The Caning of Charles Sumner - Book Report/Review Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
This was because he believed that the Republicans at that time had policies that did not favor everyone. So with his position, he…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.9% of users find it useful
The Caning of Charles Sumner
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Caning of Charles Sumner"

Analytical Review of Caning of Charles Sumner Caning of Charles Sumner by Williamjames Hoffer (55) praises Charles Sumner as a renowned Republican who took his first senate seat as a Democrat. This was because he believed that the Republicans at that time had policies that did not favor everyone. So with his position, he would be able to address certain issues freely especially that of slavery.
During this period, he took that chance as an orator and gave his first speech, stating his position against slavery, insisting that slaves should be given full freedom and equal rights just like the rest. In his quest for total freedom of the blacks, he stated repealing of the Fugitive Slave Act, and denounced it as a violation against the public conscience, constitution and divine law. In his speech, he said that his mistress, who although hideous to others, will always be lovely to him and had been taken. The allegory that he used defined the mistreatment of the black people in the North, and slavery as a whole (88). Hoffer states that it is essential to note the sexual imagery that persisted throughout the oration. He did this to protect the honor of South Carolina.
The speech caused bitterness among the other Senators, and Senator Preston Brooks took it upon himself to teach him a lesson. Brooks beat up Sumner till unconsciousness and until his cane broke. This attack as Brooks claims was to defend his family’s honor and that of his fellow citizens of South Carolina (92). After reviewing the circumstances that led to Sumner’s beating, and analyzing the cultural pressures to defend the honor within Antebellum in the Southern Society, it shows that the Caning of Sumner event represented a microcosmic instance of the cultural motivations of the civil war.
The speech that had offended Brooks, and he needed to maintain his reputation in South, and without this, he was unlikely to gain campaign supporters or endorsements from the Southern Senates in his motions, in the House of Representatives (112). The concept of honor was the cultural cornerstone of the gentleman’s society in the antebellum south. This concept was not any different in the North, but it took a different meaning there. It referred to one’s personal morals, honesty, integrity and reliability, just like what Sumner possessed. However in the South, to have honor, one required all the qualities like those of the North and in addition, to be vigorously supportive of the Southern culture.
This desire to support the Southern culture, and of honor to be precise, stood on the basis that their culture was perfect, and an insult to them was not tolerated or taken lightly. This insistence of perfection was evident in the slave supported agriculture, and was against industrialism and abolitionist views that the Northerners had adopted (128). For Sumner to spit on their honor it struck at their Southern identity and pride, therefore; they had a way of dealing with others who opposed it, as they called it the Southern Code. This code prescribed punishment to the Northerners therefore, Brooks only acted according to the culture of the Southern Honor and gave Sumner the beating that he had deserved.
In general, the Southerners concurred with Brook’s actions in defense of his honor, and this was indicated by the support that he got from them after the beating. Many canes were sent to Brooks after the beating and notes that encouraged him to repeat it on Sumner and other abolitionists from the North.
Work Cited
Hoffer, Williamjames. The Caning of Charles Sumner: Honor, Idealism and the Origins of the Civil War: Witness to History. Baltimore: The John Hopkins University Press, 2010. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“The Caning of Charles Sumner Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
The Caning of Charles Sumner Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from
(The Caning of Charles Sumner Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
The Caning of Charles Sumner Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words.
“The Caning of Charles Sumner Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Caning of Charles Sumner

Charles Dickens

...?ENG 244 Spring – Charles Dickens Order No. 528007 One of the greatest English novelists of his time was Dickens, Charles John Huffam (1812– 1870) who was born at Landport in a house which was much later opened as a Dicken’s Museum in the year 1904. He was second among eight of his siblings and spent most part of his childhood in the Kingdom of Kent. His literary instincts were nurtured by his mother who bought him story books and very often read to him. From a very young age Charles was looked upon as being a child prodigy by his father. Dickens was a highly influential personality in the social reforms of Victorian England and his thoughts and ideas were infused with a keen sense of...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Charles Dickens

...? A tale of Two Cities: Violence and Revenge College A tale of Two Cities: Violence and Revenge Charles Dickens is a well known and reputable name when the history of literature is being discussed. His literary works are full of portrayals and exposures of events prevailing in that era. “A Tale of Two Cities” is one of those literary works which grabbed the attention of readers immediately. This novel is based on the instances, events and portrayals surrounding the French Revolution. It is often criticized that Dickens’s depiction of those events and discussions provided an irrational, biased and one-sided view. However, the violence, human feelings and moral questions on the issue that Dickens raised cannot be questioned. French... view...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Charles Manson

