Nobody downloaded yet

The History of the Lubicon Lake Band and the Case Against Canada - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The History of the Lubicon Lake Band and the Case against Canada The Lubicon lake band or Lubicon lake Cree is a minority community that inhibits areas surrounding Lake Alberta. Being a minority community proves the reason why the community has little attention from the media and other state agencies1…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95% of users find it useful
The History of the Lubicon Lake Band and the Case Against Canada
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The History of the Lubicon Lake Band and the Case Against Canada"

Download file to see previous pages The community claimed that the government did not consult any of their representatives during its decision2. In addition, the group claimed that gas and oil exploration projects would compromise their habitat. The Lubicon lake community currently has approximately 500 members who are the among the indigenous community that lived in Canada before the arrival of the European immigrants. Members of this community depend on hunting and trapping as their main economic activity. Conflict between the community and the Canadian government began when the government failed to consider them in 1899 treaty3. The treaty aimed at identifying and protecting territories of indigenous communities who lived in the country. Following the government decision, members of the community failed to present a systematic or legal claim to the government to claim ownership of the land. Lubicon lake community may have assumed that the government was responsible in protecting the rights of every community particularly the minority community. On the other hand, the government did not show economic interest on Lubicon band territory. The government may have ignored the incorporation of the community in the 1899 treaty in order to protect its interest in the region4. The struggle between the lake community and the nation attracted the interests of the international community in 1984. This followed a failed attempt by members of the community to achieve any political or legal settlement for their case concerning invasion of their indigenous land. The United Nations Human Rights Committee (UNHCR) intervened in the case although, the community’s chiefs had previously requested for intervention from the international community. However, the Canadian government was against the decision claiming that they had not exhausted all domestic avenues that could be used to resolve such case5. After detailed investigations of the issue, the UNHCR concluded that available domestic remedies were insufficient to settle the case6. This is because the community did not have the ability to defend its interest against the country. In addition, the community was unlikely to win back their indigenous land back since Canada controlled the judicial system. In 1990, the UNHCR agreed that the state was a threat to the existence of the community by allowing invasion of their cultural land. The committee also agreed to include the Libicon community among threatened communities in order to attract the attention of the international community7. The committee also argued that the government had violated Article 27 of the international law concerning indigenous communities and indigenous territories. The Canadian government responded by increasing avenues for negotiation between the community and the government in relation to the controversial land. The government proposed resettlement of the community as the main solution to the case considering that the region was of national interest8. However, the Lubicon community declined the resettlement offers given by the government claiming that their traditions do not allow them to give up their ancestral land. Representatives of the community also argued that giving up their land would also be against the 1899 treaty. This is because the government pledged to protect the interests of indigenous community in cases involving land disputes. Community members also argued that currently the country did not have any ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“The History of the Lubicon Lake Band and the Case Against Canada Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(The History of the Lubicon Lake Band and the Case Against Canada Essay)
“The History of the Lubicon Lake Band and the Case Against Canada Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The History of the Lubicon Lake Band and the Case Against Canada

Lake Havasu

...for people looking out to take a break from their routine work lives. Moreover, the Lake is also a very inherent part of American culture, having been built literally by an American entrepreneur itself as discussed above. Thus, in this way it still retains a lot of attachment to the culture itself and makes the place emotionally warm for visitors belonging to the same nationality. It is quite connected to its past in a way that many people have visited it just to see the London bridge. It is full of rich history and a wonderful past and has been built on the lines of modern day culture and society. It is one of the places to visit before one dies, definitely, as suggested on a number of television travel...
5 Pages(1250 words)Assignment

The Case against Happiness

...? The Case against Happiness number number Teacher’s Due The Case against Happiness The story, The Lady with the Dog, by Anton Chekhov, is one that talks of the impossibility of finding love in modern life. Chekhov’s works, like those of Tolstoy, talk of the futility of attempting to find love and happiness through conjugal relations between a man and a woman. This futility is at once nihilistic and also a result of the historical forces that shaped the work of these writers. This paper shall attempt to explore this celebration of sorrow through an analysis of the short story, The Lady with the Dog, by Anton Chekhov. The paper shall seek to highlight the social and...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

