Nobody downloaded yet

R.V. Martin (Anthony Edward (2001) ECWA Crim 2245; Q.B1 Case (Critic) - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
How did the case impact the law?
The time that Mr. Martin committed the offences, he was facing two men who were burgling him, it is true that he did shoot the two men, but in his defence, Mr. Martin points that the crimes were committed in self-defence. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91% of users find it useful
R.V. Martin (Anthony Edward (2001) ECWA Crim 2245; Q.B1 Case (Critic)
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "R.V. Martin (Anthony Edward (2001) ECWA Crim 2245; Q.B1 Case (Critic)"

Download file to see previous pages The jury could convict the defendant if self-defence evidence presented by the defendant raised doubts or the fact that Mr, Martin had used excessive force. The manslaughter charge that Mr. Martin faced would mean the defendant is believed to have used excessive force then the sentence would not be a life imprisonment. Then this would mean that the jury did not believe the defendants defence of having acted on self-defence. The facts that led to, the sentencing of Mr. Martin is knowledge that Mr. Martin used his firearm, yet he knew he was entitled to possessing it. The jury strongly believe that the although it is true that the two men who broke into Mr. Martins house intended to commit a burglary, Mr. martin was entitled to use reasonable force yet he used excessive force when he shot the 16 year old dead and left the other seriously injured. According to the jury Mr. Martin did not act reasonably in both of the cases. The judge in passing the sentence took into consideration the frustration that Mr, Martin felt at the event of the Burglary as well as the medical report presented by his doctor. The court put into account the situation threat Mr. Martin faced, but it also pointed out that a dangerous weapon was not to be used in the manner that Mr. Martin used during the night of the Burglary.
According to Almandras, she points out that the law states clearly that a householder may be liable in civil law or criminal law or in both if he is found to have used unwarranted force in opposition to a burglar or trespasser resulting to the death of the intruder or injury. Matters raised during Mr. Martin’s case suggest that any householder who kills or injuries a burglar will have a complete defence. The defendant is acquitted if he used was reasonable force and this must prove to be in defence of himself or another in the prevention of a crime (2011. p.1). The principal issue raised by conservatives is the measure of reasonable force, which they argue, should be proven, and the householders would not face prosecution unless their action is proven grossly disproportionate. However, democrats support the view that the current law was reliable and did not require a change. In the case, of Mr. Martin Almandras observes that the accused Mr. Martin had experienced several break ins. Mr. Martin had already expressed his dissatisfaction with the police response. On the night of the burglary, Mr. Martin shot onto the two burglars with an unlicensed gun. During his appeal, Mr. Martin presented fresh psychiatric evidence showing that, he was suffering from a long personal disorder. However, the court still ruled that the Mr. Martins state of mind was irrelevant to the purpose of self-defence. The psychiatric evide ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“R.V. Martin (Anthony Edward (2001) ECWA Crim 2245; Q.B1 Case (Critic) Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1441256-rv-martin-anthony-edward-2001-ecwa-crim-2245-qb1-case-critic
(R.V. Martin (Anthony Edward (2001) ECWA Crim 2245; Q.B1 Case (Critic) Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1441256-rv-martin-anthony-edward-2001-ecwa-crim-2245-qb1-case-critic.
“R.V. Martin (Anthony Edward (2001) ECWA Crim 2245; Q.B1 Case (Critic) Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1441256-rv-martin-anthony-edward-2001-ecwa-crim-2245-qb1-case-critic.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF R.V. Martin (Anthony Edward (2001) ECWA Crim 2245; Q.B1 Case (Critic)

Case Study: Anthony Hanemaayer

...?Case Study: Anthony Hanemaayer Introduction This particular case refers to a person wrongly indicted for attempted rape, and the sequential events leading to great uproar in law circles worldwide, and particularly in Canada. The person affected and allegedly accused for attempted rape was a 19 years old construction worker, Anthony Hanemaayer, who was arrested solely due to the reason that he fulfilled the attacker’s description as provided by the victim’s mother, and happened to be employed at a construction site located adjacent to the victim’s place of residence. The victim was a 15 years old girl, Heather, who was asleep alone in her bedroom before the crime was...
5 Pages(1250 words)Case Study

The Casey Anthony Case

...Criminology: The Casey Anthony Case, was it perpetuated Due to Psychological, Sociological or Biological Criminal Causation Donna Purcell Order 594791 University Abstract The following information attempts to answer the question of psychological, sociological or biological causation in the murder trial of Casey Anthony. The information defines psychological, sociological, and biological theories and if any or all or a combination of these applies to this case. Dr. Michael Welner analyses the case through psychiatric clues. Dr. Jan Garavaglia gives an account of why Casey was charged and why the death of Caylee Anthony was...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Casey Anthony Court Case

