Nobody downloaded yet

Mess at the stadium - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
In this case, it can be noted that James and Christopher triggered the pandemonium that broke at the stadium when they blew their vuvuzelas after their team, the Riders had scored. Hundreds of supporters were killed and others injured while Christopher and James were among those who lost their lives. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.9% of users find it useful
Mess at the stadium
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Mess at the stadium"

Download file to see previous pages In this case, it can be noted that James and Christopher triggered the pandemonium that broke at the stadium when they blew their vuvuzelas after their team, the Riders had scored. Hundreds of supporters were killed and others injured while Christopher and James were among those who lost their lives. The grandmother, mother and father of the boys subsequently suffered from nervous shock (psychiatric injury). Against this background, this essay seeks to describe while giving reasons the approach that can be taken by a High Court judge towards claims of nervous shock by the affected people in view of the cases that are going to be analysed below. In view of this case of Dulieu v White [1901] 2 KB 669 which involved a pregnant barmaid who suffered severe shock after the defendant’s servant drove negligently into the public house, it can be noted that the High Court upheld her claim. The case involving the grandmother, mother and father of the boys may as well be upheld in as far as claims for nervous shock are concerned. In this case, the defendants are the police officers who had a duty to safeguard the interests of the soccer fans who were packed in the stadium. The subsequent pandemonium that killed hundreds of people while injuring others was not a result of their negligent behaviour. In actual fact, the horses were frightened by the noise of vuvuzelas that were blown by James and Christopher. It can be noted that these two boys are the ones who triggered the situation that resulted in loss of life of innocent people including themselves. Indeed, the defendant has a duty not to frighten the plaintiff by his negligence whereby it can be noted that the blame does not lie in the police but in the boys’ action that frightened the horses. If it was not because of their action, this disaster could not have happened. It the case of Alcock v Chief Constable of South Yorkshire Police [1992] 1 AC 310 concerned a FA Cup semi-final match at Hillsborough Stadium, between Nottingham Forest and Liverpool in April 1989, at which 96 people were killed and over 400 physically injured in a crush caused by negligent crowd control by the police. To a certain extent, it can be said that the conduct by the police in controlling the crowd in the case involving James and Christopher was negligent given that there is wild cheering when another team scores especially with regards to big matches and the police should always be watchful for such incidences. In the first place, they allowed the boys to get into the stadium with vuvuzelas which meant that they could be blown. The failure to control their horses amounts to negligent behaviour since people watching matches are over excited at times. Thus, only parents and spouses might claim for nervous shock and the claimants in this case can show a “sufficiently proximate” relationship to the person killed or injured as can be noted from their closeness with the deceased. McFarlane v EE Caledonia Ltd [1994] 2 All ER 1 involves a plaintiff who has witnessed colleagues dying in agony following an oil rig explosion. However, the court of appeal applied the rule by the House of Lords in Alcock where the claim failed because the claimant was not a rescuer. In the same vein, the claims involving the mother and the grandmother may fail to materialise given that they just watched the situation unfolding on television and they are not part of the rescue team. Somebody who physically experiences the action directly stands better chances of winning the claim since he will be part of the horrific events than someone merely watching from a distance. The mother and the grandmother are not even closer to the scene since they are just watching the events on television while at home. As far as the above case is concerned, the claim by these two may not materialise since they are not directly involved especially in rescuing the affected people who have been injured in the stampede that ensued after the police horses have been frightened by the noise of the vuvuzelas and ran amok causing ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Mess at the stadium Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1405801-case-analysis
(Mess at the Stadium Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1405801-case-analysis.
“Mess at the Stadium Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1405801-case-analysis.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Mess at the stadium

Camp Nou Stadium

...College Camp nou was constructed in 1957. During its construction era, many football stadiums were coming up with better equipments and had extra facilities. After its construction, it became the centre of attraction and the largest football stadium in the world. A record that it held until the late 70’s when other stadiums of better families were built. This paper gives a full description of how this five star stadium was constructed and the way that it would be constructed had it to be constructed in the present world. Camp Nou Stadium Camp nou is the largest football stadium in Spain and the second largest football...
11 Pages(2750 words)Research Paper

Old Trafford stadium

...?Old Trafford Number The Old Trafford football stadium is widely known as the home of the most notably well known football club, which is Manchester United. It is also known as the largest football ground in the UK. It was nicknamed The Theatre of Dreams by Manchester United's famous captain Sir Bobby Charlton. In spite of current refurbishments that have maintained the stadium looking elegant and up-to-date, the stadium still has an irrefutable impression. Old Trafford was the premiere stadium to have a ring of seats and stands that completely surrounded the pitch. Opened in 1910, Old Trafford was originally intended to hold eighty thousand spectators, making it the...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Paul Brown Stadium

