Free

The Melian Dialogue and the Revolution at Corcyra by Thucydides - Assignment Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The author examines the Melian dialogue and the revolution at Corcyra by Thucydides. The Melians argued that the gods and their Spartan kindreds would come to their rescue. The Athenians argued that strength is more valued over moral arguments by men.   …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.1% of users find it useful
The Melian Dialogue and the Revolution at Corcyra by Thucydides
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Melian Dialogue and the Revolution at Corcyra by Thucydides"

The Athenians claimed that if they accept the Melians’ plea to be free from invasion and their claim to being neutral, that they would appear weak in the sights of their foes and their sovereignty would be questioned and nations would begin to doubt the depth of their strength as they would attribute their decision to free the Melians to them not being strong enough (Strassler).
The Melians, however, argue that an invasion by the Athenians would do nothing but to alert the other neutral Greek states and would make them unfriendly to the Athenians and they could likely fear that they would also be overrun by the Athenians and this could make them take up arms against the Athenians, hence changing their neutrality. The Athenians argue that the neutral Greek states on the mainland would not act in this manner and that it is the unstable Greek states on the Island and the regions that have already been defeated by the Athenians that would likely do as the Melians said.
The Melians, however, argued that it would be foolish and ignoble for them to surrender without struggling. The Athenians, however, replied by stating that the argument is not about nobility, but about maintaining ones’ sovereignty. The Melians further argued that the fact that they are weaker does not mean that they would lose easily to the stronger Athenian forces as they still stood a chance of winning the fight. The Athenians on their own part claimed that the pendulum of victory would swing to their side as they are the only ones that have the right to hope on winning the war (Strassler).  Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Melian Dialogue and the Revolution at Corcyra by Thucydides Assignment, n.d.)
The Melian Dialogue and the Revolution at Corcyra by Thucydides Assignment. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1562830-the-melian-dialogue-and-the-revolution-at-corcyra-by-thucydides
(The Melian Dialogue and the Revolution at Corcyra by Thucydides Assignment)
The Melian Dialogue and the Revolution at Corcyra by Thucydides Assignment. https://studentshare.org/history/1562830-the-melian-dialogue-and-the-revolution-at-corcyra-by-thucydides.
“The Melian Dialogue and the Revolution at Corcyra by Thucydides Assignment”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1562830-the-melian-dialogue-and-the-revolution-at-corcyra-by-thucydides.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Melian Dialogue and the Revolution at Corcyra by Thucydides

DIALOGUE

..., and Griffiths, 2006: 143). Sometimes a show of unity, friendship and teamwork does not in reality, symbolize that the involved are actually friend. This paper will represent a dialogue in the form of a script, between two theorists, Michael Foucault, and Anthony Giddens. The dialogue will actually, be based on the theorists’ theoretical views on friendship. Anthony Giddens: In fact, friendship between people rewards many individuals, but to others, who lose it take it as punishment. It is a fact that, many people repeatedly find agreement with views of their own to be really rewarding. Michael Foucault: Yeah…! Anthony Giddens: This reward indeed, favors sentiments between rewarders, and the rewarded...
11 Pages(2750 words)Essay

Dialogue

...A liquid life and social networking transform what friendship means A liquid life and social networking transform what friendship means Zymunt Bauman, Anthony Giddens and Ervin Goffman are gathered at Zymunt Bauman’s home for tea. The three friends often visit each other and their conversations steer towards different issues that the modern world faces today. On this particular day, the three gentlemen are embroiled in a debate about different social issues. While discussing the transport conditions, their conversation digresses from the main topic when Bauman gets a new notification in his email inbox from the famous social networking site Facebook. The notification is an invitation from one of Bauman’s friends to be a member... liquid life...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Writing dialogue

...Good morning, sir,” said Mohamed, as he scanned the mail boxes, and hung up his coat in the vestibule. The porter was on the telephone but winked conspiratorially and inclined his head in a nod of greeting. No news from home, but that was usually the case. Mohamed picked up his briefcase and entered the inner courtyard. Alice wobbled along the narrow lane, keeping one eye on the notebooks in her basket and the other on the cobbled road ahead. At the college wall she parked her bike and then entered by the postgraduate door, nodding good morning to the porter, who was still talking. After checking for mail she turned towards the library, her head full of the dreaming spires and grey skies of Oxford. The hushed atmosphere... morning, sir,”...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Written Dialogue

