Nobody downloaded yet

English Legal Methods - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Question 1a This is a family proceedings case. Question 1b The hearing dates were on July 17th and 18th 1995. Question 1c The date of judgement was14 December 1995 Question 1d The case was heard before Judge Davidson. Question 1e Counsel for the local authority was James Munby Q.C.The counsel for the guardian and litem was Lindsey Kushner Q.C…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.5% of users find it useful
English Legal Methods
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "English Legal Methods"

Download file to see previous pages The most authoritative decision is the [1996] AC 563 as it is the House of Lord’s decision. The House of Lord is the highest court in England. The doctrine of judicial precedent states that the decisions of this court are binding on the lower courts. Question 3 [6 marks available in total] What were the facts giving rise to Mr R’s criminal trial and what was the outcome of that trial? Mr R had a relationship with the mother of four children. They gave birth to two children and the other two were from a previous marriage. The father was Mr H, and C was the eldest daughter, who alleged that in September 1993, Mr R had raped her continuously when she was between 7 and 8 years. This continued for over 5 years. Mr R was then charged with rape. He was tried in October 1994. The allegation involved four charges of rape. The main witness in this case was the daughter C. Mr R was consequently acquitted of the charges. Question 4 [6 marks available in total] At the hearing of this case at first instance what, in summary, were the two key conclusions the judge reached in respect of D1’s allegations against Mr R? The judge made the following conclusions. The first substantive issue was whether D1 was sexually abused. The judge averred that D1had proved, in her statement, the fact that there was abuse. Her story was consistent and factual. Mr. R had lied that he had never had an opportunity to be alone with any of the children, which was proved by D1 testimony. The judge felt that that D1’s allegations were true. He felt that the evidence presented by her and her statement in court was true. Mr. R had not rebutted these assertions by his evidence or his behavior in court. He felt that the allegations of abuse by D, which were true were based on presentation of evidence. He believed the evidence tendered by the girl was true. Her statement could also be reasonably suspected to be true Question 5 [4 marks available in total] Summarise the issues certified for Their Lordships’ consideration in this case. The issues before the Lordships are three, and they are as follows. The first issue is the standard of proof, which is to be proved where an allegation has been made that a child will suffer significant harm under the second part of 31(2) (a) of the Children Act. The second issue is in relation to the requirement of proof of sexual abuse, which is the standard of proof being higher than the normal civil standard of balance of probability, but lower than the criminal standard of proof. There is a question as to whether the evidence needed to prove the charge needs to be based on the seriousness of the charge. This means that the more serious the charge, the more evidence one needs to prove their case as opposed to a question of proving on a balance of probability. The final issue is where an allegation is made that a considerable injury is likely to impact on the child. The question raised here is: should one prove the likelihood to suffer harm on a balance of probability or does the presence of a substantial risk suffice instead of a speculative future risk? Question 6 [8 marks available in total] Summarise the submissions made before Their Lordships on behalf of: (a) The Local Authority (3marks) (b) The Guardian Ad Litem (2 marks) (c) The parents (3 marks) Submissions made on behalf of the Local Authority. The counsel submitted that the question of law to be addressed was on the ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“English Legal Methods Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1398499-english-legal-methods
(English Legal Methods Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1398499-english-legal-methods.
“English Legal Methods Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1398499-english-legal-methods.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF English Legal Methods

Legal Institutions and Methods

...? Legal s and Methods QUESTION Question part a) i) The term prescribed as used in the Act refers to an order made by the Secretary of State by statutory instrument ii) The Act defines BBC as the British Broadcasting Corporation iii) The Act defines broadcasting as communication by wireless telegraphy in accordance to the definition of Section 116 of the wireless telegraphy Act of 2006 or otherwise by satellite communication. Question 1 (part b) a) Conviction on indictment is a conviction after an indictment aimed not at finding the accused guilty but that the crime was probably committed and the same committed by the accused. An indictable offense under the Act includes the disclosure of information by a...
11 Pages(2750 words)Essay

ENGLISH LEGAL SYSTEM

...are required an in-depth and fuller information about the client. This fuller information helps them to assess the case and form their opinion. After forming their opinion with the aid of law and precedents, the solicitors provide their advice to the client in a minimum amount of time. By doing so, the client, the solicitors and courts consume minimum amount of time on reaching to a decision over dispute. Rift and unusual competition is growing between these branches of English legal profession. Solicitors are rapidly growing and the Barristers are considerably less in number. Barristers enjoy political support at the cost of the Solicitors. Fused legal profession The absence of...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

