Nobody downloaded yet

Functionalist and intentionalist explanations of mass murder cases - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Intentionalism and Functionalism as Explanations for Genocide: Nazis and Rwanda Introduction There are two different theories of the mind that might be brought to bear in the case of genocide – intentionalism and functionalism. These are complicated theories, so they are further explained below…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.8% of users find it useful
Functionalist and intentionalist explanations of mass murder cases
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Functionalist and intentionalist explanations of mass murder cases"

Download file to see previous pages Genocide is thus the result of ideology, as opposed to structure. With the functionalism, it is the opposite – the structures – political, environmental, etc. - are what influences the individual to act, or the group to act. A person might have an ideology that Jews are the cause of the problems of the world, and they must be eradicated, and this is what drove the Holocaust, say some historians, along with Hitler's overall mental problems. Others state that the structure is what drove the Holocaust – the recession that Germany was in, which made the people desperate enough to latch onto the ideas of Hitler. The functionalist argument could also be what explained why the individuals under Hitler, and the groups as well, would do what they did in carrying out the orders. With Rwanda, the functionalist argument is almost the entire argument, as no one individual had the ideology to carry out the genocide. However, if group ideology can be considered in the intentionalist argument, then this is one way that intentionalism can be used to explain what happened in Rwanda as well. This paper will explore these two theories, as well as explore how they fit into the parameters of these two tragedies. Intentionalism According to Crane (2007), the theory of intentionalism questions whether all mental states are intentional. Thoughts are intentional, in that they have an object (Armstrong, 1968). Or they might have multiple objects (Husserl, 1901). In other words, people who are thinking are thinking about something – there cannot be a thought about nothing. Since thoughts, by definition, are about something, they are said to be intentional thoughts (Chalmers, 2004). Crane (2007) asks the question of whether there are similar objects for emotions, sensations and perceptual experiences. Crane (2007) also explains what intentional objects are, and the intentional states of mind that are focused upon these objects. If one hopes for something, then this is an intentional mode. If one thinks of the object in different ways – champagne can also be thought of as sparkling wine, for instance – then this would be considered intentional content. The thing in the mind must be represented in one way or another, according to Crane (2007). Therefore, one must have intentional mode and content (Parsons, 1980). Crane (2007) also asks if the contents of all intentional states are true or false, which means that they are propositional. Or, the contents of an intentional state might be conceptual or non-conceptual (Martin, 2002). This means that the “state of mind has conceptual content when a subject needs to possess the concepts definitive of its content in order to be in that state” (Crane, 2007, p. 8). Nickel (2007) explains intentionalism as visual experiences that have phenomenology and content. Phenomenology is “what it is like to have it,” and content “is how the experience represents the world as being” (p. 1). He states that if two experiences differ in phenomenology, then they differ in content. Or, as Byrne (2001) understands it, one has a representation of a thought, and a sensation about the thought. The representation is the intentional part of the thought (Stalnaker, 1998). The intentional part of the thought may become separated from the sensation, according to some philosophers (Robinson, 1994). Nickel gives some helpful examples to compare and contrast when he speaks about the concepts. He explains phenomenology as being “ ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Functionalist and intentionalist explanations of mass murder cases Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1403014-compare-and-evaluate-functionalist-and
(Functionalist and Intentionalist Explanations of Mass Murder Cases Essay)
https://studentshare.org/history/1403014-compare-and-evaluate-functionalist-and.
“Functionalist and Intentionalist Explanations of Mass Murder Cases Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1403014-compare-and-evaluate-functionalist-and.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Functionalist and intentionalist explanations of mass murder cases

Functionalist and Intentionalist Explanations of the Rwanda and Holocaust Mass Murders

...? Compare and Evaluate Functionalist and Intentionalist Explanations of the Rwanda and Holocaust Mass Murders College: Introduction The mass murder in Rwanda is a perfect example of the modern time genocide born of ethnic hatred. As compared to the Holocaust genocide, the events unfolding in Rwanda in 1994 gave birth to the systematic slaughter of more than eight hundred thousand Moderate Hutu and Tutsi. This aspect position the Rwandese massacre to being a massacre of the modern phenomenon, absorbed by rationalism, bureaucracy and technology. The massacre of the European Jews, commonly referred to by a majority of scholars as the Holocaust, on the other hand is among the genocides known to the greater percentage of the educated... ...
11 Pages(2750 words)Essay

Murder

...for the commission of any of the crimes under the Code requires a different degree of culpability which is dependent on the nature of the crime. Hence, the elements of these two crimes are to be treated differently. The issue that presented before us now that needs to be resolved is: The Mens rea for murder is too narrow in certain respects and too wide in others. The fault element for involuntary manslaughter is simply too wide. To differentiate these two crimes, first thing that needs to be done is to identify the elements for the commission of each of the crimes. We start with the crime of Murder. Alan W. Norrie has reported that for the crime of murder, the case of...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Cases

