Nobody downloaded yet

Compare Aristotle justice theory to Machiavelli's justice theory - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Name: Instructor: Course: Date: Comparison of Aristotle’s justice theory to Machiavelli’s Justice Theory Aristotle, a great philosopher, formulated the theory of social justice, which is extremely related to the contemporary western idea of justice. This justice theory is based on the vital idea that fairness is proportional to equality1…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER99% of users find it useful
Compare Aristotle justice theory to Machiavellis justice theory
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
"Compare Aristotle justice theory to Machiavelli's justice theory"

Download file to see previous pages Therefore, this is never something of ruthless power grab, but focuses on the well-being of everyone. This expression of justice is extremely different from Aristotle’s point of view, who insists that justice is based on proportions, and anything less does not qualify to be just. Therefore, this paper supports that Aristotle’s definition of justice is more definite than Machiavelli’s definition of justice because it proves some fairness in its application and is easy to understand. According to Machiavelli, injustice is a stronger, at liberty, and more masterful than justice2. He also implies justice as a significant aspect of liberty. This perception also proves that those in positions of political power dictate justice more than the peace loving and righteous citizens do. Aristotle, on the other hand, did not only describe justice on proportions, but specified that for it to prevail, equal cases should be treated alike, and unequal cases be treated differently. Therefore, being treated differently should be in direct proportions to the inequalities between the cases. This, in other terms, is principally treating similar and t dissimilar dissimilarly3. Machiavelli, as an avid reader and follower of works of other prominent philosophers like Cicero, based his definition of justice from the early works of Cicero. He developed the definition of justice, based on Cicero’s ideas, as giving each person his or her dues4. However, ensuring everyone receives fair dues is extremely significant, and no one’s interests should ever be excluded unfairly or subjected to the self-interests of other people. According to Machiavelli, justice is based on fairness, and everyone should have equal opportunities to explain and account for their sides. Machiavelli was also a philosopher, during the renaissance period, which is a time of revamping of the economies through new means of production. There was also a great insist on religion for most philosophers. His writing of the prince depicts the prince as a ‘Judeo-Christian man’ with absolute characteristics. It is to this that his description on justice had mixed feelings. The prince was also the overall ruler who gave all final decisions on justice based on his personal thoughts. Aristotle believed that equality is based upon everyone, and even those in power should be treated on the same grounds. The fields of stressing equality were considered in terms of relevancy or irrelevancy of the case. The Aristotelian school of thought would allow a judge to give a ruling based on religion. The best example is a court case involving a Muslim and a Christian where a judge gave a ruling in favour of the Christian on a religion basis. This verdict was based on the theory of treating similar cases similarly and the dissimilar cases dissimilarly. This aptly proves that Aristotle theory of justice was biased in some aspects because basing judgement on religion is explicitly irrelevant. Aristotle also reiterates that justice requires proportionality. This in simple terms means that every person is treated equally with respect to the distribution of benefits and rights of the society. Relevant reasons should be available for treating anyone unequal. Therefore, this justifies inequalities, which relates to claiming justice based on certain provisions. Aristotle’s works, on social justice, have insisted on radical ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Compare Aristotle justice theory to Machiavelli's justice theory Research Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1476617-compare-aristotle-justice-theory-to-machiavelli-s
(Compare Aristotle Justice Theory to Machiavelli'S Justice Theory Research Paper)
https://studentshare.org/history/1476617-compare-aristotle-justice-theory-to-machiavelli-s.
