The Right to Roam: Balancing Private Property and Public Access - Essay Example

Comments (1) Cite this document
The right to roam which is a statutory right in England and implies that no individual may make an absolute claim to private ownership of mountainous terrain or parts of the country. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94% of users find it useful
The Right to Roam: Balancing Private Property and Public Access
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Right to Roam: Balancing Private Property and Public Access"

Download file to see previous pages Moreover, the exclusivity typically attending private ownership is protected by Article 1 of Protocol 1and Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights, 1950 which became a part of the law of England by virtue of the Human Rights Act 1998. However there are caveats to both provisions which are reflected in a number of statutes in England. This paper examines the juxtaposition between the exclusivity of private property claims facilitated by Articles 1 Protocol 1 and 8 of the ECHR and the social propriety of public access to private property via the statutory right to roam. An examination of the right to roam under English law demonstrates the extent to which the private claims are limited by public policy considerations. A further look at other sources of law in Europe permitting the right to roam exemplifies the pull of public policy considerations and the limits of Article 8 and Article 1, Protocol 1 of ECHR. Theories of Private Property and the ECHR It is generally argued that the owner has complete control over the res with the exclusive right to exclude all others.2 On the other hand it is argued, that private property ownership is not “absolute” and “involves trade-offs with community values and egalitarian goals”.3 Thus the concept of a bundle of sticks is viewed as an interface between the various values and goals. It can be argued that Articles 8 and 1 of Protocol of the ECHR reflect this latter theory of private property ownership. Article 8 of the ECHR provides that “everyone has the right to respect for his private and family life, his home and his correspondence”.4 Article 8 also states that public officials shall not interfere may only interfere with that right pursuant to law and if it is “necessary in a democratic society”.5 Article 1, Protocol 1 of the ECHR makes provision for the right to “peaceful enjoyment” of one’s “possessions”.6 Article 1 Protocol 1also provide thats “no one shall be deprived of his possessions” unless such deprivation is “in the public interest and subject to the conditions provided for by law and the by the principles of international law.”7 Article 1 of Protocol 1also provides that the state is entitled to make laws “necessary to control the use of property” in “the general interest”8 In Marckz v Belgium it was held that the right to do as one likes with one’s property is a conventional and basic component of property rights.9 However, Article 1 of Protocol 1 recognizes but limits the extent to which the state may interfere in the right to property. Interference must not be arbitrary and although Article 1 of Protocol 1 does not speak to compensation, when the state does interfere in property rights, there must be compensation.10 Compensation is only necessary in instances where interference in the property amounts to taking the property and even then, full compensation is not altogether guaranteed.11 For instance in Baner v Sweden, admitting the public access to private waters for fishing activities did not amount to deprivation of the right to peaceful enjoyment of one’s possessions.12 Thus Article 1, Protocol 1 of ECHR conveys upon the state a broad authority relative to the determination of the public interest in issue.13 It was ruled in Neimetz v Germany that the primary purpose of Article 8 is to ensure that individuals are protected against public officials’ arbitrary interference.14 First is must first be determined whether or not interference is justified by virtue of Article 8(2). In ascertaining whether or not in ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“The Right to Roam: Balancing Private Property and Public Access Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(The Right to Roam: Balancing Private Property and Public Access Essay)
“The Right to Roam: Balancing Private Property and Public Access Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
hkris added comment 10 months ago
Student rated this paper as
At first, I thought 16 of pages is too much for such a subject. But now I see it could not be done better. As the author starts you see the depth of the question. I’ve read all at once. Precise research

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Right to Roam: Balancing Private Property and Public Access

Access to Private Property on Social Network Platforms

...Access to Private Property on Social Network Platforms For Use in Personal-Injury Cases and Defences I. Introduction There have been many cases of law enforcers resorting to investigations using social networks like Facebook for the purpose of gathering evidence. Very recently, according to Kashmir Hill (2012), Phil Markoff was under investigation as the killer of an erotic masseuse. The police tried to track cell phone records at about the time of the incident, only to find hundreds of possibilities. That approach turned out to be a dead end. They tried the email account of Phil with Microsoft. Finally, it was in Facebook where the police hoped to get more information. Through a...
14 Pages(3500 words)Research Paper

Public and Private Finance in Property

...? Public and Private Finance in Property Public finance Public finance can be understood from three core perspectives namely (i) resources generation (ii) economic stability and effective resource allocation. The central government (HM Revenue and Customs) has to ensure that it has generated enough revenue that can accommodate annual expenditure plans. This means that if the HM Revenue and Customs is not in position to collect adequate revenue that can effectively meet the government expenditure plans then the government will forced to borrow additional. The monies that the government has borrowed from the public to finance its expenditure programs for a particular fiscal year is referred to as budget deficit and it consequently... ...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Public and private spaces

