Lucy vs. Zehmer - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
LUCY vs. ZEHMER 196 Va. 493; 84 S.E.2d 516 Supreme Court of Virginia (1954) 1. Statement of the facts Complainants W.O. and J.C. Lucy, brothers, filed a case for specific performance of a contract. The respondents were the spouses A.H. and I.S. Zehmer, friends of W.O…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94% of users find it useful
Lucy vs. Zehmer
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Lucy vs. Zehmer"

Download file to see previous pages The instrument the Lucys were seeking to enforce stated: “We hereby agree to sell to W.O. Lucy the Ferguson Farm complete for $50,000, title satisfactory to buyer.” It was written by A.H. Zehmer, and was duly signed by both A.H. and I.S. Zehmer. The defense of A.H. Zehmer was that he considered the offer of Lucy to purchase Ferguson as a joke, and at the time they signed the document both of the respondents were drunk. Zehmer also stated that while he did write the document, to him it was more of a response to a dare, as he did not believe that Lucy could afford $50,000, something he outrightly told the latter. In fact, although Zehmer wrote the contract, he did not deliver it, but Lucy picked it up, read it and put it in his pocket. At this point, Lucy offered $5 earnest money to seal the contract, but realizing he was serious, Zehmer refused to accept the money and instead told Lucy that had no intentions to sell Ferguson. On the other hand, Lucy contended that the sale was a done deal. He argued that at no time did he believe Zehmer to be joking. When Zehmer mentioned that Lucy would not be able to afford his price, Lucy assured him that he could. This was the reason Lucy immediately thereafter asked the help of his brother who agreed to share interests in the purchase. The lower court decided that Lucy had not proven his right to specific performance, and the case was dismissed. ...
However, if the contract remains valid, then the Lucys are entitled to its specific performance. 3. The court's decision on those issues The Supreme Court of Virginia ruled that a valid contract had been created when the Zehmers set their signatures to the instrument, creating an obligation on either side to meet its terms as contained in the document. The claim of Zehmer that he was merely drunk, and at the same time only joking (i.e., did not really intend to sell), is not sufficient to invalidate the existing contract. The complainants are entitled to the specific performance of the contested contract. The decision of the lower court is therefore reversed, and the case is remanded. 4. The rationale the court used in reaching those decisions The Supreme Court decided that Zehmer’s contention that he did not really intend to offer his property for sale does not hold water. It is true that normally, the law of contracts requires that the parties to the contract mutually consented to it. However, given certain cases such as this one, it is not so important for the parties to mentally agree to the forming of the contract; what is important is that the acts and words of one of the parties convey the reasonable meaning of such intention to the other party, that is, that the parties appeared serious in their intent to transact (Patterson, p. 74). A binding contract of sale therefore existed between the two parties, whether or not the response of the Zehmers was serious or in jest, because one party (Lucy) made a serious offer, and took their response to be likewise a serious answer to his offer. “Intentions of the parties to a contract are determined by a reasonable interpretation of their manifest conduct and expression. Unexpressed ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Lucy vs. Zehmer Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Lucy vs. Zehmer Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1432244-lucy-vs-zehmer
(Lucy Vs. Zehmer Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Lucy Vs. Zehmer Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1432244-lucy-vs-zehmer.
“Lucy Vs. Zehmer Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1432244-lucy-vs-zehmer.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Lucy vs. Zehmer

Mirror by lucy grealy

...is not real. She believes that the society lacks values and people do not take notice of any values. Nature did not give Lucy beauty, which was a popular social demand. This was due to the fact that she had to undergo chemotherapy from a very young age. The society in which Grealy existed, failed to show empathy towards her. They were not able to accept Grealy as she was. They never bothered to help her. This is what happened in Grealy’s case, whereas a real society is the one, which helps people in need and support them to conquer their sufferings and inabilities. But Grealy had to endure a lot while she was in school and college. Later in her life, after many attempts to rise up to the standards of the society and...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Analyze Lucy in Disgrace by comparing her to Lucy in William Wordsworth's The Lucy Poems. Explain at least three signi

...?A Comparative Analysis of Lucy in J M Coetzee’s “Disgrace” and Lucy in William Wordsworth’s “The Lucy Poems” “Disgrace,” a novel written by J M Coetzee and published in 1999, narrates the story of a South African professor, David Laurie, and his daughter, Lucy Laurie. The work, besides being honored with the Booker Prize, has also fetched the coveted Nobel Prize for Literature in 2003 for its author. Set in the post apartheid period, the novel has several political connotations but is noted significantly for its depiction of the social ramifications on individuals, especially the whites. The work also dwells on themes of violence and exploitation and the indelible and tormenting lacerations they leave on the victims as well... as the...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