English Legal System & Practice

..., as the judge who heard the case must review the respective law report before passing a ruling (Keenan 208). The law reports establish comprehensive legal framework for judicial precedent and maintain their continuity. The House of Lords as the highest court of appeals on civil and criminal cases within the framework of domestic law was traditionally bound by its own decisions but after the Practice Statement of 1966 it no longer had to follow this principle (Elliott and Quinn 11). To a certain extent, this was in violation in historic traditions of the English common law, but in fact the other British courts were also not bound by their own past decisions, and the House of Lords was perfectly able to...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

ENGLISH LEGAL SYSTEM & SKILLS

...? English Legal Systems and Skills of English Legal Systems and Skills Material facts of the case and initial grounds of appeal The case was an allegation that the claimant had sexually assaulted a fifteen year old school boy who was undergoing a short period of work experience at the school where the claimant had been newly employed as music assistance. It was alleged that the claimant had inappropriate contact with the boy and further that inappropriate text from the claimant to the boy inviting the boy to meet him were found in the boy’s phone. The school consequently expelled the claimant from working in the school. The initial grounds of appeal by the appellant was...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Legal Methods Paper

...? Legal Methods Material Facts of the Case   The material fact in the case encompasses a decision by Strathclyde Council on September 13, 1978 to cooperate with local Health Boards in fluoridating water supplies. The petitioner (Mrs Catherine McColl) applied to interdict and restrain Strathclyde Regional Council from executing its decision. Mrs McColl’s submission detailed that fluoridation is unsafe, ineffective, and illegal. The Council held that fluoridating water supplies will aid in reducing dental decay. Mrs McColl, the petitioner, sought to establish that fluoridation would have several unfavourable side effects such as causation of cancer and that it would be ineffective in minimizing dental decay...
9 Pages(2250 words)Term Paper

The English Legal System

...The English Legal System The Natural law content is set by nature and thus it is valid everywhere. Natural law opposes the concept of the positive law of a certain political community, or nation-state, and therefore can function as a standard to criticize that law. However the content of positive law should be known with some reference to the natural law. Thereby natural law is used to criticize decisions about the statutes, but less so to criticize the law itself. In Fact the Natural law theories have exercised a profound influence on the development of English common law. When the UK joined the European Economic Community (now the E U), as a consequence the UK is subject to Community law, and the secondary legislation of the EU... the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Case Analysis (Legal Methods)

...Read carefully through the speech of L.J Scott in the attached law report of the decision in Mirvahedy v Henley (2003), and answer the following questions (each part of the question will be allocated the percentage of marks indicated in the brackets): (a) What were the material facts of the case? (10%) (b) What was the legal issue(s) which the court had to decide? (10%) (c) What approach to statutory interpretation did L.J. Scott take in his speech? (30%) (d) In what way(s) did he deal with precedents? (30%) (e) What do you think the ratio decidendi of Mirvahedy v Henley is on the basis of reading this speech? (20%) The material facts of the case centre on the liability of the defendants in respect of the injuries caused...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

ENGLISH LEGAL HISTORY

...common law principles, make these traditional laws a sound base for many universally accepted rules now. In the below discussion we will look at some of these principles in detail. We will highlight their evolution, their importance in the development of legal system and their implications in the modern age. We will also see how the tradition side of these rules still reflects itself in the developed laws. Habeas Corpus Habeas Corpus is a Latin word which means ‘you shall have the body’. In legal sense it represents a method through which any person can claim relief against unlawful attest or detention from any other person or even the legal system itself. In other...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

English Legal System

...Word count 827 Order # 430457 d 11th April English legal system Summary of the case In the case R (E) v Governing body of JFS (2009),the admission of M, son of E was denied by the governing body on the grounds of lack of proper evidence for his Jewish origin. The specific reason quoted by the governing body was the ethnicity of the mother which was not treated as Jewish. The over subscription of the school led to refusal of several application of children, but the reason for the refusal should be proper. However, in the present case, the reason for the refusal of the admission was very illogical and discriminatory. Hence, E challenged the decision of JFS and appealed in the High Court. The High Court quashed the claims made by R... on...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Legal Methods and Legal Structures

...Legal Methods and Legal Structures Table of Contents Introduction 3 Comparison between R. (on the application of Playfoot) v Governing Body of Millais School and R. (on the application of Begum) v Denbigh High School Governors 3 2. Comparison between Dr Rowan Williams, Archbishop’s Lecture – Civil and Religious Law in England: A Religious Perspective and Lon L. Fuller’s Law as an Instrument of Social Control and Law as Facilitation of Human Interaction 6 3. Discussion of “Begum and Playfoot Show That the Law Can Successfully Resolve Disagreements over the Acceptable Boundaries of Public Professions of Faith” 7 Conclusion 11 References 13 Introduction The recent years have witnessed...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic English Legal Methods for FREE!

Contact Us