The Case Against Evolution

...The Case Against Evolution This essay addresses whether evolution ought to be taught in public schools. In my view, the answer is that there is no valid basis for including evolution in public school curriculums. My arguments are not based on the Culture Wars commonly presented in the mass media. Rather, my arguments are based on the observation that evolution is an unproven concept, as it pertains to the origins of life on Earth, and that it is too often manipulated by people with a political agenda. To this end, this essay will discuss the nature of the evolution argument, why it should not be taught in public schools, and the implications if it were included in public school curriculums. In order to...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

The Case Against Tipping

...The Case Against Tipping In his article, Michael Lewis voices his bold view opposing obligatory gratuity or tipping. The points out the downbeat surface of tipping. The main argument seems to go like this: (1) Growing appeals for gratuities are disturbing and taxing. (2) Tipping must be inhibited. The focal point of the article highlights the negativity of tipping in the present times. While many people believe that tipping is a way of ensuring continued good service (Obringer), Lewis finds the growing appeals for tips as disturbing. The author's opening statement (1) is valid only on undue practice of gratuity. His premise is arguable considering that he failed to substantiate the real value of...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Case against death penalty

...Case against death penalty Death penalty has attracted a lot of debate from society, with some people arguing against it, while others supporting it. As a form of punishment, some justice systems death penalty punishes a collective number of capital offenders who are guilty. Whereas, the definition of capital offenders differs, many offenders who are guilty of taking the life of others fall into the category of capital offenders. Despite that fact that capital offenders attract capital judgment decisions such as the death penalty, there are strong arguments that people have raised against this practice. Some people view that the death penalty is barbaric, expensive, and...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Inks lake

...Minerals and Rocks This is a Trip report that was undertaken in Devils washtub in Inks Lake National park. The basic field was petrology-branch of geology that studies rocks: their origin and formation and mineral composition and classification. The rocks under study were Magmatic Gneiss, quartzite, granite, amphibole/amphibolite, igneous intrusions(granite). The basic idea was to identify how these rocks within this area were formed, their basic mineral composition and strata arrangement. This trip was also aimed at establishing an historical background on the formation of rocks and minerals. INTRODUCTION Devils washtub is located in Inks Lake National park. This is a state park found in United states...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

The Case against Marriage

...The Case against Marriage Marriage has been considered as an important social institution since time immemorial. According to many people, tying the knot is the surest way to ensure social stability, bring up children and avoid sexual anarchy. Thus, changes in the nature of marriage in the form of higher divorce rates and cohabitation without marriage are often portrayed as an indication of social decay. However, Bennett and Ellison claim that due to the changed social situation, it is no more necessary to tie the nuptial knot legally to ensure its stability. In other words, getting into a legal marriage does not increase the stability of the union anymore. The authors claim, “legally tying down unions...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Crow Lake

...Crow Lake Crow Lake is a novel ed by Mary Lawson, and narrated by Kate Morrison, an adult womanliving in Crow Lake. At the tender age of seven, Kate and the siblings lost their parent in a tragic road accident leaving the family in a tough situation that threatens their dispersal and an end to the dream the parents had once had for their children of all getting through with their college education. An alternative is provided for each of the siblings to stay with their relatives, a suggestion that they reject based on intention by the sibling to remain together in their stay. This brings about another challenge, as they have to struggle in order to cater for the needs of the family. With...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Violence Against Women (CASE)

...against women emphasizes all members within the community play a role in ensuring violence against women does not occur. A bystander is the person who witnesses a situation and is neither the victim nor the perpetrator but in someway the person could make a difference if involved in the situation (Postmus, 2013). In many different cases, the bystander program has been found to prevent possible cases of different forms of possible violence. However, in prevention of violence against women, the bystander program has not produced effective results. Most cases of violence against women mainly occur at family level and...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Twice More to the Lake, My Lake

...(First 2 November Twice More to the Lake, My Lake I am reminiscing the bygone summer atthe Walloon Lake. We went there every summer. It was a place perfect for the family. My family of 6 unpacked our bags and ran and jumped into the cold water of the lake. That’s what we do every time we went there. The breeze coming from the placid body of water was so welcoming jumping there could not be resisted. The years had passed, but Walloon Lake remains to be a breathtaking beauty of nature. The blue water of the lake always give me the soothing feeling. During this season, there were no traces of ice and snow, but the freshness of the water was...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The History of the Lubicon Lake Band and the Case Against Canada for FREE!

Contact Us