Medieval / Modern Islamic Civilization Comparison - Assignment Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
This was a time of discovery and most societies embraced the fad. As such, the Muslim community had a number of innovation and creativity during the medieval age when it was undergoing civilization…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.1% of users find it useful
Medieval / Modern Islamic Civilization Comparison
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Medieval / Modern Islamic Civilization Comparison"

MEDIEVAL/MODERN ISLAMIC CIVILISATION COMPARISON Medieval/Modern Islamic Civilization Comparison One of the things that are synonymous with the medieval age is innovation. This was a time of discovery and most societies embraced the fad. As such, the Muslim community had a number of innovation and creativity during the medieval age when it was undergoing civilization. However, the spirit of innovation that had so much thrived during this time experienced a setback with the emergence of the modern era. This was attributed to a number of factors that the Muslims could not control, thus the setback. This paper will be a discussion of the reason why the spirit of innovation and creativity that was evident in the medieval Islamic civilization had gone stale by the time the modern era emerged.
According to Goldschmidt & Davidson, 2009, Muslim is one religion whose followers are very strict to adhere to its tenets and traditions, thus Muslims who wanted to embrace modernity that came with innovation had to do this while at the same time following tradition. This brought about a sort of conflict due to the fact that most of the innovations that brought about modernity were against the Muslim traditions. As such, the content of tradition was possibly one of the most complex and contentious issue that contemporary Muslims had to face.
As Muslims struggled to embrace modernity, the task ahead of them was immense. They had to approach modernity with a respectful but independent attitude so that they could still appreciate the teachings of Islam and at the same time incorporate what modernity had to offer in their day to day way of life (Goldschmidt & Davidson, 2009). This was a great challenge since most of the things that came with modernity were against Muslim traditions and beliefs. Since most Muslims are strong believers in keeping their faith, they had to discard what modernity had to offer so that they could practice what was required of their faith. As a result of this, the spirit of innovation and creativity that was evident in the medieval Islamic Civilization faced a decline.
Along the same thought, creativity and innovation came with rapid expansion of geographical regions thus creation of new centers of power. With this realization, there was influx of a lot of wealth, foreign ways of life and greater social stratification. The success brought about by innovation was in its own way a source of downfall to the Muslim community. This is due to the fact that wealth and power brought about corruption and abuse of power as a result of the new lifestyle that had flourished (Esposito, 2011). This was accompanied by infiltration of new ideas and practices. Most of the innovations and new ways of life were seen to undermine the older Muslim way of life. Islam always has a variety of functions, thus a host of other Muslim critics sprang up and criticized those who were embracing innovation.
According to Esposito, 2011, the aspect of power and wealth other than Islamic ideals and commitment is what inspired the Muslim community as a result of new innovations and creativity. Most aspects of power and wealth were regarded as having very little to do with Islam thus the whole aspect of modernity that the two brought had to be declined. The approach of a non-Islamic society based on these new developments was not taken well by most Islamic faithful; therefore, there was a decline on the aspects of innovation and creativity that had so much thrived during the medieval civilization.
In conclusion, innovation and creativity coupled with the resultant modernization came with a number of advantages such as power, wealth and general development. However, strict adherence to Islamic faith made Muslims shun this advent due to the contradiction that came up with regard to what modernization was portraying and what the Islamic way of life dictated. People were torn between modernization and adherence to the strict Muslim values and due to their strong faith and belief in Muslim traditions, they decided to shun modernity thus its decline.

Esposito, J.L. (2011) What Everyone Needs to Know about Islam. New York: Oxford University Press.
Goldschmidt Jr., A. & Davidson, L. (2009). A Concise History of the Middle East. Boulder: Westview Press. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Medieval / Modern Islamic Civilization Comparison Assignment”, n.d.)
Medieval / Modern Islamic Civilization Comparison Assignment. Retrieved from
(Medieval / Modern Islamic Civilization Comparison Assignment)
Medieval / Modern Islamic Civilization Comparison Assignment.
“Medieval / Modern Islamic Civilization Comparison Assignment”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Medieval / Modern Islamic Civilization Comparison

Comparison and Contrast Medieval Characteristic

...?Running Head: COMPARISONS OF MEDIEVAL, ANCIENT, AND ICAL Monsters and mothers: Belief systems as they are impeded by the female clinging to tradition Name University Class Monsters and mothers: Belief systems as they are impeded by the female clinging to tradition One of the pervasive themes throughout the history of the epic poem is that of the madly protective mother and her deformed and monstrous child. In contrast to this motif is the heroic male, his aim at protecting society in conflict with the individuated protection that the monstrous mother must provide for her mutated offspring. These conflicts can be seen to represent the feminine as a stunting presence that holds back the advancement of...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Medieval Versus Modern

...College Medieval Versus Modern I will begin the essay by focusing on the cultural differences between the medieval drama and modern drama. I will do this by comparing the medieval drama the “crucifixion” (Greenblatt 407) with the early modern drama “King Lear” (Greenblatt 1200). As the years go by, a lot of changes occur to the general way that drama is set and acted. The role of drama in the society also changes. Any comparison between medieval plays and modern plays leads to the realization of significant changes in the field of drama over time. There are lots of cultural differences...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Islamic Civilization and Byzantium

