StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Horror Stories from Auschwitz - Movie Review Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
This paper 'Horror Stories from Auschwitz" focuses on the fact that the presentation of the video, David Cole Interviews With Dr Franciszek Piper, is quite having a compulsive and somewhat convincing logic in the beginning, but it is found to weaken as the narrative progresses. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.5% of users find it useful
Horror Stories from Auschwitz
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Horror Stories from Auschwitz"

We should start worrying about how history can get corrupted like anything and how any extreme act of inhumanity can go unaccounted for as time passes by. It is a truth that holocaust is always understood as a Jewish holocaust but on the fringes of that narrative, we also see Russians, Poles, Ukrainians, and communists. Why should communists take up the Jewish propaganda is a question worth probing. Providing trivial aspects like the growth of Auschwitz into a commercial tourism spot to suggest that ‘Auschwitz’ is more hype than truth, is not adding to the serious tone of this video but only diminish it.
Also, the mocking tone reflects some kind of prejudice. For example, when the presence of shops selling video cameras in Auschwitz is mentioned it is mockingly added that the visitors need not fear about missing a shot of the “final solution” (“David Cole Interviews With Dr Franciszek Piper”). The contradiction in the statement of two ladies about the holes on the roof of the gas chamber is there but the second lady is not asked to explain her statement- that is, why the holes were made if they were not original. Also, I wonder whether the deaths (of all those people who have been killed by gassing in Auschwitz) have ever been properly documented or not. This information is lacking in this video. Did the relatives and friends of each ‘victim’ not try to locate the person, and the cause of death?
Even the revised figure of the number of deaths in Auschwitz given by Dr Franciszek Piper is 1.1 million, which is not a small figure. In any instance of mass death, there happens often controversy about the death toll. And the version of Dr Franciszek Piper also need not be the authentic version. The truth can be somewhere between these figures but that does not make irrelevant the question, how did people in such great numbers perish. Dr Piper is readily admitting that changes were made to the gas chamber and this proves that he or the museum authorities are not hiding any information. This video also does not consider the innumerable eye witness accounts, the narratives of those who have been prisoners and who have said, they lost their dear ones to the gas chamber. Even in a legal system, much weight age is given to eyewitnesses.
Some horror stories from Auschwitz, like the ‘soap story’ might have been false but it is natural that when the accounts of gas chambers and other atrocities come out regularly, the rumour-mill will essentially start working. But that is no justification to wave off all first-person accounts as well. Dr Piper is not an ultimate authority on holocaust. Nor is Deborah Lipstadt of Los Angeles Times. Hundreds of historians and experts have worked on this topic. It is curious to note that this video has an interest in Dr Piper alone. Towards the end, this video transforms into a test of Dr Piper and his level of knowledge on the topic. To the most, what can be concluded from this exercise is that Dr Piper is not knowledgeable enough to sit in his present job in Auschwitz. Technically, it can be seen that many questions heard being asked to Dr Piper, were not the actual questions that were asked. They were dubbed over the video later. This can be made out of the fact that they lack the background noise that exists in Dr Piper’s replies. And the dubbed questions are highly opinionated and leading questions. By dubbing a question on an answer to another question, the very meaning of the answer can be altered. This video suffers the same fault that it accuses the holocaust supporters of. This video is based on a preconceived conclusion.   Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Horror Stories from Auschwitz Movie Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 753 words, n.d.)
Horror Stories from Auschwitz Movie Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 753 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1584568-reaction-paper-on-david-cole-interviews-with-dr-franciszek-piper
(Horror Stories from Auschwitz Movie Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 753 Words)
Horror Stories from Auschwitz Movie Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 753 Words. https://studentshare.org/history/1584568-reaction-paper-on-david-cole-interviews-with-dr-franciszek-piper.
“Horror Stories from Auschwitz Movie Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 753 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1584568-reaction-paper-on-david-cole-interviews-with-dr-franciszek-piper.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Horror Stories from Auschwitz

Horror Remakes

...?Introduction The horror genre has been an indisputably popular one for a very long time. Audiences get thrills from being scared. That said, horror films are much more than a means for delivering cheap thrills. They are also a reflection of society, in many ways. A horror film made during paranoid times might capitalize on these times by making their films focused around paranoia as well. A film made during a post 9/11 era might capitalize on the nation’s moods, and fears, by delivering a film about good and evil, such as The Omen. The films that will be discussed in this analysis, The Dawn of the Dead, The Omen and The Texas Chainsaw Massacre all have reasons, either ostensible or...
37 Pages(9250 words)Dissertation

Auschwitz

...?Auschwitz The “Auschwitz” will be remembered as one of the most terrible places in the modern world. It was originally a small and quiet Polishtown called Oswiecim until it was invaded by the Germans at the beginning of World War two and turned into a concentration camp. Over the years from 1940 until 1944 it became the largest concentration camp of all where more than 1,100,000 men, women and children were killed (Auschwitz website). Today it is a museum and, at the same time, a place of memorial where people can come and reflect on what happened and remember all those people who suffered there. It has a solemn educational purpose to teach future generations about what happened there,...
10 Pages(2500 words)Research Paper

