Nobody downloaded yet

Trial court brief - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Trial Brief The following is a trial brief prepared by (insert your name) NEW MEXICO DISTRICT COURT STATE OF NEW MEXICO NO. CIV. 03-388 Plaintiff, JANE WHITE VS. JEFFERY CALKIN Defendant BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO DISMISS PRELIMINARY STATEMENT Jane White, the plaintiff, collided with Jeffery Calkin, the defendant, who failed to stop at a stop sign…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.4% of users find it useful
Trial court brief
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Trial court brief"

Download file to see previous pages This memorandum is submitted in opposition to that motion. QUESTION PRESENTED Under the Mandatory Financial Responsibility Act can a negligence claim be stated when a lessor who is self-insured fails to carry insurance. STATEMENT OF THE CASE Sage Rent-A-Car Inc. leased a vehicle to Jeffery Calvin. Mr. Calvin failed to stop at a stop sign and collided with Jane White. Sage did not bear insurance. Ms. White filed a negligent complaint against Sage Rent-A-Car Inc. for the negligent use of the lessor’s vehicle by the lessee. Sage filed a motion to dismiss the complaint under Rule 1-012B (6) for failure to state claim. ARGUMENT MS. WHITE’S ARGUMENT THAT SAGE HAS DUTY TO ASSUME RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE ACCIDENT IS A SET OF FACTS WHICH, IF PROVEN, WOULD ESTABLISH THE DEFENDANTS DUTY TO CARRY LICENSE AND, THEREFORE, A CLAIM CAN BE STATED AS TO DUTY. This matter is before the court on a Rule 1-012B (6) motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim. In the case Las Lumarias of the N.M. Council v. Isengard, 92 N.M. 297, 300-301 (1978), the New Mexico District Court established the standard for the granting of a 1-012B (6) motion. The court stated, “A motion to dismiss a complaint is properly granted only when it appears that the plaintiff cannot recover or be entitled to relief under any state of facts provable under the claim…” Sage Rent-A-Car’s motion specifically alleges that a claim cannot be stated in this case with regard to duty. To survive this motion, Ms. White must demonstrate that there is a provable set of facts that would establish the duty of Sage Rent-A-Car Inc. to carry license in this case. The Mandatory Financial Responsibility Act establishes the prevention of a motor owner from permitting the operation of an uninsured motor vehicle. Section 66-5-205 sets out the duty of Sage Rent-A-Car Inc. It provides, “No owner shall permit the operation of an uninsured motor vehicle, or a motor vehicle for which evidence of financial responsibility as was affirmed to the department is not currently valid, upon the streets or highways of New Mexico unless the vehicle is specifically exempted from the provisions of the Mandatory Financial Responsibility Act…” Section 66-5-218 sets out the procedure for acquiring evidence of financial responsibility: Evidence of financial responsibility, when required under the Mandatory Financial Responsibility Act, may be given by filing: A. evidence of a motor vehicle insurance policy; B. a surety bond as provided in Section 66-5-225 NMSA 1978; or C. A certificate of deposit of money as provided in Section 66-5-226 NMSA 1978. Section 66-5-207 provides for exempted motor vehicles. It provides, “The following motor vehicles are exempt from the Mandatory Financial Responsibility Act; D. A motor vehicle approved as self-insured by the superintendent of insurance pursuant to Section 66-5-207, 1 NMSA 1978:…” The Act provides for the conditions under which an owner may permit an uninsured vehicle to operate. It specifies for the exceptions to this rule, and this includes motor vehicles approved as self-insured by the superintendent of insurance. Ms. White’s complaint states that Sage is required to carry a license under the provisions of ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Trial court brief Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Trial Court Brief Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
“Trial Court Brief Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 1 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Trial court brief

Amicus (Friend of the Court) (3rd party) Brief for specified current Suprem Court case

...and violation, with an aim of putting the abuses to the task of being accountable. The organization also seeks to challenge the government and other bodies or people who hold powers to observe human rights and to end human rights abuses, particularly with reference to international human rights standards as well as that of the municipal laws. As a leading human rights body, with the aforesaid specific roles, which are highly tangential to the issues of justice , the organization has a legitimate interest to participate in the case and to present an Amicus brief for the same. The organization has a lot of interest in ensuring that justice is done to the defendant. It is the Human Rights Watch that this honorable...
12 Pages(3000 words)Research Paper

Cameras in Court Rooms Distort the Trial Process

..., his inability of his hands to fit in gloves found at the scene of murder was the most memorable event in this case. This is just like diminishing the dignity of the court. However, the television coverage provided very little prominence to scientific evidence hours that proved the possibility of the gloves having shrunk. In America for example, Court TV suggests that sensational elements of printed media pervade on television. Televisions are likely to distort true representation to a greater extent according to West, 1997, p. 48). Heinous crime trials take so long (Marquand, 1996, p. 20), that the editorial discretion is required so as to produce an informative and...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Use of Expert Witness in Court Procedings and Trial