“Compare Aristotle Justice Theory to Machiavelli'S Justice Theory Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1476617-compare-aristotle-justice-theory-to-machiavelli-s.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
CHECK THESE SAMPLES - THEY ALSO FIT YOUR TOPIC
Theory of Justice Analysis
...? Theory of Justice Analysis There are several principles of justice theories and some of them shall be discussed in this section. However, these principles of justice theories differ from traditional utilitarianism in some ways and the contrast between them shall also be highlighted and explained. It is also pertinent to note that, justice can be explained by the modern Criminal Justice System (CJS) and other entities involved in the criminal justice system and these salient facts shall also be explained in this paper. Justice as defined by the modern CJS also differs...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper
Rawls's Theory of Distributive Justice
...Lecturer; Rawls's Theory of Distributive Justice: Justice as Fairness In his book, A Theory of Justice, John Rawls exploits the values of ethics and political philosophies that affect us in our daily lives. He tackles the problem of distributive justice through the utilization of a variant of social justice. John Rawls theory of justice as fairness is defended as the best conception of justice in the community. He pioneered the discussion of distributive justice and has been described as an indisputably the most influential political philosopher of the...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
Theory of Justice Analysis
...? Theory of Justice Analysis Inserts His/Her Introduction John Rawls was the one who presented the Theory of Justice in1971 and later on revised it in the year 1975, and the final version of this theory was prepared and presented in 1999 (Rawls, 1971). One of the most common issues faced by the world in later part of 20th century was regarding the unequal distribution of resources and goods. Therefore to resolve this problem, Rawls came up with two Principles of Justice which are also commonly known as Justice as Fairness. One is known as principle of liberty and the other as principle of difference. First Principle...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Plato's theory of justice
...it “another good”. The ruling party always makes rules that favour them. Offenders of the law are punished, since infringement of the law is considered as disrespect to the justice system. Socrates disapproved Thrasymachus explanation on justice, arguing that, the way doctors use their powers to help the patient, so does the government engage in issues involving its citizens. Thrasymachus furthers on with reasons supporting his theory of fairness and unfairness as being useful to the society. An unfair person is more brilliant compared to a fair one in both personality and brainpower. Unfairness is an indication of power. Socrates deputes Thrasymachus views and...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
Theory of Justice
...that we can built institutions that are responsive and sensitive to what people really needs. As to what people really ought to have as they embarked in the journey of life. Humanity need not be blinded from all the evils that haunts his very existence in this world. Looking closely, what humanity needs is the spirit that will enable him to accommodate his shortcoming as a human being yet able to transcend at the same time accepting limitations. This may not be much compare with Rawls but I think it is a good start for justice is. REFERNCE LIST: Books Daniels, N.(1975) Reading Rawls: Critical Studies on Rawls' A Theory of Justice. New York: Basic...
13 Pages(3250 words)Essay
Rawls Theory of Justice
...John Rawls was an American philosopher (February 21, 1921 - November 24, 2002), he wrote one of the most famous books in the 1971 also it widely reading of political philosopher and this book is a Theory of justices in this book Rawls tries to address the real meaning of distributive justice through the classical philosopher model of social contract and other philosopher tries to do this is Kant. However, Rawls in concept of distributive justice goes further in hypothesizing the justice theory under the justice as fairness. The justice as fairness has two principle to drive the following Rawlsian principles of justice the first one is that the liberty principle and the second is the difference principle. Furthermore, in the theory... of...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Criminal justice-Deterrence theory
...Task Criminal Justice-Deterrence Theory Imprisonment of criminals plays a crucial role in deterring them from repeating the crime as the punishment is severe and makes them not to commit the crimes again. It also acts as a lesson to other people who may be in the same line of crime, and ensures that they do not commit the crime due to fear of the punishment they could face if they are arrested (Wu, pp 2). However, the length of imprisonment is an issue of eminent contention since it will have a say in the end results of the effects of the punishment offered. This report will look at the advisability of increasing imprisonment terms of crimes associated with theft particularly when it is associated with...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Self-Evaluation- (Justice Theory)
...DISCUSSING JOHN RAWLS ON JUSTICE Due Since the beginnings of human civilization mankind, from the mostfoolish to the wisest, have sought to discover how human beings think, why human beings act as they do, why they feel as they do as means to understand and justify human behaviors, well or bad? One of the greatest questions that humanity still struggles with is how to live together in a community or society and provide equality and justice that is fair, ethical, and just or all involved. Unfortunately, there is no one theory on how that dynamic can be achieved. There are many theories and principles that have been offered throughout the generations; each and every one...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Equity Theory and Organizational Justice Theory
...who work for them. This solution is based on the theory of distributive justice that states that burdens and benefits that an organization should be divided on the basis of those who need those burdens and benefits (Pinder, 2008, p.314). This solution will make the female workers feel that they are being treated equally as they are being allowed to take the burden of work and at the same time they are being offered with flexible working hours as a reward. The organization can even develop a child care center within the organization to ensure that female workers do not have to pay thousands and dollars for child care services. This solution is based on the equity theory which states that...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment
Aristotle's Theory
... Aristotle against Epiphenomenalism In the modern scientific knowledge, epiphenomenalism is a teaching, considering the mind and consciousness as phenomena, which only accompany physiological processes (Robinson). Epiphenomenalism suggests that mental processes do not play an active role in a causal link defining various physiological states. The mind-body problem is being examined through the denial of the significance of mental processes in the physiological functioning of the body. Analyzing the philosophy of Aristotle, one can argue that he does not support epiphenomenalism. Despite the fact that Aristotle believes that the soul exists until there is a body, the philosopher recognizes activity of the mental processes... and their...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Let us find you another Research Paper on topic Compare Aristotle justice theory to Machiavelli's justice theory for FREE!
Contact Us