StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Democracy as a Utopian Concept - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Democracy as a Utopian Concept" tells that various leading political scientists of the twentieth century have understood, defined and interpreted ‘democracy’ in a variety of ways. Robert Dahl, arguably the most influential American political scientist of the 20th century…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.1% of users find it useful
Democracy as a Utopian Concept
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Democracy as a Utopian Concept"

But plutocracy is still better than a totalitarian society where power is concentrated in the hands of a small ruling elite with no accountability. Dahl classifies political systems under a spectrum of five gradations. At the top of the scale are the fairest systems that employ ‘rational persuasion’ for gathering public consensus. At the bottom of the scale are brutal autocracies that regularly resort to ‘physical force’ to keep the population under control.

But Dahl admits that even in the fairest of existing systems the power is wielded from top-down. This means that the notion of democracy as a people-inspired and people-regulated governing system does not exist anywhere today. Professor Charles Hauss understands democracy in terms of functioning electoral politics. Any nation-state that conducts free and fair elections periodically would qualify as democratic under this view. In Hauss’ own words “free, open and competitive elections are central conditions for a democracy”.

(Hauss, as quoted in Edwards 2010) Also important to this setup is the credibility of ‘rule of law’. . To this extent this latter category of countries would only be nominal democratic societies. When we analyze the American political system in the backdrop of the definitions of Hauss and Dahl, we can note a few divergences. What Dahl’s list of options for population control does not mention is ‘propaganda’. The Chomsky-Herman propaganda model fills the gap left by Dahl’s conceptualization.

Given that America is the birthplace of modern advertising and the Public Relations industry (PR) in the country is billions of dollars worth, it is fair to claim that PR is the foremost method here for the control of public minds. It is difficult to place the American style of governance in the gradation offered by Dahl. The most benign method of generating public consensus proposed by Dahl is ‘rational persuasion’. America is an exception to even this benign form of manufactured consent, for what the PR industry does is irrational persuasion.

As Chomsky-Herman notes, advertising is all about “misinforming people so that they make irrational choices”. (Chomsky, quoted in Wilson 2010) There is less divergence with Hauss’ understanding of democracy, for the links it with the capitalist economy. America being the leading practitioner of capitalism qualifies under Hauss’ classification. Moreover, there is competent enforcement of law within the country, although America is well-known for breaching international law, especially under the auspices of the United Nations.

Seymour Martin Lipset, on the other hand, would have found the American political system disappointing in terms of how democratic he found it to be. He believed that “the more well-to-do a nation, the greater the chances that it will sustain democracy”. (Lipset, quoted in Edwards 2010)  But, clearly, despite America’s enormous wealth the country has only a plutocracy to show for it.  This undermines Lipset’s theory of democracy.

In recent years there have not been any significant changes to the functioning style of American politics.  The 9/11 terror attacks added fuel to America’s already aggressive foreign policy approach.  But the domestic policy had continued its neo-liberal emphasis and pro-business orientation.  As a result, the economy went into a crisis precipitated by the housing market bubble burst of 2008.  And it has continued to remain in recession mode for many years now.  Unemployment rates have reached unprecedented levels even as health care costs and college tuition keep nudging upwards.  The recent years have been some of the most acutely distressing for the American population since the Great Depression of the 1930s.  This state of affairs is a reflection of the lack of a functioning democracy here.

Belen Fernandez the noted journalist working for the Al Jazeera network sees American democracy from a post-colonial strategic perspective.  She is critical of American diplomatic and military interventions in the Middle East.  The fact that a decisive majority of the American population are against these interventions underscores the failure of American democracy.  According to Fernandez, the threatening rhetoric toward Iran and Syria is indicative of a lack of democratic will to reign policy measures. She believes that the election and re-election of Barack Obama in 2008 and 2012 respectively has neither improved the state of American democracy nor have they allayed the fears of insecure enemies abroad. Fernandez accuses “neoconservatives, Zionists, and other creatures” of stoking fears concerning Islamic nationalism in Iran.  She is critical of their false rhetoric about “the exporting of radical Shiite teachings to Latin America and the alleged susceptibility of the US-Mexico border to penetration by Iran.” (Fernandez, 2013)

 

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Democracy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words - 3”, n.d.)
Democracy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words - 3. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1486614-democracy
(Democracy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 3)
Democracy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 3. https://studentshare.org/history/1486614-democracy.
“Democracy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 3”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1486614-democracy.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Democracy as a Utopian Concept

Any Rand`s Anthem: Utopia and Dystopia

Following the description will be an analysis on the novel, identifying those who support or critique the dystopian and the utopian viewpoints projected by Rand, along with the practical examples further clarifying the details.... After having explored the plot, the analysis of the context also becomes important to identify where the inspiration had come from....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Machiavelli: The Prince and St. Thomas More: Utopia

Having toured Europe, Hythloday believes that many European customs are morally inferior to utopian customs.... Machiavelli is the father of Modernity and democracy and the creator of Secular Man par excellence (Eidelberg, n.... Machiavelli is the father of Modernity and democracy and the creator of Secular Man par excellence (Eidelberg, n....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

In Defense of Utopia by Lyman Tower

This ability to change and seek the improvement of people (the quest for a utopian society) is therefore the main motivation for a majority of the social movements.... Sargent demonstrates that there are three faces of utopia, which are the design or theory, the utopian movements and the utopian studies (Sargent 11-17).... According to Sargent, the utopian spirit is the cause or the foundation of many social movements, mainly the liberation movements....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Ideal Society in the Eyes of Locke and Swift

Thus the concept of an ideal society is comparatively varied in all the works analysed and ironically contain shortcomings that challenge the inherent ideological bias of their authors and the ages to which they belong.... The notion of property is linked to this concept too.... The Second Treatise reveals itself as a work that later grew into ideas of democracy and capitalism....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Death of Architectural Utopianism

The paper "Death of Architectural Utopianism" states that the modern urbanist's and architects have greatly contributed to the utopian thinking and helped build up its capacity by encouraging utopians to envision a better world and start building it.... The description of something as utopian in ordinary language implies some level of impossibility.... Over a considerable duration of time, utopian designs have been actualized due to desperation regarding urban space utilization....
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework

Comparison between Mores Utopia and Montesquieus Persian Letters

From the paper "Comparison between Mores Utopia and Montesquieus Persian Letters" it is clear that More's Utopia and Montesquieu's Persian letters criticize the forms of governments and politics in France and England while they depart on views on religion, human rights, gender and economic issues....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Portraying Utopias In Literature

Dystopia is the account of a futuristic place which depicts life very differently from a utopian model.... The paper "Portraying Utopias In Literature" discusses Peter Firchow's modern utopian fiction as one of the notable attempts at presenting utopias as fictional elements in a literary dimension.... The utopian and dystopian models have many differences in the way life is depicted between them.... ore, as a social scientist attempted to describe the above almost uniquely 'perfect' features as fundamental characteristics of utopian societies....
13 Pages (3250 words) Term Paper

The Role of Rhetoric in Political Activity

This is probably where the whole concept of government constitutions came from.... It is notable that Plato does not depict a positive towards the concept of rhetoric and its claims because he believes that philosophers who fully understand reality do not need to be fooled by certain ideologies (Judd, 2005, p.... As much as some philosophers like Plato had negative attitudes and views towards rhetoric, others like Aristotle were more positive about the whole concept since he claims that philosophers do not have advanced knowledge on the ideal state....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us