The Revolutionary Context of the Constitutional Convention - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The State Constitutions of 1776 were characterized by a variety of factors, based on the revolutionary need for a “fundamental transformation of political institutions” (Banning, PAGE #). Wishing to create a government body that did not emulate the problematic and tyrannical…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.1% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "The Revolutionary Context of the Constitutional Convention"

Question The Constitutions of 1776 were characterized by a variety of factors, based on the revolutionary need for a “fundamental transformation of political institutions” (Banning, PAGE #). Wishing to create a government body that did not emulate the problematic and tyrannical English aristocratic system, most of the individual States had established government bodies whose representatives held minimal legislative power, where “power rested with the people in a wholly literal sense” (Banning, PAGE #). As further articulated by Banning on PAGE #, the revolutionaries believed that “proper constitutions…depended on consent, but governments existed in order to protect the liberties of all…[the revolutionaries searched for a] governmental structure in which liberty and representative democracy could be combined.” While there were undoubtedly fundamental problems with creating the sort of government where the officials held little to no power, Banning argues that “whatever the Revolution was or would become, its essence lay originally in these thirteen problematic experiments in constructing republican regimes” (PAGE #). As such, it is evidenced that the State Constitutions of the individual colonial governments was a precursor to the greater Continental government establishment, and provided an ideal staging ground for the revolutionaries to experiment with the idea of new government.
Question 2
Arguably, the most significant accomplishment of the Articles of Confederation was establishing “a permanent confederation presided over by a Congress whose authority would be confined to matter of interest to all” (Banning, PAGE #). The Articles of Confederation, according to Banning, “did not issue from a systematic, theoretical consideration of the problems of confederation government” (PAGE #). Rather they merely emulated the government practices that had evolved in the State Constitutions over the years. While it was popularly taught that the Articles of Confederation were characterized by a chaotic period in the early colonies, recent scholarship attributes greater credit to the Articles than in times past. For instance, Banning points out that the Confederation years, aside from consolidating the thirteen states, “secured their independence and won a generous treaty of peace…weathered a severe post-war depression…and organized the area northwest of the Ohio for settlement” (PAGE #). The Northwest Ordinance of 1787, in fact, became the basis for “all the rest of the continental expansion of the United States” (Banning PAGE #). Hence it is noted that, while the Articles had their faults, they also succeeded in maintaining sufficient order and achievement to foster the grounds for new government in the United States.
Question 3
The primary motive for calling the Constitutional Convention evolved from a variety of inter-state government problems, and the threat these problems posed for the revolutionary ideal. Under the Articled of Confederation, the Congress held no power to compel the states to gain funds or to cooperate with one another for the greater good. The States were, at the time, more concerned with their individual interests to maintain a stable government. Banning notes that, with the immense expenses incurred by the war, “Congress could not even pay the interest on these [financial] obligations” (PAGE #). As the years progressed, the situation between the States digressed to the point where interstate commerce was nearly impossible, self-interest was increasingly escalated, and the United States were ridiculed by Europe in contradiction to the revolutionary dream of “national greatness” (Banning, PAGE #). Banning states that “public virtue…seemed to be in danger of completely disappearing as every man and every social group sought private goods at the expense of harmony and other people’s rights” (PAGE #). The culmination of this descent into petty interstate bickering was Shays’ Rebellion, an incident which evidenced the reality of needing to overhaul the Articles. Not only that, says Banning, “they saw in the problems of the Confederation government not merely difficulties that would have to be corrected, but an opportunity that might be seized for even greater ends” (PAGE #). Those ends ultimately resulted in the creating of the present Constitution, and the evolution of our government as it is today.
Works Cited
Forging the American Character: Readings in United States History Since 1985, 4th Edition. Wilson, John R. M. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“The Revolutionary Context of the Constitutional Convention Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved de
(The Revolutionary Context of the Constitutional Convention Essay)
“The Revolutionary Context of the Constitutional Convention Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Revolutionary Context of the Constitutional Convention

Author's description of The Constitutional Convention 0f 1787

...conversation to lobby, when he was not occupying the official chair of the convention. He became more and more persuasive during the ratification exercises. Berkin writes, “The usually stoic Washington made no effort to disguise his hopes for ratification. `I never saw him so keen for anything in my Life,' a Virginian told Thomas Jefferson."(p.181) But he was democratic in the real sense of the term, he exercised great caution not to put pressure on any member of the convention. Whether it an omission or the quality of a great statesman, the historians will have to explain. The backgrounder information prior to the Constitutional Convention and ratification of the...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Constitutional Convention