... a position of power; Abd-al-Rahman III. During this time, there was significant warfare, particularly with Christian groups from the North. Some of the land that had previously been under the control of the Caliphate had already been seized by the Christians from the North. Abd-al-Rahman III was able to capture some of this land back, and did manage to strike a peace deal with a count in Barcelona, and did manage to prevent some of the troubles which had been looming for the area. Works Cited The Ornament of the World. Maria Rosa Menocal. Little Brown & Co. 0316168718 Patterns of World History: Vol. I. von Sivers, Desnoyers & Stow. OUP. 09780195332889 Page 300-335 (Islamic Civilization and Byzantium, 600-1300 CE)... PROF and Number Briefly...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Medieval Islamic Philosophy

...Running Head: Impact ical Greek Philosophy on Medieval Islamic Philosophy Impact ical Greek Philosophy on Medieval Islamic Philosophy Author's Name Institution's Name Greek Philosophy vis--vis Medieval Islamic Philosophy: An Introduction The Arabs did not have philosophy, mathematics, or any rational sciences as part of their culture and tradition before the arrival of Islam. Despite the fact that they were conscious of Jewish and Christian religions since Jews and Christians lived among them, they themselves were idolaters. They were unrefined in their beliefs and attitude. When they had accepted Islam and they conquered territories outside Arabia in the seventh and eighth centuries, they came in contact with other... the heir of...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Medieval and early modern Athens

...Short Report on Medieval and Early Modern Athens Order No. 247922 Athens enjoys a very long history among the cities whole Europe and in the world.It became the capital of the independent Greek State in 19th century. The city had experienced many ups and downs and during the medieval period it experienced a decline and then again started rising under the Byzantine Empire, the city also benefitted from Italian trade. By the period of 529 A.D. " A stroke of love more important than this- or indeed than anything that you could think of for a man who , as I did , sought a name for eloquence for himself - happened as follows - after the removal of the tyrants Constantius bestowed upon Greece...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Compare and contrast the influences of culture and religion in sciences in ancient Greece and the Islamic empire

.... In comparison, the philosophies of Socrates, Aristotle, Plato etc. also work with formal examples and proofs for their ideas (Magner, 2002). Similarities with Muslims The clear similarity between the Greek philosophical thought and the Islamic philosophies which developed much later was the idea of being reasonable and encouraging inquiry with experiment or hypothesis. The continuation of these ideas led to the development of modern scientific methods as they are used in all accepted sciences today. Undoubtedly, the Islamic civilization owes a lot to the Greek thinkers since their ideas were used extensively by Muslim thinkers as they adopted and...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

The Shaper of Medieval Civilization

...According to Perry, the Christian Church played a very important role in Medieval European society. In fact, its role was so great that he calls it the "shaper of medieval civilization" (Perry 212). Three main ways it did this was through the translation of Classical works, the teaching of morality, and through its influence on the Frankish Empire. This influence can be best understood in how the Church affected Charlemagne and his followers. After the Roman Empire started its decline, learning began to be lost. Very few people could even speak Latin any more, and "literary works of classical antiquity were either lost or unread" (Perry 211). The Church, and specifically its...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Medieval ages and Modern time

...History and Political Science 12 December Medieval Ages and Modern Time The way of life of people differs with distinguished regions around the globe. More so, the cultures, values, religions and social life characters may be eroded and forgotten, but there are those certain traits in the modern society that can be traced from the ancient times. The Medieval age believed to be associated with the European history, especially after the submergence of the roman civilization to the period of renaissance, which occurred between the 5th and 15th century, and exhibits great differences in modern military, health, education and justice system....
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Arab - Islamic Culture and Civilization

...ARAB - ISLAMIC CULTURE AND CIVILIZATION Arab - Islamic Culture and Civilization Islam and Mysticism Affiliation Table of Contents Introduction 2 Sufism: Introduction and Components 5 Origin and Meaning 5 The connotation and explanation of the word Sufism has also been debated by a number of scholars (Chittick, Sufism: A Short Introduction, 2001; Lings, 1975; Renard, 2005). In broader terms, the Sufism is regarded as the escalation of Islamic beliefs and practices, or in other words the inclination between Muslims in order to unify their spirits with the Divine Reality (Voll & Ohtsuka, 2014). The word “Sufi” is an Arabic word, which is...
20 Pages(5000 words)Research Paper


...these nations since they were seen to be a more superior power in comparison to Islam. Theories were developed and they were being drafted and associated with all forms of generalization and assertions and in the process this led to the complete discrediting of Islam and gave the Europeans the power to control and rule over the Islamic nations (Harlow Barbara and Mia 101). The line of thought that believed the Europeans to be more powerful and superior than the Muslims was referred to as the Orientalism The perceptions that were born out of this period by the Europeans have been carried over to the present day as more people continue to believe in some of these...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Assignment on topic Medieval / Modern Islamic Civilization Comparison for FREE!

Contact Us