...? Marketing Case Studies (College) Airbus When Airbus was set up in 1970, it found it a tough task to break into the aircraft industry which was dominated by US aircraft manufacturers like Boeing. There was strong opposition from the part of other manufacturers and the US government. It was alleged that Airbus was resorting to unfair policies like heavy price cuts to beat off the competition. Another allegation was that Airbus was receiving huge financial support from four European governments with no repayment conditions. At the end of the argument, an agreement was reached between European governments and US government that Airbus would not be given more than 33% of the total development cost as financial aid for the...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

AIDS is a Mass Murder

...? “AIDS Is A Mass Murderer” Analyze the controversial Social Marketing campaign “AIDS is a mass murderer” The public health community is often required to intervene in the matters of regarding health conditions of individuals. (Laura McDermott, 2005). In this case, the concept of social marketing is brought into mind. Social marketing is ‘the application of marketing to the solution of social and health problems’. (Kotler P. a., 1971). The concept revolves around knowing that many problems that come into being related to behavior are usually caused by health related problems. This is how marketing is prone of understanding the health problems of people to...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Criminology Case Study - Mass Murder

...? Criminology Case Study on Mass Murder Criminology Case Study on Mass Murder Introduction Crimes are committed the worldover and the reasons individuals commit crimes can be tied down to the three theories of rational choice, Trait theory and Social Structure theory (King 2004). A case in point is the crime of mass murder. Mass murder according to Fox & Levin (2005) involves an act of killing four or more individuals concurrently within a short time period. There is really no time breaks in between the murders as they murders occur at the same time. This time of murders mostly occur in single locations where victims are killed by the murderer. The aim of this paper will be explaining the crime of mass murder and its relationship... with the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Mass murder

...). These murders mainly comprised of felony and familicides massacres. In the 1960s through to mid 1990s, there existed a greater number of mass shootings, such as the one in Newton. Moreover, in 1996, a student named Charles Whitman climbed a 27 story building where he shot and killed 14 people while wounding another 31. The incident is referred as the 1996 Texas Tower shootings. Ever since 1900, the highest number of public mass murder by use of guns occurred in 1929. Criminologists claim that the highest number of mass murder cases in US was in 1900s, and this amounted to more than forty percent of the reported...
9 Pages(2250 words)Research Paper

Defense Principles in Murder and Manslaughter Cases

...?Principles of defence in Murder and manslaughter cases in Hong Kong Module Module Number: Academic Year: Seminar Essay Question: Explain the law concerning the offences of murder and manslaughter and discussion of whether the law operates effectively in this area or whether any changes to the law are desirable Student Number: Principles of Defence Homicide refers to the execution of a reasonable human being1. Hong Kong’s common law defines lawful and unlawful cases of homicide; however, proving every ‘unlawful’ killing, beyond reasonable doubt sometimes presents the defence with a lifeline, leading to the acquittal of ‘guilty’ suspects2. Murder refers to...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Functionalist theory

... disturbances. These personal property which are also conversant by alcohol, encompass very great threat to mess up someone's life. A lot of point of view for and alongside functionalism has revolved around reasonable and mechanical issues, disappointing attempts to expand testable functionalist conjectures. However, similarity of social problems ensuing from marijuana and an alcohol misuse illustrate that they are identical and similar because in both cases marijuana and an alcohol can be resultant factor of increasing and developing obsession, addiction and habit of miss-usage of alcohol and marijuana which leads to termination of societal ties. However, possessions and effects of drug known as marijuana and it's intoxication... ...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Murder

...1 (Put the of the Here) (Put the Here) (Put the Here) (Put the Here) Murder Comparison between Dexter Morgan in Jeff Lindsay Darkly Dreaming Dexter and Matt Fowler in Andre Dubus Killings; Dexter, as established in this novel is a charming psychopath. He is working as a blood spatter pattern analyst for the police department of Miami. He is also described as a sociopath, totally incapable of normal human emotions and a serial killer. His tendencies were identified by his adoptive father when he was still younger, that he supported Dexter and persuaded him to channel them into rather socially useful, such as killing bad guys specifically pedophiles. The novel starts with him dispatching a priest who had killed orphaned...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Murder Trial and Murder Case

...Murder Trial and Murder Case The issues pertaining to the case were that an infant daughter (Lillian Rose) and her mother (Rachel Entwistle) were found dead, the reason for the death had been that of being shot by the same bullet. They were killed in their Cubs Path Home. Further the authorities have deduced that the father who was not home at that time and is still missing has been said to be a person of interest. The possible conviction of murder by the suspect and how the facts and the evidence had lead to such conviction had been resolved in the case. The murder case of Entwistle deals with an...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Functionalist and intentionalist explanations of mass murder cases for FREE!

Contact Us