Nobody downloaded yet

Discretion Granted to National Courts in Relation to the EU Legal Order - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Discretion Granted to National Courts in Relation to the EU Legal Order Course Number: Date Due: Introduction According to Article 234 of the European Courts Treaty, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) has the rights and obligation to ensure that the laws that are established by the member states of the European Union has the same meaning and it is effected in the same way to all the member states…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.3% of users find it useful
Discretion Granted to National Courts in Relation to the EU Legal Order
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Discretion Granted to National Courts in Relation to the EU Legal Order"

Download file to see previous pages The body that was named as the European Court of Justice (ECJ) that enables the national courts to refer to it. The preliminary reference procedure has been essential in designing the fundamental principles of the national legal system, the unity of the member countries, and the development and maintenance of the national laws. In Article 234, the Court has the powers to give preliminary rulings in a request from the national courts. The preliminary rulings might be about the interpretation of the Treaty, the legality and the interpretation of the actions of the member countries and the European Central Bank. The national courts have therefore a vital role to play in the administration and how the community law is implemented. However, the European Union Treaty does not precisely define “the national court or tribunal”. Nevertheless, it is vital to know that the national laws of the member states do not depend upon the definition of the tribunal or national courts by the European Court of Justice. The Court has the role to define the national laws of a given community. ...
Moreover, different cases shall be looked upon in the preliminary ruling procedure (Arnull, 1989). The Right and Obligation to Refer Cases The case of Vaasen- Gobbel came up with the decision to define the national court in order to find a way to refer to the ECJ. The case was held by stating that any body making a reference to the European Court of Justice must satisfy a number of criteria: It first need to be established by law, must have a permanent existence, it must be in a position to practice a lasting jurisdiction, must work under the rules of the Community law and its procedures and should apply the rule of law. The Court therefore had to extend the stated criteria to apply to the national courts so that they would be independent (Komarek, 2005). Several other cases including the De Coster Case, enabled the college which previously had the powers concerning the local tax proceedings and never operated on its own nor made its own decisions regarding the process later satisfied the criteria to operate as an independent body. The De Coster and CLIFIT cases demonstrate the national courts that have the powers to give judgment in relation to article 234 of the European Court of Justice (Komarek, 2007). Even though the case regarding the definition of the court or tribunal that satisfies the previously defined criteria for an independent body is at times inconsistent and therefore provides a room for some critics to disagree on which bodies are to refer cases to the ECJ. However, in order to solve this problem of disagreements, the European Court is coming up with the preliminary reference procedure that would be used by all judicial bodies while they might be dealing with cases involving the Community law (Maher, 1994). On the facts of the case, the De Coster and ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Discretion Granted to National Courts in Relation to the EU Legal Essay”, n.d.)
Discretion Granted to National Courts in Relation to the EU Legal Essay. Retrieved from
(Discretion Granted to National Courts in Relation to the EU Legal Essay)
Discretion Granted to National Courts in Relation to the EU Legal Essay.
“Discretion Granted to National Courts in Relation to the EU Legal Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Discretion Granted to National Courts in Relation to the EU Legal Order


...?COURTS Task: Courts Introduction A court is a governmental body, in the form of a tribunal that possesses the man to host, officiates, arbitrates legal clashes between different parties concerned, and in accordance with the law of the land, carries out adept administration of law, justice and order in the solution of social, criminal and governmental issues. Courts are universally responsible for dispute resolution when a complainant remits accusation or charges on the other party. Both parties possess equal rights in a way that the accused should be allowed to shield themselves from the charges, since the accusation may be false. The...
10 Pages(2500 words)Research Paper

The ability of individuals to enforce their rights under EU law before national courts

...from the Community law has received very little significance as yet. Hence, the Court of Justice is belligerent to break these inherent ambiguities of the Treaty all these years. In a number of cases, the Court has awarded interim reliefs, which are an outstanding concept for the conceptualising the difficulties that individuals witness when initiating legal proceedings before national and European courts when trying to prey for safeguarding the rights offered by the Community1. European Union law is having an equal force with any EU’s Member State law. It offers commitments and rights on the officials of the each of the...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

