Critical analysis - Coursework Example

Critical Analysis This research shows critical analysis of space and multiracialism as described by prominent Daniel McNeil in the article titled "I. Am. A Light Grey Canadian” and Minelle Mahtani article “Mixed Race Mythologies”. In McNeil (2010), the main purpose is to focus on the negative effect of the Negro culture on multiracialism and multiculturalism. Therefore, the research question illustrates that multiculturalism hampers the social life, work and religion of the black people residing in Canada.

In Mahtani (2014), the main purpose is to illustrate the collaboration between multiculturalism and ideal of progress. Conversely, Mahtani (2014) implemented qualitative methods by organizing and executing interview sessions among the women to get the status of ideal of progress after multiculturalism. The reading of McNeil (2010) provides information regarding the perspective of Negro, wherein they believe that they were being hindered to perform their work and they were being dominated due to dark complexity due to the effect of multiculturalism.

Conversely, the reading of Mahtani (2014) reveals about the collaboration of multiracialism and ideal of progress. It can be said that McNeil (2010) multiculturalism leads to black people’s personal and social growth and development, if Canadian people have mutual relationship with the Negros. Whereas, Mahtani (2014) illustration is positive towards effectiveness of ideal of progress through multiculturalism but progress also builds through genetic behavior and surroundings of the society.In the study of McNeil (2010) and Mahtani (2014), I faced issues regarding not getting proper consecutive data and information in relation to research as illustrated in articles of both the authors.

Conversely, related examples in relation to subject matter made it easier to understand.I analyzed from the study of article of McNeil (2010) and Mahtani (2014) that both the authors emphasizes on the effectiveness of multiculturalism but McNeil (2010) describes about negative believe by Negro people that multiculturalism would affect their social life, culture and religion to great extent. Whereas Mahtani (2014) describes that multicultural will leads to people growth and development which is an ideal of progress of society and country.

Racial discrimination is an issue that causes multiculturalism due to various aspects causing several issues in the society.There are various questions, which arises in the mind after examining and analyzing both authors illustrated articles. In McNeil (2010) it explains evaluating multiculturalism that affects social life, work and religion of Negro people. The analytical view also emphasis that there must be mutual relationship between Canadian and Negro people to deliver growth and development of the society.

Conversely, I am convinced of the illustration as mentioned by Mahtani (2014), that ideal of progress of individuals depends largely upon multiculturalism. In this perspective, it can be determined that the above mentioned along with genetic factors as described by Mahtani (2014) also resulted towards the progress of Half-breeds and Indians. I agree with concern view of Mahtani (2014) towards qualitative approach to show its effectiveness in the implementation of multiculturalism. Conversely, I disagree in relation to with Mahtani (2014) that they would procure more data and information about the positive effectiveness of multiculturalism towards individual development and growth.

On the other hand I agree about McNeil (2010) given review about the generation of negative tendency within Negro people in terms of their existence if evaluation is done of multiculturalism. I disagree with the author McNeil (2010) view that he should take qualitative approach to get accurate and reliable data and information about the negative view of the Negro people for their existence in Canada. From my personal view, McNeil (2010) should implement qualitative as well as quantitative methods in relation to collect genuine data and information about the negative behavior existing within Negro regarding Canadian people perception.

To the peers of the class the first question from me will be if multiculturalism gets evaluated as mentioned in McNeil (2010) will it remove the negative thinking of Negro people that they will lose their extinct in Canada. Conversely, second question will be whether multiculturalism provides positive effect towards growth and development of social, work and religion of the Negro people.To the peers of the class from the view of Mahtani (2014) will multiculturalism gives positive effect on the ideal of progress of individuals which will ultimately be profitable for the growth of society.

The negative effect of multiculturalism leads to criminal impulses and immorality due to generation of relationship between moral and immoral people. Therefore, racial discrimination and inequality should be reduced in order to provide a safe developed society irrespective of caste and creed. ReferencesMahtani, M. (2014). Mixed race amnesia. Resisting the Romanticization of Multiraciality, 1-273.McNeil, D. (2010). Sex and race in the black Atlantic: mulatto devils and multiracial messiahs. Routledge: London.