Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Fraudulent and Wrongful Trading: Dishonesty and Incompetence - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
This paper will argue that the distinction is not only clear, but difficult to miss because the scope of the application of both sections is rather different. Furthermore, they contain elements which cause them to be inherently different in nature, enabling them to differentiate between the different seriousness of dishonesty and incompetence…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.3% of users find it useful
Fraudulent and Wrongful Trading: Dishonesty and Incompetence
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Fraudulent and Wrongful Trading: Dishonesty and Incompetence"

Download file to see previous pages Section 213: Fraudulent Trading
Section 213 of the IA 1986 requires actual dishonesty on the part of the director(s) – as in, dishonesty as defined by the ordinary standards of the criminal law (R v Ghosh (1982). The requirement is rather high – the case of Re a Company requires that “real moral blame” be attached to a director (Re a Company (No 001418 of 1988) (1990)): a claim lies “only if there was conduct which was deliberately and actually dishonest according to the notions of ordinary decent business people” (Re EB Tractors Ltd (1986), French et al 2006, 665). Additionally, it is not necessary to prove that the fraudulent company member knew that there was no reasonable chance of them benefitting financially from their behaviour (R v Grantham (1984) per Lord Lane CJ). In the case of Re Gerald Cooper Chemicals Ltd (1978), it was held that a creditor who knowingly accepts money which has been fraudulently obtained by the company will be held a party to the conducting of the business in a fraudulent manner. The response of the law and the courts is rather harsh if a company member is found to have undertaken fraudulent trading (Re Todd Ltd (1990), and the Companies Act 2006 even provides the possibility of criminal liability. These aspects have, however, caused a high burden of proof for intent to defraud, and this has served to restrict the application of section 213 somewhat. ...
These aspects have, however, caused a high burden of proof for intent to defraud, and this has served to restrict the application of section 213 somewhat. The standards as set out in Re Patrick and Lyon Ltd (1933) hence require that actual dishonesty be evident; mere unreasonable acts are generally not sufficient (Re L Todd (Swanscombe) Ltd (1990)). The dishonesty of the acts which fall within section 213 require intent and awareness; that members are “knowingly...parties to the carrying on of a company’s business with intent to defraud” (Review Committee 1982: 1758). This allows directors who are merely reckless in continuing a failing business to escape the harshness of section 213 (Dignam and Lowry 2006: 17.67). The test is, however like section 214’s hybrid objective/subjective test, though this has often been hailed as the appropriate test for both sections of the IA 1986 (Keay 2006: 123). Section 213 also applies to members of the company who possess knowledge of the fraudulent activities of others – extending even to “blind-eye knowledge, which requires a suspicion of the relevant facts existing coupled with a deliberate decision to avoid confirming that they did exist” (Dignam and Lowry 2006: 17.60, Morris v State Bank of India (2005)). This broad application of the section serves two purposes: (1) it eases the potentially narrow application of the section due to its high standard of fault, and (2) enforces the concept that any person connected to fraudulent activity within the company will not escape liability (R v Smith (1996), Dine and Koutsias 2007: 321). Section 214: wrongful trading Section 214 of the IA 1986 highlights the criteria necessary to establish those who can be held responsible for mismanaging ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Fraudulent and Wrongful Trading: Dishonesty and Incompetence Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Fraudulent and Wrongful Trading: Dishonesty and Incompetence Essay)
“Fraudulent and Wrongful Trading: Dishonesty and Incompetence Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Fraudulent and Wrongful Trading: Dishonesty and Incompetence

Trading Places: Supporting Marxs Commodity Fetishism

...Trading Places: Supporting Marx’s Commodity Fetishism Although primarily seen as a form of inexpensive entertainment and amusement, the films coming out of Hollywood can often provide a great deal of insight into the functions of the greater society. Films capture the sense of current modes of thought in terms of political, social and economic structure in a given part of society. There are a great number of theories regarding how the media works to reinforce or reject specific cultural attitudes regarding class, race and gender, most of which are based on the theory of ideology brought forth by Karl Marx. “The Marxian view starts with the observation that ideological views tend to reflect economic power, and thus believes that one...
10 Pages(2500 words)Case Study

The Representation of Race in Eddie Murphy and Dan Ackroyd's Film Trading Places

...The Representation of Race When exploring the representation of a contemporary media text such as EddieMurphy and Dan Ackroyds film Trading Places, there are many ways in which race is represented in terms of place in society, behavior and abilities. Although movies are generally seen as a means of escaping the everyday world to a few hours of fantasy, they can also have a profound impact on how we view the world around us, including our concepts regarding racial issues. However, it is also up to us, as the audience, to determine how we will interpret these messages. There have been several theories proposed regarding how race is represented in the media. To understand the concept fully, it is necessary to understand how media...
11 Pages(2750 words)Movie Review

