Nobody downloaded yet

Commercial Contracts - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Introduction Lord Staughton identifies that the issue of interpreting written contract is one of the most popular conflicts and issues in the Law of Contract1. Since commercial contracts often have great worth, there are numerous forms of litigation that come with them which requires the court to examine the deeper meaning of the contract…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.5% of users find it useful
Commercial Contracts
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Commercial Contracts"

Download file to see previous pages This paper examines two approaches for interpreting commercial contracts in courts of law. The paper assesses the literal and purposive approach to examining and interpreting contracts in courts of law. The paper will assess the advantages and disadvantages of the two approaches and come up with a conclusion on the subject and the evolution process. Literal Approach In commercial contracts, the parties come up with their own terms for the exchange of consideration between them. As such, they write down the terms and conditions for the exchange of consideration. According to Lord Staughton, where there is a dispute in such a contract, the court needs to detect the meaning of the terms and this is a question of law for the judge and not a question of fact for the jury4. Hence, the Judge presiding over the case needs to use an approach to ascertain the facts and what the parties in the contract meant in order to resolve the issue at hand. In the past, most courts used the literal approach, this is steeped in the objective approach to the interpretation of contracts5. This is based on the premise that “... the intentions in the heart of a person is not in man's ability to judge, but change caused by reason of the promise”6. Traditionally, the law of contract is based on negotiations and the promises that were exchanged during negotiations. Also, some of the core maxims of the law of contract made it difficult for the judges to use any other methodology than the literal approach. For instant, English law states that consideration must be sufficient and not adequate. This therefore means that the doctrine of “caveat emptor”, which requires the parties entering a contract to be careful, will act as an estoppel to prevent judges from interpreting the law in any system or structure that would support an attempt to assess intent. Strictly speaking, the objective approach should be the basis for the interpretation of contracts even if it causes serious hardships for one of the parties. In the case of Arcos Ltd V E. A. Romaasen and Sons7, it was held that any express term that is breached in contract renders it null and void. This is because the express terms often form conditions and these conditions must be discharged, otherwise the aggrieved party gets the right to back out of the contract. In Bunge Corporation V Tradax SA8, there was a contract for the mercantile supply of goods. Clause 7 of the contract gave one of the parties the right to terminate the contact if there was a delay. Lord Wilberforce held that time was of the essence in the contract and in the mercantile industry, time lapses were severe enough to merit a cancellation of an entire contract. Lord Scarman and Lord Roskill concurred. Some judges like Lord Staughton hold the view that the court needs to be very careful not to overlook the original terms of the contract to apply new interpretations9. This means that the literal approach is the default Common Law approach to cases relating to the law of contract. Purposive Approach In Codelfa V State Rail Authority10, Lord Brennan stated that “the symbols of language convey meaning according to the circumstances in which they were used”. This therefore means that words in itself are meaningless and the literal application of such words might be devoid of the bigger picture and have some limitations. As such, a Judge will need to use a purposive approach to integrate the context, ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Commercial Contracts Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 words”, n.d.)
Commercial Contracts Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 words. Retrieved from
(Commercial Contracts Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 Words)
Commercial Contracts Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 Words.
“Commercial Contracts Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Commercial Contracts


...the clear difference between the two and how a better framework can be constituted to ensure that contracts not only manages the relationship of the parties in a construction project but also an enabler of how their relationship will be better rather than a hindrance. More often than not contracts are sometimes considered a hindrance to a better working relationship. This could be due to the disparity with regards to responsibility allocation and compensation allocation if not the assignment of risks and the disparity of the commercial exposure of the parties not aligned to the risks assigned to them. Equitable distribution of risks as well as the commercial exposure in...
12 Pages(3000 words)Coursework

What role does Lex Mercatoria Play in international commercial contracts

...? What Role does Lex Mercatoria Play in International Commercial Contracts? by The of the The of the The name of the school The city and state where it is located Date XX century was marked by the rapid surge in international economic relations, which led to an increase of the world trade volume and accelerated the trade turnover between partners from different countries. But amid the dynamic changes of relations in the international commercial turnover, the legal regulation of these relations did not undergo a radical transformation. Such means as collision and substantive rules of national legislation of parties in dispute or the provisions of international contracts...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Criticize Elizabeth Anderson's Claim that the Autonomy of Women will be Promoted by Banning Commercial Surrogacy Contracts