... Court Administration: The Pros and Cons of the use of Expert Witness in Court Proceedings and Trials Heavy reliance on experts in the legal system is a source of concern in the legal community. There are advantages and disadvantages of admitting such testimony, which has been the subject for much controversy and debate. The controversies have centered on a variety of topics. The lack of scientific theories and methods used in expert testimony is the most common criticism. Expert evidence is also being questioned on the basis of whether it is impartial, and whether qualified experts are being selected through judicial procedures. Furthermore, the costs associated with the use of expert...
9 Pages(2250 words)Research Paper

Memorandum of Points and Authorities AKA Trail Court Brief

...weapon” glass vase. Defendant was illegally arrested and his possession confiscated without probable cause. ARGUMENT THE COURT SHOULD REVERSE DECICION TO DETAIN DEFENDANT FOR VIOLATION OF PENAL CODE 12024 DUE TO ILLEGAL ARREST AND LACK OF PROBABLE CAUSE. Defendant Marco Velasco, charged with felony for single count of violation of section 12024 of the United States Penal Code, contends that the trial court erred in finding sufficient probable cause to justify his arrest. As a result, the glass vase held by Defendant during his arrest wrongly assumed as a deadly weapon used against defendant, should have been suppressed. A. Defendant Was Illegally Detained Although defendant was...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Recent California or U.S. Supreme Court Case Brief

...7 November Assignment In the renowned Supreme Court Case of Jackson v. Birmingham Board of Education, the rule of law was held to be that retaliating against a person because he has complained of being discriminated on the grounds of sex falls under a branch of intentional sex discrimination, which is encompassed by Title IX. This was an important case with respect to intentional sex discrimination and never before had such principle of law been enunciated by the Judiciary. In the light of the selected case, teacher by the name of Roderick Jackson, teaching in the Birmingham, Alabama public school system, brought a suit against the Birmingham Board of Education alleging that the board retaliated against him because he...
3 Pages(750 words)Case Study

Famous Court trial Analysis, 3 to choose from

.... In the process, a letter was found, which was written by Bite, the girl who presented the rape case, to her boyfriend. The letter entailed a statement that the girl was not raped, and therefore, her testimony in the court was false. The results of the case at trial and on appeal When the case reached the Supreme Court, the case handed over to the lower court after finding the black’s exclusion on jury. In this court, the electrocution tried all the defendants, and eight of them were sentenced to death. One of the nine black teenagers wrote a book, vividly describing all the events and his experience in the trial. The legal issues...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay


...that the defendant negligently injured the recurrent laryngeal nerve. However, the defendant claimed that the laryngeal was not severed. The rule of identifying negligence in this case is through expert opinion. The doctors argued that the method used by the plaintiff was appropriate. The trial court directed verdict on the defendant on specific negligence issue. The plaintiff illustrated the applicability of res ipsa loqoitur doctrine. The defendant claimed that the second foundation fact involving res ipsa loqoitur is absent due to the fact that it doesn’t lie in laymen’s common knowledge. This is in reference to injury occurring during cervical fusion surgery, because of inadequate care. The...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Mock trial

...the court should not pursue plaintiff consideration for damages. At the conclusion of this negligence trial, it is my sincere hope that in the interests of the justice you will find that the defendant is not responsible for the cause the loss of Joey. Thank you very much. Opening statement: Jury member We are here to determine a case where the plaintiff Andrea Davis is pursuing damages from HappyLand Company. The plaintiff is set to provide evidence and reasons why Bianca manufacturing process of Princess Beads is the cause for the loss of her daughter Joey. She has cited negligence on the part of the company due to inclusion GHB that is allegedly dangerous when ingested. The defense team working in...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Court Brief 2

...Court Brief for Brosseau v. Haugen, 543 U.S. 194 (2004), Per Curiam. No: Court Brief for Brosseau v. Haugen, 543 U.S. 194 (2004), Per Curiam Introduction Supreme Court of United States decided for Officer Rochelle Brosseau to receive qualified immunity against Haugen’s appeal. Brosseau shot Kenneth Haugen in the back when he tried to run away from the scene. Kenneth Haugen appealed against Brossaeu in the Court of Appeals. This paper will use IRAC method for briefing the case. Issue The issue highlighted in the case Brosseau v. Haugen is violation of Fourth Amendment by Brosseau and entitlement of Brosseau to the...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Court Brief 3

...Court Brief for Moran v. Burbine, 475 U.S. 412 (1986), O’Connor J. No: Court Brief for Moran v. Burbine, 475 U.S. 412 (1986), O’Connor J. Introduction The Supreme Court of Rhode Island convicted Brian Burbine of 1st degree murder, reaffirmed the decision of jury, and rejected Brian’s claim that as per Fifth Amendment and Fourteenth Amendment of the Constitution, his signed confessions in the form of waivers should be suppressed. This paper will use IRAC method for briefing the case. Issue The issue highlighted in the case Moran v. Burbine is violation of Fifth and Fourth Amendment by the police officials who interrogated and attained...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Trial court brief for FREE!

Contact Us