Patients Physical Incompetence

The four weeks at the Mumbai hospital helped me hone up my professional and personal skills. The first learning came from the environment itself. Although there were many cultural and professional differences, it was not difficult for me to adjust as I knew the local language. What was truly astonishing though was that while the other therapists were friendly and helpful they would not interact with me when others were around. I wonder whether it was a bias against gender or their reputation would be at stake if they were seen talking to a male physiotherapist. It could also be my nationality and background that disturbed them. Most of them could communicate in English although Hindi was the preferred language. Nevertheless, I did...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Climate Change and Emission Trading

...Climate change & Emission Trading The Green House Gases (GHG) Effect is one of the better understood features of the atmosphere; the science having been established in the 1800’s by the likes of Arrhenius, Fourier & Tyndall. Arrhenius (1896) estimated that a doubling of CO2 would cause 4.9-6.1o C increase in continental surface air temperature depending upon latitude and season, which is at the upper end of current predictions (1.4oC-5.8oC) under the third AR). The greater controversy surrounds exactly how human induced climate change will be realized at the regional level and across time, who will suffer and what should be done. Governments in many developing countries and at least two industrialized countries (the United states...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Carbon Emission Trading and Business Ethics in British Airways

...CARBON EMISSION TRADING AND BRITISH AIRWAYS Abstract This paper deals with the connection of the nature of contemporary organization, carbon emission trading and business ethics. A conceptual analysis is undertaken in order to know the interrelation of these notions. And to test the findings in the conceptual analysis, a case study on British Airways has been done. This study has found out that business ethics acts as the ethical framework that fits the nature of contemporary organisation as it address crucial issues like global warming. Furthermore, these paradigm has a concrete reality as manifested by British Airways’ holistic, synergistic and integrative response to the problem of global warming. CHAPTER I 1.0. INTRODUCTION...
34 Pages(8500 words)Case Study

Effectiveness of Pre-Employment Screening in the Prevention of Staff Dishonesty

... AREA: The phenomenon of staff dishonesty in the organizational culture and what or how is it caused. WORKING “Effectiveness of pre-employment screening in the prevention of staff dishonesty” BRIEF SYNOPSIS: This study deals with the notion of staff dishonesty and its various underlying fundamental causes. Apart from the different basis of staff dishonesty experienced by the organization, the effectiveness of the pre-employment screening for the elimination of the candidates with criminal records is also analyzed and the degree to which it prevents staff dishonesty. AIMS OF RESEARCH: Analyze the phenomenon of staff dishonesty and what causes it; Ascertain the effectiveness of pre-employment screening in the detection of criminal behavior...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Proposal

Slavery Trading in Africa

...Introduction Slavery trading started in the fifteenth century in Africa as a result of European colonialism. Slaves were transported to European colonies for production of crops to meet the demand of the market. The Atlantic slave trade was the largest trading of slaves across the world. The primary reason for transportation of slaves to Europe was, supplying labour to European agricultural sector because of lack of workforce across the country. Slavery was beneficial for the European colony as well as the local people of Africa who dealt in kidnapping people to make them slaves. This tradition that took action in the fifteenth century was an unsocial activity and people were made slaves against their will. Slave trade slowly...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

The Trading Relationship between the US and China

China is now considered as the United States‘biggest source of import and its second-largest trading partner. Many US-based firms believe that in order to successfully operate globally, China is a critical country to tap. Thus, China has also become a $300 billion market for US businesses, including US exports to China and the sale of US firms’ offerings in China.
The strengthening of bilateral ties between the two economies has faced a number of complexities in recent times. Trade tensions have ensued majorly because of the slow and hesitant transition of the Chinese market into a free economy. Even though China has taken steps to improve its overall trade liberation, there is still a significant amount of polici...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

Crude Oil Trading: Exxon Mobil Corporation

... of the research that the researcher is undertaking. These are therefore acting as the guiding principles, framework as well as the blue print for the research exercise. These are in a nutshell the research objectives and aims. For the research the objectives are well highlighted below to determine the major reasons for the performance of the corporation (Steve, 2013). To determine performance of Exxon Mobil corporation. To determine the pricing strategies of the Exxon Mobil corporation.. To determine stock prices in the global market. Problem statement It is very much sensible to reiterate that owing to the increased trade of oil by the Oil Producing and Exporting Countries (OPEC), there are a lot of challenges that are experienced...
23 Pages(5750 words)Research Proposal

Explanation of High-Frequency Trading

... Explanation of high-frequency trading and an evaluation of its implications for markets and shareholders of equity markets Explanation of high-frequency trading Today’s equity markets operate in a highly sophisticated computerised environment that uses varied approaches and technological trading tools (Narang, 2013, p. 23). High-frequency trading (HFT) uses algorithmic trading tools to enable traders to move in and out of equity positions in seconds or fractions of a second (Lattemann et al, 2012, p. 97). HFT uses algorithms to identify fleeting moves in the direction of equities and commodities (Aldridge, 2013, p. 35). These consist of ‘signals’ such as the movement of interest rates that can provide an indication concerning the manner...
11 Pages(2750 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Fraudulent and Wrongful Trading: Dishonesty and Incompetence for FREE!

Contact Us