How do the Memorial Day Massacre and the UAW sit-down strikes compare - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
This paper compares labor struggles in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, such as the Homestead Strikes, Haymarket Affair, 1902 Coal Strike, and Ludlow Massacre, and the Memorial Day Massacre and the UAW sit-down strikes. It assesses the changing role and effects of…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.8% of users find it useful
How do the Memorial Day Massacre and the UAW sit-down strikes compare
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "How do the Memorial Day Massacre and the UAW sit-down strikes compare"

July 5, Labor Struggles in the Nineteenth and Early Twentieth Centuries This paper compares labor struggles in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, such as the Homestead Strikes, Haymarket Affair, 1902 Coal Strike, and Ludlow Massacre, and the Memorial Day Massacre and the UAW sit-down strikes. It assesses the changing role and effects of organized labor on the economy and the relationship between labor organizations and the government and their companies. Organized labor did not get the recognition they needed during the nineteenth century, though they gained a little influence on the government, during the early twentieth century; however, the same violence erupted between the workers and the state/private police from the nineteenth to the early twentieth centuries.
During the nineteenth centuries, Homestead Strikes, Haymarket Affair, 1902 Coal Strike, and Ludlow Massacre occurred and showed that the companies and local government worked closely to stifle labor organizations’ freedom of speech and assembly. On May 1886, the workers at the McCormick Harvesting Machine Co. in Chicago staged a strike, as they demanded a shorter work day. On May 3, police were used to defend strikebreakers and a fight took place; one person was killed and several others were injured. On May 4, some 20,000 demonstrators were expected to show up at Haymarket Square, but rain and cold lowered the numbers down to around 1,500. The gathering was nonviolent until a police official sent a dispersal unit. Someone threw a pipe bomb into the police ranks, which instantly killed four policemen and sixty civilians. The police fired back and killed several workers. The Homestead strikes featured a greater degree of violence, as the company used private militia to respond to workers on strike. In 1892, the Homestead lodges of the Amalgamated Association of Iron and Steel Workers and the Carnegie Steel Company, Limited conflicted during the negotiations for several months and what happened next was The Homestead Strike. Union and non-union workers united and supported their leader Hugh ODonnell. Henry Clay Frick from the company made arrangements with Pinkertons National Detective Agency of New York, so that 300 strike-breaking detectives, called the “Pinkertons,” would break the strike. Workers sounded alarms when the Pinkertons were seen. No one could say who started the gun shooting, but the detectives fired on the workers and wounded some of the latter. Six days after this, the National Guard of Pennsylvania arrived in Homestead, as ordered by Governor Robert E. Pattison. The company then threw off workers from company homes, arrested the workers several times to charge them with bail, and got them involved in expensive trials to break their spirits. The same private militia was used during the Ludlow Massacre and the 1902 Coal Strike also did not get the union recognition they fought for. The Rockefeller family had an armored car with a mounted machine gun to use against strikers. On April 20 of1914, the private militia shot anyone who mas moving in the camp. Furthermore, when the worker camps main organizer, Louis Tikas, arranged a meeting with Lieutenant Linderfelt (the officer in charge of the National Guard) to create a truce, Linderfelt hit Tikas and others fired the latter.
Police violence and collusion between the government and companies also transpired during the early twentieth century. During the Memorial Day, more than fifteen hundred strikers, family members and some supporters staged their demonstration peacefully. Some company police and the Chicago police, however, confronted the people. Some people threw rocks and the police fired at the people, as well as threw tear gas. Some escaped, but several died and many were wounded. The police did not suffer any death and wounds. The Memorial Day Massacre shared the same violence as the Railroad Strike of 1877 and the Haymarket affair. The UAW sit-down strikes also encountered riots with the police, where many were injured. Still, at the beginning of the twentieth century, organized labor became more powerful and they were able to get some of the conditions they worked for.
Organized labor is assessed as not becoming any more sympathetic to business interests, because they staged demonstrations, even when the economy would be affected. Nevertheless, their influence increased during the early twentieth century. These labor groups could not become sympathetic, because they were still fighting for fundamental rights of increase in labor and better working conditions. Since the companies and the states were not helping them, they resorted to strikes and sit-downs to get any form of positive response. Organized labor also increased in influence during the early twentieth century, as the government recognized some of these labor unions. They were able to generate more positive changes for the workers during the twentieth century, such as shorter work days and higher wages.
U.S. History. Haymarket Square Riot. Web. 4 July 2011 <>. Sit-Down Strike Begins in Flint. Web. 4 July 2011 .
Marks, Rachel. Anthracite Coal Strike of 1902. Web. 4 July 2011
works/anthracitestrike.htm>. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“How do the Memorial Day Massacre and the UAW sit-down strikes compare Essay - 1”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(How Do the Memorial Day Massacre and the UAW Sit-down Strikes Compare Essay - 1)
“How Do the Memorial Day Massacre and the UAW Sit-down Strikes Compare Essay - 1”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF How do the Memorial Day Massacre and the UAW sit-down strikes compare

Nanjing Massacre

...that ‘there probably is no crime that has not been committed in this city today’ (BBC News 2005). Foreigners in Nanjing have been forced to leave the city, during the first days of the Massacre. This fact is highlighted in a report of Tillman Durdin, a journalist of New York Times, who were in Nanjing when the Massacre began and who had the chance to see many of the atrocities developed by the Japanese troops (BBC News 2005). According to Durdin, as he has leaving the city, his car had to pass over series of dead bodies (BBC News 2005); at the same time, mass killings were developed around (BBC News 2005). Figure 1 – 13th December 1937, the Japanese troops enter in Nanjing (Source: BBC...
10 Pages(2500 words)Research Paper

