Nobody downloaded yet

The Constructive Role of Ambiguity in the Policy Process - Essay Example

Comments (1) Cite this document
Summary
The Constructive Role of Ambiguity in the Policy Process
According to Lane (2000), elaborate policy procedures may be ambiguous, mainly due to incongruities between political interests and goals and current legislation. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER99% of users find it useful
The Constructive Role of Ambiguity in the Policy Process
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Constructive Role of Ambiguity in the Policy Process"

Download file to see previous pages Furthermore, contradictions between long-term and short-term goals are likely to bring in ambiguities in policy formation and implementation, as well as compromises between irreconcilable intentions, like protected natural reservoir and dam projects.
This essay discusses the positive contributions of ambiguities to policy formation and implementation, particularly in the sectors of health and environment. More importantly, the discussion tries to demonstrate how these ambiguities provide an opportunity to successfully and productively integrate diverse perspectives, worldviews, and values of different stakeholders, as well as how such ambiguities create and strengthen a system of participation. Strain brought about by ambiguities in policy formation and implementation may have serious ramifications on the opportunity to develop a rational policy-making process and employ practical systematic instruments for priority setting (Birkland 2010). There is a need for ambiguities to be recognised and organised, normally in a course of increased stakeholder involvement with an emphasis on social concerns instead of procedural concerns only.
An Overview of the Pros and Cons of Ambiguity in the Policy Process
Ambiguity may be not as much of a tactical tool used by policy-makers as they wish than an unavoidable outcome of the political mechanism. It is thought that implementation becomes unsuccessful because system of government is either not adequately capable or unduly independent (Hill & Hupe 2002). Nevertheless, the complexity innate in realising effective implementation, that is, the alleged ‘implementation deficit’ (Lane 2000, 106), may reveal a much more severe risk to the notion of policy implementation. According to Birkland (2010), the policy system could function to make ambiguity general in each and every policy. Hence, policy implementation becomes unsuccessful not due to a discrepancy between sound policy formation and inadequate policy implementation but because of the policy’s inaccuracy. More importantly, it is claimed that policy is inseparable from implementation, that, in contrast, policy is only recognisable in the implementation process. Thus, the entire notion of a policy framework could be relegated to the mere study of public governance or organisational research (Lipsky 1971). However, if ambiguity in the policy-making process were as common as argued, if policy were the consequence of implementation, then is it possible that policy ambiguity assists policy formation and implementation? Ambiguity, far from being an impediment or an abnormality, is a necessary component of policy process. It has disadvantages because it causes disorder, chaos, and uncertainty in policymaking. Ambiguity obliges experts to have plenty of information (Sabatier 2007). However, a great deal of information will not automatically eliminate ambiguity; it will only increase the clarity of the process. According to Colebatch (2009), perspective rather than intention becomes crucial. Resolutions seldom mitigate difficulties; they only apply or work them out. Nevertheless, ambiguity also confers advantages. Improvement thrives because it grants new insights an opportunity to be implemented to work out old issues. It allows disagreement or inconsistency to be scattered ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Constructive Role of Ambiguity in the Policy Process Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1394795-the-constructive-role-of-ambiguity-in-the-policy-process
(The Constructive Role of Ambiguity in the Policy Process Essay)
https://studentshare.org/history/1394795-the-constructive-role-of-ambiguity-in-the-policy-process.
“The Constructive Role of Ambiguity in the Policy Process Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1394795-the-constructive-role-of-ambiguity-in-the-policy-process.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
fr
frederick21 added comment 10 months ago
Student rated this paper as
This document saved me today. I liked the structure. It was very useful for my history course.

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Constructive Role of Ambiguity in the Policy Process

The Policy Process

...as guiding principle for decision making and so the healthcare provider would always embrace long term care policy because it would help in realizing the aims and goals for healthcare delivery. Stages in Policy Process Before the long term care becomes a policy, there are a number of stages that the policy process will be taken through. Each of these stages plays an instrumental role in ensuring the final product, which is supposed to be the policy itself becomes a success. To this end, each stage ought to be treated with special importance and attention. The three major stages identified on the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

The Policy Process

...the policy process and policy outcomes and makes recommendations to stay the course or change.” (Smith and Dunne, pp. 383) The above policy process is roughly the same across all policy areas, although they involved some changes in the governmental agencies involved. Explaining this process becomes controversial. Some models focus on the role of individuals, groups and institutions and, hence, base their argument on the linear step-by-step characteristic of the process. Others models, on the other hand. are more concerned about the situations in the policy...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Policy control process

