Nobody downloaded yet

Theory of Dispute Resolution - Dispute between Shylock and Antonio (Merchant of Venice) - Essay Example

Comments (1) Cite this document
Shakespearean literature has been long commended by scholars for its incorporation of legal discourse into its plot structures that further paves way for interdisciplinary study of law. Practically all of Shakespearean texts are known to have tangential relation and relevance to legal practice…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.1% of users find it useful
Theory of Dispute Resolution - Dispute between Shylock and Antonio (Merchant of Venice)
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Theory of Dispute Resolution - Dispute between Shylock and Antonio (Merchant of Venice)"

Download file to see previous pages 1 The play does not only have an entire scene depicting a courtroom trial that had been the prime source of dispute resolution in that era and this method is also known as “litigation”, but play has also paved way for legal analysis and “Alternative Dispute Resolution”. The term “Alternative Dispute Resolution” or “ADR” refers to a repertoire of mechanism that can substitute court trials and litigation efforts to resolve a dispute; they largely entail discussions between the disputant parties. 2 ADR is further subdivided into negotiation, mediation, arbitration or adjudication and ombudsmen schemes; these methods are also known as “out-of-court settlements” and often entail the involvement of a third party to assess the situation and give their unbiased opinions on the matter. Although, ADR methods cannot substitute courtroom trials or litigations in all matters but they are cost-effective and are less time consuming. ADR methods actually aim to eradicate the root or the main cause of dispute that enables the disputant parties to resolve their issue as healthily as possible without having any detrimental repercussions on any of the parties involved. It is important to understand that the procedures followed by each of the ADR methods is essentially the same, the only difference lies in the implementation of the final verdicts. Hence, the decisions in a dispute are non-binding if they are made through “mediation” and “negotiations”3. On the other hand, all decisions can either be binding or non-binding if they are made through arbitration and adjudication, respectively. It largely depends upon the agreement made with the third party. Arbitration is binding, the verdict is implemented whether the decision is approved by either parties or not; whereas, adjudication is non-binding and if the verdicts are not approved by the parties then it is nullified and the parties can actually approach the court for a resolution. Thus, it can be deduced that for ADR methods to work, the entire process is largely contingent upon the willingness of the parties to establish a truce. In case, ADR fails to find a solution to the problem then litigation serves as a last resort method to aid the individuals in reaching an agreement. Adjudication or arbitration is often referred to as a private version of a courtroom trial but is a much more formal process than a court hearing. All of ADR methods parallel each other in many ways but there are certain differences that stem from how binding the verdict is and the degree of involvement of the third party in aiding the communication between the disputant individuals or groups. 4 For instance even mediation is a parallel of litigation in every way but there some very substantial differences in the way how things are assessed in a dispute. Unlike litigation that is usually implemented in accordance with a legal principle, the guiding principles in mediation can be legal, moral or religious and it is up to the disputant parties to choose a method that fulfil the parties’ needs. Justice is brought about through two aspects; the rudiments and the process through which those rudiments or standards are applied. It is apparent that adjudicative measures in resolving issues can result in a bias in the case and the justice arising from it is established using a specific line of thinking ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Theory of Dispute Resolution - Dispute between Shylock and Antonio Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Theory of Dispute Resolution - Dispute Between Shylock and Antonio Essay)
“Theory of Dispute Resolution - Dispute Between Shylock and Antonio Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
johannachamplin added comment 1 year ago
Student rated this paper as
This document saved me today. I liked the structure. It was very useful for my law course.

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Theory of Dispute Resolution - Dispute between Shylock and Antonio (Merchant of Venice)

The Dispute between Shylock and Antonio

...?Introduction In The Merchant of Venice, the parties to litigation are in high conflict. One of the parties, Shylock, requires no less than the deathof the other, Antonio. There are a variety of reasons for this animosity, but the fact remains that Shylock is not negotiating from a reasonable position. This paper will examine the three modes of settling a dispute – negotiation, mediation and litigation. Negotiation is basically a dialogue between two parties in an effort to create an agreement between the two parties. It is most effective when both parties can see the other's side, each party has something to give the other, and the conflict is not high (Cohen, 2003). It is ineffective when one or both parties are bargaining... and witnesses...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Alternative Dispute Resolution

...? Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) Insert Business Law Business Law Introduction Business law is the law thatis appropriate to business units like partnerships and corporations. For sometimes, QuizLaw has concentrated on the laws associated to the locations and creations like a business. However, most business cases involve disputes brought about by business rivalry, competition or misunderstandings. Such business cases led to the development of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR), which helps business people find solutions to their problems before proceeding to court (Schwartz 2005). Therefore, the ultimate aim of this context is to examine the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Dispute resolution