Roadside memorial is making improper use of the Christian cross, which does not seem proper at public places. Third reason why roadside memorials should be banned, as asserted by Tiernan, is that they are a big distraction for the motoring public. A driver may get busy in reading the text about who got died, when, and how, written on the memorial, and may bump his car into something. And, if the drivers, for the sake of safety, are not supposed to slow down and read these memorials, then what is the point in building them at all? If the memorials are built on median strips along the highway, they are enough highly structured to be a disturbance for...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Nanjing Massacre

...buildings in the city, forest and entire villages around Nanjing were burnt to the ground. NANJING MASSACRE On December 7, the Japanese army came close to the city walls of Nanjing. They dropped leaflets into the city, requesting the surrender of Nanjing within 24 hours and promising mercy to innocent civilians. Otherwise they were threatening to level the city down. Japanese did not receive and answer for this proclamation. Then General Matsui commanded to take Nanjing by force. Nanjing was under heavy attack for the next several days, then Chinese troops retreated and fled. The chaos followed and on December 13 the Japanese entered the walled city of Nanjing. There was no military...
5 Pages(1250 words)Term Paper

The Homestead Strike 1892 compared to The Great Sit Down Strike 1937

...?The Great Sit-down Strike and the Homestead Strike Compared The Great Sit-Down Strike The Great Sit-Down Strike is a successful strike compared to the Homestead Strike mainly because of the peaceful way the strike was conducted as well as the government’s attitude in tackling issues confronting workers. The great sit-down strike at General Motors (“GM”) which happened in the period of 1936-37, involved workers at several Flint plants,...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

The Valentine Day Massacre

..., W. J., & Bilek, A. J. (2004). The St. Valentine's Day massacre: The untold story of the gangland bloodbath that brought down Al Capone. Nashville, Tenn: Cumberland House. St valentine's day massacre, 1929: Fbi files relating to the murder of seven members of the. (2001). S.l.: Diane Publishing. Parr, A. J. (2005). The true and complete story of 'machine gun' Jack McGurn: Chief bodyguard and hit man to Chicago's most infamous crime czar Al Capone and mastermind of the St. Valentine's Day massacre. Leicester: Troubador. Green, V. (2006). St. Valentine's Day massacre. Canmore, Alta:...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Tlatelolco Massacre

...and on the eve of October 2 at Plaza de las Tres Culturas aggressive means of methods were used against these students to make them finish their demonstrations. However after the massacre it was till 2003 not established as to who was responsible for the massacre. The government at that time claimed that some of the students hiding in other buildings had started firing on the security forces and in response the security forces did the same. Although different stories have been put up by the State department, FBI and CIA the view points of CIA would be emphasized more in this essay. The State department which was being informed by different sources about the incident is still not having clear claims...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

St. Valentine's Day Massacre

...St. Valentines Day Massacre The members of Al Capone’s gang displayed, acceptance and loyalty to his leadership styleas it can be seen during the planned and executed massacre against Moran at the Garage. The leader-member relation that Al Capone had with the members of his gang can be termed as being positive. This is supported by the fact that, the massacre was an idea of one of Al Capone’s gang members, an upcoming lieutenant, John McGurn who was himself a subject of a previous hit (Allen). Normally, if the leader-member relationship is negative, the leader would not tolerate ideas ad plans from his members, which is contrary, to Al Capone did in this case, accepting...
1 Pages(250 words)Movie Review

Requiem for Memorial Day

...a chance to visit graves of our departed and beloved relatives and make prayers for them. Moreover, it is a great occasion to bring families together to celebrate life and learn how to live it fully and responsibly. For people who were not on good terms with their relatives, it is a good reminder to treat well those who yet live. Memorial Day should not be taken for granted. Today, Memorial Day has lost its essence, because the Americans have forgotten the meaning and the substance of the day. The graves of the fallen are being neglected and ignored, and most people do not recall the proper etiquette of the flag. I...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Llighting strikes

... number Lightning Strikes and Paramedic Care Introduction The discharge of large build ups of static charge in the atmosphere to the ground are known as lightning strikes. Typically, lightning strikes deliver hundreds of thousands of volts to the ground’s surface. Any object on the ground that interacts with the lightning strike becomes a conductor due to the large electric potential involved. Estimates delineate that lightning strikes kill around 24,000 people and injure some 240,000 people each year (Holle). Lightning strikes are the second largest weather event killer in the United States where some 9-10% of lightning strike victims die each year (Cherington). Effects on Human Body Lightning strikes do not burn the flesh since... an hour...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment


...that they develop a contingency plan before a strike occurs and appoint a strike-handling group, which is competent and informed in managing such issues. On the same note, the management such as that of the United Automobile Workers (UAW) is responsible for actively negotiating for no cases of strikes during their meetings with the trade unions. Therefore, the management ensures that its employees do not strike by signing an agreement and including a no strike clause in their business operations. According to Karnes (2009), business ethics have immensely affected the relationship that exists between managers and...
11 Pages(2750 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic How do the Memorial Day Massacre and the UAW sit-down strikes compare for FREE!

Contact Us