Nobody downloaded yet

Criminal Law - Assignment Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Name University Course Instructor Date Criminal Law Introduction Recklessness has been adequately recognized by the criminal law as the elements of mens rea in order to ensure that liability is fully established. It actually indicates a lesser culpability than that of the intention, but rather a more culpability than that of the criminal negligence…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.7% of users find it useful
Criminal Law Assignment
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Criminal Law"

Download file to see previous pages The court is expected to carry out three different kinds of tests such as objective test where the particular court imputes the elements of mens rea based on the fact that any of the reasonable individuals that possess the same kind of abilities and knowledge as is possessed by the person that is accused in this case is expected to have such kind of elements. The second test is the subjective; in this test the court is expected to make an establishment as to what the person accused was thinking of at the time he caused the actus Reus. Finally, another test is the hybrid that involves both objective and subjective tests (van den Haag, 1978, p 27). These arguments was advanced by Dori Kimel in his case comment, ‘Inadvertent recklessness in criminal law’ (2004) LQR 548, where she analyses and critically evaluates the decisions of the House of Lords in R v G [2003] UKHL 50; [2004] 1 A.C. 1034 and R. v Caldwell (James) [1982] A.C. 341. This paper will therefore briefly identify the key arguments advanced by Kimel in her analysis of the two cases. Further, it will discuss whether Kimel’s critical evaluation of the two decisions is persuasively argued. Arguments advanced by Kimel in his analysis The facts of the case was that there were two boys who were aged 12 and 11 years, they are reported to have been camping without any particular permission by their parents when they decoded to go to the backyard of a nearby shop in the morning, they had newspapers that they had lit. The newspapers that they had lit are reported to have caused fire in nearby bin that was located against the wall of the shop, the fire immediately spread up the wall and eventually onto the roof. The fire caused an estimated damage of $1m. The two children made an arguments that they were expecting the fire to eventually burn itself out and did not give any thought to the risk that could be caused incase the fire spread (Kimel, 2003, p 21). In the judgment of the House of Lords, Lord Bingham actually saw the need of modifying the definition of Lord Diplock in order to ensure that infancy of the defence was accounted for which was containing the mischievous discretion notion. This rule required the various courts to make a consideration of the extent the children who were aged from eight or more years could be able to have a clear understanding of the differences that existed between wrong and right. Therefore, the test that was stipulated by Diplock of obviousness was expected to actually operate in unfair manner for the two children incase they were eventually held to the same particular standards the reasonable adults were held to. The courts finally held that the defendant must be clearly shown to have indeed subjectively appreciated a given risk to the property and health of the other party but eventually carried on any particular event before they could actually be said to be completely criminally culpable. This ruling abolished the historical objective reckless test that had been previously recognized under the famous R v Caldwell (Kimel, 2004, p 548). Dori Kimel has indicated that recklessness is actually the particular critical mental element that exists within the Critical Damage Act of the year 1971. However, ten years following the enactment of the particular legislation, the House of Lords in the context of R v Caldwell made a controversial interpretation of the recklessness objectively as well as ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Criminal Law Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Criminal Law Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1444295-criminal-law
(Criminal Law Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Criminal Law Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1444295-criminal-law.
“Criminal Law Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1444295-criminal-law.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Criminal Law Assignment

CRIMINAL LAW - HOMISIDE

...? Criminal Law – Homicide Criminal Law – Homicide When a human being is killed by another human being, the act is known as a homicide. The two main types of homicides are murder and manslaughter with the difference being that manslaughter is a less serious offence than murder (Slapper & Kelly 1999). The English legal system is a system of law that is practiced in England. This kind of system is practiced in most of the commonwealth countries. The English legal system recognizes homicides and continues to explain that for a case to be rated as a homicide, there must be a person who is dead and the death of that person came as a result of an act by another...
10 Pages(2500 words)Assignment

Criminal Law

...?Swarna1 Word Count 2038 Order 528374 d 1st May CRIMINAL LAW Case study: Claire and Tony have been married for 15 years and they have 3 daughters aged 4, 11 and 14. Tony has always been a very domineering husband and father but over the last 3 years his desire to control everything and everybody around him has become more extreme. When Claire disagrees with him or wants to do something on her own without his permission he loses his temper and shouts and screams at her and both threatens to be and is physically violent to her. Sometimes his violence takes the form of sexual assault – which he says is just his right as a husband. Claire is terrified and feels powerless to do anything. She wants to protect...
9 Pages(2250 words)Assignment