...POLICY CONTROL PROCESS Be it a family or nation or even an international organization, the policies are formulated and controlled by power circles only. The factors that vest such power may vary depending upon the area. However, wealth, status and knowledge are the three main criteria that underlay the power lobby. Something like water and anger power also flow downwards. But the quantum of power when gauged at the end user level it is zero. This formula is maintained at the making of policies itself, because the end-users are left with the 'fruits' alone. The end-users namely the masses are not concerned with the policies but with the fruits only. The...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Participants in Policy Process

...Participants in Policy Process By Devangini Mahapatra Chauhan Public policy may be defined as that of things or action where the public ities exercise their freedom of choice in order to deal with certain issues. The tools or mechanisms used to deal with these issues are known as public policy. Public policy may also be defined as a set of decisions that are interrelated to one another. These decisions in turn, are taken by political parties, or other individuals involved in social service, with the broad aim of selection of certain goals that will fit into the situation at hand. Public policy may be implements to various aspects of one's...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Ambiguity

...Running head: AMBIGUITY The Impact of Ambiguity on Actions and Consequences xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx People must be able to covey exactly about what they think to others. Moreover, clarify in thoughts is an important aspect to succeed in one’s respective field. However, ambiguity prevents this nature. When there is an ambiguity in one’s words or intentions, they can be interpreted by people in more than one ways. It may often lead to misjudgment of one’s intentions. Furthermore, there are different opinions for various people regarding the impact of ambiguity on actions and thoughts. While many people view it as an hindering factor in...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Policy Process Paper

...Policy Process Paper: Ending Racial Discrimination within Youth Justice Public ities have a duty to promote racial equality and end discriminatory practices within the criminal justice system. Discrimination promotes oppressive policies and the unequal treatment of youth and it was recently shown that a higher proportion of black and mixed-parentage males are remanded into custody (when compared to their white counterparts), according to a comprehensive study commissioned by the Youth Justice Board (2001). Recent studies like the one above demonstrate the persistence of discrimination within the justice system. Attempts are presently being made to counteract the serious problems associated discrimination with youth justice... of...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

The Policy Making Process

...The Policy Making Process The Policy Making Process Policymaking is referred to as the actions and decisions taken by the government with an intention to solve problems and improve the quality of life for its citizens. It is an invitation to struggle as portrayed in various instances in the constitution making process; in 1788, the congress was divided into two respective houses while power was divided equally among the judicial branches, executive, and the states of the federal government. The struggle is a central point in the US constitution thus a relationship between the congress and the president. The constitution states directly to separations and other balances of powers as it offers little guidance between the legislature... and...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Policy Analysis Process

...Policy Analysis Process U.S. Health care Delivery System and Pay for Performance The introduction of a healthcare policy can be a difficult initiative. Still, the necessity of such action is significant. The current status of healthcare industry in the US is reviewed in this paper. An effort is made to analyze and evaluate the elements of the industry. At the same time, a new healthcare policy is suggested. The key parts of this policy have been designed to effectively address the quality and cost. The most important advantage of the suggested policy is the incorporation of strategies that benefit all stakeholders. It is concluded that...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

Policy-making process

... Policy-Making Process: Immigration Policy The five processes in policy-making include identification of objectives, policy formation, adoption of the best solution, implementation, and evaluation of the policy directives. Policymakers identify the issues the policy is intended to solve in the first stage of policy-making. The issue proceeds to the second stage if it gains sufficient attention. In the second stage, the policy-makers strategize and brainstorm the ways of addressing the unresolved issues. The agenda is set that paves way for the alternative selection. The third stage entails the development of the alternative policy responses to the public problems. At this stage, the makers select the policy tools to use to address... the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Theories of Policy Process

...Theories of Policy Process A public policy refers to means used by the government to maintain order and address the needs of its citizens through constitutional actions. Policy process refers to a series of steps used by an individual or an organization to implement a certain procedure (Sabatier 17). There are several theories of the policy process, but this paper explains three theories with their strengths and weaknesses. The Punctuated Equilibrium Theory The theory attempts to provide an explanation as to why change occurs in certain complex systems (Sabatier 54). It borrows its concept from the biological theory. Bryan Jones first used this theory and Frank Baumgartner in the early 90s.The theory explains the reason... for the...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The Constructive Role of Ambiguity in the Policy Process for FREE!

Contact Us