...? Charles Manson Lecturer: Freedom from physical attack is paramount to all members of a society since the right to life and physical security is core to all other inalienable rights of an individual; therefore, crimes of violence against persons warrant severe penalties (Carper, McKinsey and West 2008). Even though, violence often develops from emotions that are often hard to control there are distinctions in moral culpability. Murder is the illegal killing of a person with malice, which denotes the highest level of moral responsibility or blameworthiness. The presence of malice aforethought as implied by the conduct of the accused constitutes murder; thus, without malice the homicide becomes manslaughter. Apart from malice being... a...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Charles dickens

...? Commentary: “The Old Curiosity Shop.” This passage from Chapter IX of Charles Dickens’ “The Old Curiosity Shop” is a typical example of the great author’s writing. It features the three main characters of the story: the grandfather, Little Nell and Daniel Quilp. It depicts Nell’s vigil at the window, her conversation with her grandfather and Quilp’s dialogue with the old man. The passage illustrates Dickens’ mastery over the use of setting as a means of communication, illuminates different facets of Nell’s character and shows Dickens’ complex characterization of Quilp. Dickens’ uses the setting communicate Nell’s emotions to the reader. Nell’s mood is reflected by the streets and rooftops of London. As Nell keeps her...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Charles Darwin

...Charles Darwin Since time immemorial, scientists have been contemplating the idea that some form of evolution led to the emergence of living things across the world. Nevertheless, they lacked leadership or a universal theory to explain the dynamics of evolution (“Bio Web” 1). For many years, philosophers argued that due to the incredible complexity of nature, a supernatural being / creator must have been the creator of life (“Truth Reality” 1). However, Jean Lamarck who was a biologists and Charles Darwin made significant efforts in trying to explain the evolution of life (“Understanding Evolution” 1). Nevertheless, Charles Darwin’s theory of Evolution is the most controversial and...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Charles Manson

...Charles Milles Manson was born on November 12, 1934 to an unmarried woman d Kathleen Maddox in Cincinnati, Ohio. Maddox, who was reportedly only sixteen at the time of his birth, was not fit to care for a child and, therefore, Manson’s early childhood development suffered. A while after Manson was born, his mother married a man named William Manson, which is how Charles got his last name. This man was not his biological father, but Manson was given his last name anyway. It is possible that Manson never met his biological father. Manson’s mother was the source of many of his early problems, as she was a heavy drinker. At one time, she sold him to a waitress for a pitcher of beer. This waitress kept him...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Charles Darwin

...understood is that animals with variations have the ability to adapt with the environments they live in. They have the better chance of survival and the ability to breed. They hand over their characteristics to their children. I know that it has paved the way for controversies, especially as it is one that diffuses the literal interpretation of the Book of Genesis in the Bible. I have also noted that “Populations remain roughly the same size, with modest fluctuations” and “Food resources are limited, but are relatively constant most of the time” (Charles Darwin: The theory of evolution, 2010). It has led me to the inference that surviving in such an environment is really a struggle among individuals. “In the struggle for...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Charles Goodyear

...The Role of Rubber in the Life of Charles Goodyear and the Role of Charles Goodyear in Modern Life Although Charles Goodyear was never a titan of industry or a billionaire entrepreneur like Andrew Carnegie or Cornelius Vanderbilt, he established the basis for a thriving industry at the heart of American manufacturing. With the invention of the vulcanization process of rubber, Goodyear made the production of rubber products financially and physically feasible for mass production. As a result, rubber is manufactured cheaply and abundantly all over the world for use in products with as diverse functions as tires, gloves, and garden hoses. The enormous influence of rubber over our daily lives...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper

Charles I

...Charles I: A Life of Religion, War and Treason Hibbert, Christopher, and David Starkey. Charles I: [a Life of Religion, War and Treason]. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2007. Print. Introduction The subject of the book is the life of Charles I, since he was born until the time he was executed for having been accused of being disloyal to the state, soon after the English civil war, when the House of Commons back then passed the ordinance for the King’s trial (Hibbert, 255). The book seeks to trace every aspect of the King, starting with his childhood and how fate landed him the position of the king after the death of his elder brother, highlighting his marriage life and the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay


... Lecturer: CHARLES Introduction The question of the influence the persona of Charles I had on England is the ultimate question that this book addresses. The personalities of Kings are thought to influence the general culture of the kingdoms in which they rule and the subject of Charles I: A Life of Religion, War and Treason presents nothing more than a perfect picture of this ideology. As a biography about Charles, Hibbert approaches the life story of Charles from a perspective that gives a subject of the influence of kings’ persona on their kingdoms. This approach to writing biography is not one that has often been used, especially when writing about kings. But once this was approached in a very open ended perspective by Hibbert... ...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Book Report/Review on topic The Caning of Charles Sumner for FREE!

Contact Us