...Criticism of Elizabeth Anderson’s claim that the Autonomy of Women will be promoted by Banning Commercial Surrogacy Contracts Introduction Surrogacy refers to a relationship where a woman on behalf of another person or a couple bears and gives birth to a child. The woman acts as a replacement or surrogate mother for another woman who cannot carry the pregnancy until birth or is unable to produce fertile eggs. Surrogate mothering would be classified into two. The first one involves the implantation of the husband’s sperm in the surrogate mother through a process referred to as Artificial Insemination. If the intended mother has the ability to produce eggs that are fertile but is unable to carry the...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Commercial Contracts Problem Question Assignment: Queen Industries Ltd is the manufacturer of a heavy-duty washing machine which

...? Commercial Contracts For assessing the contractual liability of the Queen Industries Ltd and the retailer Radio Stores; the first issue to be considered is whether they were in breach of section 13 of the Sale of Goods Act 1979. The implied terms in section 13 of the Sale of Goods Act 1979, permits a buyer to reject the goods supplied, if they have not been described correctly. However, the purchaser should have relied on the description of the goods provided by the seller, for this provision to be applicable. Moreover, the Sale of Goods Act 1979 enjoins that the goods supplied should not have any defect (Von Bar, et al., 2004, p. 280). To make Queen Industries and Radio Stores, liable for a breach of...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Commercial Contracts

...entered into a contract, where Watchtowers Ltd was supposed to supply Classic Gift Ltd with both the antique watches and the cleaning oil. The latter owns several shops that specialize in the sale of such watches. The managing director of Classic Gift Ltd agreed on a contract with Matthew Achbold, who was the sales director at Watchtower. It is this contract that was supposed to bund the two parties, in ensuring that everything happened according to the stipulations therein. The challenge After the delivery of the goods to Classic Gift, it was found that some of the oil provided had some defects. According to the letter addressed to the sales director of Watchtower, the oil led to...
14 Pages(3500 words)Essay

Commercial Transactions (Contracts)

...Order 145403 Commercial Transactions (Contracts) The four elements of a valid contract are: - i. Agreement. ii. Consideration. iii. Contractual capacity. iv. Lawful object. Currently, contract law is used based on the objective theory of contracts. The objective theory states that if an objective third party (Jury) believes the parties intend to form a contract, then a contract should be found, meaning we prefer to interpret them to find there is no contract. In this context the theory does not apply to this case. Firstly the way John Leonard did. He believed that the Harrier jet was really in existence...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Commercial law ( commercial contracts )

...Legally Enforceable Offer & Acceptance., in Commercial Contracts Offer An offer includes any ment which if objectively construed, should containan unequivocal indication of a desire or willingness to be legally binding if its conditions are accepted. In commercial contracts, whether a specific statement amount to an offer or not will depend upon the facts of each case and price lists, estimates, advertisements and circulars are not an offer and do not have any contractual binding. Acceptance In commercial contracts, an acceptance of an offer must agree to all the terms of the offer unconditionally. An acceptance with a new condition or...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay


..., the offeree must provide a specific compensation for the promise fulfilled, often referred to as a consideration. Additionally, agreements only amount to contracts when formed with a legal purpose and with the intent to create a legal obligation between the parties involved. For this reason agreements between family members, with the exception of commercial agreements do not create a valid contracts. Certainty of the subject matter is another essential requirement of a valid contract since contracts cannot be based on ambiguity or unclear subject matter. Finally, agreements forming contracts must be mutual, coercion or undue influence...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay


...Insert Wood v. Lucy, Lady Duff-Gordon (1917) Facts Lucy Lady Duff-Gordon was a popular public figure who attached her togoods in order to improve sales in return for compensation. She hired Mr. Wood to assist her and allegedly forfeited the exclusive rights of issuing licenses out to third parties to her new agent under an arrangement that would entitle her to half of the returns obtained therefrom. Mr. Wood sued her for the breach of contract following her direct participation in the same business, now alone and without sharing the proceeds with Mr. Wood (Smith 29). Issue The court was to determine whether Ms Duff-Gordon was in breach of the earlier contract. Decision The lower appellate court...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment


...Contracts A contract can be described as an agreement between two or more parties pertaining to the details of the various particulars that have been settled upon in this understanding. It holds legal viability and therefore can serve as a means of protection for individuals ensuring that they are not dealt with in an underhanded manner after an agreement has been made. It can also serve as evidence of the agreement that is in place(McKendrick Pg2). There are a number of different contracts that are available to an individual and they can be of use depending on the particular situation, some of the more common contracts that help most individuals involved in business...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Commercial Contracts for FREE!

Contact Us