Nobody downloaded yet

Hart-Fuller Debate - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Hart-Fuller Debate 'While Fuller’s argument that law has an inner morality is unsuccessful, his eight principles provide an important supplement to Hart’s rule-based concept of law.” HLA Hart wrote the book “The Concept of Law” in 1961 which defined the way a legal system should work…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.4% of users find it useful
Hart-Fuller Debate
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Hart-Fuller Debate"

Download file to see previous pages Introduction to Hart’s Concept of Law: Hart in his book addresses three critical issues. The questions which arise from these legal issues are (1) how does law differ from and how is it related to orders backed by threats? (2) How does legal obligation differ from, and how is it related to, moral obligation? (3) What are rules and to what extent is law an affair of rules?1 Laws, Commands and Orders: Hart argues in the first chapter of his book that laws are varieties of imperatives which differ in nature according to the tone of the individual. The acts of human beings to ask someone for help, to request someone for an act, or to order someone to do or to abstain from doing something, which might be backed by threat, or in other case where a man might be coerced to do something are all an indigenous part of the social nomenclature in which the society thrives and survives. Hart argues that law is a social construction backed by history. Law is an institution which always did not exist. It emerged for special reasons, and because of those reasons it has taken the form it takes. Law as the Union or Primary and Secondary Rules: Fundamental lawmaking power rests of the customary social rule, and it is through this rule that the sovereign authorises itself to make laws. Hart argued that law is nothing but a social construction of primary and secondary rules. In order to understand the effect of such rules, it is crucial to realise that Hart identified Rules of behaviour and rules of recognition as minimum standards for the existence of a legal system. We shall analyse the understanding of these rules later in the paper, but for now, it is important to draw a distinction to draw a parallel between these two rules and associate them with the primary and secondary rules. Primary rules may be defined as such ruled which guide behaviour of an individual by imposing duties on people, secondary rules provide for identification, change and enforcement of primary rules. Both these rules are attached to the law of recognition and behaviour and the law works within this social pattern living in the society. Rules are present when there is a certain kind of social practice, regular behaviour together with the set of attitudes known as acceptance.2 Sovereign and Subject: Hart conceptualises that wherever there is a law, there is a sovereign, characterised negatively and positively by reference to the habit of obedience; a person or body of persons whose orders the great majority of the society habitually obey. This is the fundamental relationship between the subject and the sovereign.3 The most basic characteristic of democracy is the uninterrupted continuity of law making power by rules which bridge the transition from one lawgiver to another: these regulate the succession.4 Hart argues that in a sovereign State the laws are made through the acceptance of obedience of the majority of the people. The Constitution is the document which authorises the legislature to make laws for the people, but the legislature is not beyond the law since the power vested in him was granted by the Constitution itself. Therefore, it can be argued that the Constitution is the supreme law of the land and the law making bodies come under the purview of the Constitution. However, the lawmaker is not limited by the Constitution in order to enact laws, and he has the will to be obeyed by the ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Hart-Fuller Debate Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved de
(Hart-Fuller Debate Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3000 Words)
“Hart-Fuller Debate Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3000 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document


Hart-Devlin Debate

...Hart-Devlin debate Introduction Laws are necessary for the survivor of any society. Rules are broken and an offence is often committed. Laws consist of a group of rules forced by the authority and defying them often results to punishments. Morals are often personal. They often defined right or wrong in the society, and people often stand to those principles. The law is not enacted when one is not moral or does not act in a certain moral way. The reparations of not being moral are often individual. Morality and laws often contradict in their formation and implementation. Moralities develop after a while, are not easy to alter, and are often a mindset that people have. Laws on the other hand, are easily...
9 Pages(2250 words)Term Paper

Hart-Devlin Debate

...Hart-Devlin Debate Analyze and resolve the “Hart-Devlin” debate. Lord Wolfenden chaired a meeting in 1957 that recommended the existence of homosexuality activities in private. The chairperson suggested that as long as their activities remained private they should not be criminalized (Cane 21). Wolfenden and the entire committee argued that; criminal law meant to protect the public from injurious activities and protects people against corruption and exploitation. However, the law is not against the private lives of people and the activities they undertake in private. Therefore, a law cannot be imposed that interferes with the private lives of people. The report by the...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

