Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Medical Ethics Case Study - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
In this situation, the ethical situation is for a young women patient from a rare Christian religious sect, that has given birth to a baby boy and following the delivery she is suffering from severe bleeding and may risk her life if not immediate action is taken by the Physician…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.3% of users find it useful
Medical Ethics Case Study
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Medical Ethics Case Study"

Download file to see previous pages In this situation, the ethical situation is for a young women patient (from a rare Christian religious sect, that has given birth to a baby boy and following the delivery she is suffering from severe bleeding and may risk her life if not immediate action is taken by the Physician. The doctor considers that Blood transfusion is required as the hemoglobin level is low, the tissue perfusion is seriously affected, and if the same continues, there is chance that the patient would be at a risk to lose her life. However, there is one problem in this case concerning the religion from which the patient belongs. She is from the religious sect Jehovah Witness Group which is totally against blood transfusion (Kee, 1995). The woman does not wish to do the blood transfusion as it is against her religious beliefs. In such a circumstance, the doctor is in an ethical dilemma as whether he should go against the wishes of the patient and perform the blood transfusion or avoid blood transfusion and seek alternative treatment modalities, whose effectiveness may be in question. Here, the patient’s right to self-determination to prevent blood transfusion is put to test against the doctor’s duty to disrespect the autonomy of the patient and perform blood transfusion in order to save the life of the patient. Alternatives need to be carefully weighted considering their effectiveness and safety. Ethical Principles The ethical principle being discussed in this situation is the right to autonomy which is a basic right given to every patient. This is a principle regarding self-determination of every patient to make an informed decision regarding one’s body and such decisions be made on one’ values, principles and beliefs. Others should not interfere with autonomy and not influence a patient’s choice, values and principles. However, considering that in an emergency situation patient’s may be bound to make a decision that may not rightly represent one’s values and beliefs, there are some situations wherein the right to self-determination and autonomy may have to be overlooked based on the patient’s condition. Hence the right to autonomy is not an absolute right. Consideration should be made whether the patient is competent to make a valid decision about one’s self, and that the doctor is acting on the best interests of the patient. Determine alternatives to resolve the ethical issue According to the Jehovah Witness Group Faith, the members of this religious group can accept alternatives to blood transfusion (such as glucose infusion, IV Fluids, etc) and medical and treatment procedures including surgery and administration of drugs (Kee, 1995). However, they are forbidden to accept blood transfusion or products of blood to be infused, as it is against their religious beliefs. The doctor is in a dilemma whether he should go against the patient’s wishes and disrespect the patient’s right to autonomy and act in the best interest of the patient, or respect the patient’s wishes and religion and use alternatives even though they may be less effective and not save the patient’s life. A step-wise process by which the doctor can develop a method of developing his action and considering alternatives ethically has to be used. Legal cases and the Law Past cases demonstrate that blood transfusion may not be important in saving the life of a patient who has lost significant amount of blood (Finfer, 1994). There may be other factors that may ultimately be responsible for fatalities and blood transfusion may not be very important. For example, 2 people suffered serious injuries following a car crash and lost blood and body fluids critically, requiring immediate transfusion. However, both the patients rejected blood transfusion based on their religious beliefs, and the physician had to accept this, respecting their right to self-determination and instead other alternatives were chosen. Both the patient had the same trauma scores ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Medical Ethics Case Study Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Medical Ethics Case Study Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words)
“Medical Ethics Case Study Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Medical Ethics Case Study

Changing Complex Information Systems: Medical records at Anersley Hospital

The problems, which rose due to the inability of the administration to maintain or replicate the status quo, and also due to the staffs’ or workers’ indifferent attitude to the assimilation process.

In an organization, the decision-making process should be carried out perfectly for its survival and for further growth. The important cogs in the decision-making process will be the top-level management and the department heads or supervisors with some inputs from the basic level workers also. But, the actual decision will be or should be taken by the top management in coordination with the department heads. But, if the top management and the department head are not on the same wavelength, then the important dec...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

Medical Physiology

D. Smooth muscle cells: Though smooth muscle cells are recruited by day 3 or 4 of the wound along with fibroblasts, myofibroblasts, pericytes, and smooth muscle cells, their main role is fibroplasia, synthesis of connective tissue matrix, tissue remodeling, wound contraction, and wound strength. They do not produce cytokines and chemoattractants (Sephel, 72). Hence this is not the correct answer.
A 68-year-old man with prostate cancer and bone metastases presents with shaking chills and fever. The peripheral WBC count is 1,000/uL (normal = 4,000-11,000/uL). Which of the following terms best describes this hematologic finding?
A. Leukocytosis: This is not the correct answer because leukocytosis means an increase in WBC co...
14 Pages(3500 words)Case Study