...Science and Scientific Revolutions of the In his laboratory Sir Isaac Newton is unaware that fumes from Nitrogen Oxide commonly known as “laughing gas” have escaped a chamber and he inhales fumes of the gas. Surprisingly instead of the fumes driving him into fits of laughter they cause him to hallucinate and in his hallucinations he engages in philosophical conversations with three philosophers: Socrates, Charles Darwin and George Orwell. With Socrates leading the conversations he attempts to establish the root of the philosophical approaches of the rest and the truth in their philosophies with regard to science and scientific revolutions. Socrates dwells on mental approaches employed by the philosophers...
8 Pages(2000 words)Term Paper

Dialogue

...Dialogue between Walter Benjamin and Myself Me: The concept of Aura is among the most famous theoretical by WalterBenjamin. However, first describe who is Walter Benjamin is? Benjamin: Walter Bendix Schonflies Benjamin is a German-Jewish essayist, literary critic, translator, broadcaster, and social critic. I am famous for combining Romanticism, Jewish mysticism, and historical materialism to make the influential contributions to Western Marxism and aesthetic theory. Within the communication realms, Benjamin is known for the ‘aura’ concept (Benjamin 19). Me: That is a very amazing description. So what is the ‘aura’ concept? Benjamin: In recent times, the concept of aura has had many definitions depending on the area of...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Interactive Dialogue

...Lecturer: Interactive Dialogue ALICE and CATH are close friends who have not seen each other for quite a long time. CATH makes a point of visiting ALICE and they both seat in her living room. ALICE: It occurs to me that your boss is completely obsessed with the aspect of punctuality. CATH: (nodding) indeed he is. ALICE: Does he tell it to your face when you are even a minute late? CATH: (Kidding) not only does he react to a minute but also when you are a second late. ALICE: Lately, has your boss been coming to work? CATH: No. He has not been coming to work for the last three months. ALICE: (Amazed) Three months! That is quite long. CATH: Yeah…I do not know what caught up with him. ALICE: Do you prefer your old...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Dialogue between Two Women

...Biographical information for each woman Two notable women from 18th and 19th century will engage in an imaginary dialogue that will be based on facts, as if trying to relive those two centuries. Jane Austen (1775-1817) from the 18th century was a British novelist (Cashion & Sultan, 2010). Most of her work revolves around romance and fiction. For the purpose of this paper, let’s assume that Jane is in her early twenties (23 years old) and spends most of her time at home reading, cleaning and cooking. The other notable woman is Flora Tristan (1803-1844), a French socialist and writer, from the 19th century (Chastain, 2004). One major difference between the two centuries is the industrial revolution that...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Summary of Thucydides, The Melian Dialog. Summary of Machiavelli, Chapter 18 of the Prince

... Summary: The Melian Dialogue (Thucydides 5.84-116, Rex Warner tr The whole story portrays a dialogue between the Malians’ and Athenians ambassadors who were on a verge of war with each other and the representatives sent by the Athenian (an apparently strong figure of war) gathered the Melian hot heads of the state on the negotiation forum to consider all the possibilities which in Athenian’s perspective would lea to the calamity of the situation and rectify the animosity which , with the course of time had developed in Athenians for the island of Melos and their natives as they were pro-Spartans ( a Greek city and political hub) . Before this, the Athenians already had invaded an island Argos with a considerable amount of army... and...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Dialogue

...Dialogue It is often that some people do not possess the ability to converse topics that are important to them without getting into a dispute. This can get even worse when people are holding onto their personal interests. It’s often that positional versus interest-based communications will result into a conflict due to such individual stands. Personal stand is where one party holds on a particular opinion of an issue often conflicting with a common underlying interest whereas interest-based communications’ focus is on utilizing the common interests with an aim of benefitting the resolution process (Furlong, 2005,). Dialogue is a way of conversation in which conflicting parties relate and converse in search of for an understanding... . In this...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Thucydides, the peloponnesian war, the Melian Dialogue ( Book 5, chapter 17)

... Essay, Political Science 8 October Thucydides, the Peloponnesian War, the Melian Dialogue This paper discusses a dialoguethat happened between two parties, the Athenians and Melians. The Peloponnesian war of 431-404 BC was fought by Athens against the Peloponnesian Empire led by the Sparta. This war lasted for 27 years. The war was caused by the Spartans who were not happy that they no longer possessed military prestige. Athens pressured its allies and neutral cities and finally the Sparta were unhappy about the increased power Athens had (Thucydides 1). The Melian dialogue was a debate by Thucydides, a historian who served in Athens during the war. The Melians was a colony of many islands, but Athens wouldn’t submit to them... . They...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Assignment on topic The Melian Dialogue and the Revolution at Corcyra by Thucydides for FREE!

Contact Us