StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Legitimate Authority - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
This essay discusses that while the author of “Power Politics” does a good job examining the types of authority, legitimate and illegitimate, that exist, it works under a series of assumptions that can be problematic when put into practice in a school environment…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.5% of users find it useful
Legitimate Authority
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Legitimate Authority"

While the of “Power Politics” does a good job examining the types ity, legitimate and illegitimate, that exist, it works under a series of assumptions that can be problematic when put into practice in a school environment. One of the problems with this article is that the author insists that choice is an important part of legitimate authority. He says that part of legitimate authority is voluntary compliance with commands, rather than people obeying commands for some other reason (172). The problem with this is that it leaves the subordinate in the superior-subordinate relationship to determine whether or not to obey a command. For instance, everyone can agree that a teacher has the ability to assign students work and grade them on the said work. But, sometimes a teacher assigns work that a student considers inappropriate – the student believes that it is too hard or not to grade level, is too long and so on. Should the student have the right to challenge this assignment? And if the student challenges it, and the teacher insists upon their command, does the teacher have the right to force the student to finish the assignment, or punish them for not doing so by failing them? In the practice of authority relationships in school, the answer is no, the student does not have the right to challenge a command, and yes, the teacher has the right to essentially coerce the student into following it through the threat of a failing grade. This does not mean that the system itself is wrong – the ability to fail students who do not behave or follow instructions is important to run a school or class room, but only that school systems fail to meet the requirement for legitimate authority functionally, meaning that other systems need to be in place to make authority legitimate in the way the author says. This problem of choice also extends to other areas of the article. The author talks about principles and students and so on “accepting” the rules of schools, and entering an “agreement” with schools and other institutions (173). The words “accept” and “agreement” both work under mean the person, such as the student or the principle, has a choice whether they want to be part of the school or not, and that by choosing to do so they agree that all authority above them is legitimate. But students are often forced without their choice by law to attend schools until a certain age, and the school they attend is decided by the where they live or what their parents tell them to do rather than their own choice. So legitimate authority, as the author talks about it involving choice, cannot function for the students; if they need to “accept” and “agree” for authority to be legitimate, as the author says, they should be able to say that none of the authority above them is legitimate, because they did not accept or agree to it. This essay does not intend to say that the organization of teachers, administrators and so on are not legitimate forms of authority, but rather that choice to be part of an organization cannot be part of forming legitimate authority in school environments. This means that other structures have to stand to take their place, for instance the ability to appeal decisions a student or parent questions questions, because coercive forces work on subordinates in school relationships without them having a choice. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Legitimate Authority Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1427721-critical-thinking-essay
(Legitimate Authority Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1427721-critical-thinking-essay.
“Legitimate Authority Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1427721-critical-thinking-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Legitimate Authority

Introduction of the Euro and the European Constitution in Terms of Framework, Authority, and Aspirations

... some amendments in the Maastricht Treaty on EU of 1991. This QMV was used as a legislative control authority that had its share in the voting through a qualified majority in the Council. QMV has the right to help the council in anyway it can to recommend the approval of any proposal pending on the commission’s table providing it has the support of nearly 70 percent of the total votes cast. This also varies in accordance with the voting member states’ population size in the Council. The Council of Ministers also has the legal binding to hold governmental and law making responsibilities with the European parliament. It is another fact to be noted here that the influence the parliament has on legislation and government as such is very...
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

Hobbes and Rousseau on the Creation of Political Authority

... since Rousseau dose not agree to give so much power to the ruler of any state. Rousseau believes that a ruler or a government must establish its own legitimacy before it seeks the consent of the governed to take away certain rights. While Hobbes comes across as a believer in the force of authority and the strength of a central figure even as per the title of his work, Leviathan, Rousseau gives a more positive view of government. For example, he does not suggest that governments have to be created by force but rather that legitimate governmental authorities can only be established when the people of a state agree to be governed by a particular person (Delaney, 2006). This is certainly a more enlightened view as compared to the view taken...
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The Football Safety Authority - Its Powers and Authorities

...The Football Safety ity – Its Powers and ities Introduction Under the government framework of the United Kingdom, there are agencies denominated as non-departmental bodies. There are three types.1 An executive body is one that undertakes a good number of tasks involving its own operations and regulations in connection with its defined powers and authorities. It also deals in commercial and semi-commercial transactions. Another kind is the advisory body which is usually comprised of a team of people highly skilled in their specific fields of endeavours and, within that ambit, renders advices and recommendations to the government on a certain concern. Tribunals are those which have judicial or quasi-judicial functions. In the case...
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The General Guidelines Provided by the Saudi Food and Drug Authority