...other. One of the parties might think you are favoring the other side in the decision you are going to make while at times reaching the goal is near to impossible. Mistakes are always common to everyone. Even professionals also do make mistakes in the things they do. I have also learnt the importance of making apologies to the people we have made mistakes to. This helps in rebuilding our relationship with them once more. This helped me when I had problems with my parents. I apologized and I could be forgiven. My bond with them grew stronger that before. Reference Domenici, K. & Littlejohn, S. (2004). Mediation: empowerment in conflict management (2nd edition). Chicago: Waveland Press. Abdel, W. M. S., Katsh, M. E., & Rainey, D. (2012)....
15 Pages(3750 words)Coursework


...clause to be invalid if the contract is, then they can state this as well. If the parties intend for the arbitration clause to be interpreted substantively by national courts and procedurely by arbitration panels, then it can state this too. In short, the parties can make their explicit wishes known, and this is what governs. On the other hand, if they do not make any explicit wishes known, then the default position would be to give the arbitration clauses full effect in virtually every case, void contract or no. This is really the best evolution of the issue, because the parties’ agreement should always be the basis for the resolution of any kind of contract dispute, and the assumption that a savvy...
15 Pages(3750 words)Coursework

International commercial dispute resolution

...? International Commercial Dispute Resolution The essay analyses the distinguishing aspects of processes of arbitration in contrast to the municipal laws. The various arbitration theories in the context of Kerr’s statement on arbitral procedures are detailed in the essay as well. TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction……………………………………………………………………….4 History…………………………………………………………………..................4 How is Arbitration Different From Other Municipal Laws................................4 Dispute Management………………………………………………………………6 How Detached Are The Arbitration Procedures From Municipal Laws............9 Theories and Examples That Support The Judiciary Nature Of...
16 Pages(4000 words)Coursework

Theory of Dispute Resolution

... Theory of Dispute Resolution A letter of advice to Mr. Conn, on the most appropriate dispute resolution mechanism Introduction The dispute represented in this case falls under the law of supply of goods and services. The relevance of this letter is to make Mr. Conn fully aware of the facts under this case, and the liabilities borne by different parties, and finally advise on the appropriate dispute resolution mechanism to be applied, among negotiation, litigation and mediation. Facts of the case According to the law of supply of goods and services, there are certain implied terms during the transfer of goods from the transferor to the transferee, most important being that the goods transferred are of good quality and fitness... of...
11 Pages(2750 words)Case Study

Online Alternative Dispute Resolution

...this dilemma; as well as to facilitate the resolution of disputes that occurs offline. Dispute resolution is the process of resolving disputes between parties, and there are various methods of dispute resolution, which includes such things as: lawsuits (litigation), arbitration, mediation, conciliation, as well as many types of negotiation. Dispute resolution processes fall into two major types: adjudicative processes, such as litigation or arbitration, in which a judge, jury or arbitrator determines the outcome; and consensual processes, such as mediation, conciliation,...
25 Pages(6250 words)Essay

Alternative Dispute Resolution

...into which there is introduced a third party17”. Furthermore, Roney refers to Cowan Erwin’s definition of ADR as “any means of providing a resolution of a dispute between two or more parties which does not involve traditional adversarial procedures”18. As such, ADR has been viewed as a response to litigation, which is costly and sacrifices privacy in bringing the dispute into the public domain. Arguably the most important justification for recourse to ADR is the preference of the solution being based on fairness and equity rather than the rule of law19. It has been propounded that the business community’s propensity towards negotiation and finding an appropriate...
16 Pages(4000 words)Essay

International Dispute Resolution

...of international agencies, unification of laws of different countries is yet to be achieved. It is for these and other allied reasons, alternative dispute resolution methods are resorted to for commercial disputes between parties belonging to different countries.1 Different methods or forms of alternative dispute resolution under international commercial contracts are (1) Arbitration, (2) Fast Track Arbitration, (3) Conciliation, (4) Mini-trial, (5) Med/Arb and (6) Baseball arbitration. These are not exhaustive. Thus Altair Plc, a British entity can adopt any one of these or some of these as forms resolution of potential...
21 Pages(5250 words)Essay

Alternative Dispute Resolution relate their theory about the answer but I will also be able to make them feel more at ease with the group. Making their mistakes, if any, seem easy to rectify and starting off with how I also once got the answer wrong initially will help me in connecting to them, making the whole effort more effective. 10) Last and most importantly, being genuinely interested in listening to people, understanding them, appreciating them and encouraging them in order to make myself more likeable as a person are attributes that sound very realistic and versatile in their application. The above ate only some of the many lessons I learnt form the book. From the moment I finished the book, I have started off by making an effort to smile...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Theory of Dispute Resolution - Dispute between Shylock and Antonio (Merchant of Venice) for FREE!

Contact Us