EU Legal Contexts

...and dismissal issues, and also exhorts for equal and non discriminative rules without any kind of prejudices based on age, gender, colour, sexual preferences or religion and is applicable with equal force both in the public and private sectors for paid as well as well as nonpaid work. The preponderance of EU Directives over national or domestic laws are important, especially in this context, since this law relating to 25 years being the baseline year had been drawn up way back in 1928 in order to address prevailing issues as to seniority and length of service in employment matters. In its current context, it does seen that this rule is much extinct and very much out of...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Administrative Discretion

...a decision or performing official acts or duties (The Free Dictionary). In other words, when a legal system permits an administrative authority to practice discretion, it is called administrative discretion. The discretionary powers are given to an administrative authority by statute or delegation. It has observed that, generally, broad discretion powers are given to administrative agencies in order to effectively exercise their administrative authority. However, it is held that the discretionary power must not be vague or arbitrary, but it has to be in accordance with legal requirements. US Supreme Court stated that “an...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Police Discretion

...?PD Discretion> and Section # of Police Discretion In the fast growing world, the crimerate is ever rising, hence the police officers in charge of daily civilian peace face a variety of situations which they have to deal with in order to maintain public law and order. It rarely happens that the same incident takes place in the very same manner as every incident or crime has a specific signature attached to it. Usually the police officer facing the situation is the judge at the precise moment of action and a slight error of judgment can cause massive loss of either the officer himself or public property and order. This is the soul essence of the report, the police officer and his judgment actions at the spot, in the field... officer helping a stranded...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Development of Legal Protection in EU Courts

... Development of Legal Protection in EU Courts The EU legal order protects individuals before the European Union Court of Justice and before the domestic courts. The critical discussion draws attention to the action for annulment by private applicants before the Court of Justice and the Development of Legal Protection in EU Courts for non-privileged applicants under - Article 263 TFEU that was introduced by the Lisbon Treaty. Additional procedures before the Court of Justice are treated as a substitute to the action for annulment. In addition, the paper underscores the uncertainties and the ineffectiveness of EU’s judicial protection given the strict approach the European Union Court of Justice interprets Locus standing of the non... that...
18 Pages(4500 words)Dissertation

Primacy of EU Law over National Law

...lead to the imposition of civil liability or civil obligation on an individual 3. Thus, Simon can expect Otis to be held at least for civil liability if he hales the company to court based on the EC directive. The same ruling was laid down in C-106/89 Marlesing SA v La Comercial Internacional (1990) ECR I-4135: "In applying national law, whether the provisions in question were adopted before or after the EU directive, the national court called upon to interpret it is required to do so based on the wording and purpose of the directive in order to achieve the result pursued by the latter 4." In an imaginary Simon v Otis Chemicals...
11 Pages(2750 words)Essay

EU Law and Legal Contract

...Running Head: English Law and Legal Contract English Law and Legal Contract of the of the EnglishLaw and Legal Contract Tasks: 1. Explain the main sources of English law and how they are created. Choose an example from each source relating to business activity and indicate what legal areas or principles are involved with your chosen examples The EU makes laws which must be respected by all member states. Since the aim behind the creation of new European laws is often to standardise laws between the different member states, it is inevitable that EU laws are passed which some member states do not like. Even if they do not...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

The National Family Legal Foundation

...defrauded. Keating was found guilty in 1990 of more than 40 charges of fraud. Keating's impending imprisonment and the collapse of his business empire sent the CDL into a downward spiral. Alan Sears noted the CDLs falling credibility in relation to Keating's legal problems: "It's pretty hard to raise money for a nonprofit [organization] when it's national news that the founder is going to prison [for fraud]" (cited in Buntin, 1999, p. 4). Sears took over as the executive director of the Citizens for Decency through Law in an effort to preserve the once prominent organization; to more effectively recognize the founding goals of the CDL, Sears renamed the Citizens for Decency through Law...
13 Pages(3250 words)Case Study

Legal Order of European Community

...of the EC. More specifically, the ECJ ruled that citizens of the EC can enforce their rights provided by the EC legislation in treaties, directives, regulations, etc in national courts on condition that certain criteria are satisfied. These criteria for the establishment of direct effect are called the "Van Gend en Loos criteria", and include the following clauses - the provision must be stated clearly and precisely, it must grant a concrete right for a claimant, and it must be non-dependent or unconditional. So, one of the crucial qualities of a new legal order within the EC is the special correlation between domestic legal systems of...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Discretion Granted to National Courts in Relation to the EU Legal Order for FREE!

Contact Us