Foundations of Criminal Law

...?Foundations of Criminal Law Insert Foundations of Criminal Law Set A: Related Articles Fraud refers to the deceitful conduct modeled to manipulate another individual to issue something of value through telling lies, repeating something that is recognized or should be identified as false or suspected by the fraudulent party. It may also involve concealing a fact from the other party, which could have saved that party from being deceived. The following are examples of articles with fraud related cases. Therefore, this context examines whether the law was rightly implied and justice done or not. Jail for Sainsbury's IT boss who stole 17 million Nectar...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

Criminal law

..., if the assailants are apprehended, they would also be charged with attempted murder. This owes to the fact that they were actually ready to commit this had the man refused to provide them with what they wanted. The difference between the two articles is that while there is use of force in in one, the other one has no such intensions to harm the individual. However, they are both similar in the sense that in both, theft is the main act. In matters of giving sentences though, the burglars using violence to obtain property may get up to life imprisonment depending on the laws of a particular country. This owes to the fact that such thefts committed more than one criminal act. They intended to murders,...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

Criminal law

...?Criminal Law Articles Boy of 16 used disguises when he carried out robberies The legal issues being discussed in the above article include: the series of violent robberies committed by Miles Alura and the use of various disguises in order to perpetuate the offense1. The article does identify the issue accurately and clearly, but mostly focuses on the fact that the offender wore various disguises in order to perpetuate his robberies. I believe that the main issue in this case is the robbery itself including the wearing of the disguises. I believe that the wearing of the disguises added more intent to the crime. The use of violence also added necessitated the treatment of the crime as an adult offense....
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

Inside Criminal Law

...Inside criminal law Purpose of criminal law: A modern and civilized society is supposed to protect its members from harm and other kinds of injustices. For this purpose various statutes and laws have been passed, whose final enforcement is in the hands of a well developed and honest judiciary. This is also the case with acts of crime. Hence, “the primary legal function of the law is to maintain social order by protecting citizens from criminal harm” (Gaines & Miller, 2010, 80). According to the authors, there are two distinct purposes of enacting a criminal law in any society. The only...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment

Criminal law

...Task Criminal Law Substantive law is conclusive of communal and private ifications in the field of law, whereas procedural law concerns itself with the rulings made in a court. Examples of substantive law comprise of laws stemming from traditional grounds. The traditional law is habitually denoted as the common law. Procedural laws can be exemplified by such laws as the ones pertaining to rights of citizens. This ensures that the jury makes staunch decisions after following the procedural laws. Substantive law has its...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Criminal Law - newspaper articles

...Introduction In this assignment, six selected articles from newspapers will be discussed in legal terms. The task will involve reading through the articles and then identifying the legal issue that is presented in the article. Thereafter, the law that relates to the legal issue that will be discussed and then applied to the scenario being discussed in the article which after will lead to a conclusion based on the argument presented. Three of the articles are related to fraud while the other three articles are touching on matters to do with insanity and the difference that exists between insane automatism and non-insane automatism. The overall purpose is to reach a conclusion on the accuracy of press reports that touch on...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

Criminal Law

...Criminal Law work Problem By 29, Jan Word Count: 1096 Question One Criminal liability attaches if the accused commits an unlawful act (actus reus), with the requisite guilty mind (mens rea). In the scenario question, Victoria dies while in a secret air-tight compartment where she had been hidden by the accused. The main issue in the scenario is whether the accused is culpable for the death of Victoria or whether the act of the police officers to arrest him, and hold him for more than 24 hours while the deceased was in the compartment is to blame or in way excused culpability for her death from him as an intervening cause. The guilty act/omission of the defendant must be the factual and...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment

Criminal Law

...Criminal Law: Definition of Terms Case law Case law recounts to the ruling as recognized by the consequence of previous cases. It also refers to the set of decisions advanced by adjudicatory tribunals that are citable as precedent. In United States, precedential case law emanates from adjudication ruling or judicial ruling in the executive agency branch of the State. Civil law Civil law delineates the confidential legal relations within the judicial system that only relates to community members issues and not those of religion, military, and criminal affairs. Case law has historical...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Assignment on topic Criminal Law Assignment for FREE!

Contact Us