Why was I Love Lucy so popular

...Why was "I Love Lucy" so popular? The rise in popularity of television in the nineteen fifties led to the development of condition comedy. This was a style that got the attention of viewers by introducing a story with an opening, a middle part, and a cheerful ending. I love Lucy was one of the most popular shows that employed this technique. In addition, this show remains accepted among both the old and young members of the population. Some of the viewers are more than forty years old. For many viewers, the response to how this show effectively and continually keeps viewers glued to the television is that it is humorous. Nonetheless, I Love Lucy contains more than the funny elements that...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Mirrors by Lucy Grealy

...Fields of Reading Mirrors Fields of reading is a book containing numerous curriculum divisions of social sciences, art and humanities as well as sciences. The divisions are written by diverse authors who are established writers and teachers. One of the art and humanities topic is a story called mirrors by Lucy Grealy. She is a poet who has won numerous awards. In her story mirror she talks about how she has struggled with her own image as she constantly found numerous flaws with herself. For a long time she has hid her face using a scarf or mask since she did not want people to see her “there was a long period of time, almost a year, during which I never looked in a mirror” (Grealy 2007). While she was 9 years, Grealy...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Case Study Lucy and Peter at the GP

...for that person to be evaluated. This may open the door for discrimination in health care decisions and insurance policies. Also, it may be involved in the clinical decisions within the CPOE systems. Therefore, because of its growing importance, genetics must be taken seriously in regards to safeguarding the privacy and confidentiality of patient's records. Case analysis In a particular case, two young adults are in search for a private for a private healthcare treatment for their mother. Their mother's general practitioner recommended they look for a private service for their mother to suit their needs. 1) Lucy uses an online service provider to find and make an appointment for their mother. She was unable to...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

A letter from Lucy

...The letters from Lucy to her mother can be written from two perspectives. The first letter would exhibit Lucy’s anger and emotions of hatred towards her mother. The second letter would exhibit the total opposite i.e. the feeling of remorse, emptiness and guilt. Mother, I don’t know why I should mention or even begin this letter with the word mother. Our relationship was always estranged for as a child I was neglected. On leaving my homeland I presumed that I would be rid of my past and my future would be enduring with the dreams I failed to have because of your presence. Till date your presence, though it not being physical, still has an immense pact on me and I wonder why? My goals, my education and...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Critical research paper on the book Lucy by Jamaica Kincaid

... A critical review of the novel ‘Lucy’ by Jamaica Kincaid Lucy, a novel by JamaicaKincaid (Elaine Potter Richardson), was first published in 1990. This book, first of the series to be based outside the Caribbean scenario, tells the story of a young girl named Lucy who comes to America to work as an au pair to a white, wealthy couple. The entire story is narrated in first person and closely reflects Kincaid’s own life. In fact, the main protagonist Lucy Josephine Potter shares a name and also the birthday with Kincaid. Therefore, in a certain sense this book can also be called an autobiography that is more or less based on the writer’s own life and experiences. We notice this trend of having an autobiographical base in nearly all... of...
10 Pages(2500 words)Research Paper

How I Met Your Mother vs. I Love Lucy

...How I Met Your Mother” vs. “I Love Lucy” Question The two comedies are different in the plots in, which they are developed. How I met your mother concentrates more on many relationship stories, while in I love Lucy; the show concentrates on one relationship, and tells of how their relationships with their friends and family are affecting this relationship. Both shows are hilarious since they show the characters smoking or drinking, and this tends to depict consumption of alcohol in a new light. All the characters have similar behaviors in both shows. This makes individual actors to look good in their acting. Additionally, both the shows revolve around the theme of relationships and,...
2 Pages(500 words)Movie Review

Woolley v. Hoffmann-La Roche, Inc. and Lucy v. Zehmer

...manual is different from the employment contract to make everything clear. Case study 2 Task 1 The whole task of selling the land ends up in a total dispute. It is accompanied by corruption such as bribing for the sake of convincing the buyer to fix the bargain. In addition to that, it seems that Zehmer was intoxicated with “drinks “at the time of the sales process, later confirming that the whole process was a joke. In addition to that, the price for the quoted land is far much low according to the economic standards, such that one may see it a joke buying such huge piece at such a low price. Zehmer also makes a commitment to sell the farm without making a prior and sober agreement with the wife but...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

TSCA VS REACH VS CEPA

...Environmental Studies Environmental Studies Efforts to protect the environment has been a touchy issue with the affected parties pointing a finger at one another for blame. Environmental protection requires participation of everyone in the community and sustainable use of resources in the environment with the state or the government as the lead agency (Girard, Day & Snider, 2010). In addition, the intervention in environmental protection is achievable through the state participation by endorsing regulations in favour of environmental protection. These regulations include TSCA, REACH AND CEPA. This paper present a comparison of TSCA and REACH with Canada’s regulatory framework, Canada Environmental Protection Act, CEPA... Studies Environmental ...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Lucy vs. Zehmer for FREE!

Contact Us