...? Constitutional Convention Establishment of People’s Councils Amendment Establishment of People’s Councils Amendment proposes amending the United States Constitution to: Establish people’s councils in every county, city and township/parish/borough in all of the states, whichever is applicable; and Make these people’s councils the primary means where local officials would be elected, wherein consensus building would be the primary means Summary and Analysis: Local elective positions in the United States government have been elected through a direct election of the people, through the use of a secret ballot, wherein the candidate who garners a simple majority would win the elections. This method of electing officials has been made... Constituti...
2 Pages(500 words)Case Study

Marpol convention

...?Marpol convention The Marpol convention refers to the international convention adopted in order to prevent marine pollution by ships either due to operational or accidental causes. There were two treaties that were adopted for this cause; one in 1973 and the other in 1978, followed by the Protocol of 1997 (Annex VI) (International Convention, n.d; Marpol 73/78, n.d). This international convention was administered by the International Maritime Organization (IMO) owing to the increasing number of marine accidents such as oil spills and other forms of pollution from ships in to the marine environment. The problem was only aggravated by the increasing...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Constitutional Convention of 1787

...Constitution of 1787 The Constitution of 1787 laid the groundwork for the newly established United s government. The principles, in terms of government, established in the Constitution have remained pivotal elements of the United States over two hundred years after it was established. In addition, this document remains heralded for its profound insight into human and governmental rights within the changing world. This essay considers the constitutional Convention of 1787 through an examination of the key contributors, the compromises that took place in the documents construction, and the outcomes thereafter. While the United States had previously...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Armerican Revolutionary War (Constitutional Arguments)

...?American Revolutionary War (Constitutional Arguments) It has become fashionable to support the present attempts of the American Colonies to separatethemselves quite completely from their previous attachment to the British state. While there may be many tempting reasons to pursue this line of action, not least the benefit of keeping all the riches of this wonderful continent for the benefit of our small colonial societies, there are significant reasons why these moves are ill judged and doomed to fail. The proposal to set up a fully independent American confederation, with separate laws and no allegiance to the British crown should be opposed on three main grounds: it is legally wrong, it is morally...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

UK constitutional convention

...? Constitutional Convention 30th, November, UK constitutional convention A constitutional convention is an uncodified or unwritten and an informal procedural agreement, which is followed by institutions in a state. Common wealth states for instance states that they follow the British west minister system of government. A constitutional convention is therefore traditional unwritten laws that form the fundamentals of the written constitution. Most states in the modern world are guided by constitutional conventions instead of the written constitutions1....
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Constitutional & Administrative Law

...The European Communities Act (1972 c. 68) is described as the Act of the United Kingdom Parliament providing for the incorporation of European Community law into the domestic legal order of the United Kingdom The Human Rights Act 1998 is a United Kingdom Act of Parliament which received Royal Assent on November 9, 1998, and came into force on October 2, 2000. Its aim is to "give further effect" in UK law to the rights contained in the European Convention on Human Rights. Effect of the European Communities Act 1972 and the Human Rights Act 1998 on UK's constitutional order considering the principle of Parliamentary Sovereignty Specifically talking about the UK scenario, since entrenched...
11 Pages(2750 words)Essay


..., 1788). Indeed, the constitutional ratification by the states would give political legitimacy to the American constitution and establish its credibility and dominant position in the world forum. (512) Reference Lincoln, Abraham. Available from: [Accessed 21 February, 2010]. The Debate in the Convention of the State of New York, on the Adoption of the Federal Constitution. (17 June, 1788). Available from: [Accessed 21 February, 2010].... The political ideologies and democratic pattern of a are strong indication of the government to represent the common man. The democratic systemis the most popular way of reflecting and incorporating the welfare of the masses. New York is intrinsic part of America and it is important that as a citizen of a...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Class Constitutional Convention

...Constitutional Convention: Foreign-Born Naturalized Citizens Should Be Able to Become President Word Count: 590 (2 pages) I.Introduction Section One, Article Two of the Constitution should be amended to allow anyone who is a foreign-born naturalized citizen to be able to become President. There are several reasons for this amendment, and several reasons against this amendment. Hopefully it might be possible that an agreement will be reached in the future regarding this amendment. II. Pros of Foreign-Born Naturalized Citizens Being Allowed to Run For President There are several pros as to why foreign-born naturalized citizens should be allowed to run for President. Naturalized...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Constitutional convention

...Constitutional Convention By the fall of 1786, reality downed upon the Americans that the Articles of Confederation, the underpinning document for the new-fangled United States approved in 1777, had to be significantly customized. The Articles denied the Congress any authority to control domestic affairs, no clout to control commerce, and no authority to tax. Lacking coercive authority, Congress entirely depended upon monetary hand-outs from the states, which at that time refused the Congress requests to be financed (McClellan 1-2). Congress at this time was totally bogged down by the bankruptcy it was steeped in, and could not afford to compensate the military for their services in the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The Revolutionary Context of the Constitutional Convention for FREE!

Contact Us