...? Casey Anthony Case Casey Anthony case The late Caylee Anthony, daughter to Casey Maier Anthony and granddaughter to George and Cindy was reported missing on July 15 the year 2008 (Hopper, 2011). The young girl had been missing for the last 31 days before Cindy decided to report the matter. This was after Casey finally admitted she had no idea where her daughter was, although, for the past one month she had been claiming Caylee was with her babysitter, Zenaida Fernandez Gonzalez. This lie was later discovered since Caylee never had a babysitter by that name. On this note, investigations on the disappearance of the young girl began immediately. The sheriff conducting the study interrogated every member of Anthony family concerning... to the...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

R v Adomako, Law case

...?The case of R. v Adamako case was decided in the House of Lords by a bench composed of Lords Clashfern, Keith of Kinkel, Goff of Chieveley, Browne-Wilkinson and Woolf. This case discussed the offence of involuntary manslaughter whereby a medical practitioner who was supposed to administer anaesthesia to a patient was accused of being negligent in his duties. The appellant while in his duties in treating a patient with an eye ailment failed to notice that an oxygen pipe he had connected during an eye operation had been disconnected resulting in the death of the patient. The jury found him guilty of the offence of manslaughter after which he appealed and...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Case Analysis: R v Chaouk [2013] VSC 48

...? R v Chaouk VSC 48 Task R v Chaouk VSC 48 The two rulings delivered by the Supreme Court in February by Justice Forrest and Lasry impacted criminal trials by order stay. In the first case, Victoria Legal aid issued a decision instructing that financing of a solicitor to be done two half days after the trial regardless of the duration taken to issue a ruling. In the first ruling made by his honor Justice Lasry it was argued that the accused would be declined a fair trial if at all he was dispossessed his right of having his solicitor present. That position was accepted by his honor who cited 16 duties that are within the delineate role of a solicitor....
9 Pages(2250 words)Article

Edward R. Murrow, Army-McCarthy hearings

... Edward R. Murrow, Army-McCarthy Hearings Army McCarthy hearings gained prominence in 1954. Primarily, these hearings were the result of the conflicts between the renowned senator Joseph McCarthy and the US army. McCarthy stated that the US army favored the communists and it was risky for the country. Indirectly, he criticized the policy agenda of President Truman. From here began a series of raging arguments, inquiries and hearings, now remembered as the Army-McCarthy hearings. At the end, only shouts and incidents of misbehaviors were seen, but not before McCarthy was censured of ill doings. Joseph McCarthy was a RepublicanSenator andwas thus against the Communists. He constantly accused the federal government of being involved... but as...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper

R v Hayter [2005]

...R v Hayter Introduction This work deals with an analysis of the case R V Hayter. In this regard, relevant legal principles relating to the issue of confession have been examined. Procedural and legal issues in the case have been scrutinised. In addition, opinions of the judges and evidentiary principles have been discussed. With the rejection of the appeal to the House of Lords, in R v Hayter, it was clearly established that the confession of a defendant could be admitted as evidence against a co – defendant in a jointly tried criminal case. The reasoning behind this common law principle...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

James Q. Wilson, Bureaucracy, parts V-VI

...This book is “comprehensive" (in the exacting significance of the word), plainly composed, lavishly backed by concrete cases (generally, federal organizations) and guides about state bureaucracy fundamentally in the United States. From prologue to the end, Wilson unmistakably and convincingly exhibits the reasons why the government agencies do what they do and why the do it the manner that they do it. The book is composed into six sections: Organizations, Operators, Managers, Executives, Context, and Change. In the first part, Wilsons proposition is that associations matters. Association must be as per the goals of the organization. In the second part, the creator looks at the behavior of the operator and how their...
2 Pages(500 words)Book Report/Review

First nation studies - R. V. Sparrow case

...Advancement of Anishinabe rights in Canada: Gains and costs The court case of R. V. Sparrow helped the cause of advancement of Anishinabe rights in Canada that led to specific gains and costs paid for the same. Initiation of court case The court case was initiated by the Musqueam band member, Ronald Sparrow who was arrested for the cause of fishing with a net which was deemed to be longer than what was permitted to him as per his fishing license. The respondent of this court case of British Columbia was Her Majesty The Queen. Basis of claim in the court case The claim for this court case was filed on the...
3 Pages(750 words)Case Study

Edward R. Murrow

...Edward R. Murrow and the Birth of Broadcast Journalism Edward R. Murrow and the Birth of Broadcast Journalism The story is about an American journalist who specialized in Radio and Television news broadcast. Edward Murrow performed live shows of the WWII for the CBS developing the journalism for mass media. Born on April 25, 1908 in North Carolina, Edward Murrow became the director of talks for the CBS. He started news broadcast in 1935 and continued through the World War II. Murrow became a fixture on American radio during the World War II by risking his life reporting the London bombing from the rooftop. In his...
3 Pages(750 words)Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic R.V. Martin (Anthony Edward (2001) ECWA Crim 2245; Q.B1 Case (Critic) for FREE!

Contact Us