American Literature - Margaret Fuller

...through intellectual debates and freedom, as nobody else could be expected to help them in the regard. Throughout her book Fuller reiterates how equality of man and women in religious an intellectual terms is the solution and key to all happiness. She illustrates this through examples, particularly in the union structure of marriage and its various forms as well as the fundamental spiritual differences between man and women. Fuller states that the happiest form of marriage is one in which man and women are equals progressing equally towards an ultimate goal. This allows them to have trust and respect for each other, along with dependency and regard, with neither aspect compromising on...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper


...? Palestinian vs. Israeli Debate of the of the Concerned July 12, Palestinian vs. Israeli Debate It goes without saying that throughout the history of the Arab-Israel conflict, Israeli’s solution and response to the Palestine issue has been predominantly military. Time and again, Israel has not only responded to the popular Palestinian aspirations with military might, but also the tactics adopted by the Israelis have been brutal and lethal in their approach and ramifications. Since the onset of this conflict Israel has killed a large number of innocent and unarmed men and women, children and the aged. This amounts to a gross violation of the established Military Rules of engagement, UN conventions and the...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper

Lullaby by John Fuller

...LULLABY BY JOHN FULLER A lullaby is song, which is usually sung to young children before they go to sleep. The intention of a lullaby is to speed up that process of sleeping in children. Lullabies are often simple and sometimes repetitive. John’s lullaby goes as follows: Sleep little baby, clean as a nut your fingers uncurl and your eyes are shut your life was ours, which is with you Go on your journey. We go too The bat is flying round the house like an umbrella turned into a mouse the moon is astonished and so are the sheep their bells have come to send you to sleep Oh be our rest, our hopeful start Turn your head to my beating heart Sleep little baby, clean as a nut Your fingers uncurl and your eyes are shut...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Case study Gary hart

...? GARY HART CASE STUDY s Analysis of Gary Hart’s expenses costs Total cost of all ingredients per table: 17*24= ?408 to be paid two weeks after the receipt. Kitchen staff salaries= ?57,200 per year Waiting staff ?13,728 Social security costs ?20,800 Utilities ?2,600 per quarter and payable by direct debit the first week of the following quarter. Rent ?40,000 paid in four installments, beginning of every quarter Council tax ?8,000 paid in four installments of 2,000 each payable beginning of each quarter Advertising cost ?12,000 incurred the first week Analysis of revenues Revenue per day: 75%*60*24=?1,080 Payment in cash per day: 50%*1,080=?540 Revenue per month: 1,080*24=?25,920 Revenue per quarter:...
9 Pages(2250 words)Assignment

Margaret Fuller

...Margaret Fuller, misplaced as a feminist in American Literature Sarah Margaret Fuller Ossoli (1810 - 1850), commonly known as Margaret Fuller, has been generally regarded as one of the earliest feminists in American literature, and she was one of the major figures associated with the American Transcendentalist movement. Margaret Fuller was celebrated as an important women's rights activist associated with the American transcendental movement and her position as a transcendental female writer is more than justifiable. She has also been labeled a feminist by more recent scholars. However, a reflective analysis of the works and writings of this journalist, critic and women's...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay


...Fuller: Generalship and Age DEPARTMENT Fuller: Generalship and Age It is almost an established fact that there may be a strong link between success and age. The age when one is considered young is when one is thought of as being strong enough to undergo certain activities in certain ways. The ages when one is really considered young may differ from person to person. As it touches on generalship and the rate of performance, Fuller, in his appendix, seems opined that it is between the ages of thirty and forty-nine.1 According to him, this is the age when most generals are found to be most efficient. Yet, as this position is not exactly corroborated in the body of his book, it may not be...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Bret Hart

...The celebration of the virtues of the social under in Bret Harte’s stories: Bret Harte is a whose works are full of human empathy and insight. He is also exceptional in terms of attention to detail and gifted in coming up with beautiful turns of phrase. In the three short stories of the author chosen for this essay, we see ample examples of remarkable literary and humane touches. The force and achievement of Bret Harte’s works are best understood when considering the social milieu and literary norms of his time. In other words, Harte was one of the early American writers to project the lives of the underprivileged into mainstream literature. This essay will flesh out...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay


...Disciplining Children with Special Needs Disciplining Children with Special Needs Many parents and teachers often have a misconception that with special needs do not require the same standards of discipline with typically developing children. Different authors have expressed their opinion about disciplining children with special needs. Although the majority of the authors agree that, all children need discipline. However, children with special needs deserve the same standards of discipline with typically developing children. This paper will highlight the reasons why it is fair to discipline children with disabilities as typically developing children. According to Nelson et al (2011), all children, irrespective... Children with Special...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Hart-Fuller Debate for FREE!

Contact Us