The Features of Corporate Social Responsibility and Ethics

... use it as a motivating factor to address environmental issues. Some times it also happens that small firms want to compete for large projects are coerced to join in some CSR programs. Whichever are the methods but firms try to balance their CSR programs against profitability. Firms try to seek competitive advantage through philanthropic activities. It has been found that integrating operations, quality, strategy and technology can help sustain competitive advantage and strengthen the focus on doing things right. Strategies require the involvement of top management and ISO 26000 strengthens the focus on wider stakeholder base. If the ethics are not adhered to, it could results in billions of dollars of losses as has been faced by MNCs like...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

Business Ethics within the Organization

.... I believe as a manager I would want to provide them complete medical coverage. As an organization, I believe that compared to other organizations my organization is very ethical. However, there is considerable room for improvement especially in grey areas where ethical boundaries are not strictly defined. I would like to refer to my earlier examples where I think that my company is either not performing ethically or there are better ways to perform: 1. Treatment of Volunteers after we have outsourced this function completely to our recruiting company. 2. Providing medical coverage to shift/functional/daily wage workers 3. Privacy of clients & data sharing 4. orientation provided to new recruits after induction and career counseling...
10 Pages(2500 words)Case Study

General Electric Medical Systems

...ESSAY Submitted by: GENERAL ELECTRIC MEDICAL SYSTEMS Conduct critical analysis in relation to Int’l Business Strategy Case Analysis: The case in point pertains to Milwaukee based General Electric Medical Systems’ (GEMS) – world’s leading manufacturer of diagnostic imaging equipment. The case describes GEMS’ cross-border management and operations, and it is centered around reducing costs, enhancing profits and maintaining an upward swing in sync with its celebrated parent General Electric (GE). Joe Hogan, the President and CEO of GEMS was expected to decide for himself if he should alter Global Product Company (GPC) concept launched by his successful predecessor, while dealing with the pressures of rapidly evolving healthcare technologies...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

Ethics in the Manufacturing Environment

An ethical scenario arose during my first six months in this management role involving a 21-year-old employee who I witnessed smoking pot in the parking lot over lunch break. This scenario demanded that I consider the needs of the employee, as well as satisfying my obligations for enforcing the strict drug use policy administered at the senior levels of the company. This project describes the ethical scenario in detail, offering personal reflections on the incident as well as suggesting an ethical framework for handling situations like this in the future.
The situation which occurred had a young worker smoking pot on his lunch break on the company grounds. This, according to policy, is a termination offense and it is expected...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

The Obligation of Business Ethics

... by the majority within a certain cultural context. Business ethics should therefore not be seen as a independent moral principles quest but rather as part and parcel of the pre-legislative as well as pre-regulatory dialog (Sims, 2002). The matter of getting involved in deceptive advertisement as indicated above is just an instance of a legal business operation that ought to be deemed morally impermissible as per our traditional thinking. Several topics related to business ethics have been perceived as part and parcel of the bigger question of if businesses have the moral obligation that goes beyond the requirements of the law. For instance, currently the law provides that businesses have the power of accessing the medical records...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

Marketing Plan for Private Medical Clinic in Birmingham

... market. However, in order to combat with such issues, entrepreneurs must consider a number of tasks before starting a new venture. Effective planning for plausible set of market strategy is one of the most crucial tasks for an entrepreneurs and for this a comprehensive marketing analysis and research is mandatory task (Longenecker et al, 2005, p. 147). This paper will attempt to present marketing mix strategies for a new venture based on the situational analysis in respect of proposed business plans. 2. Background of Scenario This business report deals with the formulation of marketing mix strategy for a new venture of private medical clinic in Birmingham. The private medical clinics offer wide ranges of health care services by taking...
9 Pages(2250 words)Case Study

The Legalization of Medical Cannabis

The federal government, through the 2009’s Controlled Substances Act, makes the use of marijuana a criminal offense. However, various states, such as Arizona, Colorado, and California, have legalized the use of cannabis for therapeutic purposes. This paper presents an argument that marijuana should be made legal for its therapeutic uses.
The legalization of medical cannabis is justified because of the positive therapeutic effects of the drug. Proponents of the legalization of medical cannabis argue that if marijuana is made illegal, patients will not be able to access and use it for the relief of their symptoms (Gwynne 29). Marijuana has been reported to be a safe drug for the treatment of various conditions. The drug a...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

Should the Family and Medical Leave Act Be Changed

...Should the Family and Medical Leave Act be changed? Robert Anthony Barnes Jr Strayer Carissa Jordan February 20, Introduction The economy of America has been on a long-term recovery path from the period of the great recession. The recession resulted in mass unemployment, social inequity, and low payments for labor. This notwithstanding, the economy has expressed resilience to the challenges of the recession. The economic recovery has inevitably resulted in labor issues that necessitate the assessment of the federal labor provisions. The efficacy of the Family and Medical Leave Act that was signed into law in 1993 to protect workers’ welfare amidst the pressures of employment arouses discussions. Although economic recovery in America...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Medical Ethics Case Study for FREE!

Contact Us