...? Public and Private Spaces PUBLIC AND PRIVATE SPACES Amendment I, or the First Amendment, is a section of the United s constitution that was added in 1791. It stops the formulation of any laws that; impede citizens from exercising their religion freely, respect the establishment of any religion, abridges speech freedom, interferes with the citizens’ right to assemble peacefully, infringes on press freedoms, or stops citizens from redressing their grievances to the government through a petition (Stowe & Stump, 2007: p12). The First Amendment is exploited in various ways. For instance, the movie Borat is presented as a satirical look of life in America. Using real events and people, the film’s star Borat becomes a basic lunatic... that border...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Intellectual Property Right Universities, commercial entities and Public Research Organizations has become a serious issued in the recent past. The issues relating to Intellectual Property (IP) rights are also on the increasing trend and this further intensifies the necessity to get the IP right protected. In fact the protection of IP rights has given considerable boost to the research on scientific issues and inventions. Such protection has lead to the provision of additional funding for the research studies, enhances the efforts on the technological innovations and has also led to the creation of a number of new start ups. Generally the concept of IP covers the legal...
32 Pages(8000 words)Essay

Private Property the surplus level (Clarke and Kohler, 2005). The other three conditions on the legitimacy of Locke's view on property are the spoilage condition and the necessity of satisfying the disabled right of charity and dependent children's right of maintenance. Since everyone is originally entitled to this access in the state of nature, a weaker sufficiency condition would allow the institution of private property to injure some people by infringing their access to the means of production and would thereby reinstate the presumption that their consent is required (Clarke and Kohler, 2005). No attempt was made in general to...
8 Pages(2000 words)Book Report/Review

Intellectual property right

...and patents. Summarizing, copyright protects expression, trademark protects names, and patents protect ideas. “Patent protection affects and is likely to restrict access to technologies and information which may be critical to sustaining the health of poor populations and supporting development efforts” (McGrath 1996). TRIPS forms the protective layer over all three domains, which helps profitable and ethical functioning of organizations. The modern protection for intellectual property rights developed first as national legislation in developed countries, followed by international agreements such as the Paris Convention, the Berne Convention resulting in TRIPS. (Alsegard 2004). TRIPS...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment

U07d2 Laws Balancing Access and Protection

...Running Head: u07d2 LAWS BALANCING ACCESS AND PROTECTION u07d2 Laws Balancing Access and Protection Submitted by: Setara Azizi Number: XXXXXXXXX Capella University Tutor’s Name: With the changing times and the growing technology, the healthcare industry has also been growing tremendously. From the old handwritten papers, the times moved on to the type writers and now to use of computers. The current healthcare industry has grown to a great extent and has developed to be able to compete with any other industry. Now in the current times, doctors and nurses are expected not only to know about the medical theories and explanations but also management. Also, with the growing...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Locke teaching on the individuals right to private property

... Locke’ teaching on the individual’s right to private property John Locke is one of the most prominent and influential thinker of politics belonging to the western part of the world. John Locke started the concept of British Empiricism; it lays the foundation of United States of Americas constitution. Locke believes that all humans have certain rights which are given by God. He advocates equality. Religion is the back of all theories presented by him. State, individuality and private property are some theories based on the same principle. In this book he discusses how humans have a right to property and how and to what extent this affects the God. He advocated that although humans resided in a socially set system but all could... . It is not...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Private and public school

..., it would be appreciated that public schools are better than private schools as they offer less costly access to education and further apply more current instructional approaches than their private counterparts. Whereas critics argue for better academic performance in private schools, studies that adjust for the differences in background and math performance of the subjects affirm the preference for public schools. Therefore, the cost and academic performance advantages make public schools a better option than private schools. Works Cited Institute of Education Sciences. “Fast Facts: Educational...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Protecting Private Property

...Protecting Private Property Hitler appeared to adopt a capitalist stance here by emphasizing and elevating the value of private property. It is a known fact that capitalism derives from the need to provide individuals with the opportunity to enrich themselves using whatever means possible as well as the need to create classes of people depending on access to wealth and resources (Sen 14). Capitalism also derives from the need to develop fast and efficient manufacturing and production methods to support rapid growth. In the process, it creates, directly or indirectly, clear distinctions between various classes of people. It is quite surprising that Hitler...
5 Pages(1250 words)Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The Right to Roam: Balancing Private Property and Public Access for FREE!

Contact Us