as argued by the trial judge, it is strange for an investment broker to carry out business through a cashing outlet, who should have used a bank instead. Guarino was also found not to have history of cashing similar checks. On this matter, the judge argued that the speed at which the check was cashed should have been the same speed used to confirm with the drawer who for whatever reason could have stopped the payment. Considering that the $10,000 check was a significant amount, fair dealing required Any Kind to carry out the transaction with a high degree of caution. Basically, in the case of banks, the drawer has the right to stop payment. The bank mitigates the risk of loss by holding funds after the payee presents the check (Nichols 35). This leaves the legal dispute between the drawer and the payee and in the event that such check is cashed, the loss lies with the drawer who confirmed the check. The due course doctrine applies when Any Kind immediately releases the funds to Guarino. Even though the pace at which the transaction was effected was meant to benefit the economy, the argument of easy negotiability does not in any way outweigh exercising of caution. Notably, the attraction of many check cashing outlets is their speed and convenience. However, unlike banks, a cashing outlet cannot hold a check before releasing funds. Further, the law requires immediate release of funds for any instrument received from an individual engaging in the activities of cashing checks. However, this does not support the action of Any Kind and, therefore, we cannot say that the court erred in its decision since the $ 10,000 was not a typical check. According to Thomas, the speed at which Any Kind transacted with Guarino depicts loose application of principles of good faith, making it a target for other forgers with the intention of swindling others out of their money (69). The court decision can be considered as fair by deeming Any Kind as a holder in due course for the $5,700 check and not for the $10,000. Considering that any check above $2,000 was a significant amount and the supervisor, Ms. Michael, had initially thought of confirming the check with the drawer before making payment, it becomes more apparent that Any Kind should have verified the $10,000 check with the drawer to determine its validity. Even though transaction verification would have gone contrary to the longstanding policy of speedy transaction and free negotiations, the principles of the holder of due course still applied and, therefore, Any Kind should have approached the transaction with a great deal of care. So, had Any Kind confirmed with Talcott immediately the check was presented, they could have learned that the drawer had stopped the payment. Confirming the check of $5,700 with Talcott, Any Kind satisfied the good faith requirement for any holder in due course. The definition of holder in due course is any cashing outlet that accepts an instrument devoid of any evidence of alteration or forgery and without notice of claims and in good faith for value (Marinelli 22). In the case of Any Kind Checks Cashed, Inc. v. Talcott, it was important to determine whether Any Kind acted in fair dealing and good faith as required to attain the status of a holder in due course. Good faith refers to being honest and observing commercial standards of fair dealing in every transaction undertaken (Chan-Hyung 54). I concur that Talcott was responsible for the $5,700 despite fraudulently being induced to issue the check. In this second case, a supervisor with the authority to approve checks for over $2000 at Any Kind, called Talcott who confirmed cashing the check, and in doing so Any Kind complied with the good faith requirement for a holder in due course. However, in the earlier cashing of the $10,000 check, Ms. Michael, the supervisor, tried to call Talcott to get his approval, but after her efforts to reach him failed, she relied solely on her experience and judgment, which was a major test on acting in good faith. Therefore, the circumstances under which funds were paid to the endorser without proper authentication from the drawer arouse suspicion on the part of Any Kind. Works Cited Chan-Hyung, Chung. “Holder in Due Course of Commercial Paper under the U.C.C. and a Good Faith Purchaser of Bills and Checks under the Geneva Uniform Law.” Commercial Law 13.2 (1990): 33–57. Print. Greenlee, Mark B., and Thomas J. Fitzpatrick IV. “Reconsidering the Application of the Holder in Due Course Rule to Home Mortgage Notes.” Commercial Law 5.3 (2008): 67–69. Print. Marinelli Jr., J. Arthur. “Negotiable Instruments and the Holder in Due Course.” American Business Law Journal 8.3 (2007):15–24. Print. Nichols, Pu. “Comparison of Instruments Law with Article 3 of the Proposed Commercial Code.” Negotiable instruments 14.2 (1954): 22-39. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Case Study on Kind Checks Cashed, Inc.Talcott Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Case Study on Kind Checks Cashed, Inc.Talcott Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from
(Case Study on Kind Checks Cashed, Inc.Talcott Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Case Study on Kind Checks Cashed, Inc.Talcott Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words.
“Case Study on Kind Checks Cashed, Inc.Talcott Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Case Study on Kind Checks Cashed, Inc.Talcott

British Petroleum America, Inc

...? BP America, Inc; Case Study BP America, Inc: Case Study British Petroleum (BP) had its birth in the year 1901 when William Knox D’Arcy got the chance to explore Persia’s oil resources. At first, the company was known as the Anglo-Persian Oil Company (Eugene D. Fanning Cente, p. 9). In the year 1914, it entered into an agreement with the British government. With the funding from the British government, it spread its operations to start marine bunkering stations and aviation fuel production. By 1935, it had refineries in Australia, Canada, South America, Africa, Papua New Guinea, and Europe (p. 10). It was in the year 1959 that BP found the presence of Hydrocarbons under the North Sea and under Alaska’s permafrost. Thereafter... such...
3 Pages(750 words)Case Study