Auschwitz

...camp and the remaining two were its extensions. Auschwitz I was used as administration camp and all the actions related to prisoners were controlled from this place. The prisoners were made to work without giving any heed to their physical condition. Not only Jews but also non-Jews were exterminated in these camps (Cole and Smith 1992). In my opinion, the camps that were constructed were made for punishing prisoners and this punishment was very severe as prisoners were not only enforced to do hard jobs but also murdered during their confinement. There were no rules or regulations regarding the prisoners and they were deprived of their due rights. The people who say that all these extermination stories...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Viewpoints, Monsters, and Language in Two Horror Stories

...and Section number 26 February Viewpoints, Monsters, and Language in Two Horror Stories Horror stories often carry both a sense of the paranormal and the rawness of reality. Two stories, The Boarded Window by Ambrose Bierce and The Tell-Tale Heart by Edgar Allan Poe, explore the genre of horror stories using realistic and supernaturally-tinged plots. This essay compares and contrasts the point-of-views (POV), monsters, and atmospheres of these stories. Poe uses the first person POV to allow readers to understand the narrator’s most intimate thoughts and emotions, while Bierce employs the third person POV...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Enjoying Horror

...Task: Hawkins, Joan. ‘Revisiting the Philosophy of Horror’, Film-Philosophy, vol. 6 no. 6. 2002. 13th July http www.film-philosophy.com/vol6-2002/n6hawkins. Summary There are various factors researchers use to explain why most people enjoy watching horror movies. One of the reasons is the desired effects that the films have on viewers. The gore and the blood stimulate pleasures from the viewers and also measure the level of threats in males. “The dread which is not a fear of anything in particular, but rather the experience of the threat of nothing in particular” (Hawkins 1). This is same as arguing people watch horror movies because they want to be frightened. The plain suspense in...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Horror Film

...Horror is about excess. One of the most pervasive characteristics of horror films is that they exhibit or expose something that we, as human beings, are at once repulsed and attracted to. Quite often, this simultaneous attraction and repulsion is generated by the portrayal of emotions or desires that we all have, but displayed to their relative extremes. Williams writes, "Gratuitous sex, gratuitous violence and terror, gratuitous emotion are frequent epithets hurled at the phenomenon of the 'sensational' in pornography, horror and melodrama."1 This much about horror films is almost universally true, as well as relatively obvious. However, sometimes a filmmaker might...
7 Pages(1750 words)Movie Review

Auschwitz - A New History

...interrogating Piper for long, Piper admits that the gas chambers that are widely acclaimed to have been used in killing Jews were only created after the Second World War. Piper asserts that the ‘’gas chamber’’ was originally an air raid shelter which had walls and a ‘’chimney’’ added to it after the war. Therefore, from this, the stories we hear about Jews being tortured in gas chambers in concentration camps in Poland have been quashed by this interview. From this, it is evident that David Cole had his reasons for believing that no Jew was gassed in Auschwitz. Hence, this video lambastes the questionable propaganda concerning this area of Poland. Therefore, the video by Cole, asserts that the official...
1 Pages(250 words)Movie Review

Holocaust in Auschwitz Camp

...Holocaust in Auschwitz Camp When David Cole, a revisionist, interviewed Dr. Franciszek Piper, the curator of Auschwitz museum, the main purpose was to find out the truth about the Jews holocaust. The mass slaughter of Jews in the concentration camps of Auschwitz, during the WWII has been a major issue that has been shrouded in mystery. Auschwitz museum has become a major attraction for tourists who want to see if the stories about the mass murders have been true. The museum at Auschwitz has supposedly bullet holes and gas chamber, where Jews were gassed to death, has lingering traces of gas. But according to interview, Cole has...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Auschwitz Holocaust

...Auschwitz Holocaust When considering history, it is important to gather facts and separate it from fiction. I think David Cole's interview of Dr. Franciszek Piper on the Auschwitz Holocaust is a classic example of how historical evidence should be separated from word of mouth and handed down information. Cole has carried out his research with the purpose of exposing the real history of the Auschwitz camps. I agree to a certain extent the approach he has taken especially by first taking a tourist tour, and then interviewing the officials at the camps. When one filter evidence through different people, there is bound to be discrepancy but in the end you can get the true picture. However,...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Symbols in Edgar Allan Poe's Horror Stories

...the close connection between Gothic genre and detective fiction plus the connection between Gothic and science fiction  3.1 Works of Edgar Allan Poe ‘Illegitimate power and violence is not only put on display but threatens to consume the world of civilized and domestic values. In the skeletons that leap from family closets and the erotic and often incestuous tendencies of Gothic villains there emerge the awful specter of complete social disintegration in which virtue cedes to vice, reason to desire, law to tyranny.’  (Botting, 1996) Aside from a common literary basis, there is a psychological intensity that is typical of Poes writings, particularly the tales of horror that consist of his best and best-known works....
38 Pages(9500 words)Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Movie Review on topic Horror Stories from Auschwitz for FREE!

Contact Us