... Suspension of the drug Avandia in Saudi Arabia Introduction: The drug Avandia which was used in the treatment of Diabetes Mellitus 2 was recently suspended in Saudi Arabia for a period of six months because of the element of risk associated with it, as a cause of heart failure. In association with this move, the Saudi Food and Drug Authority which was responsible for this move, has also taken steps to circulate information publicly on the dangers of the drug and the Ministry of Health has offered some tentative guidelines on the drug for those who are treating patients on the drug and pharmacists issuing the drug, on the manner in which the drug is to be handled. This research study proposes to undertake an examination...
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Can Terrorism Be Considered a Legitimate Form of Revolutionary Warfare

...Can terrorism be considered a legitimate form of revolutionary warfare? Recently, the problem of international terrorism increasingly has occupied the center stage. This kind of terrorism is termed international because it meets one or more of the following conditions. To start with, the target of terrorism is selected from a country other than that of the terrorists themselves. Secondly, the commission of terrorism involves crossing national borders, and thirdly participating members and/or sponsors of terrorist activity are from more than one country (Anthony 1963). Terrorism is instilling terror mainly by inflicting force, threats, intimidation, trickery, or some other form of pressure or strength to a certain community. Such events...
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Authority and Power in International Affairs

...Authority and Power in International Affairs In all forms of government there is always an element of dissent and disobedience to the authority of the state. While in totalitarian states, dissent is not tolerated and crushed as and when it happens, in the more democratic forms of government it is actually seen as a healthy sign. If we go back in history, we find that most of the progressive legislations and grants of civil liberties have been won through hard struggle from below. So the merits associated with democratic governance today were largely a product of grassroots struggle of the people and their contestation of the authority of the state. So instead of looking at contestation of state power as a malign expression of social...
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Ways to Improve the Work Environment at Capital Market Authority

...Executive Summary The Capital Market ity (CMA) came into existence as a result of the passing of the Capital Market Law, which was issued by Royal Decree in July 2003. In the recent times, the HR department of CMA had been facing a lot of issues in areas of employee motivation and retention. The author chose a combination of primary and secondary research design to suggest suitable ways to improve work environment. The author suggests redesigning the compensation structure of the organization along with providing company provided transport to the employees. The purpose of this memo is to suggest ways to improve the work environment at CMA. The next part of this report contains a brief background of CMA. This is followed by a discussion...
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

Describe the principal characteristics of the Weberian ideal type bureaucracy. What are the roles of power and authority in this model Discuss strengths and weaknesses of the bureaucratic form of organization

... and its influence in politics presciently, for Hitler was to begin his rise to power from the Ashes of the Weimar Republic Weber helped to form within only a few years of Weber’s death. In the Charismatic leader and the type of society organized under its rule, Weber believed one would be more likely to see bias and illegitimate authority passed from generation to generation through the hereditary transference of wealth and power. Where land or property ownership was concentrated of one class, authority might wield that power in an arbitrary or authoritarian manner in order to maximize the benefit of a minority group in society. Thus the charismatic and the hereditary both represented a threat to the establishment and growth of progressive...
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Write a report for the authority of a city or town making the case for greening the city. The purpose of your report is to explain to the authority why it is important to develop urban green spaces and to propose ways of greening the city or town

...Greening the Institute’s Introduction This report is written regarding the research in Tyndall Centre for Climate Change suggests that we need a 10 % increase in green space in our cities to fight and survive change in climate. This report if for the authority of a city or town, where we will be making the case for greening the city. This report shall explain to the city authority why it is important to develop urban green spaces and to propose ways of greening the city or town. The city that I have chosen for the report is Columbia City. The term Greening the city means creating parks, gardens and other places where plants are grown. This means that the city must have more gardens and parks. This will not only help the city combat...
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Greater London Authority in London

...Greater London Authority in London Introduction Greater London Authority (GLA) is a high level governmental unit in London. GLA was developed by GLA Act which was passed in the year 1999 and recognised officially in the year of 2000. GLA performs cooperatively with four organisations which are: Transport for London (TFL), London Development Agency (LDA), London Fire and Emergency Planning Authority (LFEPA), and Metropolitan Police Authority (MPA). GLA mainly covers three fields which are: economic growth and wealth construction, community improvement, and environmental enhancement. GLA is in charge of strategic management of Greater London. It enjoys the right and authority of local government. GLA was developed with the aim of improving...
11 Pages (2750 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Legitimate Authority for FREE!

Contact Us