Nike inc

...a sharp decline in the current ration relative to the preceding year. The decline was by more than 100% as against its previous year. This implied the company was stepping towards insolvency and had fewer current assets available to pay off its current liabilities. This can be a big hurdle for any company for continuing its daily operations and generating cash from its operations. Hence, it posed a problem to maintain the profitability of a leading company like Nike. The inability of Nike to generate cash from its operating activities showed in their significant decline in the working capital, which came down from $ 1,208,444,000 to $ 938,393,000 during the fiscal years 1994 and a995 respectively. It...
3 Pages(750 words)Case Study

Apple Inc

...?Apple Inc. Apple Inc. (Apple Computer) was founded in 1976 by Steven Wozniak and Steven Jobs. The first product of the company was a mass-produced personal computer Apple I. Today the mission statement of the firm points out that “Apple designs Macs, the best personal computers in the world, along with OS X, iLife, iWork, and professional software” (Apple Inc., 2011). In addition, Apple’s goal is to lead the digital music revolution with the help of iPods and iTunes, as well as reinvent the mobile phone with iPhone and iPad. The company’s vision and strategy are in providing the world with innovative products. Apple Inc. sees innovation and products with superior ease of...
2 Pages(500 words)Case Study

Apple Inc

...? Apple Inc Case Study APPLE INC CASE STUDY Question By the end of Apple Inc’s shares listed on the NASDAQ in New York rose to over $660, which took its stock to the highest point in recent history, while raising its market capitalization to over $619 billion (Sutherland, 2012: p52). This is the highest market cap in the world and was over $200 billion for second placed Exxon. This high market cap can be attributed to several factors. The first is the release of the highly successful iPhone 5 with the iPhone being the company’s most profitable product. In fact, it contributes to over 50% of Apple’s bottom line and with the sales of its iPhone 5 surpassing that of the iPhone 4s, the...
9 Pages(2250 words)Case Study

Dell Inc

...Street Address ST ZIP e-mail phone fax Dell Case Study The following is an analysis of Dell, Inc. This isa company within the technology sector that services and sells computer components. Dell services customer's world wide. This analysis is current as of 2004 and focuses on Dell's China market. I. Current Situation A. Current Performance Dell Inc. has continued to be a leader in the marketplace. Dell's greatest challenge was entering the global marketplace with operations in China. Currently (2004) Dell has 18.2% of the global market share in the computer industry. The company has continued to have increased sales (currently about 8 million). Dell has successfully entered the Chinese marketplace...
5 Pages(1250 words)Case Study

Grocery, Inc

...Scenario: Grocery, Inc. is a retail grocery store chain based in Any U.S.A. Grocery has stores throughout the United s. Tom Green works as the produce manager for the store in My Town, U.S.A. Jeff Fresh, 17 years old, is spending his summer vacation working for Tom in the produce department. Case 1 Though the case was a bit weak, ultimately, it was Grocery who won the battle. While the agreement clearly stated that the Masterpiece was given the contract at a certain price and had to complete it within the specified time frame, there was no written clause stating that the contract could not be handed over to a sub-contractor. Thus Masterpiece argued that it had done so in the best interests of both the parties...
5 Pages(1250 words)Case Study

Bizland ,inc

...What type of company is this? Why has it been successful to How does the firm make money? What are its three key success factors? How are they evolving? Bizland is a start-up company in the digital ecommerce industry. The firm’s business concept is based on processing credit card payments online and offering web hosting services, but the company quickly diversified into other profitable products and services. The first obstacle that the firm faces eliminating its web hosting service because this division was not profitable and it was draining the cash resources of the company. Three success factors for the company are the quality of its human resource, the ability of the company to adapt to market changes, and the fast...
2 Pages(500 words)Case Study

Alden, Inc acknowledge receipt of the materials to avoid challenges with supply. b. Control procedures for the weaknesses The control procedures for the above problems include passing a policy for the removal of materials from the store room only under written authorization and recording of the amount and value of the materials retrieved. Keeping a perpetual inventory system is the other procedure to solve the problems at Alden. This will allow tracking o material usage at Alden for the company to be able to forecast sales and making demand forecasts to avoid losses from shortages and reduce theft. Sending receipt reports to the supplies and checking on quantity and quality needs to ensure the supplies meet the...
1 Pages(250 words)Case Study


...are imposed on U.S. imports by the politically instable countries, Gap operations will be greatly affected. For example, china constitutes of over 50% of Gap’s foreign merchandise. The recent threat of U.S. denying china most favored nation (MFN) status is a cause for concern to Gap’s management since the move is likely to affect Gap’s operating cost. To be successful in business, one needs to be sure, of what the customers need to be able to produce as per the expectations (Sarin 361). Gap makes specification for the kind of products its target market would want to purchase. This strength ensures that the company delivers the best the customers can find in the market. Customer loyalty is strengthened which makes Gap...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

Apple Inc

...Case Study: Apple Inc by Apple Inc. has seen a lot of growth that is a function of Resources, core competence andgeneric strategy of the company. The Company boost resource in terms of knowledge, entrepreneurship, people and finally financial resources. Core competence factor on the other hand comprise of its outstanding leadership, hardware, culture and the most population innovative image. Apple’s success is finally a function its generic strategy. In its strategy to outdo its competitors, Apple employ a strategy based on differentiation and differentiation focus. Resources form the most fundamental premise for any business idea. Before any firm initiates its plan therefore it must put in place a good...
2 Pages(500 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Case Study on topic Case Study on Kind Checks Cashed, Inc.Talcott for FREE!

Contact Us