...Summary of the facts Hamilton County is the home of the baseball and football teams the Cincinnati Reds and Cincinnati Bengals. In 1996 the had negotiations with both teams for two new stadiums. The Bengals stated that if they were not given a new stadium they would relocate. The city negotiated a very bad deal with the Bengals in which they assumed practically all the costs to build a new stadium. They also gave the Bengals a preferable lease agreement. The initial estimated cost of both projects was $540 million. The Bengals project was wrongly estimated. The cost rose from $280 to an all inclusive costs of nearly $555 million (Albergotti & McWhirter). The county took out $1 billion in...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Melting Pot or Mess

...Your Your Melting Pot or Mess Why the United s Needs no Official Language In the years since September 11,2001, what had already been a predominant sentiment against immigration received the validation of fear: these foreigners seething into our country's borders might not only be taking jobs away from hard-working Americans, so the argument went, they might also be planning to murder thousands of those Americans. Forget the debate about illegal immigrants sucking up billions of dollars in health benefits, education for their children (who as often as not drop out before graduation!), and other social services - now the anti-immigration forces have the banner of national security to carry. To some, it may seem...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Athens Olympic stadium

...The Athens Olympic stadium was first inaugurated in 1982 at the 13th European Athletics Championships and hosted a number of international athletic and cultural events, before being refurbished for the Athens Olympic Games of 2004. The renovation of this stadium was assigned to the world-renowned architect Santiago Calatrava. Calatrava refurbished the entire main Olympic complex, including the stadium, using his trademark style of arches and white color. Refurbishment involved the construction of an arched roof to cover 95 % of the seating of the concrete bowl of the stadium. In the following pages how the stadium's renovation turned out an enormous...
5 Pages(1250 words)Case Study

Master of FinanceBentley College

..., failure was not an option. Failure meant our chapter would go bankrupt and lose our fraternity house. There was no one to bail us out if we made a mess of things or mishandled funds. Not even the national fraternity headquarters would come to our rescue. When first nominated for the position, I was hesitant to accept, fearing that I would mess up or cause the loss of the house. While running for the position, our fraternity was in debt with barely enough finances to keep and maintain our chapter house. Based on my high grades and reputation for having a talent with numbers, my fraternity brothers elected me as their treasurer. I was elected to the annual position in May of 2004. We had only a year to...
2 Pages(500 words)Admission/Application Essay

Beijing National Stadium

...BEIJING NATIONAL STADIUM The Largest Bird’s Nest of Beijing China SPECIFIC DETAILS: Contractors: Jacques Herzog and Pierre de Meuron Project Architect: Stefan Merbach Artist/ Building Designer: Ai Wei Wei CADG Leader: Chief Architect Li Xinggang Date of Construction: December 2003 Formal Opening: June 2008 Project Worth: $423 Million BEIJING CHINA is a city known for its beauty and stance in modern architectural designs. Hence, upon being chosen to be the host of the 2008 Olympic Games, the Chinese government aimed to prepare further for the event through offering the world with an innovatively designed structure that would be out of the ordinary style of architectural creations known to the human society at present...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Qualcomm Stadium Sponsorship

...Qualcomm Stadium Sponsorship I travelled to Qualcomm Stadium, which is the home of the NFL’s San Diego Chargers and the San Diego Aztecs college football team. Until 2003, the stadium served as the home of the MLBs San Diego Padres. Qualcomm Stadium is a multi-purpose stadium in the Mission Valley area in San Diego, California. The stadiums current naming rights are owned by Qualcomm (NASDAQ: QCOM), which is an American global semi-conductor company that designs, manufactures, and markets digital wireless telecommunications products and services. The organization has its headquarters located in San Diego, California and is currently in...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Bose stadium sound system

...Bose Stadium Sound System Bose sound systems is one of the best sound system for the stadiums, this is because they arecustom engineered to fit a particular facility. The speakers provide unclouded speech and natural-sounding music which is advantageous when crowds are cheering. The systems are programmed to run automatically therefore it is simple to control it when reporting a game in the stadium without having to shut it off when the game is at half time. This sound system does not require sound treatments that would reduce the cheers made by the spectators, making the game even more interesting (BOSE UNITED STATES). Bose stadium sound systems are designed to...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Levis Stadium

...Levis Stadium Levis Stadium Levis Stadium serves as among the world’s best outdoor entertainment and sports venue. The arenais a football stadium in the suburb of San Jose, San Francisco Bay area in Santa Clara, California. It is a home to San Francisco 49ers. The stadium has a capacity of approximately 68,500 seats, featuring 165 of luxury suites and about 8,500club seats. The $1.2 billion venues, designed by HNTB are 1.85 million square feet. Levis stadium has a structure that takes advantage of the Silicon Valley climate, having a green roof proving to be the next cohort of stadium design that is environmentally friendly. It consists of hundreds of solar panels from three of the solar bridges connecting to the main parking area... of the...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Mess at the stadium for FREE!

Contact Us